Definitely over priced and not worth the money. We just got in town for work after traveling all day and we were hungry.. Ordered banana peppers as a topping.. got a pizza with green and red peppers. I called and asked if I got the right pizza. Attitudy Judy told me I did, didn't acknowledge the mistake after I asked about it... Large pizza, crispy chicken salad & 2 cannolis... $70... read more

If this is New York pizza, then New York pizza is awful. Maybe just call it substandard pizza? Rude people to boot! It has all the class of a hot dog cart. read more

Ordered a pizza for the first time. We ordered a large pie with olives, sausage and broccoli. It came to $36. I didn't realize it until we left that it was $36. What in the world was so much money?! And the pizza was too doughy and not the best. Way too much cheese. Probably never be back. Way to expensive... read more

We drive 40 to 45 minutes to get here. Their pizza is awesome, food is great, service fantastic. If you know good pizza and Italian foods, you'll agree. read more

Best Pizza in New York Staff are right on it and wait time is fast. I love The boneless wings too. read more

On our way down to Massachusetts and we spotted this tiny pizza shop. it was either that or the McDonald's down the street. Soooo we decided to try the so called "New York Pizza" shop in the middle of NY country. Oh my gosh it's so good!!!!! It definitely is "New York pizza." The sauce is perfect. So much cheese it just falls over. The crust is just right. Not too crunchy or too fluffy. $20 for an 18'inch, I believe it's very reasonably priced. This is was pizza usually cost. If you find yourself around this area stop by for some good worth your while pizza. read more

New York Pizzeria - Cheese Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Lowville, New York

Let me begin by saying how happy i am that i found a real italiano restaurant. We live in Carthage but a trip to lowville salvage yard brought us past this amazing restaurant today. My husband had the calzone pocket which was made perfectly with ricotta, mozzarella, pepperoni and let me add how fricken HUGE this thing was, I ordered a slice of pepperoni pizza and a mixed sub with italian peppers and dressing. If your in the area, just driving through and your hungry and wanting italian then this is definitely the spot! Oh and add a cannoli before you leave!! Delicious read more

See all

I got a slice of cheese here, I found it particularly expensive compared to other similar pizza joints around me. I can't remember the price but it was over $3.50. I found it really strange that the pepperoni pizza looked like it had been a cheese pizza, but with raw pepperonis added to it...? They need to change their cheese distributer, it lacked any flavor regardless of how generous they were with it. The sauce was super sweet and had a strange flavor to it; I could compare it to Ragu. They need to change it or start adding some herbs. The crust had very little flavor, perhaps some more salt. Also a bit thicker than traditional NY style, but I myself don't mind. The size of the slice was nice and large. Until they change the above mentioned, I wouldn't buy from here again. read more

Terrible customer service over the phone. Spent $100 to help in celebrating the moving up of an employee here in our office. Ordered a sheet pizza and 40 wings. Called to let them know people were unimpressed about the pizza. Sauce was too sweet and way to bready!! They wanted me to bring back the oEder then another lady came on the phone to tell me no refund !! And very rudely and loudly .. Other employees could hear her yelling from the phone !! Would definitely not recommend this place. I have eaten at other New York Pizzerias and had wonderful food and experience. Just not impressed , very disappointed , unprofessional manners !! Then to top it off the one loud lady came over to accuse us of mistreating her delivery person? My employee had her sit the pizza on the counter while she retrieved me to sign the receipt. I came around the corner and politely signed the receipt and told her thank you very much and to have a wonderful day!! I'm not sure where the rude came from? Then she challenged me by asking me if I cook ? Why would you ask that of a customer? Completely and utterly wrong in how she conducts her business!! Will not be ordering from them again nor will I suggest anyone else to stop into their establishment in LOWVILLE NY read more

I ordered to-go pizza from this restaurant twice this summer. The first time I looked at their menu and saw that they had a veggie pizza that included broccoli, but broccoli was not an option on the toppings menu...so I decided to get the veggie pizza and ask for meatballs on top....The guy behind the counter thought this was hilarious as apparantly you have to be a vegetarian to buy a veggie pizza. I explained my reasoning to him and went on my way. Two weeks later I tried to order the same thing, as it tasted good. I called it in, 10 minutes later they called and told me they were out of meatballs....someone failed inventory class. I was staying at Chase Lake so I was already on my way into town to get the pizza...so I said fine and figured I'd pretend I was a vegetarian that night. I picked up the pizza and they charged me for the meatballs anyway--FAIL. So this was normal yet very overpriced take out pizza (my veggie with meatballs without meatballs cost $32), with not so great counter service. read more

We ordered a large pizza a little over a week ago and were very disappointed. It was terribly expensive, we ordered a supreme but didn't want peppers, or anchovies. The guy didn't want to eleminate the peppers. I had to pick off the peppers because I am not able to eat them for health issues. I will never go there again. I will go elsewhere . read more

Stopped in with the family (8 of us), after a long hike at a nearby State Park. Service was friendly and fast, and the pizza was very good. Even my wife, a very discerning downstater when it comes to pizza, loved it (made us eat it folded). Try the sweet flavor wings too. Very good. We will definitely come back when we are back in the area next summer. read more

My husband and I just came in for lunch and I was terribly disappointed. I got a pepperoni slice and a "chicken wing" slice (which most places call buffalo). My husband got a cheese slice and a white broccoli. We had to send back the broccoli and chicken wing slices because they were so well done that the cheese was brown and yet they still thought acceptable to bring to us. They brought them out again and the chicken wing slice was disgusting. The cheese was hard and chewy. The crust was unbelievably dry and hard. The pepperoni slice was decent but was reheated as if it were put in an average oven, so the sides were burnt and crispy, not how they should be coming out of a PIZZA oven. My husband's broccoli slice was decent and the cheese slice was actually good. The atmosphere of this place is pretty typical for a real NY pizzeria but the employees and a man who seemed to be the owner do not come off as welcoming or friendly. We made eye contact a few times, so I smiled, and I got an off putting look in return. We definitely will not be returning, at least not for more than a plain slice TO GO. read more

New York Pizzeria - two slices of pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Lowville, New York

This pizza is expensive, but worth it. We normally buy pizza from Mr Subb down the street, which is cheap but 'meh'. This pizza is well made, quality ingredients, and so tasty. I just got a white pizza with garlic, onions and sausage, and it came with gobs of ricotta on it as well. So good. Its worth the extra couple bucks for a real good ny style pizza. I don't really understand why people are giving low review based on price alone. It is pricy, but prices are clearly posted. I looked at the prices before i ordered. If you think its too high, go somewhere else. Its pretty simple. read more

Amazing little pizzeria with so much to offer. The inside is absolutely spotless, as well as the kitchen. Highly recommend coming here after a long hike to refuel! read more

Ate there today. I had a Stromboli roll, my mom ordered a small pizza with three toppings and my husband had 10 wings. We all got a fountain drink. The food was good, but our check came to $53!!!! The food wasn't that good. I asked for an itemized receipt because I thought that didn't sound right from the prices in the menu. Sure enough the pizza was $3.25 more than the price in the menu and my Stromboli was $1 more. When I asked the worker about the differences he said yeah I know they are wrong, but I can't do anything about it. He said the owner is always changing the prices! Also they charge $2.75 for a medium fountain drink. That's excessive. That is not how you do business. So needless to say we will NOT go back. If you're thinking of going there read other reviews where more people have complained about the prices. read more

Not sure how this place can call itself "New York pizzeria" and serve thick crust (dry). Traditional "New York pizza consists of large thin slices. Anyway, the pizzas we ordered were thick, dry and dense. The chicken wings were the worst we've ever had, very small, hardly any meat and very, very dried out. The 'hot' sauce was mild at best and so greasy the sauce actually separated. Do yourself a favor and skip it read more

Their pizza made me sad! The check made me borderline depressed! They are the only pizza place in town, but once you realize that Nice N Easy has better pizza and you can order wings at Tjs you wont want to go there; when you learn the fact that the pizza and wings special comes out to be 40 plus dollars and the above comes out to be 20 youll faghettaboutit (sorry my inner pizza loving italian came out) read more

It is for me, only OK pizza. I remembered this place from many years ago and thought I loved it. My recent experience was not so great. The staff seemed preoccupied and disinterested in me or having my business. Again, the pizza was sub par at best and I have no plans to return, even at a fair or food truck event. Kindness tends to go far with me. I didnt find any here. Oh, doughy bland blah with an ok sauce. Nothing like NYC's Original Rays Pizza. Now thats NY pizza! read more

Incredible! Sauce was so good that I forgot the usual condiments. Had the pizza and chicken parm "tunnel" (hot sub). Real NY style, loved it. Husband remarked multiple times once we left how good it was. Friendly atmosphere and quiet setting. Right on Main St. Definitely stop here if you are passing through! read more

There are alot of Mom and pop pizza joints around the Watertown/Ft. Drum area. This one is hands down the best. The sauce is slightly sweeter and the dough is always chewy and delicious. I have eaten here many times and like to stop by when ever I come through town. Great pizza for a reasonable price. read more

My favorite pizza joint. A little pricey, but that's because Carmello uses the best ingredients. Always consistent and friendly. Have been going there 20 years or so. read more

I don't think I even have enough time to write all the things i would like to say. 1. They will do anything to sell you food. Make up prices based on the day. I called them several times over an ongoing issue over a miscommunication when I placed an order. I was told to mention a "personal size calzone" and I would get it for 5$ during lunch hour because you know, they false advertise on the menu and it's 15$ per calzone and you must pay PER topping but yo wouldn't know that until you see your receipt. Secondly, we figured we would order a pizza, and they fucked it up once again. I called them write up on the phone and the man was extremely nice and offered to fix it and said he would have a credit waiting for me when i got there the next time. I then was there today, and the owners daughter is a rude bitch. I have never met anyone so rude in my life. She has the attitude of a reptile. She claimed she had my receipt hanging on the wall, and according to her note that she made As she pointed in the computer I was getting one credit for one topping and that was it. ( not what her father had told me). He was willing to credit us a pizza. I am over it. She then giggled like a little school girl and walked away. False advertisement, and they make up prices as the day goes on. read more

Stopped in Traveling home. Saw other reviews about it being pricey. In my opinion totally worth the cost. Had Spaghetti and Lasagna. Both were good, especially Lasagna. Best I've had from a restaurant in years, and serving was way to much to eat at one sitting. Had to take leftovers home. Now that it's gone, I want more. Think I would absolutely travel the 50 miles for more. read more

Good local pizza joint. Our waitress was Dana and she was great. Always had a smile and very attentive. We had house salad which easily would have fed three and was very fresh and good. Like the pepperoni pizza! Stop here every summer when we are in town. read more

Way way to two expensive. $20 for a pizza is ridiculous. Stewart's pizza is only $6.00 and is much better. I think fast track pizza is also much better. There cheese is much more tasty than NY. read more

Ate there three times earlier this year. First time was for the Chicken Alfredo and it was good. Second time was for a small broccoli pizza and wings, and again good. The last time was for a large supreme...good. The waitresses though are no good...employer must hire them based on "Casting Couching". The first one was a short blonde and chubby and seemed like she was in the sky somewhere. She treated me like I were 'special'. The second one was a young girl who was overly kind and used way too much hair products. Seemed not to know she was doing. The last one was just competely duh! I had to repeat my order four times to her. Good food, but the girls don't know what there duties are. I'd hate to see what the place is like on the weekend for them. read more

Worst restaurant experience ever! Myself and my girlfriend ordered dinners and we waited about half an hour and they bring out my girlfriends dinner before we get our salads or bread! So her dinner sits there for five minutes before we can get someones attention. So then they come take her dinner back and bring us our salads bout 5 min. later. Then they bring us both our dinners finally one being out of the oven for proly 20 minutes so it was dryed out chicken alfredo at that point (17.50 a plate for that). Then later that night my girlfriend gets sick from the food that sat around and throws up!! The service was horrible and was hot and smoky in there! Plus they charge almost $3 for a little bottle of water! I will not be going back....! read more

my husband and I ate there and ordered a salad with our pizza when the bill came I was charged 2.oo more fore some thing so I asked and the price for the salad was 1.oo more than the menu and we got dressing on the side so it was 1.oo more I asked why the salad was more then menu and was told well the menu was subjuct to change and the other 1.oo was for the dressing on the side because they had to wash the dish now get real these extra charges should not have been well i dont go there any more plus the way the owner yells at the help just terrible sorry enough other nice places to go and youll get charged what the menu says read more