The Verrazano was phenomenal. The quality of the meat was outstanding, the Swiss was perfectly melted and they don't skimp on portions. I left absolutely stuffed. Must-try. read more

New York Butcher Shoppe - Verrazano - Butcher Near Me - Birmingham, Alabama

Best sandwich ever Will be back again It's a nice hidden Gem . Lots of different meats other food items read more

Friendly service. Good selection of products and always willing to help. Plus the food is delicious!

Excellent sandwiches with tons of meat. Fresh toppings and fresh bread. Skip all other sub shops and come straight here.

What a cool sandwich and wine shop! Have lots of pre made meals too that you can heat and serve later. Place is clean and employees friendly You need to check this place out! read more

New York Butcher Shoppe - Butcher Near Me - Birmingham, Alabama

**chefs kiss The hoagies are the best in the area, hands down. Everyone is so nice. I can't wait to go back and do some shopping read more

Honestly, after hearing good things about here, I have to say that the tales woven about the great food here simply did not live up to the reality. Yes, the sandwiches are big and with the amount of meat piled on it, $9.99 was a fair price, but the sandwich was barely heated, so much so that the cheese has not even begun to melt. I had ordered the Verrazano, which is corned beef, pastrami, and cheese, so this is something that you would prefer hot, or at least I would. I was also not a fan of the ordering system where you walk up to a tablet and punch in your order. It was like being in a convenience store. The butcher shop part of the store also looks very high and pricing. It was almost nine dollars a pound for preformed hamburger patties. I don't see myself returning here. There are just better options out there. read more

New York Butcher Shoppe - Butcher Near Me - Birmingham, Alabama

Love the food , everything thing I try is great! Love the pimento cheese. Lasagna awesome, sandwich too good! Hamburger, chicken cordon bleu , garlic green beans. I keep going back read more

Amazing food will be coming back for sure. Nice shop very clean and tidy. Steaks looked wonderful, and had some dry aged steaks as well. Lots of great looking sausages and pork chops crusted. Didn't come prepared enough to take some home. Got sandwiches today staff were friendly and very courteous! read more

New York Butcher Shoppe - Verrazano on sourdough - Butcher Near Me - Birmingham, Alabama

I would also like to add the staff is extremely personable and will help you with any questions you might have. The shop is clean and well stocked with goodies you won't find at your average grocery store read more

New York Butcher Shoppe - Pimento Dip - Butcher Near Me - Birmingham, Alabama

Went by since the seafood shop in the shopping center was closed. Purchased a prime ribeye and a couple of their house made bratwursts. The bratwursts were just OK (at a premium price) but the "prime" ribeye was anything but prime. Purchase and grill prime cuts from other local grocers/butchers and they're always worth the extra $. This was more pricey and just awful. Maybe I caught them on a bad day but won't take the gamble of spending $40 on one of their "prime" cuts again any time soon. read more

Ditto....whenever I come in here, I want to leave with more!!! I haven't ventured into their prepared foods but next stop! read more

New York Butcher Shoppe - Dude....corned beef and swiss on rye? Amazing. - Butcher Near Me - Birmingham, Alabama

Best steak I have had for a while, staff were were very helpful and it was my first time there as I am from out of town, so I googled and found them now telling all my friend in Birmingham how great the service and food was. One stop shop for all you need to Grill and Drink for a great home cooked meal. read more

Excellence selection, special cuts & marrow bones! Great wine selection. Take home freezer meals. Just a great Butcher shop! read more

New York Butcher Shoppe - Butter of the Gods! - Butcher Near Me - Birmingham, Alabama

See all

I ordered the Manhattan and asked for it to be hot. I saw the guy making it stick the meat and cheese in the microwave to prepare my " hot " sandwich. I assumed my hot sandwich with cheese on it would be toasted under a broiler. I told him I didn't want it very hot so he would take it out of the microwave. It was supposed to have a proprietary blend of pepper on the sandwich. It was literally a wad of Boar's Head roast beef with white cheese on it between a nondescript bun. I tried to redeem the situation by broiling it when I got home, but I was just grossed out by the whole situation and lack of nuance. Admittedly, I live in NY and I'm down here for a year, but really - get a toaster oven. I'm throwing out my $10.95 sandwich. Sad about my sandwich and money. :( read more

Always helpful extremely friendly best spot in Birmingham area for fresh cuts of meat! And the sides are number 1! Banana nut bread out of this world. read more

I am new to Cahaba Heights The people that have lived here probably know how great this butcher shop is. This was my second time to buy fillets from them. I paid the extra money for a prime cut. It was so tender you could almost cut it with a fork. They also do sandwiches and have other items like wine to buy. I plan on patronizing them regularly. read more

New York Butcher Shoppe - Prime fillet. The other items didn't come from here. - Butcher Near Me - Birmingham, Alabama

( In reference to my picture I attached) I know it looks like an open face sandwich but it's actually on a hoagie roll. It looks like that because they are very generous with their portions. I liked the whole ambiance of the place. I ordered my sandwich and it was prepared pretty quickly. The taste and flavor from the sandwich was great. I was highly impressed by the place and i am not a life time cut I'm we read more

New York Butcher Shoppe - This is called the big apple sandwich which has ham turkey and roast beef on it. - Butcher Near Me - Birmingham, Alabama

I used Shipt.com to use the New York Butcher Shoppe. Today I focused pre-made dishes. Meatball parmigiana & Veal Parmigiana. I also ordered chocolate & cheese cake. The red sauce was very good. The quality of the meatballs were also very good. Prices were fair and Shipt.com delivery was on time. I now have an alternative to cooking or going out. Just my two cents. read more

Quaint shop that is always buzzing with people. Walk in and you are surrounded by wines, spices, frozen take home items, and geeked by one of the many workers behind the counter. Great place that is always stocked with PRIME Steaks, Chops, Burger and Brisket. Some of the best sandwiches you can get in the city that are so jammed with meat and toppings they lay flat when you eat them. Order the sandwich online to skip the lines at lunch or stop in for a quick steak or grab and go meal for the family. read more

If you are a person who loves a sandwich that is loaded with meat, then you've come to the right place! I ordered the Manhattan which is roast beef and cheese with spices. You can add toppings as well. I added lettuce tomato and oregano. The sandwich was about 6 inches long but about 4 inches high. I would have loved to put it on a scale to see how much it weighed because it was heavy. There were very generous with the cheese too. This is definitely a sandwich that a hungry man would love! They use Boar's Head meats which are my favorite. Roast beef was nice and lean and still pink the way I like it. Sandwich was $8.99 and comes with a bag of Zapp's. Many varieties from which to pick. The sign says New York Butcher Shoppe so I was hoping for a hard roll. So if you are hoping for that as well, fuhget about it! But the roll was okay anyway. You can't eat inside but there is a nice outdoor seating area. Butcher shoppe area looks really fresh and lots of premade meals if you want a quick dinner. They also have beer and wine and lots of other goodies. Check it out! read more

New York Butcher Shoppe - The Manhattan - Butcher Near Me - Birmingham, Alabama

See all

Make no mistake, these guys know their way around a sandwich and take their art very seriously! Their sandwiches are enough for two servings so do yourself a favor go ahead and cut it in half so you can save the rest for later, haha. Their location is easy to find in the shopping mall in Cahaba heights. Lots of parking too. No complaints! read more

See all

Went this weekend to order something we had never had. We were treated with disdain, with very little help being offered. We called several times, trying to get more information and still were left feeling like we were stupid and beneath helping. We went to another butcher and were treated amazingly. All our questions were answered, tips and tricks were thrown in that we didn't even know to ask. AND the exact same product was $10 per lb less. That butcher earned themselves a customer for life! read more

I've come to this spot twice for lunch now and both times were great. I've had the Italian sub and Vezzerano(sp?) - pastrami & corned beef, so good. The Sandwiches are huge packed full of meat and cheese and come w chips and it's all for about $9!They have a nice selection of family meals inside (meatloaf, lasagna, etc.) and lots of other stuff like you'd find in a little market too. There's no seating inside so be prepared to get it to go or eat outside under the covered area next door. read more

New York Butcher Shoppe - Butcher Near Me - Birmingham, Alabama

Way to welcome someone and make them feel like a valued customer on their first trip. I have to say, without a doubt two of the most inconsiderate and obnoxious employees I've ever run into. Congratulations on making a first impression.I was just in there shopping for someone and had the rudest two people ever "help" me. From the attitude when placing the order to the "take care of it after you check out" cashier, I couldn't even inquire about some cuts for dinner for my wife and I. And I won't. Some people genuinely do not need to work with the public and it shows. If I could give this a -5 star rating I would. read more

This is my go to place for high quality steaks and other meats. The selection and knowledge of their products makes unrivaled. Price is in line with the with what your getting. Need something special ask. read more

I like that this butcher shoppe is small and quaint. Great selection. Great service. I enjoy patronizing this business. read more

Wow....simply wow! This place knows how to make a sandwich! They have about 8 house favorites to choose from or build your own. They have order forms at the counter and you simply add on all the extras you want. I Love when places do this. Fresh Boar's Head meat piled high...no need to worry about doubling the meat! Plenty of cheese...plenty of other options (lettuce, black olives, banana peppers, tomato's, onions, bell pepper, etc). The hardest thing you will have to do is try to fold this in half if you get the hoagie roll. Great flavor and huge sandwich! $8.99 gets the sandwich and a bag of chips. Try their brand of sweet teat....some of the best I've had in the area. So glad I found this place and tried it out. Additionally, they can fill your wine/beer needs with a plentiful selection that features local brewery selections. They also have their own branded spices and cooking seasonings as well as several take and bake options. Anxious to try some of the other things they have to offer. My only negative comment would be there is no indoor seating. Plenty of outdoor covered seating is available. Highly recommend! read more

See all

The New York Butcher Shop was a random lunch stop for us on President's Day, after we needed a much-needed break from wedding planning. We wanted to go somewhere new that we had never been before. Jasper ordered the Brooklyn sandwich and I ordered a veggie sandwich. I could have used more fresh vegetables on mine, since it was mostly cheese. Jasper felt his sandwich had too much meat (some too salty) and not enough other flavors or ingredients to actually be appetizing. The open face of the sandwich made it difficult to actually fold the sandwich, and to eat it in general. I did like that the 8.99 price includes chips. They have beer options to go with the sandwiches, and a grocery portion with unique items (e.g.Wine Ice Cream--I purchased two pints of the Raspberry Chardonnay) and even prepared foods (e.g. Eggplant Parmesan!). All in all, I might go back for a sandwich when I'm in this area again if I can't find other options. However, I give 3 stars because I wasn't blown away, especially not such that I would drive out of my way just to come here again. I would only drive to buy sandwich options that offer a full nutritious input with lots of veggies + flavor read more

See all

STEAK AWESOMENESS!!! Heads up dudes - If you want to impress your lady, this is the place ... you can get everything here that you need for a romantic dinner for two! We run into this place a few times a month. It's the best source we've found in Birmingham for beautifully hand cut steaks. I've never had steaks that are quite so tasty (yep! go for the Prime cut - you know you want to and when you do, you won't be disappointed!). They have a tremendous selection of fresh butcher meats - I saw some good looking veal chops yesterday while I was in (definitely not things that I see in the meat case at my local Publix!) - as well as a fine selection of wines, cheese & crackers, veggies and pretty darned good looking sides in their fridge section, like pastas, mashed potatoes, & casseroles, etc. The perfect fixins for a great steak dinner! The fresh meatloaf has its own following as does the chicken pot pie! And, as with all good butcher shops, they make a mean sandwich of only the finest meats (Boar's Head!). You could share one of their sandwiches with a friend (call me if you don't have anyone to share your roast beef sandwich with - I'll have it with spicy mustard, please, and can you pick me up a cold drink while you're there?)! The desserts shouldn't be overlooked either! The staff is super friendly and over the top knowledgeable. I always feel like I was just in there yesterday when I talk to the guy who runs the place. He's just that kind - There to give advice on how to cook nearly anything in the place! Some of you may like that place over in Bluff Park, but that's just a bit far for me to drive, and frankly, I really like the New York Butcher Shoppe better! read more

New York Butcher Shoppe - BEAUTIFUL filets from the NY Butcher Shoppe on MY plate! a lil Olive Oil, kosher salt and pepper is all it takes! - Butcher Near Me - Birmingham, Alabama

Food is pretty good, but I've had two bad experiences with the staff especially a really big guy who looks like he could have played O-line in high school. Today's sarcasm/smart mouth experience went like this. I ordered, went outside, ate and then brought my trash back in to throw away. I asked, "hey do you have a garbage can?" He just have me this annoyed look and said "uhhhhhhhhh, we have several actually." I just kept waiting for him to take the bag I was reaching out toward him, and then he says, "what, were the one outside full?" as if I was really being annoying. A lot of it was tone of voice and facial expressions. Look, I can get rude behavior for free. I don't need to pay for it. How about simple courtesy and assistance like, "sure, I'll take that for you."I think I'll eat elsewhere from now on... read more

This place is a gem. What you can get here: Fresh butchered meat Freshly made sandwiches Already prepared foods cheeses specialty meats wine a selection of fresh vegetables variety of sausages and specialty meats crackers sweets lots more I got the Manhattan sandwich, which was loaded with roast beef and cheese and a variety of toppings on white sub size bread. You can order one of their sandwiches (hot or cold) and fill out how you want it prepared on a printed paper, or you can build your own. The sucker was HUGE. I am talking huge like I couldn't even fit it in my mouth huge. And it was fantastic. You have to be a sumo wrestler in order to finish that thing. I also got already prepared goat cheese mashed potatoes to take home. Today I heated them up in the oven and they were fantastic. Plenty for two people. We also got a slice of Chocolate Lovin' Spoon Cake. To.Die.For. I saw so many things offered, and that just gives me excuses for return visits. The customer service was also very friendly. Awesome awesome place. read more

New York Butcher Shoppe - Butcher Near Me - Birmingham, Alabama

I'd say the previous reviewers are a bit over zealous. We can start with the name of the establishment, there is NOTHING New York about this place. Now that is not a bad thing, but having lived in NY for 20+ years and visited many butchers, this does not hold a candle to them. There are lots of varieties of meat, any that are not beef, pork or lamb are sitting frozen in a case and don't qualify as fresh. Most of the meat in the fresh case (not frozen) is all cyrovac-ed (in vacuum bags) which I am sure increases shelf life but does not say "fresh" to me. There is an entire wall of wine, the only fresh vegetables I saw were potatoes, all other vegetables were in the freezer. There were two types of sausage, italian hot and italian sweet. About a dozen retail cheeses (in plastic packs) A pound of Fresh chicken salad was $10.00 Sandwiches were $7.99 and were large and filled with meat, all made with Boars head meats (that's NY!) and was a great value! It was not the Oasis I was hoping for and 90% of what I could get here is available at Publix. read more

If your looking for a top of the line butcher shoppe look no further. I called all over Birmingham looking for a place to get tomahawk ribeyes and no one would order them for me. I called New York Butcher and they ordered me two amazing Prime cuts that turned out amazing. I will continue to use them for all my grilling needs. Keep up the good work guys. read more

New York Butcher Shoppe - Tomahawk Ribeye - Butcher Near Me - Birmingham, Alabama

See all

Boy is this little shop a treat! I'm a bit sad that we didn't discover this while we actually lived a little bit closer to this area. Ah well, we'll still return! The sandwiches are HUGE (as a sign on the front door indicates). It's no joke either. The Mrs and I split a sandwich (wasn't starving) and had a brew a piece. We sat outside because the weather was nice. What a great lunch date! The meat on the sandwiches is very very moist and tasty! Bread is good, beer was tasty and you can't quite go wrong with Zapp's Voodoo chips!! I actually haven't read the other reviews to come before me, so I'm not sure if this has been mentioned but this place really reminds me of Mr. P's. That's a compliment if anybody from New York Butcher Shoppe reads this. The service was great, friendly, genuine and personal! Great customer service can do wonders for a visit anywhere! We didn't take advantage of any fresh meats for purchase, but wouldn't be opposed to it at all if they are as fresh as the deli meats. There's no reason for this place to have any less than 5 stars. Great food, great service, great locale, great selections, great time! read more

See all

I have always had a great experience with my purchases here. Butchers are extremely nice and knowledgeable. Feels like they are actually there to HELP you more than just sell you meat. I am a Big Green Egghead and this is the only place I'll buy meat for smoking. They've provided me with excellent Boston butts, briskets, steaks, sausage, ribs, and T-bones. Not to mention, their ground beef is the best I've ever had. I've cooked burgers for people and they come to ask me where I got the meat. It's delicious. The prices are a bit higher than what you'd pay at the grocery store - but the quality is worth it. You get what you pay for. Check out my picture of their Boston butt in the photos and then compare that to your Publix butt. Case closed. read more

New York Butcher Shoppe - 6.5lb Boston Butt from NY Butcher Shoppe - Butcher Near Me - Birmingham, Alabama

Great cuts of meat. Awesome staff. The damn biggest sandwiches I have ever had and they taste amazing, piled super high with Boars Head meat. The frozen meatball Parmesan has become a staple on our busy nights for dinner. read more

Twice this has happened where they sell me "prime" $40/ lb filet. They have strings around meat holding it together that looked more like beef tip. I posted a picture and hope you can see it. Not your typical round filet but a long piece from the butt end of the meat. I took it back and they argued with me and tried to educate me on tenderloin and said they would get it in a restaurant like this. Finally they replaced it but I don't trust them because they offer "choice filet" and the "prime" is hidden behind the counter and they say they cut to order. Not that I would truly notice the difference. The steak they replaced mine with was not that tender though. I have been a long time customer and won't be going back. I didn't want to write this review but now that it's happened twice and the owner was confrontational I feel you need to be aware. read more

New York Butcher Shoppe - Butcher Near Me - Birmingham, Alabama

I get a sandwich from here almost every week. Every time I am amazed at how much food they can fit in a sandwich. I have had a turkey sandwich, a roast beef sandwich, a tuna sandwich, and a chicken salad sandwich and they are all good. I honestly don't think there is anything you could get from here that isn't good. It may seem a little pricey for a sandwich and chips but I promise you will be full and maybe even have half a sandwich left over. read more

New York Butcher Shoppe - Butcher Near Me - Birmingham, Alabama

Always on the look out for a great italian deli...def found one here in the south, to-go sandwich counter, amazing prepared foods to take home to the family..staff super nice..excellant quality food!! read more

New York Butcher Shoppe - The Brooklyn...great sandwich, fresh bread..great price..a must go place! - Butcher Near Me - Birmingham, Alabama