Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    New Fish Plus

    3.6 (5 reviews)
    Closed 9:00 am - 7:00 pm

    New Fish Plus Photos

    You might also consider

    More like New Fish Plus

    Recommended Reviews - New Fish Plus

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    1 year ago

    The Fried Seafood Is Always Delicious And Tasty Whenever I Have It! I'm going to try the steamed crawfish my next visit.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Candice N.
    13
    102
    56

    3 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 1
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    7 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    7 years ago

    I always buy fresh fish from here and I'm never disappointed. They keep a good variety of local seafood at a reasonable cost.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Mark A.
    299
    396
    2181

    11 years ago

    Helpful 2
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - New Fish Plus

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Seafood Markets 50,816 times last month within 10 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Central Fish Market - Fried shrimp (1lb). Delicious!!

    Central Fish Market

    4.7(32 reviews)
    2.6 mi
    $$

    My go to place for seafood! Amazing fried shrimp and broiled salmon seasoned to perfection. A…read morefamily owned and operated establishment run by kind, friendly folks. and am never disappI get cravings for this place and the food is always on point. It's always delicious and reasonably priced. 10/10!

    Central Ave is full of lil shops that serve cultural food, hair salons, nail shops, bodegas. This…read morespot is hidden among them, but is a helluva gem of a fish spot. If you walk close enough to it, you can smell the loveliness of fried or grilled fish, and if you peek inside there's usually one woman at the helm, cooking and frying and grilling fish like she loves it, but a 7 day rest she'd love even more. I smile at her with my eyes and I'm very patient with whatever speed she makes my food. The food prices are reasonable, and whatever you think you're gonna get for the money you've paid is nowhere near the amount of food you get. No matter how many times I've ordered from them, I still am hella surprised when its presented to me. Fried with just the right amount of crunch, no extra oil, the fish mounted on top of a mountain of seasoned fries, which are also great tasting and all the items fried have their individual taste, (cuz Ugh I hate it when everything in one meal that's fried tastes like the oil its fried in). Last time I went, I ordered flounder, & she said she didn't have any, but had basa. When I asked for scallops, she said they were frozen & gave a lil Mama Frown, so I got calamari instead. WONDERFUL. (see photos) Now... I dunno what the real name of this spot is, but the receipt says "The Height Fish Market" Meh, doesn't matter, I know it as the only spot for great seafood. Go git it.

    Photos
    Central Fish Market - Salad. Perfectly seasoned!

    Salad. Perfectly seasoned!

    Central Fish Market - Whole grilled Bronzini, rice, salad tahini sauce, babagonush, fried shrimp with fries and two drinks for $39.

    Whole grilled Bronzini, rice, salad tahini sauce, babagonush, fried shrimp with fries and two drinks for $39.

    Central Fish Market - Grilled Bronzini for $10.99. so delicious!!!!

    See all

    Grilled Bronzini for $10.99. so delicious!!!!

    Lobster Place - The cooked lobster experience.

    Lobster Place

    4.2(1.6k reviews)
    4.0 miMeatpacking District, Chelsea
    $$

    You really can't beat the raw bar at Lobster Place which is located right in the middle of Chelsea…read moreMarket. There's plenty of seating, both tables and bar seating. To order, you fill out a paper sheet for the raw bar items and place a separate order in the back for kitchen fare. Every time I've been here, the seafood has been incredibly fresh and delicious. It's definitely not cheap though and our most recent meal came out to almost $500 after tip. We ordered: - 2 bread bowl NE clam chowders ($15 ea)--delicious and hearty. The peasant loaf bread was fine and everyone enjoyed it - 6oz lobster roll ($38)--a delicious cold lobster roll with a mayo-based sauce, great flavor, and a soft buttery bun - 20 oysters ($3.75 ea)--all fresh and delicious, primarily East Coast oysters although they occasionally have some West Coast ones. Fisher's Island was akin to drinking straight sea water - 5 Peruvian scallops--small and sweet with a strawberry sauce - 2 California uni ($19 ea)--one was incredibly sweet, clean tasting, and much better than the other, which was slightly more bitter and minerally - 2 diver scallops ($15 ea)--drizzled with olive oil, yuzu, and sea salt - 8 shrimp cocktail ($3.25 ea)--one of the most unworth things I've tried in recent times because the shrimp was so cold it tasted barely thawed and was watery with almost no flavor You order at the counter or via paper ticket and they bring everything to your table. Staff have always been friendly and service was great. They sell fresh fish and some frozen specialty items like escargot. I don't know if anything would ever deter me from coming back here :)

    High quality fish dishes and great staff inside Chelsea Market. Rating 8/10…read more Pros: Quality, seating, staff, good smell. Cons: Mediocre Sangria, smallish size, price.

    Photos
    Lobster Place - A fun and relaxed raw bar atmosphere.

    A fun and relaxed raw bar atmosphere.

    Lobster Place - The raw bar spread.

    The raw bar spread.

    Lobster Place - Great craft beer selection.

    See all

    Great craft beer selection.

    Scale Fish Market - Shrimp cocktail

    Scale Fish Market

    4.7(46 reviews)
    1.4 mi

    Food (4/5): We ordered the catch of the day sandwich, truffle fries, and crab cake sandwich. The…read morefood was quite delicious and fish fresh. My favorite was the crab cake sandwich. The catch of the day was solid but could be more flavorful. The fries weren't my favorite as you couldn't really taste the truffle. I also generally prefer thin cut fries. Service (4/5): The staff were nice and friendly. The place was very busy when we went on Sunday late afternoon around 530pm. Some of the items like the fish and chips weren't available because the shop was short staffed. The food took around 25 min to come out due to the short staff. Ambiance (5/5): Chill fish shop ambiance with indoor and outdoor seating. Nice relaxing music playing and cool fishing decor. Tables inside are a bit cramped while outdoor tables have more space. Spot is pretty busy.

    We were thrilled when Scale opened a store in our neighborhood where we can buy fresh fish at any…read moretime. We used to buy fish from Citarella in Manhattan, but now we're glad to have a local store that sells top-quality fish. We often buy their salmon to make oven-baked salmon with red bell peppers and onions over jasmine rice. Their salmon is always incredibly fresh, moist, and tasty. I also love their oyster po' boy and 'fish of the day' sandwiches. I highly recommend Scale's fish to anyone who lives in or visits Jersey City.

    Photos
    Scale Fish Market - Menu that day

    Menu that day

    Scale Fish Market - Brown Butter Warm Lobster Roll

    Brown Butter Warm Lobster Roll

    Scale Fish Market - Storefront

    See all

    Storefront

    New Fish Plus - seafoodmarkets - Updated June 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...