I am originally from New York, I was hoping for that foldable ability with the crust. But with that said, the pie was very good, great flavor and ingredients nicely displayed evenly. No stealing from another slice! read more

New York Pizza - New York Special Pizza - Medium 12" ! - Pizza Near Me - Pascagoula, Mississippi

This is our go to pizza place , Great pizza , love pepperoni !! Great sandwiches and chicken wings!! Great service!! We usually drive through and take home read more

Finally a pizza that deserves five stars. Jake is one of the cooks and he truly has a passion for delivering the best pizza possible. The servers also take pride in the customer service and like their job!!! I live in Mobile from Pittsburgh and will definitely will be back. read more

New York Pizza - Yes to this to this PLACE!!! - Pizza Near Me - Pascagoula, Mississippi

Always fantastic service. Nobody is standing in the restaurant without being talked to. The cheese pizza is the best in the coast. They treat the customer first! read more

This is the best pizza in town. I especially like the fresh crust. The service is fast and friendly.

Great food, great people! I haven't found anything I don't like in the menu. Everything is so good!

Not bad. Service was on point and professional. I love thin crust pizza and New York Pizza does it well. This is a order at the counter and self seating restaurant. Wait was less then 7 minutes once seated and it was a busy Sunday Afternoon after church rush. Dinning area was presentable and clean. My friend's order was messed up but mine was perfect. Highly recommend a visit! read more

New York Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Pascagoula, Mississippi

New York Pizza is the only sit down pizza place we have in town anymore. But that's not the only reason you should come here. Located on the corner of Polk and Market there is easy access to the private parking. The building is an old national pizza chain location. The menu is large for a pizza place. There are pizzas, salads, sandwiches, wings and pasta. There is no bar, but there is bottled beer. I like the antipasto salad. It's huge and delicious. The pizza is even better. The dough is chewy, and absolutely fantastic. I love the sauce, the cheese and all the toppings. This pizza really is my favorite. And I have eaten a TON of different pizzas. The prices are great and you cannot beat the friendliness. You will always be thanked and you will always be invited back. read more

New York Pizza - The only place you should get pizza in Pascagoula. - Pizza Near Me - Pascagoula, Mississippi

Let me start by saying my order was a "to go" order. I ordered stuffed shells, shrimp Alfredo pasta,(pasta plates come with 2 breadsticks each), 1 order of breadsticks (4 per order) with marinara and a slice of dill pickle pizza (because I love pickles & curiosity got the best of me) The stuffed shells were very good! They didn't skimp on the cheese, well seasoned & Delicious! The breadsticks & marinara were fresh & good! The pickle pizza was good believe it or not. The crust was NY style, thin, foldable with a slight crisp to the crust. The pickle was not overwhelming, it was pretty mild actually! My one complaint is ordering "to go" the slice of pickle pizza was placed on a paper plate then put in a bag uncovered with cups of sauce and breadsticks, my shells pan broke and leaked. Because of the sloppy packing I had to be extra careful bringing my order into my hotel & it took a couple of trips (not usually a huge deal but it was absolutely freezing today) I'd definitely order again but I'd ask for things to be packaged better. read more

See all

There's nothing like the taste of burnt bread enveloping the steak and cheese sandwich. Pizza we ordered for the kids were fine but sandwiches shouldn't have left the kitchen. read more

New York Pizza - two hot dogs wrapped in foil - Pizza Near Me - Pascagoula, Mississippi

I'm not from here. I make it a point to stop by when I'm in town for work. This is my fourth time now over the past two years and it's been a very good pie each time. The crust is perfectly crispy on the bottom!! Barstool score would be an easy 8.4 read more

We ordered pizza by calling ahead, the people here are awesome and so nice! However when the pizza got to us one them was soggy on bottom for some reason. I normally love their pizza because of the crust but I do not like soggy crust They did get the order right and the service is always fast and they package the food well. I absolutely like the variety of items in their menu I do enjoy this place and the pizza tasted good anyway despite the texture! read more

Solid pizza joint. Everything seems pretty fresh and fairly priced. I've only had the pizza but they do have other things on their menu like wings. Bottled beer available. Seating is decent, and wait time for a fresh pie isn't pretty quick. read more

New York Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Pascagoula, Mississippi

So so disappointing. Looks so good in the pics. Sugar in the crust, sugar in the sauce, no other seasoning to speak of, mid-quality cheese. Cooked on a screen with some kind of oil all over the bottom. If you love Papa John's and dream of eating it in a restaurant, this is your place. Seriously. It tastes like Papa John's. I am not kidding, not even a little bit. Dull, bland pizza. Even the worst pizza I've had in New York beats this by a solid distance. But lots of people like Papa John's, so I'm not going to sit here and say it's terrible. You may find it delicious. Just know what you're getting before you go in. read more

Two words: Pickle pizza. Trust me, everything is good from the single slices to the stomboli to the phillycheesesteak sandwiches. Do try the pickle pizza though, it is amazing and unforgettable. read more

If you like Mew York Style pizza, this is your place. I love that you can go in and grab a couple of slices to go, take it home, and it's still hot and fresh when you eat it. The people working there are friendly, the place is clean, and the pizza is delicious. I also love supporting a local business. read more

I've never had a good experience here, but some reason my girlfriend keeps giving them another try. This latest time we ordered chicken fingers for our toddler and it was almost entirely inedible. Overcooked and dry as hell. We ordered a salad that had more onions than anything else, and a couple slices of bland pizza. We ended up throwing most of our meal out. Not to mention when we picked up our food the employees were either goofing off, cursing at each other or complaining about orders that they had messed up on and had to redo, very unprofessional. Then again I didn't even see any adults around at all, the oldest employee had to be like 24. Needless to say, after numerous attempts to get decent food , we won't be returning. read more

New York Pizza - Burnt/hard as a rock chicken fingers - Pizza Near Me - Pascagoula, Mississippi

**Updated**. 3 of us stopped in for lunch on a Saturday. They were busy but we had a short wait. We had the X-large Chicken BBQ Pizza. They can customize the specialty ones, no problem. We happily devoured the Pizza when it made it to the table. We also had cannoli which were good, too. Now we need to waddle home! I ate here last week. The pizza is better than I remember and is authentic NYC style and taste. Yummmmm. I just got 2 slices of cheese to go so I could easily eat them in the car with a minimum of fuss. I devoured them on the way to Wally World to do some shopping. read more

What is not to love? Family owned, fantastic pizza. The staff is always friendly and the food is always good. I love their supreme and their garden sandwich. Thanks for great food and friendly service. read more

Last minute run with a group of 12 and was right on time before the lunch rush. Ordered cheese pizza, pepperoni pizza and sausage pizza. They were good but not great. And you can also ask for no carbs pizza if you are trying to get your figure right. Chicken wings was really plain and bland. I didn't get what was going on on the chicken wings but they need to do something with it. Service was great though. I'd come back again here whenever I want pizza since it's closer from work. read more

See all

The reason I give a pizza shop five stars is based on the fact that they are the total package. Service over the top, they personally greet everyone that walks through the door. Direct ties to Italy and all their sauces are made fresh daily from their grandmother's recipes. This family run business is a gem. They have a drive up window, serve dine in or carry out, by the slice or whole pizzas, salads, sandwiches, pasta dishes, cold beer, deserts. Family friendly and community minded, I give NYP my best recommendation. read more

See all

Excellent Pizza, Cheesesteak, Stromboli and my fav.... Cannoli! Fast Great Service Casual with comfortable feel read more

When your tired of the franchise pizza places this small town has and your craving dine in pizza check out New York Pizza. This is not a hipster pizza place with video games, entertainment for the kids and pitchers of beer. I was able to dine in and enjoy a beer though. You have to order your pizza and pay up front for your bottle of beer and they will bring the pizza to your table when it's done. They have several selections. I ordered the New York Special Pizza which is a combination with extra cheese. The pizza is ok read more

New York Pizza - New York Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Pascagoula, Mississippi

I had the deluxe pizza. It was really good. The crust has a different texture than most.... Good though ! read more

New York Pizza - Pizza and wings! - Pizza Near Me - Pascagoula, Mississippi

One of my favorite places to get pizza, here in town or anywhere else. It's a blessing to have such a high quality pizza joint in Pascagoula. read more

Well... let's just say... I doubt the owner, employees, or cliental have ever experienced an actual New York slice. To call it such may be a bit of a misnomer. read more

The reviews here are absolutely great five star review I mean it was so freaking great I love it no joke pizza it is absolutely the best that looks and taste are all you need to see how many taste and Lucas are you need to taste and it was amazing best thing I ever had in my life five star rating and a five star cook to whoever cookie whoever designed New York pizza is incredible and love you to death lol lol yea it all good news But it was one thing that was strange the bathroom was terrible but good the soap ran outta in the water was out the water pressure wasn't good at all it was no right or pressure read more

Best pizza in town and one of the best pizzas I've ever had. If you know what real pizza is, there is gonna be grease. People who complain about grease on a real pizza are used to cheap pizza like little Caesar's or Pizza Hut. When you have real mozzarella and pepperoni, they both make a flavorful grease which is as much a dressing as that hilly billy ranch you yee yees eat. New York pizza makes a mean pizza, and their little bread twist are great too. read more

Of the three NY's in this area, this is the best. I say that because pizza is cooked the best, sauce and toppings the best and sandwiches, salads are first rate. Quality is always consistent. Even the "white" pizza is superb. Service is friendly and efficient. Have tried all three spots and always come back to this one read more

The Real Deal!. I detoured off the interstate to try some slices, and it was well worth it. Nice crunch, and good quality ingredients. A very solid slice anywhere along the coast is a rarity. read more

New York Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Pascagoula, Mississippi

I am from NY and live in the Philadelphia region. New York Special.....hands down one of the best pizzas I have had. There is a layer of cheese on top and underneath it is soooo juicy. read more

I ordered a Hawaiian pizza, the crust was tasteless, and all I could taste was the pineapples.

The dough has a great texture and flavor. The New York special is really a tasty treat. No cookie cutter taste here!

I love pizza. I moved to MS from Chicago, three years ago now. And 1) I already have a loyalty aversion to NY style. 2) This is mediocre pizza to begin with. Which sucks since I do like helping out local businesses. And this is meh. Nothing offensive to hate about it or rag on. The place was clean when I picked it up, the pizza was made competently. Just the flavor was unimpressive. You can take canned sauces/pastes and add your own seasoning to it to make it better. I sadly usually choose Pizza Hut over this when I want pizza. AT least with Pizza Hut, you know there is nothing "authentic" about it. Though, when I go west, to Gulfport, to visit my friends, they have a NY style joint there and that pizza (while still gross NY style), is better even the atmosphere is better. I feel like proper NY style has to be in a greasy looking stainless steel clad place with the ovens about 2 feet from the counter. This looks like they occupied a sit-down pizza hut and painted it white. As I said, this is as middle of the road you can get. They know what a pizza is, they can cook said pizza, and they can deliver it competently. It feels like the pizza you'd cook in a culinary class where you'd get marked points off if you tried to add your own 'flair". Also, not priced offensively either. So, even if you do try it, you're not out any significant money. Yes there is a "ma and pa" premium compared to the assembly-line Pizza Hut, but it's not that bad. I can see how locals like this place, but I'm a well traveled man, and I've had proper NY style in NYC, also had the original pizza in Naples. I know me some pizza. read more

Like the pizza. Once you over more than 3 toppings the price doesnt change. I prefer NY style pizza. I recommend.

My husband and I live in Alabama but will be moving to Pascagoula soon. We have dined in this restaurant several times while visiting. They make EXCELLENT calzones! All the food has always been fresh, hot, and delicious every time. The service is always great with such a friendly staff. Can't wait to live closer and eat there more often. read more

Great food and great people! I normally get the New York special sandwich which is really good.

Super nice guy so proud of his background and food! Happy to take menus back to my hotel to share! Get the homemade meatballs OMG!!

Nice local joint for a decent slice. Ate the white pizza and antipasto salad. Good for a road trip stop or a local. read more

New York Pizza - White pizza - Pizza Near Me - Pascagoula, Mississippi

Out of the last three times I have been here, only once did I recieve what I ordered. Twice I was only given part of my order. Both times there was no explanation provided and I was given attitude each time I asked to be refunded for the food that was never prepared. read more