Delicious! I know my…read moresweet tooth and I did my best to control the urge to sample every one. A quick glance I kind of already knew what I was going to order, Dark Salted Caramel and Butter Pecan. There were a couple others I was tempted to switch out but was very pleased with my selection. Staff was super friendly and accommodating. You can tell they all love their job!

Joann's Fudge was a great stop while on Mackinac Island. Tried the toffee flavor and it was…read moreexcellent, perfect texture and flavor. Worth the visit if you're looking for good fudge on the island, will definitely be back next time I'm there.

Delicious! Classic confection shop with that old timey feel…read more The store is located within downtown and is pretty large with high ceilings. Open area to see where they make their sweet treats. Staff are friendly and we chatted with one staff who said she has worked there season after season. Tons of fudge, ice cream, sweet treats, and freshy made waffle cones. I went with the pumpkin ice cream in a waffle bowl and it was heaven! The ice cream so smooth and rich. The waffle bowl was churchy and sweet. It hit the spot! Also got some fudge and it was just as delicious!

My favorite ice cream flavor from Kilwin's is their Mackinac Island Fudge and there was something…read moreso poetic about ordering this flavor (one of my first ice cream cones of the summer season) at the Kilwin's ON Mackinac Island no less! Kilwin's is a Michigan staple that I absolutely LOVE! I live closest to both their Ann Arbor and Plymouth locations, which are the ones I frequent the most, but often times they run out of their Mackinac Island Fudge flavor. I was so glad it was in stock on Mackinac Island AND that this Kilwin's was the largest Kilwin's I've been to yet! There are live fudge demos that you can watch, along with their entire "kitchen" area looking like it's out in the open so you can watch the workers hard at work! They have a massive selection of so many different sweets and treats - so many more offerings than I've ever seen at another Kilwin's too! It was a *treat* to see and always a MUST VISIT stop whenever you find yourself on the island! Love you, Kilwin's! :D

Not authentic Mackinac Island fudge, fudge had a salty, processed taste. Truly disappointed.read more

This place caught my attention because you have to walk through it to use the restroom if you are…read moreover in Nonna Lisa's or the winery. Nice selection of salt water taffy, candy, caramel corn and ice cream. They even have an arcade. Where they got marked down was that I found the caramel corn that they make in St. Ignace 200 miles away at half the price. I know there is a mark up for the tourist in Mackinaw City but c'mon. I didn't buy any fudge because Joann's has that market cornered. Street parking. Organized and clean. Lackadaisical staff. If you go be ready to pay up.

Family owned and ran for 75 years and the chocolate candies were absolutely delicious, the caramel…read morefilling was perfectly chewy and over sweet and the fudge was perfect. I would recommend going here over the 5 for $30 sweet shops that are spread throughout the rest of the town, and the frozen lemonade was a perfect drink for walking around.

The two staff ladies were quiet and behind the counter. One felt like she was watching us the…read moreentire time we were there. It felt a bit unsettling. The second staff member that was more into the counter and store offered to help us if we needed anything. The two staffers didn't give us a welcoming feeling at all, perhaps they are both shy? This is the only shop that offers an all caramel fudge block. They don't offer an extensive amount of fudge, but they have a ton of popcorn and taffies. An entire wall of different flavored taffies. The caramel fudge is unique and only available here. I do enjoy caramel flavored candies. Caramels make everything a lot yummier. Their caramel and cheese popcorn kernels are quite sizable and very tasty. Their caramel fudge is different, let it melt in your mouth some. The taffies are quite a variety of flavors. Some are really good, the caramel apple is right on the money. Some have hints of flavors, but aren't as distinguishable. This is the same taffy sold at Joann's, since the packaging is exactly the same. The assortment of dark chocolates are decent. Their cheese and caramel popcorn are both good.

$33 for 3 pieces of fudge. $15 brittle boxes…read more The store in town sells Moomers Traverse City cherry ice cream (that waa deeeeelishus).

They don't say too much when you come into the store- I guess to let you browse but it was a little…read moreawkward. No prices are posted anywhere - she said 'it has to be weighed' - how about just a sign with the normal lb price somewhere besides the scale? So sharing here- $25.95/lb for just a single slice purchase. This is a gift for our family reunion so will weigh in on taste later. They do have specials - I've posted the current ones, but you have to buy quite a bit more and we just don't have room for anything else at the moment. Smells amazing in here tho.

As we entered the bakery, we were disappointed to find pre-wrapped breakfast burritos, similar to a…read moregas station mart and seemingly, only doughnuts. As we approached the bakery counter, we discovered hot breakfast sandwiches to order. Even better, we found several types of muffins. We ordered a croissant egg, cheese, bacon, and avocado breakfast sandwich, a chocolate chip banana muffin, and coffee. Everything was fresh and delicious. We highly recommend.

We were hungry after the bridge walk, so I was looking for a place that also had matcha…read more The lines were long worth so many people being in the city that morning, not they moved quickly. Staff was very friendly and patient with the chaos in the store. The place is pretty big, and a little confusing with two separate lines, plenty of people and you still want to see what baked goods they have. And they do carry a huge selection of baked goods. We got a breakfast burrito, bagel with avocado and tomato (vegan), giant cinnamon roll, apple fritters, one regular coffee and iced matcha latte with oat milk. Total $35 plus they charge you for cc payment. Not cheap. The bagel was delicious, chewy and fresh, hubby enjoyed the burrito even if a little small for the price, , the apple fritter was too dry, not many apples were there. Cinnamon roll very good. Iced matcha was good, but the coffee was very mediocre. They have a huge sitting area where we relaxed and enjoyed our food.

let's start out on a positive note, the outside and inside of this shop was very cute! And I was…read moregetting the vibe! But....... The fudge itself was just ok. I got a single slice of the plain chocolate and it was kind of dry and crumbly. and when I asked the worker to cut a slice in half because I didn't want an entire piece, she simply just said, "we don't do that here." also, who wants to pay $16 for one dollar dollar bill sized piece of fudge!!!! that's ridiculous!!!!

It's not the lowest price fudge on the island, nor does it have the most variety of flavors but…read moreafter buying a sampling from each store on Mac Island, my family voted this Murdick's Fudge by far the best. Please add nut free Michigan Maple and English Toffee if you don't mind my suggestion. It is so smooth and scrumptious that Murdick's will be featured in all my Christmas gifts to relatives this year. I'm positive it will be a hit!

FOOD- This fudge was OUTSTANDING!!! You know this fudge is…read morebuilt different, and just straight out amazing if you're not a fudge person! Also, I didn't have ice cream but it looked delicious, but I for sure recommend getting the fudge... And more specifically, get the peanut butter and pumpkin ones SERVICE- The workers were so kind!!! They were answering our questions, letting us taste test, and were just so happy and smiley! ATMOSPHERE- The atmosphere was so cute, welcoming, and clean! Highly recommend

The place smells like fudge heaven. Rich and chocolaty and delicious-you want to wear the smell…read morehome, but you can't. But you can take some great fudge back and rub it on your wrists! I had Sea Salt Dark Chocolate Caramel Fudge, which is a trendy flavor. Other flavors are Butterfinger, Cookies and Creme, Pumpkin, etc. Raspberry Truffle is excellent!