It was very greasy. Can't say anything else. People were nice and they seemed to know everyone that walked. Maybe it's just not to my taste. read more

Its a takeout place, but food is make with love, and you can taste it! Get: Pep, bacon, pineapple, hot peppers and garlic sauce! read more

Ordered a panzerotti with pepperoni bacon and onions. It is baked in their pizza oven. It was a little over done on top and somehow a little under done on the bottom. It was was still great and the left over the next day in the air fryer came out great. Very inexpensive and good quality. read more

Mountain Shores Pizza - Panzerotti with pepperonis bacon and onions - Pizza Near Me - Collingwood, Ontario

Best pizza in town. Pizza is always ready at the time they tell me to pick it up. Donny is a friendly guy and remembers your order.

I've known donny for 20 plus years make the best panzo I've ever had love u man also always service with a smile read more

Mountain Shores Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Collingwood, Ontario

First time at this place. From out of town and saw the reviews so had to check it out. Small hole in the wall place but the food is amazing. Make sure to Bring cash as they don't take any cards. Will be on the regular rotation when we are in Collingwood. read more

Mountain Shores Pizza - So much yummy cheese! - Pizza Near Me - Collingwood, Ontario

This is THE best pizza in Collingwood! Quality, taste second to none! Panzerotti is ridiculous good!!! The largest and so so tasty! read more

Hole in the walI is about right. It's right across from Cameron elementary school in between Mac's convenience store and a dry cleaner. Upon first going in, it doesn't look like much, but then you get talking to Donny or Carol let me tell you, it's one of the best pizza's in town. Made fresh before you. You can always customize it to your liking and it's always delicious. BUT, if you are a fan of Panzerotti's you absolutely have to get that. It's so big, it'll serve you for 2-3 meals. Baked to perfection. The place may not be the most clean, but if you look past that, and partake in his food, you won't regret it. Donnie is quite the character and an all round good guy. Help support the very definition of a small business. read more

Delicious sauce and very cheesy! Generous with the toppings. Maybe a bit over cooked? No biggy. Bring cash - they don't take debit or cards. $35 for a large Hawaiian and a pepperoni - we will order the same next time we're in Collingwood. I picked up - easy to find in a quiet strip plaza - Macs right next door was also convenient, and on the advice of the Pizza Guy, I used the ATM at the laundromat to save a couple bucks. read more

Mountain Shores Pizza - Large Pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Collingwood, Ontario

See all

TOO SALTY!!!!! Was hoping to rate this high. Other reviews were high, positive about the owner, his pedigree in Collingswood pizza. Bought a medium cheese pizza. Couldn't finish the second slice. It's the sauce! Crust and base is chewy, heavy. Was looking for an old school pie. Maybe the positive ratings are because it's the only game in town for older styles. And all the others are doing Napoli style. Pretty sure none of those have wood burning ovens. Collingwood pizza scene is very sad. Won't return until the sauce changes. read more

Cheese on top is my favourite for pizza! Although it's a small pizza place with barely enough room to stand, they make excellent pizza and great value, fresh toppings, sweet and personal service. A real mom and pop's place. I visited Blue Mountain and stopped here on my way back to Waterloo. I loved the Pizza cold too! Much better than any Pizza Pizza or Pizza Hut, and excellent value also! My large pizza was under $20 and fed 2 people with left overs. I went during a lunch time and they had small dollar slices too. read more

Mountain Shores Pizza - Large pizza with cheese on top of toppings! - Pizza Near Me - Collingwood, Ontario

ABSOLUTELY AMAZING BEST PANZEROTTI EVER!!! Been getting them for at least 20 years now and I have to say it is still as good as good as the 1st time. Best panzerotti I've ever had. read more

I can't say enough good things about this place. It starts with the owners, the nicest people. Pizzas are fantastic and this is a must try spot in Collingwood. Support Local! read more

The best pizza ever. Our 'go to' spot for pizza when we are in Collingwood. All fresh ingredients and in correct proportions. Pick up only but worth every penny. read more

Not the cheapest, but for the quality & value its the best. Fresh ingredients, friendly owner, tasty pizza. It is one of the best if not the best pizza I have ever eaten. Value = superb! Taste=superb! Owner attitude=superb! Overall superb rating. I ordered the Hawaiian pizza & its the best one I've had so far. Even the crust tastes good! The crust is a little sweet which was a pleasant surprise. Usually I don't eat crusts, but in this case i had too hehe so good. This a take out place with 2 chairs for u to sit on while u wait. This is not a sit down restaurant and there is no table for u to eat on. But that's okay because the place is still pretty awesome. Pizzas are made fairly quickly. Done in around 10 minutes. Give it a try & u will fall in love. read more

Mountain Shores Pizza - Mouth watering Hawaiian pizza - Pizza Near Me - Collingwood, Ontario

We ordered a pizza expecting this to be a cut above the other places in Collingwood , but it really tasted like all the others. It was not as good as Toppers but better than Pizza Pizza. read more

3 Came here because of the great reviews. The people that worked there were extremely nice, and it felt like a local pizza shop that everyone comes to. Very friendly atmosphere and therefore good customer service. Pizza was good. Personally there was too much cheese for my liking and I prefer more toppings and tomato sauce over cheese, but at the end of the day it was a good pizza and maybe I should have specified my preferences. If you are a lover of packed cheese, and meat, and that sort of greasy hit the spot pizza, like after a night out or drinking, then this is a fantastic place to get your carbs on. read more

I try to order a pizza or panzerotti every time I visit Collingwood. It's real pizza! Made with real fresh ingredients. I live in Toronto and have yet to find anything as good as this place. I highly recommend it. And the owner is super friendly. read more

Mountain Shores Pizza - Panzerotti - Pizza Near Me - Collingwood, Ontario

See all

Stopped by here again, and it was just as good as I had remembered. Very friendly service, and delicious pizza! I think it's safe to say I will be back here again and again! read more

Mountain Shores Pizza - Couldn't even wait to take a photo before digging in! - Pizza Near Me - Collingwood, Ontario

Love, love, love this place! Many years ago when they were on the main drag I stumbled in and got a slice. I didn't live here then but was so blown away by the amazing taste. Next time I was up here I was disappointed to see the place gone. It took me a bit of time but discovered they'd not closed, just moved. Phew. My fav pizza for sure. It is definitely my go to pizza in town. Cash only, quick service and always excellent quality. My mouth is watering just thinking about it. Hmm....maybe I'll order pizza tonight!! read more

The pizza was delicious. Good amount of toppings and lots of cheese. The sauce was really tasty too! Service was great. Will definitely return when back. read more

One of the best pizzas that I've had in a long time! Delicious and reasonably priced. I highly recommend, especially if you're tired of the same old chain stores. read more

Easily the best pizza in the area! Staff/owner personable and easy going! If you detest chain pizza joints you must try this place! Don't worry about the fact that it is literally a hole in the wall; it's all about the pie! Fresh ingredients and lots of cheese at a reasonable price! Can't beat it! read more

This is really great pizza. Fresh toppings, tangy sauce and great crust! All made and served with a smile by Don. Thanks!

Nice and cheesy, just the way I like it. Fresh topping and nicely sized toppings. Great pizza you can tell this pizza is made with love. The owner is super friendly and wants to feed you something good. Will be back next time I'm in blue mountain. read more

This is how you don't do pizza. Once upon a time, Mountain Shores was a reliable alternative to chain pizza but it's deteriorated to the point I can't say I would ever go back. The pizza is so incredibly greasy and the cook on the pizza is inconsistent (undercooked to overcooked). Sometimes the amount of cheese is sufficient and sometimes it seems like there's twice as much. The store is a dive. Good thing it's so small. The garbage can is always overflowing and the counter looks like it hasn't been wiped in weeks. You can imagine what the floor looks like, too. Rather than have slices, they have small pizzas made ahead of time that are left in boxes sitting around. I'm sure that's not the preferred way to keep product at temp. I couldn't imagine what the storage areas look like. read more

Great pizza. Place was crazy busy, they even took the phone off the hook. Well worth the wait - great pizza and the panzerotti was massive. Highly recommend supporting this local artisan. read more

Easily the best pizza I've had in Ontario.. the value alone is worth the visit! Try the panzerotti, they are huge. The homemade pizza sauce is very very good.. read more

Amazing pizza, I was there tonight. They helped me carry it to the car and even added extra cheese. Got home and tried it for the first time. Amazing. I'll definitely be a repeat customer. The Hawaiian pizza was perfect, best I've ever had. Hidden gem!!! The only thing I wish I had known in advance was they don't take credit cards, luckily there was an atm next door. read more

We were in town for the OCR World Championship & this place hit the spot & then some! Reasonably priced, awesome owner & pizza creator, & delicious pizza. You can't go wrong here! We'll be back next year! read more

The best pizza in the area. Carryout only. Not a dine in place. It looks like a one woman operation but she can handle it. Pizza crust just thick enough to hold the toppings and cheese. Our order was pepperoni and bacon and then a cheese only for my kids. It definitely hit the spot. No leftovers. Although we are only here a few days on vacation, we will make a return trip before we leave. read more

This place is great. I tried it for the first time the other night and was very impressed. You get loads of toppings - right to the edge. And the ingredients are fresh and tasty. If I lived closer, I'd eat here all the time. read more

One of the best pizzas I ever had. We come up to Blue Mountain every year but first time we went. People were so nice there. Cash only, no seating but well worth your time to bring it home. It was incredible. read more

Best pizza I have had in along time. Old school pizza. You always get what you order and have it delivered with a smile. Keep up the great work Mountain Shores. read more

Very friendly owners, great pizza, can't wait to have it again next time we are passing thru

Hole in the wall place but great for take away. Very generous with the toppings. Be prepared though - cash only!

very good pizza, good service, one of the best pizzerias i have been to in my life, this is a good place you guys should definetely come to this place read more