We had my son's first birthday party here and it was the best! The staff was so helpful and accommodating, during both the party and the planning leading up to the event. My guests were raving about how delicious the ice cream was and how cute the shop was! It was the perfect place for the party and we truly enjoyed it so much. We can't thank them enough! read more

Not great. The ice cream tastes kind of fakey/cheap. It's not homemade or fresh. The flavors also aren't very creative. I'm so bummed!

Nellie Bly's is your quintessential small town ice cream spot. It was so sad when this sweet spot burned down a few year ago, but we are so happy to see it back up and running. The ambiance is a huge part of what makes Nellie Bly's, Nellie Bly's! There's a model train that circles to the ceiling, movies projected onto the wall, the most adorable tables and chairs, especially for the kids. A perfect place to swing by with the entire family! The establishment is fueled by Bassetts Ice Cream, aka some of the best. Cookie Monster and Guatemalan Ripple are my two favorite flavors. J typically opts for a milkshake of sorts, which never disappoint...and so many other yummy options. While I've never tried the waffle sundae, it looks INSANE! If you dine in, your order is served in the sweetest little dishes and the overall vibe is just immaculate! The only downside: the establishment abides by seasonal hours, so unless it's the summer, you're likely not popping in for a little night cap unless it's the weekend. read more

Nellie Bly's Riverton - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Riverton, New Jersey

Long line but service was great! Cute cute ice cream parlor located in Jersey. You order are the counter. There are indoor and outdoor. It's child friendly. There's a toy train rail running on the wall. The ice cream flavors are vast. There's also a lot of dessert options. We got the skillet cookie sundae which was a bit too much for 2 people. Definitely recommend this for 3-4 people. read more

Nellie Bly's Riverton - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Riverton, New Jersey

They serve Bassetts Ice Cream, which is very high quality, and the first nice cream manufacturer in the U.S. The decor is very charming; what an old ice cream shop would have looked like. They serve a wide variety of flavors. read more

This is the cutest vintage ice cream parlor close by. The staff is super friendly and helpful. My boyfriend and I came here on a Saturday around 4 PM. We were the only ones in the shop to order but once we got our icecream a flood of people came in so we definitely beat the rush. This is definitely a bang for your buck with really tasty icecream. We both got a small in a cup. They give it to you in a little takeout box and with a generous two scoops. Will definitely be returning when in the area. read more

Nellie Bly's Riverton - a scoop of ice cream in a box - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Riverton, New Jersey

I'm displeased with myself that I didn't get pictures while there. My son and I decided to take a trip over the bridge to try this place because it looked so cute and it really is. They have a big selection of ice cream and toppings. My son got cookie dough ice cream in a bowl. When you order in a bowl it comes in like a Chinese food take out carton sort of. I ordered a scoop of strawberry and a scoop of sweet and salty pretzel I think it was called. Unfortunately I didn't know the pretzels in the ice cream were chocolate covered which I'm allergic too so I couldn't eat them but the ice cream itself was good. We went Friday night around 7:30-8 and it was filled with teenage kids, seems like a cute little hangout. I plan to go back soon to try some other flavors and of course get some pics. We sat at the cute old fashioned looking counter. read more

Ice cream was good there were so many good options, I just stuck to a basic cookies and cream with Oreo crumbs along with a cookies and cream milkshake! It was pretty good and the customer service was very friendly. read more

See all

Old style ice cream parlor located in a very cute part of town. Serves Basset's famous ice cream with a large selection of flavors. I used to have to travel to Philadelphia for Bassets at Reading Terminal. Order the scookie sundae where a fresh baked cookie is served in a skillet topped with your flavor of ice cream. Amazing! (See pictures). If your hungry, start with some authentic Mexican (4+ Yelp stars on 75+ reviews) just a few doors down. read more

Nellie Bly's Riverton - I've cream on a freshly baked cookie. Amazing! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Riverton, New Jersey

One of my favorite spots in Riverton. This charming spacious ice cream parlor is one of the special places in this neighborhood. The ice cream is delicious, the staff is always friendly, the place is fun and almost always full. People WANT to come here and bring their family and friends. Read about the adventures of Nelly Bly, watch the antique train make its way around the room and enjoy a movie with the kids. It's worth the trip. read more

Great staff and so many options. Really cool town and atmosphere. Highly recommend Nellie Bly's

Nellis Bly's Riverton is the cutest ice cream parlor in the area. The shop is located on the main street in Riverton. As soon as you enter the shop you'll get the vintage feel, everything from the small parlor tables, to the ice cream bar, to some of the mirrored walls give this place a totally unique vibe. NBR offers a variety of ice cream flavors, all the classics and a few unique ones like Cookie Monster, Pomegranate Blueberry Chunk, and Guatemalan Ripple. They even have seasonal flavors like Egg Nog and Pumpkin. In addition to ice cream, NBR offers sundae specials that can be served on warm skillet cookies or freshly made waffles. Things to note: - Credit cards accepted. - Street Parking. - Great place for small parties & events. - Open throughout the winter, check site for specific hours. read more

Last night we wanted something different so we made our way over to Nelly Bly's. We had high hopes with all of the positive reviews from yelp. Stepping into this place is like taking a step back in time. Vintage feel with all the modern flavors. They offer bar seating and an ample amount of tables, including children's tables. They do accept credit cards, a previous review said they didn't. It wasn't very crowded for a warm night but it was busy enough. They have an extensive amount of flavors and they use top quality Bassets ice cream. I believe Bassets has the best ice cream around. It's extremely hard to find. Their prices are a bit high but again, it's quality ice cream. We paid $24.00 for 3 sundaes. Overall I would give Nelly Bly's 4 stars but there was a major issue with my Skookie last night. Yes, I ordered their famous Skookie which is a fresh baked chocolate chip cookie with 2 scoops of ice cream, whipped cream and a cherry. As I said previously the ice cream was good. The cookie was as well until I found my issue. I was shocked to see whipped cream from a can, with the prices I expected fresh whipped cream. My wife's sundae was delicious just as expected. It was banana and coconut ice cream with whipped cream and cherry. I must say though that the owner is extremely nice and when I brought up the issues she was beyond apologetic. She gave us a gift card and some ice cream to take home. She tried to make it right. read more

Nellie Bly's Riverton - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Riverton, New Jersey

See all

A nice antique ice cream parlor that's serving up some delicious dessert. There are many unique & traditional flavors to choose from & a bunch of toppings to add on BUT the best option here is the scookie which is a homemade right on the spot chocolate chip cookie with whatever ice cream & toppings you want on top you'll have to wait 20 minutes for it to be baked but you'll be glad you did! read more

Nellie Bly's Riverton - The Scookie - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Riverton, New Jersey

See all

Get the skookie- which is a skillet cookie- and share it with a friend or your kid. It's so rich and decadent, although we all know the dough is probably Nestle's. Who cares if it tastes amazing piled high with any type of chocolatey or vanilla-y ice cream. I've brought various people here and they're always happy with the decision. It does seem a little bit run-down since it first opened, but who cares when you can eat amazing ice cream desserts. read more

Nellie Bly's Riverton - The history of nelly bly - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Riverton, New Jersey

See all

I love this place. I come every chance I can. The space is so cute, the service is great and the menu offers a variety of fun desserts. Everyone got gift cards to Nellie Bly's this Christmas. read more

This is a review by a lacto-ovo vegetarian Milkshake. Taken by itself literally this word is not too appealing. When defined by the experience at nelly bly's it's downright attractive. Nelly Bly's is an old fashioned ice cream parlor manned by teenagers and primarily for families. They manage the crowd well and serve up all the classics like sundaes, bannana splits, milkshakes, malts, and cones. They make waffles right there and the place is redolent with the smell of freshly ironed carbs. A milkshake is 3 scoops of ice cream, milk, and a shot of syrup. There is a more expensive version that adds a "topping" like oreo pieces. They have suggestions but easily handled my custom job: 2 scoops vanilla peanut butter, 1 scoop banana, shot of chocolate syrup. On a different night I tweaked it: 1 scoops vanilla peanut butter, 2 scoop banana, shot of chocolate syrup. yes, I was trying for a chunky monkey milkshake. The later worked better. Eat dinner where you like on 130 but save room for dessert and come here. read more

Took a drive over the bridge to check this place out. Large selection of ice cream flavors, sundaes and other treats. I ordered the skookie which took about 20 mins to come out but it was delicious and we will certainly return. read more

Nellie Bly's Riverton - Skookie - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Riverton, New Jersey

This ice cream parlor is adorable. Such a quaint small town feel that brings you back to decades long gone. I had the Cookie Monster ice cream it was amazing. Very clean ice cream shop and great customer service too. read more

Nellie Bly's Riverton - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Riverton, New Jersey

How cute is this place?? Visiting family nearby when we decided we wanted ice cream. After an extensive search we stumble upon this place. It wasn't too far. Located in a cute little town right across the bridge from Philly. Stepping into the place was as if we had stepped foot into another time. A chalk board on the wall lists all the ice cream flavors and options. We got a waffle ice cream and a brownie ice cream. Service was so friendly. She answered all our questions and gave us truthful reccommendations. Everything we ordered was delicious. If we are ever in the area and want ice cream we now know where to go. read more

See all

Excellent milk shake, bassett ice cream, wife hadda Sunday, very good, great old place, worth the drive from tacony

We are locals, and we love this place. Lots of good basic classic ice cream choices, waterice, and shakes. And the shakes... awesome malted shakes... Old time feel, calm decor, fun vintage throwback without being cheap plastic. Did I mention the shakes? I'm on a low-carb sugar free kick, I really enjoy that they have true sugar free ice cream. (at least one flavor..).. Its a treat! Eat in, or our favorite is to walk a few blocks down old victorian streets down to the river and watch the sunset or boat races, - its almost too perfect and classic and sadly often lost Americana in a nice quiet town. Parking is free at the town lot across the street, or on the street if you can score it. They are cash only, - ok, its a hassle, but frankly it adds to the old time feel. $5 gets you 3 NICE SIZED scoops in a cone. No soft serve here, just dreamy big scoops. Kiddy tables, classic wooden stools on a marble bar.. its pretty awesome. read more

Whatever you do, get the skookie. It's pricey, but worth it, and can easily feed two people (or three). Service was great and friendly. They had no problem adding a little extra toppings we were excited about. The shop is adorable. read more

Nellie Bly's Riverton - Skookie w/ ice cream on the side. - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Riverton, New Jersey

This is hands down my favorite ice cream shop near me. The vintage look is so cute and a great place to bring the family. The ice cream is incredible, especially the skookie. They have SO many options I have to keep going back to try more. The customer service is perfect and the workers are beyond friendly. The owner is also very nice. Definitely go here it's great! No complaints! read more

Just a fantastic place to be. The cream is fantastic and the scenery and environment make it a family friendly place for the kids/grandkids. The vintage feel somehow makes the cream taste better, and the service is fantastic. Overall definitely a place to spend a whole paycheck, lol. read more

Felt like summer in 1979.... we'll what I can imagine it feeling like because I wasn't born yet. I have to apologize because I have no pictures of my "scookie" because I took them to go but please take my word. A warm fresh baked ... yes fresh baked chocolate chip cookie cooked the size of a paper plate in a hot skillet and then topped with two scoops and two toppings. I got Guatemalan ripple and English toffee with hot fudge and sprinkles. The Guatemalan ripple is for the coffee lovers, and the English toffee is smooth and creamy and awesome. My friend got the cookies and cream on a waffle cone which was looking real appetizing as I waited for my cookie to bake (12 minutes) call ahead if your inpatient but it is worth the wait. This is my new summer spot and this isn't some overpriced creamery that sells quarter cups of ice cream for $10.00 this is old school family style ice cream parlor. read more

Awesome old time ice cream place that feels straight out of a vacation destination. Huge servings, I mean HUGE. Split the sundae's, they're massive. Bassets ice cream at it's finest. Most definitely will be back. I highly recommend "the scookie", it's a skillet cookie that is made to order with ice cream and toppings on top. read more

Nellie Bly's Riverton - Brownie sundae - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Riverton, New Jersey

See all

Great place great ice cream good browinie good cookies. Great place to risk it all. Cant wait to come back goos seating. Good people. Orginal and nice local feeel. read more

See all

This is our 'go to' ice cream parlor. The Skookie is absolutely to die for. Its a large baked(on a skillet) chocolate chip cookie with ice cream on top with a big old mountain of whipped cream. The hot cookie melts the ice cream and really is a great sweet combo. Nice decor and the owner is very nice.. read more

This is the cutest little ice cream shop. They have tons of flavors and it always smells like chocolate chip cookies, thanks to the warm skillet cookies they are always serving with the ice cream. They have ice cream and waffles too! Highly recommend. read more

Nellie Bly's Riverton - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Riverton, New Jersey

Average rating: 3.5/5 stars --- I've been here with my boyfriend a few times and always get the milkshake (love it). Tonight I came here with my best friend and we wanted to write a review. This is a really fun spot, cute little tables for kids with an overhead train and projector movie playing on the wall. Super quaint place. I got a black and white milkshake which was amazing (I love milkshakes and this one is sooo good). My friend got the skookie with 1 scoop toffee ice cream, 1 scoop mint chocolate chip ice cream. Ice cream itself was very good. The cookie's taste was delicious but the cookie itself was a bit under cooked in the middle and they could've been a little more generous with the hot fudge. Overall good experience. Love to support local mom and pop shops and this one is worth it. read more

Nellie Bly's Riverton - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Riverton, New Jersey

See all

I love Nelly Bly's! They are close to the train station, have a great selection of flavors and Sundaes and have great specials. The staff has always been helpful and agreeable. Sure they don't take credit cards, but if you've been there more than once you are aware of that fact. If you have little kids, it is a fantastic place for a birthday party and very affordable! For that reason alone Nelly Bly's gets its 5 stars. Plus, during the off season, they'll open up and have special parties near the holidays. My kids love seeing Easter Bunny there, making heart shaped cookies for valentine's day and having a chance to get a picture with Santa. read more

Love it! Excellent ice cream,friendliest staff We go every week.. Always something new to try But still like traveling back in time read more

Great desserts, nice old style ice cream parlor. Large selection of flavors & the portions are larger than you need.

Nelly Bly's is in a great location. That's the single best aspect of this place. I think the place is nice inside. Of course they inconveniently don't take credit cards (like it's not 2010). The service was terrible. A pair of friends and I waited ten minutes to even be acknowledged at the bar. We all ordered milkshakes. The worker actually cried about them being the hardest thing to make and he really didn't want to do it. I am not lying. Really dude? So we all ordered milkshakes. I had a cookies and cream. It was 4.79, and it was weak. Predominantly milk, and i could barely taste the cookies. I finished it within minutes instead of actually enjoying it. read more

we stopped by here last weekend to get some dessert. I didn't realize that the place is under new ownership now. It still as the same vintage feel, but they've upgraded to Basset ice cream and now takes credit cards (a huge convenience for us). I'm glad to see that they kept my personal fav, the Skookie, on the menu (ice cream served on a freshly made giant skillet cookie). My friend tried and really liked their new ice cream pocket, which is ice cream sandwiched between an L & M glazed donut. i'm glad that we have a mom and pop option still around the neighborhood. read more

At 9:00 on a recent Sunday night, I was in need of some quick comfort food after attending a nearby funeral. Suffice to say my options were limited at this off-hour, so I wound up at this little shop in the center of (for me) never before visited 'downtown' Riverton. I'm happy to say that by keeping things simple and reasonably priced (coughcough-overhyped Gelato places that require a bank loan for a small cup and try to dazzle you with inexplicable flavors that have no business in a freezer-coughcough), Nelly Bly's came through big time. Simplicity was the watchword here and the hifalutin shops could learn a lesson. Admittedly, it's pretty hard to go wrong with a warm, freshly baked chocolate chip cookie topped with two scoops of ice cream, pineapple and wet walnut toppings, and a swirl of whipped cream with a cherry on top. But if the formula works, why mess with it? Nelly Bly's doesn't and provided exactly what I needed on a depressing Sunday night in late summer. Being 53 years old, I was, of course, 35+ years older than everybody else in the place (a sprinkling of kids as closing time approached), which apparently is the norm here. So if you're self-conscious about that kind of thing, stuff your pockets with a pile of twenty dollar bills and head to those other places. I can only say that once I tucked into my yummy plate of gooey goodness, satisfaction reigned. And the local kids were perfectly behaved and polite. I paid my bill, left a generous tip, and still had the $2 I needed to make it over the Tacony Bridge and head home. If I'm ever in the area again, I'll return to Nelly Bly's. I might even make a special trip. read more

Hidden gem. They have fresh waffles of two sizes that partner with a wide array of excellent ice cream. You can basically have anything you want from the ice cream world and boy is it good! The shakes are excellent as well if you want something simple and quick. I recommend the peanut butter chocolate. read more

Great Old Fashioned feel. The kids love watching the old cartoons on the movie screen while they eat their huge scoops. The sundaes are big enough to share. Little pricey but nice for a treat. read more

Ok...the ice cream is great, but so are a few other local places. Wife and I got one 2-scoop cone, and 1 1-scoop cup of ice cream that set us back $8. A bit much. read more