Cancel

Open app

Search

My Cakes Your Cakes

5.0 (1 review)
Open 7:45 am - 10:00 pm

My Cakes Your Cakes Photos

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - My Cakes Your Cakes

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

7 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Ask the Community - My Cakes Your Cakes

You might also consider

Verify this business for free

People searched for Custom Cakes 838 times last month within 10 miles of this business.

Verify this business

The Baking Cup

The Baking Cup

4.8
(5 reviews)
5.5 km

We got a birthday cake for my daughter's 5th birthday and two dozen custom cookies, both in a…read moreRainbow Brite theme. Not only did Eliza communicate directly with me several times during the week, we also ordered a cake topper from Etsy that I was afraid wouldn't come in on time so she planned for that just in case and kept in touch with me about it. She also texted the day after the party to follow up and ask how everything went. The service she provides is TERRIFIC all the way around!! She is such a kind lady and did SO much hard work to create the perfect cake and cookies for my daughter's special day! I heard so many compliments on the cake and how beautiful it was and also how great it tasted! Several people asked where I got it and I gave them the name of the bakery and encouraged them to go see Eliza! Another dad (who has to be careful with sugar) ate some cake and said it was the perfect level of sweet and he really enjoyed it and asked where it was from also. The kids LOVED the cookies!!! They took them home with their goodie bags and were super happy to get them. Everything was so beautiful and tasted great!! Thank you so much again for all the work you put into both of them! We appreciate it so much!!

I communicated with the baker via WhatsApp, she replied consistently. I ordered a cake for 25…read morepeople, but honestly, this kid could've fed 50. The decoration was 5/5 , it was created exactly like the inspiration picture. The chocolate cake was fine, tasted like a box mix, and the raspberry filling lacked raspberry flavor. It tasted like sugar with a touch of texture. If you're going to order a custom cake from here, I would just be very specific on your flavor profile and what you expect from the cake. One selling point of this bakery is that everything is made from scratch.

Photos
Rainbow Brite cake complete with Color Castle!
Rainbow Brite cake complete with Color Castle!
Stich Birthday Cake.
Stich Birthday Cake.
Stich Birthday Cake.

See all

Stich Birthday Cake.
Nanni's Cakes

Nanni's Cakes

4.2
(5 reviews)
8.7 km

I stumbled upon Nani's Cakes after getting coffee next door and made two visits in two days. Yeah,…read moreI loved the cookies that much! They are a very small store front with a very modest showcase with limited small desserts. Apparently, the primary business obviously is custom cakes for special occasions. The team working the kitchen and front counter are helpful in their descriptions of each dessert. The cookies are very thick due to various stuffings but not very large in diameter. All are excellent in their own way but the Biscoff Chunky Cookie with white chocolate filling is crazy good. If gourmet cookies and custom cakes are of any interest, Nani's is well worth the drive.

This is a small bakery with a few eat-in seats. I suspect most visitors pickup their cakes & sweets…read moreto go. This review is based on their cookies since those are the only sweets I tried. They have a good variety of what they call their 'chunky cookies'. The person who waited on us educated us as 1st time visitors. She said almost all of the cookies have some kind of filling. Well, filled cookies are not typically my favorite but these cookies were quite good! I tried the pistachio, almond & biscoff cookie. They were all crunchy on the outside & soft (but not too soft) on the inside. The filling was not as I expected. I was expecting to see some type of noticeable creamy inside filling but that's not the case. The inside just tastes & looks like a regular soft cookie inside. If you didn't tell me there was a filling I would not have immediately noticed. All 3 cookies were good. The almond cookie was my favorite. All the cookies I tried had a nice crust / crunch outside with a softer but not gooey inside. If you don't like stuffed cookies don't let that stop you. The cookies are very good, they are very rich, but good. They sale coffee drinks which could be a little challenging since they are literally next door to a coffee shop, but it allows 1 stop shopping if you like. They also do custom cakes (the designs look pretty amazing), cupcakes & a few other sweets I didn't experience. These cookies rival the larger, more well known cookie companies. They cost about a $1 more, but they are a good size, creative flavors, & hit the spot for a tasty gourmet cookie. I say come give this small business a try for your next cookie fix. Also I checked out their website & they have several other types of sweet treats. I love their 'bento box' concept which is a small round cake with a few cupcakes; it would make such a neat gift idea!

Photos
Cake examples
Cake examples
Cake design displays
Cake design displays
Inaccurate description

See all

Inaccurate description

My Cakes Your Cakes - customcakes - Updated July 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...