Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    New Garden Restaurant

    4.0 (4 reviews)
    InexpensiveAmerican

    New Garden Restaurant Photos

    Business Info

    You might also consider

    More like New Garden Restaurant

    Recommended Reviews - New Garden Restaurant

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration
    Photo of Rachel S.
    213
    11
    3

    3 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    7 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    14 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    11 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for American 22,357 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Emily - The Emmy Burger

    Emily

    4.0(997 reviews)
    2.2 miClinton Hill
    $$

    We loved the food…read more Came here on a saturday for lunch before the world cup. We arrived just when it opened I think. The place was pretty quiet. Friendly waitress greeted us and sat us immediately. Menu's came out and they recommended a pizza and burger. We agreed and ordered. Place started to pick up and get busy immediately after we ordered. Food came out pretty quickly. We each had a burger. Not a lot of options on the menu but we all tried the emily burger. It was worth it. Think, juicy and with an amazingly unique taste. The ingredients were high quality, the burger cooked to perfection. The table also split the modern pizza (I think). Not sure what to expect from this one but turns out it was perfect, unique and delicious. The cheese taste really shined through. Overall, we were super happy with the food here. Stop by if you have a chance.

    Absolutely loved our experience at Emily in New York! We ordered two burgers and a pizza to share…read morebetween four people, plus a bottle of white wine, and everything was delicious. The burgers are definitely famous for a reason they were so good! The price is a little on the high side, but honestly, it's worth it. I would 100% recommend it. They also have a lovely outdoor patio, and we were able to bring our dog, which was a big plus for us. The service was great and everyone was very friendly. Definitely a must-try if you're in NYC!

    Photos
    Emily
    Emily - Emmy Burger

    Emmy Burger

    Emily - Karaage

    See all

    Karaage

    Brennan & Carr - Roast Beef Sandwich

    Brennan & Carr

    4.0(896 reviews)
    4.3 miSheepshead Bay, Midwood
    $$

    It's an old school restaurant with a dark dining room that seems like it's been there forever and I…read moremean this in the best possible way. The service is impeccable, the wait staff is well versed in the menu and will offer help if you don't know how to truly get the best sandwich that you can. The star here is the roast beef sandwich, it's moist and flavorful and cooked absolutely perfectly. My suggestion is to order it with cheese and have it dunked in the au jus. I prefer what they call a "knife and fork job" where the sandwich, the meat the bread is all dunked and comes out in a river of au jus. They make amazing sides, I typically go for the onion rings and corn fritters which are tasty, fried nugget of sweet corn and they are delicious. Do note, they only take cash and sometimes it takes a while to get your food but in the end it is so very worth it.

    Though I grew up walking distance from this restaurant, I'd never been. And it's not new! Brennan…read more& Carr was established in 1938. Curious about the "famous" Brooklyn roast beef war -- yeah! it's a thing! -- T and I decided to see for ourselves. (Once I try the competition I'll weigh in with my vote.) With a reputation built on beef we ignored other options and researched how to order. You can get double dip, "dingle-dangle" (don't ask), cheese/no cheese ... it was confusing. We both went with rare roast beef, cheese and onions. T asked for his double-dipped in gravy. Yum! Short of five stars, but yum nonetheless. We ordered two unhealthy sides which added to the decadence of our lunch: corn fritters and onion rings. If you only get one, go with the fritters. The place is busy. You'll likely have to wait a bit -- but I found it interesting to watch the guys at the counter work. Service was friendly and attentive. Unlike someone's comment about paying blind -- not so. We were given a check with an accurate breakdown of what we ordered. Prices are posted. And yes -- cash only.

    Photos
    Brennan & Carr
    Brennan & Carr - Garguilo burger with dipping jus on the side!

    Garguilo burger with dipping jus on the side!

    Brennan & Carr - Menu

    See all

    Menu

    Nura

    Nura

    4.4(230 reviews)
    4.4 miGreenpoint

    One of my favorite meals I've had! Everything was absolutely stellar. From the wine to the ceviche…read moreto the king oyster mushrooms to the fish! The ceviche was probably the best ceviche I've ever had in my life. It was blood orange based, but the citrus was really well balanced. The king oyster mushroom dish was soo delicious. The sauce and the texture of the mushrooms were to die for. I've salivating thinking about them right now! The fish was also so amazing. The bottoms were so crispy, it was almost like it was a layer of potato chip! Really great texture, and the fish meat was cooked to perfection. Really sad that they're closing, but looking forward to whatever the chef/restaurant team does next!

    Our food experience at Nura was a bit of a mixed bag, but when I think about the total package with…read moreambiance, environment and service, I feel like it earns four stars. It's a beautifully designed space, and we went in the evening so it was dimly lit and had good tunes, contributing to an intimate and cool vibe. The service throughout was good both by our primary server and the rest of the team that was bringing out dishes. For the food, we did not feel that it was a strong start, but the ending was great! The first dish to come out was their cornbread, which we agreed was very light and had a super tender texture, but there was just nothing special about the taste profile to us. The second dish were their prawns. We couldn't put our finger on the off-putting flavor in there, but we agreed that something just wasn't right and almost tasted spoiled. You also had to work a bit to dissect the prawns and remove the heads and skin. To work for it and then not enjoy the taste wasn't a great combo for us, unfortunately. It started turning around with their sweet potatoes, a type I'd never had before that were "baby" and purple on the outside while white inside. They served the potatoes with a gorgeously whipped Greek yogurt that added the exact right amount of tang to balance the sweet potato and the herby topping. The stars of the night were the coconut basmati rice and the lamb shank. My goodness! The rice dish was so complex from a flavor and texture profile and just hit all the right notes for us, and that lamb! Definitely one of the best lamb dishes I've had - Impossibly tender and seasoned to perfection. One other note I'll make regarding drinks is that they did not have a strong wine list. I ended up ordering a red, but later heard our waiter recommend against getting their wine to another table and suggesting their cocktails and mocktails instead. Just something to keep in mind if you're a wine lover!

    Photos
    Nura - Coconut gelato 10/10

    Coconut gelato 10/10

    Nura - Ribs

    Ribs

    Nura - Bread basket and assortment of spreads

    See all

    Bread basket and assortment of spreads

    The Corner - Crème Brûlée French Toast

    The Corner

    4.3(59 reviews)
    5.7 miBay Ridge

    I found family and culinary excellence on one block. I walk…read morein and I am greeted by name.. The owners also run "The Kettle Black" and "Old School Italian Restaurant". I feel like I am with my Italian friends and family in Corona,NY. There is nothing but love in all three restaurants. They have everything covered. The staff are a beautiful group of "International", young people. The tastes of the food and the creativity, blew my mind. The Crab Cakes are the best I have ever had! Food wise, Bayridge rivals Manhattan. The female staff made me fall in love! They make this old man feel special. Drinks are awesome and inventive.

    visited this establishment on a few different occasions (brunch and dinner service). Certain…read moredishes were overly salted and the others were mediocre. The fried calamari could've been less oily, as this took away from the crunch; also slightly overcooked. Baked clams were decent. Salmon was cooked to perfection. Pizza was great! They reheated for us, since our group was too busy chatting. Desserts - phenomenal! Drinks- ehh. Brunch menu - French toast was decent. The salmon over hash brown , was lacking a touch of something , couldn't pinpoint what was lacking. Chicken and waffles, decent, wasn't the best I've had. Service- jonathan was our waiter during brunch and also our bartender. He's GREAT! During service dinner, we had a female waitress and I felt she lacked attention to details and couldn't flag her down when we wanted something. Overall, service is a hit or miss , I guess? If you're looking for an intimate dinner, nope. Love their vibes and music playing in the background. You might need to "shout"'to hear

    Photos
    The Corner
    The Corner - Burger Royal

    Burger Royal

    The Corner - Old School Italian

    See all

    Old School Italian

    The Commodore

    The Commodore

    3.8(689 reviews)
    3.7 miWilliamsburg - North Side
    $$

    Came here around 6pm, and I originally wanted to sit outdoors because I had a two year old with me,…read morebut all tables were claimed and inside was practically empty! Later, I noticed they began checking IDs, but we made it just in time. It filled up quick as we ended our dinner around 7:30. We chose the Commodore because I was craving their fried chicken. In my younger days, I frequented here often. It's somewhat like I remembered it but with outdoor seating. Self-service, order at the bar. The fried chicken is still yummy. Unlike my younger days, I branched out to the black-eye bean soup, which was pretty tasty and makes it a better-balanced meal. I ordered The Commodore (pina coloada) for old time sakes, which was refreshing for a hot day.

    Wow! The Commodore is hittin!' A friend told me about The Commodore a year ago and I finally made…read moreit and glad I did. You would do well to arrive earlier that 8PM on a Friday to find a place to sit. I managed to catch a seat at the far side of the bar in the corner after several people departed. There is seating out on the sidewalk and the bouncer will ask for your ID, which, at my age, is a compliment and I am happt to show my ID. It's a busy place with a great playlist. The energy on a Friday eve is quite tangible and palpable. The bartenders are busy until the surge subsided around 9PM. Note: they are making frozen cocktails with their Vitamix. Here's a place where you can really chill during the hot summers and I have my mind on a frozen spicy marg next time I am here and there will be a next time. The young lady took my beer order and food order for the Chicken Plate and the Wedge Salad. They have a small selection of beers on tap, probably about five or six from what I saw. My friend who told me about The Commodore was more emphatic about the food here and now I understand why. The wedge salad was fresh and with all the blue cheese dressing and crumbled bacon to satisfy your cravings. A hard boiled egg sliced in half and plenty of cracked black pepper amp this salad up. I devoured it all and it worked well with the chicken plate, comprised of three chicken thighs fried to an ultra-crisp, served with three small biscuits and three ramekins of hot sauce, chili oil saut, and I believe melted butter for the biscuits. I never tasted that ramekin. You might think the hot sauce is go to, but check out that chili oil sauce with its mix of heat and sweet. That's your go to sauce for this crispy chicken. The chicken may not be as seasoned as one would find with soul food or southern kitchens, but it more than makes up for it with that audible crispiness. The three chicken thighs are huge and quite satisfying. It was all so good that I ordered a chicken plate to go! I can well understand why my friend gives The Commodore a high rec and so do I. I should be here on the regular and that salad and chicken plate, with a few frozen spicy margs or whatever is your pleasure, will be in repeat. Great with friends or your girl on a date if she can catch this vibe. The people working behind the bar are working hard and they do so with a great attitude. Tip them well. The Commodore is every bit of four stars!

    Photos
    The Commodore
    The Commodore - A German Pilsener, chicken plate and wedge salad for the win and my satisfaction.

    A German Pilsener, chicken plate and wedge salad for the win and my satisfaction.

    The Commodore - She stuck outside cuz no ID, so don't be a chump and bring yours

    See all

    She stuck outside cuz no ID, so don't be a chump and bring yours

    Sunday In Brooklyn - Incredible pancake and the cutest latte in all existence

    Sunday In Brooklyn

    4.0(1.7k reviews)
    3.9 miWilliamsburg - South Side
    $$

    I'm obsessed with Sunday in Brooklyn!!! Everything about our visit was enjoyable and lovely. We had…read morea reservation and got our table right away. It was a warm day in the city so we opted to sit inside. Because it was my friend's birthday, we were given a little card and they gave us a candle alongside the pancakes! The server was nice and answered all our questions. We of course, got the hazelnut pancakes! We also tried to oat milk mocha, s'mores espresso, breakfast sandwich with avocado, and the cheddar biscuit. The food looked wonderful and tasted even better. As a southern gal, I was skeptical about the biscuits, but they were buttery and savory and fluffy. They were definitely more of a bready biscuit than a flaky one, but delightful nonetheless. The breakfast sandwich had a great flavor and I liked the option to add avocado to keep it vegetarian. I just wish there were more slices of avocado on it. The espresso was good but nothing too special. The star of the brunch would have to undoubtably be the pancakes. The hazelnut flavor was divine and coupled with a fluffy, cake like pancakes!! I definitely would go back just for the pancakes alone. I highly recommend eating here!!

    Please visit in person. It's an entirely different experience. I wanted a fancy brunch for myself…read more So I ordered the French toast bites (incredible), scrambled eggs (good!), and cold brew with oat milk and brown sugar. Not all restaurants should deliver. And sadly, this is one. Sustainable packaging is great until it's not. Sub the scrambled eggs were melting into the box when they arrived. And had they arrived a moment later, they would have seeped through the box. Fine. I'll just get them out of the box, onto a real play. Ha. They must have been added to the box while they were fresh off a hot pan. A good amount was welded to the box. Annoying, but fine. And then the brew arrived without sugar or (paid for) oat milk. They hate me. It's ok, I'll just drink it black. And that's where 2 stars get knocked off. Worst tasting coffee ever. Cold brew is supposed to be smooth, with very little acid. This was extremely sour! As if it was made previously and had been sitting around for a couple of days. It took me a minute to realize how bad it was. And suffering as a result. Intense stomach pains and tummy issues. From coffee. Smh. I will probably eat there, in person. But I will never trust their cold brew again. Or delivery.

    Photos
    Sunday In Brooklyn
    Sunday In Brooklyn - Hot Chicken Sandwich

    Hot Chicken Sandwich

    Sunday In Brooklyn - S'mores Latte

    See all

    S'mores Latte

    New Garden Restaurant - tradamerican - Updated August 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...