An associate at one of the clothing stores on Main street, Nikisha, recommended the fudge at Murray's. She said it was the creamiest. We ordered 4 kinds - 1/2 a square of each kind. In total it was $20. We ordered Smores, Heath, pecan, and caramel macchiato. Nikisha was right... Creamy goodness. Also, the woman behind the counter was really nice (unlike the entitled millennial behind the counter at Murdicks). read more

Walking in, I was impressed with the feel of the place and all the flavors they offered. However, my joy soon left when I was met with the surly person working behind the counter. While she allowed me a few samples, she appeared to do it begrudgingly. I only asked for three samples and I later learned that was their limit. I bought all three in nice small 1/4 pound pieces. This was the only place that allowed you to buy it in smaller portions. The "fudge" was good but not the consistency of what I consider fudge. They're known to have the creamiest fudge but it was beyond creamy and was almost melted after just an hour in the summer heat. I got the orange dreamcicle, the cappuccino and the cookie dough. All were good but not the consistency I was after. read more

See all

This is the best place to get fudge on the island. They'll let you sample all the flavors and I feel like they're the only place that has Superman fudge. I got the amaretto turtle. It was amazing, I'm still thinking about it. read more

Holy wow! Best fudge in town! Samples galore flavors like you would not believe! Staff super helpful and sweet! In the Murray Hotel! They also have a little Mexican restaurant as well! We left with 4 pounds of fudge. I just don't wanna talk about it. read more

Murray Hotel Fudge - Cinnamon bun, and amaretto walnut - Desserts Near Me - Mackinac Island, Michigan

See all

If only I could leave a negative star. Absolutely awful. Room is 9x10. Queen bed actually lifts off the floor if I sit on the side. Mattress is definitely from the 50's. Closet is a rod stuck in the corner of the room. Bathroom is so small you can't turn around so they stuck the sink on the wall in the room. And they think it's appropriate to charge Hilton Grand rates! Go ANY place else on the island! read more

The lady became overwhelmed by the line and skipped me. She started serving the people behind me. Everyone in line got a sample except for me. I guess she didn't like me. My husband was mad that I wasn't ready to check out and I was mad I wasn't served yet. I had to speak up to have her help me and after this entire fiasco I ended up with the wrong fudge. read more

We tried all five brands of fudge open on Mackinac Island at the start of the 2022 season. Murray's Hotel Fudge was the only fudge shop that didn't make the fudge where they sold it, so you didn't have the benefit of the fudgy smells. We found that Murray's fudge had great flavors but were mildly to very grainy. read more

The room was clean and the beds comfortable. It was all good till I showered and the tub backed up and I had to stand in the dirty water. The town was pretty quiet at night, but the hotel guest above our room (on the 3rd floor) walked around till nearly 3:30am (when I finally fell asleep) with very heavy steps. Wtf are you doing up there man?! Just walking back and forth? Maybe it was not a guest ? Maybe it was the hotel kitchen? We tried a couple of free samples of fudge from the super friendly staff member outside and decided to buy some inside... but we could not separate the two magpies from gossiping long enough to notice us. Yes my husband spoke up and made our request for some fudge. One of the two women seemed like she heard us and her body sort of moved towards us, but her coworker's story must have been too interesting cuz she just couldn't pull herself away. We paused for a long moment before we turned our heels without any fudge read more

See all

Best fudge on the island and that's saying something! I highly recommend sampling even if you know what you want, the samples are as good as the real thing. Service was outstanding even with the crowd. Lots to look at while you're waiting. It definitely has an interesting ambiance; I think I'd like to try to stay here next time we go to the island. I'd love to be able to be wrapped in the smell of great fudge for my entire visit! I parked my bike on the street with everyone else and didn't have any trouble. Seriously the best fudge on the island, we tried every fudge we could find! read more

Did not stay at this hotel but I tried their fudge...creamy and sweet. Staff were friendly especially when they are selling home made fudge for $15++ a pound. No regrets buying. Less line / crowd. Good packaging. Yummy fudge!!! read more

I'd say one of the best fudge on the island. I've had them all and this one always seems to be the best. My favorites are the heavenly goo and the peanut butter explosion fudge. All are great though! read more

See all

Fudge was very good.The counter person was very helpful. They also told us we where near the point that we could get free fudge

Best fudge on island. Samples are great and the flavors are unique. Kept coming back each day for more.

Cannot compliment this place enough. Best fudge on the planet, much less the island. They aren't afraid to sample because they know. So smooth and creamy. You hear about some of the other big name fudge makers, but make no mistake, they are all fighting for second place. It's a shame I can't give them more than 5 stars. read more

The fudge here is not overly sweet, and very creamy. They also have a lot of interesting flavors. Definitely worth checking out. read more

See all

The BEST fudge hands down. We went around and tried all the fudge places. The selection and overall taste is amazing. Apple pie is phenomenal. I would definitely recommended this place over all others in Mackinac. read more

This place has the best fudge in the entire planet!!!!!!! My favorite flavor is chocolate peanut butter. Great customer service and so many flavors! They let you try as many pieces of fudge as you want before you buy it without making you feel pressured l! read more

This is our favorite fudge shop on the island. We request a box of fudge from visiting family and friends, too. Our favorites are Tiger and Dark Chocolate Sea Salt & Caramel. You won't be disappointed. This is the creamiest fudge we've had! read more