Cancel

Open app

Search

New York Pickle

3.0 (4 reviews)
Closed Closed

New York Pickle Photos

Business Info

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - New York Pickle

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration
Photo of Brian H.
71
423
0

5 years ago

Helpful 3
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

4 years ago

Their half sour dills and new pickles are to die for! And they always have a wide assortment of olives, spreads and other tasty stuff.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of Glenn T.
27
123
0

14 years ago

Helpful 2
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

11 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

You might also consider

Verify this business for free

Get access to customer & competitor insights.

Verify this business

Union and Finch

Union and Finch

4.5
(801 reviews)
0.7 mi
$$

We had an early reservation prior to an in-town concert. The restaurant was packed. We sat by the…read morebar (I never saw the main room). Our light bites food was delicious and the service attentive. Salad was tasty, fries were hot and fish tacos delicious. We didn't have the burgers but they were huge.

We sat outside in what they call the "garden room." The ambience and lighting were cozy and…read morepleasant, and it was comfortably warm despite the 30°F temperature. Unfortunately, there was a strong cold draft at floor level, leaving our feet uncomfortably cold throughout the meal. The hostess was sweet and greeted us with a smile. The food service was unremarkable. Our waiter was not particularly friendly nor personable. The drinks were a weak start. The red sangria was poor. The bourbon cocktail was an odd mix of bourbon, apple cider, and other elements--an awkward, Frankenstein-style whiskey sour that simply didn't work. Worst of all, both drinks were served in thin plastic cups, which immediately cheapened the entire experience. I ordered the falafel sandwich and specifically requested a toasted bun. It arrived not just room temperature, but cold. I sent it back, and it returned burning hot... the bottom soggy... literally too hot to pick up... with no browning or color change, clearly microwaved. Microwaving is not toasting. At that point, the sandwich was inedible. I removed the bun entirely and ate just the falafel, which was dry and largely tasteless. At this point I knew coming back to this restaurant was a mistake. Food timing was another issue. The dishes took roughly 45 minutes to arrive after the drinks, possibly longer. We were all getting annoyed and what started out well when we first walked in turned negative. I wasn't impressed on my first visit years ago... and this second visit confirmed it. Between the poor drinks, cheap plastic cups, ridiculously long wait (with no explanation nor apology), and careless food execution, there's no reason to return.

Photos
Seating area by door.
Seating area by door.
Hawaij seasoned mushrooms on seasoned yogurt
Hawaij seasoned mushrooms on seasoned yogurt
Moroccan Eggs ($13)

See all

Moroccan Eggs ($13)
The Udder Bar

The Udder Bar

4.3
(110 reviews)
0.2 mi
$

The ice cream was so good I FORGOT to take a picture of my flavors.... That never happens. The…read morepeanut butter lover in me was so impressed they had a choco-peanut butter option AND vanilla pb option. Both were fantastic. Went with the vanilla pb which was so fluffy and yummy. Also the coffee was so smooth and creamy. Per usual, the husband got the gluten containing cookie dough and loved it. If we lived locally, we'd be here DAILY. Also appreciated the kind staff allowing us to trying probably too many flavors and the cute ambiance.

I decided to do a quick ice cream run and entered into a slight nightmare. We arrived at…read moreapproximately 8:10 PM. The line was just at the door. We made it inside and waited patiently for our turn to order. Before you knew it, we realized that we were in line for 50 minutes just to get to get two scoops of ice cream. There were six associates behind the counter. Only two were working. The others was goofing off. I wanted to leave, but I also wanted to try this ice cream because I've heard such great things about it I got the rum raisin ice cream because you can't find that particular flavor everywhere. The ice cream itself was a 10 out of 10 for flavor and texture. But my overall experience with The Udder Bar was a 3 for customer service. It shouldn't take almost and hour to get ice cream with 6 people behind the counter. Most likely I will not be returning.

Photos
Interior Decor ~ 7.5.24
Interior Decor ~ 7.5.24
Waffle Nachos 7.5.24 ~ No wasting broken cones here :)
Waffle Nachos 7.5.24 ~ No wasting broken cones here :)
Waffle & Donut Sundae options ~ 7.5.24

See all

Waffle & Donut Sundae options ~ 7.5.24
Sumo Sushi and Japanese Fusion

Sumo Sushi and Japanese Fusion

4.3
(237 reviews)
1.5 mi
$$

Sumo Sushi and Japanese Restaurant is a casual spot that specializes in both traditional Japanese…read morecuisine and fusion-style sushi. Located in Village West on Tilghman Street, it's open Monday through Thursday from 11:00 AM to 10:00 PM, Friday from 11:00 AM to 11:00 PM, Saturday from 12:00 PM to 11:00 PM, and Sunday from 12:00 PM to 10:00 PM. I was looking for a place to grab dinner before going to the movies, and since I hadn't had sushi in a while, I decided to give Sumo a try. Kicked things off with the crispy calamari, which was perfectly fried. It's a familiar favorite, served with a sweet chili sauce that complements it nicely. Next up were the Kani salad and seafood miso soup. While the soup was loaded with seafood, both dishes were fairly average and a bit bland. For the main event, sushi! I tried the Sumo Roll, with spicy crunchy salmon and avocado inside, topped with seared salmon, white tuna, crispy rice ball, and tobiko with the chef's special sauce. I also had the Cracked Lobster Roll, filled with spicy shrimp and lobster, sweet potato tempura, and topped with Kani salad and a Japanese cracker with garlic mango sauce. Both were fresh, delicious, and beautifully presented. Overall, everything was enjoyable. I'd rank Sumo somewhere in the middle among the sushi spots I've tried.

Fast service, although the staff wasn't overly friendly--just kind of neutral. That said, the food…read morewas excellent! Sushi was super fresh with a great variety to choose from. We sat outside, which was nice even in the strip mall setting. Love that it's BYOB. We will definitely return!

Photos
Sumo Sushi and Japanese Fusion
Sumo Sushi and Japanese Fusion
Interior

See all

Interior
Mercatino Italiano

Mercatino Italiano

4.3
(68 reviews)
12.8 mi

Sandwiches and desserts are to die for! We always order the chicken cutlet or steak sandwich and…read moreboth are loaded with meat. Also the rolls are fresh and seeded. Great selection of to go foods as well. South Philly in Quakertown !

Mercatino Italiano was originally named Giacomo's. They were sued by the real Giacomo's and had to…read morechange their name. Giovanni's Pizza & restaurant is next door is owned by the husband of Mercatino's. Both places serve really good food! My bad experience there today was due to how LONG it takes to order, pay for, and get your food. WAY to long. Plus, everything is overpriced. They make you order from one of two kiosks. Kiosk ask some odd questions that force you to go to the counter to ask things like, what is pressed hot? By the time the lady had time to answer my question, my order was timed out and I had to start all over. Then my chicken cutlet ssandwich comes with broccoli rabe, but the kiosk suggested I add it and pay more for it. WHAT? The friendly lady came out from behind the counter to help me with the order. Then she asked for my email address and phone numberto complete the order. WHAT? She claimed I HAD TO input my phone number and email address to complete my order - WHAT??I We argued a minute and I said I just want to buy my sandwich which doesn't require giving out my email and phone numbeI. I finally completed my orderand asked at the counter what's next. The lady behind the counter says here's your reciept, you have to go up front to the cashier pay for it 1st. I said what the heck and she explained someone walked out, not paying so this is their procedure now. So, okay, I walked to the fron register, presented my nvoice and paid. So, again I ask what's next. The cashier hands me a paid for sticker and said go back to the counter in the rear to get your food. Okay, so I walked back to the rear counter to discover they hadn't started to assemble my sandwich yet. So, I milled aroiund with other confused looking customers waiting for their food. 20 minutes later I got my food and FINALLY left. The food is good but very expensive, the staff is friendly, but I'll never go thru that again. Their bakery is exceptional but they get it from La Dolce Vita Italian bakery in Wescoville, it's a great Italian bakery in Wescoville. Their bread comes from NY and itself is worth the trip there. The frozen section is exceptional as well. Just don't order a sandwich unless you have the day off or like me, are retired!

Photos
Mercatino Italiano
Bacon, egg, and cheese on a sesame bagel
Bacon, egg, and cheese on a sesame bagel
Ribeye, Cooper sharp, Sautéed Onion

See all

Ribeye, Cooper sharp, Sautéed Onion

New York Pickle - gourmet - Updated July 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...