Food was excellent. Skirt steak I expected to taste good but What surprised me was the mushroom taco because that was awesome. The drinks are well crafted. Legit bartenders and a vibe that makes you feel like it's authentic and you're on vacation. The service is great as the owner makes sure you're taken care of. read more

Food was excellent, service was fantastic, and the people were wonderful ! 10/10 would recommend

I mean... yummmmm! I had the steak quesadilla, and it was delish!!!! I was too stuffed to order anything else but margaritas and churros dessert.. I'm so happy that Montoya's is in the neighborhood. The biggest highlight, aside from the steak's taste, was the manager, Robbie. His hospitality was top-notch. He worked the room and made his guests feel welcome. That's what will set the place apart from mediocrity. read more

My friends and I wanted to check out Montoya's -- especially because we enjoyed Metro Taco; the restaurant that previously occupied the space. When we visited Friday we immediately headed to the backyard patio. It's spacious and nicely adorned with Tiki lamps and other tropical fixtures. The food was flavorful, but I would say the drinks were my favorite. Their Montoya's Margarita was tasty. However, the place could benefit from having a happy hour to lure people in. Cocktails are priced at $16. In terms of the food, we shared the Guacamole, Tostada Nacho Tower (it ended up being different from what we expected based on our server's recommendation), and the Crispy Potato Taquitos. We also ordered the Pulled Pork and Skirt Steak Tacos. Of the two, the Pulled Pork was my favorite. For my friend, it was the reverse. Another companion ordered the Tuna Tostada and loved it. We shared the flan for dessert on the recommendation of our server, but she neglected to mention that it came with a hint of orange zest to it. We wouldn't have ordered it had we known. The flan wasn't creamy -- it was gelatinous and light (nothing special). The restaurant is new to the neighborhood, and as a result, they are trying to figure things out. The place was not crowded, but as people streamed in, the service declined. When we were ready to leave, we had to request the check. It arrived with errors including items we had not ordered. It took a bit of time for them to correct the bill and return it to us, too On a positive note, the restaurant has a decent lunch menu that should attract locals. Verdict: good, but in need of improvements. read more

See all

Tried this place out tonight, and it was just OK. The outdoor space was set up very nicely in terms of decor, but there were tons of bugs. Ants were swarming the ground and crawling over my feet during dinner from dropped food that hadn't been cleaned prior to us being seated. Also, lots of nymph lantern flies on the ground and one landed on our table. The plants really give the space a nice aesthetic, and I know it's an outdoor space, but there has to be ways to control the insects. Food was just OK, I wasn't mad at the tacos, but they weren't the best tacos I've had. Also, for the price, they're VERY small. $6/$7 per taco and it was a small Guerrero corn tortilla. Chicken had good flavor, but there was no sauce. Fish taco was catfish and better than the chicken. Complementary chips and salsa was nice. Service was fine, server was nice, but seemed to be the only one working so things moved a little slow. read more

See all

Sadly I have to give them 3 stars not because of their food but because of the VERY slow service. The waitress was absent for the most part. She got one of the orders wrong. It got replaced without any issues but then everything was really slow. We ordered more tortillas for a plate of fajitas we were sharing which arrived almost 30min later when we had already finished our plate :/ Not the waitress fault but definitely everything to do with management. Not sure I want to go back if the service is not improved. read more

This is a soft opening review. Drinks were good but a little overpriced as they are using well liquor for the drink specials. Service at the bar was excellent, but everything changed when we went to our table. It took over 30 minutes to get appetizers. Those hit our table around 7:45 PM. Our waitress was often absent. We had to ask for napkins, silverware, more chips and salsa. There six of us at the table and they gave us one basket of chips and one salsa to try to pass around I guess? If our waitress had been on hand to offer refills, take more drink orders for cocktails, it might've been better. But by 9 PM we still didn't have our entrées. The staff tried to convince us to stay even longer saying that we would have our dinners by 915, but by then we were all just done. The restaurant did comp the appetizers, but where they failed this night was not in the bumpy service, it was in communicating with us. When service is going poorly and the kitchen is overwhelmed, that's the time to step up the table service and provide whatever you can in the meantime. Unfortunately, none of that happened. The queso fundido with pork and the guacamole were tasty. I hope they get things sorted out soon. read more

Montoya’s - Mexican Near Me - Forest Hills, New York

See all

This place has such a cute little outdoor space, I wish the food was better so that I'd come back. I got a mushroom taco and an Al pastor taco. First the waitress brought me a cauliflower taco which I didn't order so I had to wait for my food to be made properly. The Al pastor taco was flavorless and fatty. I've never actually had a fatty pork taco but there's a first for everything. My favorite taco is usually a mushroom taco but this was the worst one I've ever had. There was no seasoning, no sauce nothing. It was just plain mushroom with a little tomato and onion. Sadly not for me. read more

Montoya’s - Mexican Near Me - Forest Hills, New York

See all

Montoya's is a newcomer to the Forest Hills food scene but brings some credibility with a chef from the ever popular, well loved 5 Burro. Located off the main strip, on Metropolitan Ave, Montoya's offers delicious Mexican fare and great cocktails. The owner is very friendly and will proudly offered a variety of seats that the space has to offer: there is seating at the bar as well as tables and a really nice outdoor dining space. Food wise, the tostada nacho tower is an excellent variation of standard nachos. The queso is a great flavor and texture and adheres to the crispy tostada better than melted cheese Tacos were solid with flavorful meat that was cooked fresh to order and definitely not reheated. The al pastor wasn't too powerful in flavor and the meat was tender. The standout was the skirt steak which had a great taste. Drinks were made really well, passion fruit margarita packed just enough punch. Would definitely try the frozen ones next time. Our server was also so friendly and attentive. I read some questionable reviews elsewhere but can assure that wasn't the case at all for our tables or the ones around us. Very excited to have this new spot and look forward to returning to try more menu items! read more

See all

Tried Montoya's, a new Mexican restaurant. The food took a little while to come out, but the portions were decent and definitely filling. Overall, it was a good experience, and I'd be willing to give it another try. read more

See all

This spot is sooo good and I wish I didn't live so far because I would be here every week. I came with a couple of friends after work and we made it just in time to get a few drinks for their happy hour that goes until 6 o'clock. The margaritas were so tasty and were strong. Complementary chips and salsa were great. We ordered the spicy chicken quesadilla and steak fajitas. My friend also ordered a burrito. The spicy chicken quesadilla was honestly one of the best quesadillas I've ever had. The chicken was so flavorful and the tortilla was perfectly crisp. The steak fajitas were incredible and my friend's burrito looked great as well. The churros were yummy, but a bit overpriced in my opinion. The service was amazing. Our waitress was bomb. The backyard is so cute and so thoughtfully decorated. I will definitely be returning when I'm in the area or even if I want to go out of my way to come back. read more

Montoya’s - Backyard so pretty - Mexican Near Me - Forest Hills, New York

See all

An actually good new non-chain restaurant in Forest Hills! Call it 5 Burro Cafe South, from a chef of the beloved longtime Austin St spot, this one on Metropolitan with a very similar menu. I have a feeling it will be packed soon, especially when it finally gets warm and people can sit in the backyard. Start with the Tuna Tostada and get some tacos or enchiladas fajitas for a good time. read more

I must admit I wasn't expecting to eat the best tacos in my life on Metropolitan Ave in Forest Hills Queens NY. I came in for Happy Hour and had one of the best Margaritas on the rocks I ever had so I decided to get the tacos chicken, pork and chorizo. They were so amazing I was too busy eating them to even take a photo. Even after happy hour deals were over we shared more tacos, guacamole and an amazing flan and tres leches cake. What was also pretty cool is their beautiful extra large outdoor space in the back. The staff was amazing and service from the waitress excellent. This is definitely going to become a weekly happening as good Mexican food in an cool atmosphere is a rarity these days. No lines, no pressure just excellent drinks food and service. 10 out of 10. PS I will definitely update this with photos the next time I come. read more

Montoya’s - Flan. - Mexican Near Me - Forest Hills, New York

See all

This place is a gem! There's a surprisingly large outdoor space tucked away in the back with festive tiki & palm tree vibes. I'm in love with the frozen sangria - the perfect, fresh, icy deliciousiousness for summer. The food is excellent - I've had the pulled pork burrito and the chicken quesadilla - and the staff have all been so sweet every time I've stopped in. Loving this new addition to the Forest Hills food scene. read more

Montoya’s - Cute summery vibes! - Mexican Near Me - Forest Hills, New York

See all

Cute new spot. Friendly hostess invited us to check it out. The menu's small and limited, but everything was tasty. The tacos were really flavorful. Free chips and salsa was a nice touch. We'll definitely go back. The frozen drinks were okay, but we might try other things next time. read more

General public advisement - would not recommend going hungry or with kids during their soft opening on a busy night. Appetizers took about 1.5 hours and 30 more minutes after that for the entrees. But if you have a lot of time to spare and you enjoy a late slow night with a lot of drinks in-between - then this would be a good place for you on those nights. I also heard going earlier or for brunch is much less busy. Ambiance: outdoor patio is really lovely but inside felt warm and air felt stagnant. It can get quite loud inside too. I would recommend some kind of quiet fan to circulate air. Service was amazing 11/10. Very kind and accommodating. They did know that the food was taking a long time and I don't blame them at all. Food and drinks: sangria and frozen sangria were delicious. Appetizers were better than entrees, but the entrees were not particularly memorable. But I can tell they prioritized the quality of the food instead of just pumping out dishes. Kitchen did a good job on this. Everything felt fresh and cooked to order, but something about the flavor of the entrees did not feel elevated for the type of place you are paying for. I felt like I was paying for the ambiance more than the food. Potato taquito - solid appetizer. Would order again. Nacho tower was nice. I would recommend having smaller chips as an option so it's easier to eat (its originally just three big fried tortillas in a tower) and having a fork and knife on the table already. My table had to ask for utensils after trying to eat with our hands. But the tower was kind of hard to cut even with the knife. But it was creamy and satisfying with the beans and avocado. Tacos: Mushroom: solid mushroom taco. But wouldn't order again. Pork: solid choice Chicken: average. would recommend chicken thigh because it's a little dry just because it's chicken breast - not sure if that's traditional though. Nicely seasoned for chicken breast Steak: cooked perfectly to medium rare - but not seasoned. Would recommend at least salting the beef the night before for more flavor. Chicken Fajita: average. Wouldn't order again. I think the flavors were just based on preference for me, so I personally wouldn't go back (and this is strictly based on the food, not the wait time) but I think the ambiance is nice enough for others to give it a try and see if they like it for themselves. read more

Amazing service, met both owners great hospitality love the vibe. Food and drinks are truly excellent. Recommended the steaks in any order and there montoya margarita. For sure a hidden gem and a must go. Love the outdoor seating very well done. read more

Montoya’s - Memories last long on a photo - Mexican Near Me - Forest Hills, New York

See all

This newly opened restaurant has a lovely outdoor area in the back. Enjoyed the steak tacos and chicken fajitas. Excellent service as well! read more

Montoya’s - Mexican Near Me - Forest Hills, New York

See all

Montoya's was such a pleasant surprise. They have only been opened for less than a week and they are operating like a well oiled machine. The servers were attentive and saw to our every need. It felt like we were long time customers. The vibe was family friendly without being a TGIF! We are already planning to have my daughter's 30th birthday there in September! The food was well seasoned, flavorful and elevated. My favorite were the black beans with rice that came with my enchiladas. You can tell a lot about a chef from the way he flavors his beans! The frozen margaritas pack a punch - they tasted like a grown up drink instead of your typical slushies. All in all I have no notes!! If this is an indication of things to come we are here for it! Welcome to the neighborhood Montoya's! read more

See all

Had a very good experience trying Montoya's, a new Mexican eatery, located on Metropolitan Ave. in Forest Hills. Was welcomed by Jackie, an artist who designed the interior of the restaurant. We started with delicious margaritas, then tried the nacho tower and had a few tacos. Everything was yummy. We will be back again with our friends. Congratulations & good luck! read more

Montoya’s - Pre apps salsa & chips. - Mexican Near Me - Forest Hills, New York

Great spot. Love the fact there is an outdoor space. Margaritas on point.. and food is great!

wanted to try Montoya because I missed Metrotaco, which previously used to be here. I ordered shrimp fajita, guac and chips, and a chicken taco. The chips were missing from my order so I called and requested that they deliver it to me because I was only a block away. The chicken taco was tasteless. Bland, unseasoned and dry. The shrimp fajita was decent. Lots of peppers included. The rice and beanswas the best part of the whole meal. The guac was completely flavorless. The chips were crispy. overall, no for me. read more

Excellent. Finally an authentically flavored and delicious Mexican restaurant in the neighborhood. My husband, daughter and I had dinner there and the food was fresh and delicious. My daughter and I each had tacos and shared a quesadilla both were so good. My husband raved about his chicken dish. We will definitely be back for more. The staff is very friendly and attentive. They have a lovely back patio dining area. I look forward to my next visit. read more

Called on Weds. to make reservations for a party of 7, a lady answered took my info and said no worries. We went there tonight, they did not have the reservation. No big deal, they made room for us, it was tight but no worries. Main issue and it seems to be a theme as this is being reported by many and its now the 2nd time happend to us. The wait time for getting your food is 30 - 40 minutes after you tell the waiter. They keep feeding us chips and salsa to keep quiet. And we were not the only table...And tonight it was worse as they never brought out the appetizers we ordered and went straight to our meal, how does this happen, get your house in order.. If this continues your stay in FH will be short. read more

What an incredible addition to the neighborhood. It's as if Metro Taco and 5 Burro had a baby. The food was delicious and the backyard ambiance makes you feel like you're on an island. Robby, one of the owners, was extremely hospitable and made us feel like old friends. I will absolutely be back! read more

We had a wonderful event for 30 people in the yard and it was so much fun. The atmosphere is great, the drinks were one better than the next, and the staff was all about the customer experience. The night was flawless, everyone had a fantastic time. Thank you to Robbie and his team for their hospitality and to the chef for the delicious food!! So happy this just opened up in our neighborhood. read more