Picked up 2 prime ribeyes, 2 potatoes and deli pimento cheese for a special occasion. Spent a little over $90 and it was truly worth every bit of it! The butcher seasoned our steaks with the house sauce and it was the perfect seasoning to go with this meal. I twice baked the potatoes and put the pimento cheese inside the potatoes and honestly can say those were the best potatoes I've ever made! Selections at the butcher shop were great! Deli section with meats and cheeses. Seafood options if you don't like red meat. Sandwich and chips to order. Pretty good wine selection. Only con was there was not many champagne options chilled. Thank you for making this meal and celebration one to remember! read more

New York Butcher Shoppe - Prime ribeye - Beer, Wine & Spirits Near Me - Birmingham, Alabama

See all

I picked up a Sub as dinner for later! I'm glad I asked for condiments on the side because I could only eat 1/3 of this massive sandwich at a time. Yes it costed more than Publix or Subway. But it had more protein than Publix and definitely more than Subway! I took everything off the bread and wrapped the fresh toppings up then refrigerated it. Wrapped the bread up tightly and put in bread box. I had that one delicious Club sandwich three different times! Their meat is amazing and I must have a tomahawk from them again soon! read more

Best Italian subs in town! Always fresh, with top-quality meats, cheeses and ingredients, and served on fresh baked bread. All of their curated, artisan sandwiches are very tasty and well-portioned. Service is always friendly and fast. The best choice for hand-crafted, premium sandwiches. read more

Sandwiches are packed with meat, so much that you cannot eat the whole sandwich. Fresh ingredients, friendly service at a great price.

Always great steaks and prepared meal items. Staff is great with makes great recommendations. Have made me a regular customer.

What can I say? High quality products, fantastic customer service, and the best deli sandwiches you'll find in town. It is on the pricy side however that price reflects the quality of what they provide. Boar's head deli products are just consistently excellent. It was always a special treat as a child for me to get samples at the deli counter weekly with my dad and when boar's head was on sale, it was always a great day, since it was normally not in the budget. I've never been unhappy with anything I've purchased here, and there's always a smiling face at the counter. Added bonus that they carry coffee from the best local roaster in town - Cala coffee, give it a try. read more

New York Butcher Shoppe - Italian sandwich - Beer, Wine & Spirits Near Me - Birmingham, Alabama

See all

Love this butcher shop! Everything is always fresh and full of flavor. Their tuna salad has become a weekly staple in my refrigerator, and they even have beef sticks for my dog -- which he absolutely loves! The staff is always friendly and helpful, and you can really tell they care about quality. A great local spot I'm happy to support! read more

Great sandwiches and butcher shop. Not the cheapest, but always satifies with the quality.

Usually I love their service, this time I wasn't impressed! Had ordered side items for Christmas Eve! Husband went to pick up the cornbread dressing for Christmas Eve! It was frozen! I was NOT told it had to thaw 24 hours! Had my out of town guests wait an extra two hours to eat, also... I was supposed to have Squash casserole, got mashed sweet potato casserole instead. It was too late to call them back. They need to do a better job of communicating' read more

This place is amazing. The sandwiches are massive and high quality. I can't help but grab something in the fridges like Cajun chicken salad or chicken parm whenever I visit. The staff and owner are very friendly. I'll have to try some of the wines and seasonings soon. read more

I love coming to NYBS, best butcher shop I've ever been to. The meats are always fresh, the staff is knowledgeable and not afraid to make suggestions and recommendations. The samiches, are too Yuge big to eat by myself, but somehow, I manage. My wife loves the wine selection and frozen casseroles and soups. Which are quite tasty and a huge time saver, whether midweek or weekend meals. Easy in easy out. read more

I can't say enough good things about NY Butcher Shoppe. I've been going to the one in Cahaba Heights for a long time, mainly to get their huge, delicious sandwiches and occasionally to pick up a speciality item or two for cooking dinner. This new location should be a welcome addition to the Inverness area. They probably have among the highest quality meats available anywhere. Rack of lamb, an entire brisket, whole filet tenderloin, homemade sausages, veal chops, dry aged steaks, you name it. So if you're planning on cooking a special meal, you owe it to yourself to stop here and take a look at what they have to offer. Besides the meats they also sell a good variety of wines, craft beer, seasonings, cheeses, prepared sides, and a few things you may be looking for that could be hard to find like duck fat or truffle butter or a variety of other things you may need for cooking up something amazing. Besides that...the sandwiches. They're huge. They're inexpensive. The meats are fresh sliced daily. You'll have a hard time trying to find something to eat that's as good an overall value as one of these sandwiches. I feel like it's got about 1lb of meat on it and it's only 8.99 which includes a bag of chips. You could solve the problem of world hunger by building a NY Butcher Shoppe on every corner. If this place isn't on your radar it certainly should be. read more

See all

Great place for a special steak to grill on the barbecue. Prime meat cuts with good dry rub if you like.

My coworker raves about the sandwiches at NY butcher. So here I am for lunch. The process to order was very simple with the computers on the wall. Sandwich came up in about 5 minutes. I ordered the Verrazanno on rye, and it was pretty good. Lots of meat and a good amount for toppings based on what I added (Mayo, spicy mustard, black olives, lettuce and tomato). My only complaint is the bread was a little soggy. I think if the bread was sliced thicker the sandwich would be amazing! read more

New York Butcher Shoppe - Verrazzano and chips - Beer, Wine & Spirits Near Me - Birmingham, Alabama

Such a wonderful restaurant. Best turkey sandwich .. so fresh .. great location - Cahaba Heights - .highly recommend!

Hands down, the BEST deli sandwich I've ever had in my life. So good, so fresh, so flavorful. Ordering process is easy & guarantees your order will be just what you want. Staff was friendly. Place is clean. Will be going back soon & often. read more

All I want is a GREAT steak to bbq on my green egg. Very few places in Birmingham have quality beef. I have to add, I am on the Keto Diet, eat only once a day and only have beef once a week. So, that steak better be great. I have two butchers in Birmingham that I achieve that goal. The New York Butcher Shoppe is one. I got two choice ribeyes. Over one lbs each. They were perfect. My only regret was I did not see their Tomahawk Steak was on sale. No regret, maybe next week end. Eat well. read more

Good sandwiches and good cuts of meat but terrible service. I was treated with animosity after purchasing a product and not leaving a 15,20 or 25% tip. Normally, a cashier acknowledges your purchase with a simple "thank you ". In this store, the Rastafarian looking cashier, says nothing and gives you a look of absolute distain if you do not leave a big tip. Keep in mind that he has provided no special service. He simply feels entitled. Good products but very questionable service. read more

A must go to for lunch! Their sub sandwiches are delicious and big enough for at least 2 meals. They also have take home dinners, a large beer and wine selection, and a large selection of meats. I was so happy they opened a place off of 119. read more

This is one of the best sandwiches I have ever had, anywhere. They don't highly advertise that they do sandwiches but it is a very well kept secret. You simply go in and order on the tablets in the back of the store and have some great options. Their sandwiches are also HUGE! They are very generous with the meat! It is easy to split with someone else also. read more

New York Butcher Shoppe - Their sandwiches are amazing! And huge! - Beer, Wine & Spirits Near Me - Birmingham, Alabama

Awesome butcher shop. Huge sandwiches made to order. Lots of pre pared meals to take home and cook Good selection of wine and craft beer read more

Wow, talk about a stuffed sandwich! I ordered the Verrazano, and it was MASSIVE!! All the toppings were delicious. I do wish they had given me just a little more mayo, but I added some homemade pesto to it, and that remedied the problem of slight dryness. Seriously, this sandwich was almost as big as my head. Also, NYBS sells jars of pickled okra which I have been searching for forever! Such a great Southern summer treat. There is also a great wine and pantry selection. I can't wait to go back! :) read more

New York Butcher Shoppe - Verrazano - only half. These sandwiches are HUGE! - Beer, Wine & Spirits Near Me - Birmingham, Alabama

So good! The employees are always helpful. Their recommendations are spot on. We love their pimento cheese dip. I don't even like pimento cheese usually because i don't love mayo, but this is just really fresh and more cheesy than creamy. Bone-in pork chops melt in your mouth. Ribs this past week were just perfect. Gave gift cards for teacher appreciation week because other than meat, you can get a nice sandwich at lunch or a take home meal for dinner from refrigerator section. read more

How is this place still open? They have ready made food that sits for a week and then try and sell it to you ON the expiration date. Chicken salad PACKED 7/1, expires 7/7 per label. I go in on 7/7 and they tell me they won't make any fresh until tomorrow 7/8. Won't be back here. Save your money. read more

Possibly the best sandwiches in town. Seriously. I double-dog-dare you to say otherwise.

Both locations are great! The staff is knowlegable and attentive. Yes they will season your steaks and make them ready for the grill. Their deli sandwiches are a regular and we Love their lasanga. read more

A must ....moved here from Michigan and everything is good here. A great butcher shop but they have plenty of ready to bake meals or sides to take home. Extensive offerings. We love the quiche, the chicken pot pie, Cajun chicken salad and the casseroles in their frozen section. Really can't go wrong. Prices are reasonable and meals delicious. Thanks for all you do to make it a great experience. We support you! read more

Way overpriced and the customer service is lacking. The best butcher shop is Mr. P's in Bluff Park. I cannot comment on the lunch, but I can comment on the price and quality of the meat and other items for sale in the store. I'd suggest going to Whole Foods, right down the street. read more

The sandwiches are hand crafted and can be personalized. One sandwich is too much for one to us so we share. Their forte, is of course the meats! We have never been disappointed with them from the prime rib, fillets to smoked pork butt. Their prepared dishes are good too. Their quiches are not our favorites though. read more

This little place opened close to our house not too long ago. We've eaten there a couple of times and it's always so good. Unfortunately I didn't get any pictures but it's the perfect place to stop and pick up a sandwich. I have to say they are absolutely huge. Both times I've gotten just one sandwich and it was more than enough for both my husband and I to share. They also have an excellent selection of wine! Absolutely recommend you try soon! read more

Generally, this place is a little pricier than other places, but I am more than willing to pay extra for quality. At best, it is hit-and-miss. Whole Foods and Fresh Market are better, but not as convenient to my location. That said, I will not hesitate to go to either of those for my future needs. Just bought 6 pork chops. Two were edible. 4 were nothing but fat and connective tissue. After trimming, I managed to save enough meat for 4. I didn't watch the guy, because I didn't know I would get shafted if I didn't. Enter at your own risk. read more

I got the Manhattan Sandwich, never have I seen so much fresh roast beef on a sandwich! Friendly staff, I will be back again. read more

New York Butcher Shoppe - Manhattan Sandwich, delicious! - Beer, Wine & Spirits Near Me - Birmingham, Alabama

One of the best sandwiches I've ever eaten. One sandwich was enough to share. And at $9.99 you can't beat the price. Loaded with meat, cheese, and toppings of your choice. Yum!! read more

The sandwiches are the only thing I've had here and let me tell you they're phenomenal. The only sandwich I get in Birmingham now. They load it with the meats and condiments. I would give 5 stars but I cannot because the employees can be in a rush or quite rude sometimes. read more

5 Stars, LOVE THIS PLACE!! This is hands down the best sandwich in Hoover. Good quality meats, fresh good tasting bread, and all the fixings you would want on a sandwich, all for a reasonable price. These sandwiches are also huge and will fill you up if you are a big eater like me (or you can split them). I also really like the touch screen order pads they use. The folks that work here are super friendly too. read more