We have been trying the bagels in the area, decided to try this spot today. It was just ok. The bagel toasted with butter tasted like a bagel you get a supermarket. The bagel with cream cheese was a little hard and not as much cream cheese as they give you at other places. That didnt bother me, my coworkers were not pleased. I would say pass on this spot... read more

New York Bagel Stop - Bagel Cream Cheese - Bagels Near Me - New Hyde Park, New York

Yet another bagel store here in New York being run by people who have no idea how to make bagels; not sure if they're even made on the premises. I swear I think there should be a law that says these kind of places should not be able to call themselves bagel stores.I don't know, maybe bodega or maybe convenience store or maybe just delicatessen. One thing is for sure, if you're coming for a good bagel, go elsewhere. The only reason I came here is because the other store a mile away had a broken oven and no Bagels today. One other thing, neither of these stores has a fresh cookie or piece of cake. I just don't know if people are in business to make money; why would you be so misinformed? read more

I cannot believe this place is in business. How are you charging people extra for a special cream cheese that has absolutely nothing on/in it. Look at that bagel!! How is that acceptable! I'm also glad that I had asked for an egg bagel also!! They should be ashamed!!! read more

See all

While I haven't been to NY Bagel in years (I moved to TX) I recently ordered bagels online. The service and price were amazing! No delivery fee, included in the price. Placed the order on Sunday and had my bagels Wednesday. They were fresh and delicious!! I would highly recommend ordering for them. read more

the bagels have a weird taste to them. They are incredibly dry. I think this bagel place is under new management and they have changed their bagel recipe. read more

Oof. Some businesses insert "bagel" into their name when they should use other terms like "fried bacon sandwich joint" or "potato chip haven". New York Bagel Stop hasn't quite figured out yet what they want to be when they grow up, but I don't think it's a bagel shop. There are a few desperate selections (see pics) of both bagels and cream cheese as well as some egg sandwiches choices. But navigating the ordering process is like stumbling into a vintage Keystone Cops episode: three people behind the counter bumbling into one another, phones going off, general confusion and an insistence on the customer repeating every order 2-3 times. By the time we were finished ordering we just wanted to flee... which is just as well because there is no seating. But there are protein bars! Half of an entire shelf is devoted to them. The other half of shelving is empty. Just strange. read more

I was in the need a good bagel ... my trusty yelp app brought up New York Bagel Stop this is a little store only 3 tables and seating for about 8 there bagels are REALLY good as in my own way of reviewing a bagel means you can it it on its own as in plain. Cleary super fresh I had a egg & cheese on plain bagel hot & fresh They have nice breakfast specials posted and the prices are good. 4 bucks and you have a hearty bagel sammie and coffee or tea I love this bagel store more then many others why...because the women working there as friendly you can see they truly take pride in their food. Everyone is wearing cute aprons you know there is something to be said about everyone looking spiffy. Such a happy atmosphere in the shop. I took home some bagels gosh they were so good I will be back 6 bagels and I was told please pick another you get one! take note this is a cash only read more

New York Bagel Stop - Bagels Near Me - New Hyde Park, New York

See all

Bagels here are actually pretty decent above average. And $1 each (no CC) makes them much more reasonable than hand rolled up the street. $2.50 with CC. However I was disappointed by the breakfast sandwiches. $4.50 for a BEC (can add coffee for $0.50) makes it an appealing deal but sandwiches themselves weren't very good. Average, were a step above a city bodega BEC but not quality to charge nearly $5. Also cash only, there may be signs but didn't see any. read more

New York Bagel Stop - Bagels Near Me - New Hyde Park, New York

See all

there's a lady who works there, she's very rude and passive aggressive towards not only customers but even those who deliver. The food isn't even worth the buy, the lady wouldn't wear gloves and not only that but I found a hair in my food. They don't follow NYC 3-1-1 Food Standards. It was horrible, I don't recommend this store. read more

I been looking for a good bagel place since my old favorite bagel shop closed down in Woodside, Queens. This place is not bad they have specials for breakfast until 10:30am everyday. I got there around 10:45am and paid $3.75 for a sesame bagel w/cheese and eggs. For me that was pricey because I never paid more than $1.50 for a bagel even with my editions at my old bagel shop. The owner was really nice, she was definitely friendly. As for the bagel it was good and fluffy. I have this thing with bagels they have to be big and fluffy. Some of the bagel shops not sure what it is make bagels that look anorexic . Overall it's worth trying this place out for breakfast since you probably get more for your . read more

Best bagels!! Owners super nice and attentive. I am now a regular! Do not order the garlic bagels, they are all mine!! read more

New York Bagel Stop - Pumpernickel Everything!! - Bagels Near Me - New Hyde Park, New York

Good coffee, rude employees. Some advice for the workers there: do not give unsolicited comments on your customers appearance. Do not tell them they have to get haircuts when all they ask for is food. I won't be coming back. read more

This place not only messes up your order, not make things right but they have roaches..... infested. Don't eat here!

One of the nicest bagel shops I've ever stepped inside Everyone was super friendly, the owner knew everyone and even played with some kids that came in AND she knew their names!! Great cheap food, fresh bagels, eggs here are very fluffy and not greasy!! read more

New York Bagel Stop - Egg and Swiss $3 (FLUFFY Eggs!) - Bagels Near Me - New Hyde Park, New York

See all

Old owners where great fresh bagels nice and hot new owners not so good i have been there 2 times Both times shelfs where almost empty and 3 out of the 6 bagels where hockey pucks check bag before you leave read more

Great bagels and prices. Staff is warm amd kind. cash only be prepared and get there early they run out early.

First time and love it! True NY breakfasts.. got myself Bacon, Egg and cheese, my kids a BLT and the softest croissant with a delish and giant iced coffee and it came out to less than 20 bucks!!! Will be coming back, Super nice people too! read more

See all

Awesome Great prices Friendly service They'll have your coffee order remembered after the first time you go in read more

Stopped in early Sunday morning. Great everything bagel with veggie cream cheese. Will definitely be back read more

Ordered 2 hero's , they didn't even put Mayo , or the ham on the hero which it comes with! I don't know if they tried to pull a fast one or tried to scam me! Very disappointed and I paid like 25 bucks for 2 hero's! Do not recommend buying from them ! read more

Delicious bagels and friendly staff. We've been to a number of bagel shops in the area to find the best one and this place sure fits the bill. The bagels are always fresh. We get ours toasted so it is always perfectly crispy on the outside and chewy on the inside. They have a number of cream cheese flavors but our favorite has to be the scallion with lox. We love both flavors - what a brilliant idea to combine it! The only caution is with the lox - at times it can be a little to fishy and overpowers the bagel. read more

First time here, very good egg sandwich spot. Not sure about the bagels but great BEC and ice coffee. Quick and convenient! read more

New York Bagel Stop - BEC SPK - Bagels Near Me - New Hyde Park, New York

See all

If I could give zero stars I would! Had company over the weekend for breakfast, bought a dozen bagels and they were horrible!!!! We bought them at 10 AM Sunday so wasn't that we came in the afternoon and the bagels sat out all day. Well, I believe they sell day old! Every single bagel was hard and stale! If I hadn't had a full house we would have brought them back. Do yourself a favor and go elsewhere! read more

Mediocre service. Limited options. Didn't even have certain things that were being advertised by themselves. No fork or napkin for takeout. Unseasoned food. And lastly hair in my food! Always was curious as to how this place was gonna be. DISSAPOINTED! Save your time. read more

What a pleasant establishment -- fresh and delicious bagels and quality cream cheese, and the owners are very nice. A great way to start a Sunday morning. read more

Love this bagel shop! Love being greeted with "Hello honey!" every morning. The cheerfulness of the staff is infectious. So for that alone- I love visiting New York Bagel Stop right before I go in to work. Service is very quick and the bagels are delicious! There's also breakfast sandwiches which I have yet to try- but am sure are very good as well. There's a large selection of drinks and a few small tables for eat in dining. *Cash only! read more

Best bagels ever , not too doughy , not too small just right. Great selection and great cream cheese assortments. I usually get the the toasted everything bagel with salmon and cream cheese...to die for :) . It's very clean and well organized. There are a few tables to sit down and enjoy the food. read more

See all

Best bagels around. Better than A&S bagel because of quality of food and service and price

This is my favorite bagel store. Bagels are always fresh and delicious and the service so warm and friendly. They hand roll the bagels fresh in the back! A real mom and pop establishment with tasty bagels and spreads! read more

New York Bagel Stop - Delicious whole wheat and regular everything bagels!!! Always perfect with so many spread options! - Bagels Near Me - New Hyde Park, New York

I love this bagel place. The owners and staff are soooo ridiculously nice ! They always have fresh bagels and I must say the chicken salad is so good. I have been going there for years and have never had a bad experience! For sure one of the best bagel spots around! read more

Ordered a plain bagel toasted with butter. The same man preparing my bagel was also handling cash and making a tea, all while wearing the same gloves. Totally unhygienic and just plain gross. read more

Stopped by on my way to the bank, and it is a lovely quaint bagel shop. The service is so friendly and the ladies are sweet as can be, I would return for that alone. They have a solid variety of bagels and some interesting cream cheese spreads! I walked out with cranberry cream cheese, and it was fantastic, highly recommend it. It's a great place to get a bite to eat and sit with friends, or to just start your morning off right. I can't wait to come back and try more. read more

Bagels are generally still warm in the morning and the women and gentleman behind the counter are consistently friendly and helpful. Whole Wheat Bagel - Bacon, Egg, & Cheese is the way to go. read more

New York Bagel Stop - Warm Salt Bagel w/cream cheese. - Bagels Near Me - New Hyde Park, New York

I generally eat a bagel every morning. I drive out of my way to have a bagel here. While they may not make the bagels, I like them. There is usually a line but they seem to have enough staff behind the counter to make it very efficient. Try it out. read more

The bagels were not very good. Too much bagel and they are relatively small. The amount of lox they gave was so small that it does not even justify half of the 7 dollars they charged. Normally I would have given this place 1 star but the service was speedy and the ladies in the front were very sweet. I was very disappointed in this place. I am comparing this place to utopia bagel and three sons bagel both of which are several degrees better than this place. read more

Every time I'm in the area I go to the store. They have got a cranberry cream cheese that is to die for! The bagels are just the way I like them nice and fresh and the people there are just wonderful . read more

They have the best bagels! Always taste fresh no matter what time of day!!! Totally recommend!

Delicious bagels and sandwiches. I'm not in the area often, but make it a point to stop here when I do. Also, the owners/staff are very friendly and helpful. As I've sit down to eat, I see that they really know their customers and it looks like they are a staple to the community. read more

This is my bagel and coffee place to go in the morning. The owners are friendly which is a plus. They enjoy what they do. If you need coffee, bagels, or anything else, go to this place ASAP! read more

We've been coming here many times a year and the place is totally consistent with service and outstanding bagels. The croissants are fantastic. Coffee is good. The people that work here are so wonderful, they are kind and they get to know their customers which isn't the case sometimes at other places nearby. They're quick to make friends with the little ones handing out lollipops to them. The prices are fine. We drive past 2 bagel shops to come here, other bagels no longer make sense, these are too good. read more