Go there every weekend I am here. It is one of the best places in Pymatuning. The food and service are top notch and you could not ask for a better place to hang out, have a few drinks and listen to some music. If you want some wine just walk next door to the Gatehouse Winery. If you want a cool hand made hat talk to Bruce and Torpedo Bay Hats! read more

See all

Stopped here for a late afternoon lunch while out exploring with family. Loved the property as a whole - lots of covered outdoor seating and indoor seating was comfortable while we waited for our drinks. Food was delicious and reasonably priced - the loaded mac and cheese was perfect and my husband enjoyed this smash burger. We stuck to the beers/ciders but they had a great cocktail list, too. There's plenty to do there since it's attached to a small winery, ax throwing and gift shop. We'd definitely return on our next trip out! read more

Mortals Key Brewing Company - Breweries Near Me - Jamestown, Pennsylvania

See all

Food overpriced, bartender he was rude and the staff does not even get your orders they just go around and collect the pizza boards. And to have a young boy like 10 years old in a brewery and winery at night to pick up pizza boards not good practice. read more

Beers and burgers after a tubing trip Down the Shenango River . There was a band playing and the place was packed.. even though it had started pouring once we got there . People were inside snd under table umbrellas and tent for outdoor seating . Burger was excellently cooked. I had the Hefeweizen beer. Delicious! read more

Cold beer. Good service. Good location. I would recommend unless you don't like big crowds. Lots of patrons.

Great brewery near Pymatuming State Park! I love the set up of this place. It shares the property with a winery, a shop, and a kayak rental place. The place is really large- particularly the patio. It is a great place to hang out and try craft beer. Cocktail options too. They have food as well as live music. I went a few times during my camping trip- one time on a Sunday and they were packed-- people were even bringing their own chairs! The place is also dog friendly and there were a lot of dogs there- which my dog definitely enjoyed! I will definitely be back next time I am in the area! read more

Mortals Key Brewing Company - Breweries Near Me - Jamestown, Pennsylvania

A true and tasty delight! We make it a point to plan a day trip to this brewery - that's how good the beer is and how lovely the atmosphere is! Whether it's cold outside and you can cozy up inside of the incredible rustic yet architecturally rich environment and take in some bluegrass or roam outside among the sprawling areas, you're gonna be comfortable and enchanted. I've never tried a beer here that wasn't top notch. My hubby, who is an IPA enthusiast, was crazy over many of the IPAs, while I loved seeing a perfectly done Kolch on the menu, in addition to a great Pils and some darker favorites too. There is a modest yet deeply satisfying menu that includes a homemade pretzel shaped like the logo of the brewery along with pierogis and many burgers. If you sit outside it will be hard to resist the sandwiches which you can smell and watch cooking. The location is very convenient to Pymatuning State Park, especially the Jamestown facilities or Ohio/Andover facilities. It's a short and direct drive over to I-79 so this is a very accessible place if you're traveling from or between Erie and Pittsburgh. While I've not tried the adjoining winery yet it will be part of the itinerary next time, as it was equally inviting! I cannot wait to return. Highly recommend! read more

See all

Stopped here after some hiking in the park. Food was good, beer was good, staff was really friendly. Live music was rockin. Outdoor space is really cool. Accommodating to kids and dog (outside). We'll be back next summer! read more

The food was delicious. I recommend the Mac n cheese with some nice smoked meats. The bus straight from hogwarts inside is pretty cool too!

This place is definitely just as good as the reviews suggest. We were visiting Pymatuning Lake and a couple of friends who also visit the area from time to time told us that Mortals Key was their favorite. Now we know why! The atmosphere with the dog-friendly outdoor dining is outstanding. The brisket tray was terrific. The beer was super, especially the Baltic Porter and the New England IPA. (I took home a growler...) The bartender, Chris, was very gracious, and the young lady working the kitchen was friendly and kind. We really enjoyed our experience in a brand new place for us. The next time we are in the Pymatuning area, we'll be stopping in here again! read more

Mortals Key Brewing Company - Breweries Near Me - Jamestown, Pennsylvania

Such a cool place! Connected to a winery! Live music on weekends. Absolutely delicious food. They offer flights of their beers! Patio is dog friendly, lots of parking! Closes at 9pm read more

Mortals Key Brewing Company - Patio - Breweries Near Me - Jamestown, Pennsylvania

We enjoyed a flight of beer and some snacks here on a Friday afternoon. My favorite beer was the sour beer they were featuring, very tasty and had a floral taste to it, ended up getting a glass after we finished the flight . We shared an order of pierogies which were flavorful and a pretzel which was good with some nice dipping sauces. Their outdoor patio is very large and very nice. The view is beautiful as well. The inside of the brewery looked really nice too. Food selection is limited and it's mostly small plates. Not necessarily an actual dinner menu. The bathrooms were nice. I was turned off by the fact that the man pouring the beer was not wearing a mask nor were some of the customers in line. Definitely not happy about that. read more

See all

Food is great, beer is great, atmosphere is great. Not much more to say about it than that.

A must have after a day at Pymatuning Lake. Pulled pork or smash burgers are great options. Beer is good too.

We found this place passing by driving on Eclipse 24' weekend! We ended up there twice it was so good! We had lunch and listened to live music while the kids were entertained playing outside in the creek! The service was quick and menu fit a variety of preferences! I would highly recommend if you are in that area! read more

Drove by and had to stop to get a picture best decision ever I saw there was a brewery so I ran in and got myself a Hefeweizen beer. Absolutely loved it. Cant wait to come back the next day for another beer and try some food read more

See all

Being a first-timer, I ordered a flight with two porters, an amber and a few others. I really liked them all but the sour porter and amber were my favorites. We ordered two different pizzas: a roasted tomato and white pizza with banana peppers. They were so good! There was a guy playing guitar and he sang a variety of different types of music. Can't wait to go back!! read more

Awesome place to chill. Good beer. Good vibe. Back patio is amazing. Live music is a nice bonus. Drove all the way from Buffalo area. It's on my list of destinations. I bought a T-shirt to try to spread the word also. Lol read more

We came here to try out Lago Winery. We did not know they have a brewery next door. We had the Kolsch, and Brown Ale. They were both very good beers. The place is absolutely cool inside. They have TV's, couches, and areas to sit down and enjoy your beer. read more

Mortals Key Brewing Company - Breweries Near Me - Jamestown, Pennsylvania

See all

Came here for a few drinks for my friend's bachelorette party weekend! The location is absolutely beautiful and I love that there is a winery next door- there's something for everyone here. Although the food looked wonderful, I only had some beers. I tried a flight- which was reasonably priced and was a great way for me to try multiple beers. I really liked their ESB and their hefe. I was not so much of a fan of their raspberry beer. Overall, this is a wonderful place to bring beer drinks and non-drinkers alike! You can't beat the gorgeous scenery- it is just so relaxing! read more

What an unbelievable eating and beer experience, this place was. A most beautiful facility, with very interesting and relaxing seating. Our bartender, Nick is a really cool guy with tremendous knowledge of the brewery and the beers. A sample flight of 5 types lead us to our choices of Porter and a hearty stout! I had to get verbal with the cook, a big, friendly guy who prides himself on his smoking and preparations of brisket and pork shoulder. A platter of both meats, some nice mac& cheese, green beans ( also great) and some grilled pumpernickel rye, filled Rosie and me up. We only had room for 1 truffle each! read more

We get here maybe 5 times a year and, We Love This Place! Great beer, food, atmosphere and staff! Good thing they close at 9:00 or we would "Just one more" it till closing! read more

We just found this place a couple months ago. It is about an hour drive for us, but we have driven it 3 times already. Surprisingly good food for a brewery and delicious assortment of beers. Would highly recommend trying it. read more

Great beer, moonshine slushees, and burgers. Nice outdoor, covered patio with live music. A little out of the way, but worth the trip! Wonderful setting. read more

This place is just cool. The whole set up is over the top. There is a winery there as a bonus. The brisket was really great and the NEIPA matched. We sat outside because of Covid and had plenty of space. The food took a little longer to come out than we would have liked but that just gave our group longer to taste the beer. If you're a craft beer fan you don't want to pass this up. Ambiance along with beer and food are a great experience right by the water! read more

See all

Here visiting from Pittsburgh -- this place is awesome. It's super cozy but also industrial. The fireplace and couches are a plus. I liked every beer I tried, which is a rarity. Plus the wine from Lago Winery is also great. Our bartender, Nick, heard that we couldn't get a fire started at our AirBnB and was super kind and got us tinder. Couldn't ask for a better experience. read more

Mortals Key Brewing Company - Breweries Near Me - Jamestown, Pennsylvania

Great beers! Choose from a Kolsch, Amber, IPA or Porter. If you want to try them all you can get a flight. They also have growlers available. It's located right next to Lago Winery and offers a great view of a cute Bed and Breakfast up the hill. Love the atmosphere here. Great outdoor space with tables and stools. The inside of the brewery is pretty unique with an old bus, boat motor tables and some old church pews. This is the type of place you can spend an entire Saturday afternoon hanging with friends. There's also a place next to the brewery that you can rent paddle boards, kayaks or bikes. Check it out! read more

See all

Have wine next door at Lago Winery, walk across the street and down the trail to the lake then come here for outstanding beer. We have a blast every time we come here! read more

Mortals Key Brewing Company - Breweries Near Me - Jamestown, Pennsylvania

Samantha H. was right. This place has terrible service. It was our first time as well and were not sure how their set up worked. As we were the only people in the bar, we just stood there as the three employees behind the bar carried on a conversation with one another. Finally, I asked if we could sit anywhere, do we order at the bar, etc. The bartender was polite when she finally acknowledged us and took our orders. At first, we were told it would be a few moments until our food was ready but then another employee came over and told us that it would be about 15-20 minutes. No big deal. Over an hour later we were still waiting for our food. I went up to the food pick-up counter and asked if any of our food was done. The girl just looked at me and said, "No". That was it. I told her we had been waiting for over an hour so she said she would check in with the kitchen to see if it was almost ready. The kitchen is outside and the cook was looking directly at us and said, "No it's not ready! I am only one person and I'm going as fast as I can". Like somehow, it was our fault that we had ordered food. Overall the food was just ok. The atmosphere was decent. Will we be back? Eek! Methinks not! This business could really use some customer service training. read more

Interesting lay out. Beer is good not great. Food was better than good. Covid restrictions while I was there were not executed well. Was taking 40+ minutes to get a beer. read more

Love love love love the atmosphere and feel of the brewery and Lago winery. They are on the same property and connected (you can order food/drinks from either). The beers are brewed on site and there's typically 5-8 beers on draft to choose from. They have a good variety typically always have a stout, pilsner, and lager style on draft with a couple other seasonal styles on draft as well. Beers are 5-7 dollars each so very reasonably priced! The food is quite good but a bit on the pricy side. I like the BBQ and sauces offered at mortal keys much better than the pizzas from Lago. The pizzas are quite small and incredibly overpriced. They taste good but 17 dollars for a maybe 10inch thin crust pizza with a sprinkle of toppings is just to much. This is an excellent place to stop and grab drinks with a date or a group of friends. There's plenty of outdoor seating and the whole place has a light open and airy feel. Check out carried away kayak and paddle boarding. It's a perfect afternoon spent yaking down the river or on pymatuning lake then follow it up with a few beers at the brewery! Check out their website to see if there's any live music playing. They have some great musicians and bands! read more

See all

Awesome hand crafted beer. Great atmosphere! Coolest thing around Pymatuning lake.... read more

Mortals Key Brewing Company - Breweries Near Me - Jamestown, Pennsylvania

What a gem! Have been going to Pymatuning Lake since I was a kid. In my travels, I have stopped at a number of great breweries. But this one was really put together with a friendly staff, delicious bbq, good music, super atmosphere, and excellent beer. If you're within an hour and 1/2 drive of the brewery, you should make a day trip out of it. read more

This place is awesome. Best of both worlds. Laid back brewery plus a winery that you just have to experience for yourself The service was great. Friendly and knowledgeable We went kayaking across the street. It made for a perfect afternoon read more

I am absolutely in love with their loaded Mac and cheese! They constantly have great bands and it makes the environment so welcoming. It's nice to sit outside and relax with a great drink after work to start off the weekend! read more

What a hidden gem! We stopped here this past weekend on our first trip to Pymatuning. There is plenty of outdoor seating as well as a sizable bar and seating inside. We tried their sample paddle and all the beers were really delicious. The service was great and my cousin is a vet and appreciated their military discount for growlers. While they don't have bottles or cans to go yet, you can get a growler or crowler. For food, there is some delicious BBQ. My only issue was with their coleslaw. Not good. it would just shredded cabbage with olive oil on top. Not my cup of tea. I would definitely recommend a day trip out here. They are fabulous! read more

Really cool little place. Beer and burgers were very good. Once you find it, you'll be back! Love to find hidden gems like this. Nice music too. read more

Excellent music and brew venue. A bit out of the way from Pittsburgh but easily worth the drive. Growlers available. Great staff and service. read more

Very good beer here! The food menu is quite small, so I took off a star for that. But the atmosphere and beer make up for the lack of food. We took our 3 year old during the day, and it was fine, but I wouldn't call it exactly kid friendly. It seems like just a great place to hang out with friends and have a couple of beers. read more

What a place! We visited Mortal Keys on Saturday and LOVED it. We live in Pittsburgh, but we were visiting some family that live up that way. They suggested we spend the afternoon at Mortal Keys. That was a terrific choice!! We walked through the winery and the outdoor areas before choosing a spot at the bar within Mortal Keys. While there, we were able to try a lot of different beers. My husband got the sampler so he was able to try different ones. The sampler had their Kolsch, IPA, Porter, Oktoberfest, and Dunkel. My husband LOVED the IPA. He actually purchased a whole growler and brought it home. My favorites were the Kolsch and the Dunkel. Delicious. Wonderfully made and hearty. We had a chance to try some of the food from the winery that day. We enjoyed their white pizza and their cheese/meat tray. The pizza was out of this world. Full of garlic and love. The cheese tray was lovely and the perfect snack. The owners came around and made sure everything was up to par while we were there. They were SO friendly and kind. At one point, the bar was packed and booming. The owner jumped behind the bar and assisted the bartenders. That was really great to see! We loved this place and will be back to visit! read more