Staff seemed very confused throughout our whole ordering process and when we asked about the check-in offer. Opted for slices and the crust was WAY undercooked. I couldn't even eat mine and made my super hungry bf eat it. We came through Boulder for a day trip and scoured Yelp to pick a spot worth our money. This was not it and I was super sad, when Boulder is filled with food gems. read more

Nick-N-Willy's Pizza - Uncooked dough - Pizza Near Me - Boulder, Colorado

See all

Great pizza place in Boulder on Pearl street, so close to shops and everything else. It's a small place that has a few bar type seats to seat about 6-8 people but most of the people bought the large pizzas to take away. We had slices and it was great!! I had the international which was my favourite, the wild willy combo which was huge! Toppings were overflowing and the basil, tomato and garlic. I was really hungry when I ate here and went for 3 slices which was more than enough! It's a cool spot and when I checked in on yelp they gave me 6 free chicken wings (at least when I checked in), another good reason to use yelp! Definitely be back as I enjoyed it! read more

Terrible. No sauce and terrible at unwrapping and putting in oven. I would not recommend. It is super gummy and almost impossible to put in oven. read more

Nick-N-Willy's Pizza - Try it. Really is terrible ....unwrapping, putting in oven and practically no sauce. I put bottled sauce on it - Pizza Near Me - Boulder, Colorado

Awesome place, super friendly staff with amazing pizza and chicken wings. Wish I lived in Boulder so we could go there on the regular. read more

Nick-N-Willy's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Boulder, Colorado

Pizza by the slice cooked to order!! Most "by the slice" places simply reheat one of a few options. Here the whole menu is available by the slice!! Friendly people, nice place and an extensive menu make this a five star experience. read more

This pizza is worse than Digiorno's and it was $60 for 2 pizzas, a salad and horrible garlic bread. No flavor, and you have to bake it yourself. Awful. read more

Took my kids here for slices - we all thought it was our favorite in town. Super thin, crunchy crust, thin but flavorful sauce, and deep toppings. read more

Some of the best pizza in Boulder. The Earthbound Underground is basically a garden's worth of vegetables piled onto a delicious, well-charred crust. Great service. read more

Woah. Specialty pizza (anything more than just a slice of cheese) will cost you $5-6/ slice. That's a little steep for my wallet. There are intriguing slices (I think I remember seeing a Thai slice) and it seems to be a Boulder/ Pearl Street favorite, but I just can't spend $12.00+ on two slices of pizza for lunch. I opted for two slices of cheese (1.99/ slice) and lamented at the nakedness of my slice. (Margherita, how I longed for you...) The slices were... cheesy. Very okay; nothing great but not awful, and so very symbolic of existence. read more

I sorta don't get the point of take-n-bake if it's not cheaper than pizza served to you in house. Seriously, why pay the same price for pizza you have to take home, cook yourself, and do all the dishes for? Nick-N-Willy's take-n-bake is not appreciably cheaper than any higher-quality pie you can get in a restaurant. But it IS good. I'll admit that. Their crust is probably my favorite in town, and their fun, off-the-wall combinations cater directly to my tastebuds. I don't really like the run-of-the-mill mozzarella, tomato sauce, pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms thing. I like my pizza with a twist; pesto sauce, white sauce, chicken, spinach, goat cheese, brie, pineapple, BBQ sauce, whatever. Nick-N-Willy's offers one or two of these twists at a time, making the pizzas appetizing to me without allowing me to go totally crazy and order a feta-pineapple-bacon-sundried-tomato-alfredo pizza and then regret it later. Last time I went I was with two friends and we decided to order the extra-large - I think it was called the Mountain Goat or something (it's not on their website so I have to guess). Anyway, it had goat cheese, mozzarella, chicken, garlic, and some other stuff, but the operative ingredient for all of us was goat cheese. We ordered the pizza and were hanging around waiting for it to be ready, when the girl behind the counter goes, 'Actually, we're out of goat cheese, is there another kind of cheese you want on it?' The pizza was already made, so they didn't offer us the option of ordering a different pizza. We just had to choose another cheese. They gave us samples of the feta and the fontina, and we chose the feta. Personally, I think that if you're out of an ingredient, you should tell the customer BEFORE their pizza is already made so they have the option of ordering something else. And if you accidentally screw up and don't do that, you should give the customer a small discount on their order. They didn't do either. We were charged full price, which is not a huge deal, but sort of rubbed me the wrong way. I'd go back though, but probably just for slices, since the pizza is so tasty and it's right down the hill from my house (and across the street from Spruce Confections, where I can get a delicious dessert cupcake afterward!) read more

Don't waste your time. Ingredients seem like they are out of a can. Some of the worst and most expensive pizza I've ever had. Any other option would be better. read more

Offer of free wings was misleading. People were nice but pizza was average n overpriced (maybe usual for Boulder I guess)

The wings are good. However when I picked them up , I was charged $1 more than was quoted on the phone AND it's listed on the menu at the lesser price. The staff said although it's listed on the board at $12.99 the computer showed $13.99 It's not a big deal, but owner should know in case wants to explain to me the mistake. It's not the money as much as the principle. I should have been charged what was told to me and what's listed. I will come back and let management know what happened. (Maybe they read these reviews and respond) read more

Saw this place the first night we visited downtown Boulder and knew I had to get a bite before I left back to Dallas. So I finally stopped by today with my family and it was amazing. The employees were so nice and prepared the pizzas beautifully. They even gave my small nephews dough to play with while they waited on the pizza. Seeing them prepare the pizza and toss the dough was amazing, but finally getting to taste a slice was the best. Really good! Definitely stop by to get a whole pizza or even a slice. If and when we cone back to Boulder I'll make sure to stop here again! read more

Nick-N-Willy's Pizza - Cheeses Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Boulder, Colorado

Is this a joke? As someone originally from Brooklyn, I feel personally victimized by Nick-n-Willy's pizza. If you want cardboard, DiGiorno crust topped with marinara sauce and a block of Polly-O mozzarella and CHEDDAR (yes, cheddar fucking cheese on a slice of pizza), then fine. Go here. But if you have any dignity, take yourself to Audrey Jane's for some real NY style pizza. read more

Nick-N-Willy's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Boulder, Colorado

So Nick N Willy's has a few things going for it. The primary plus for me is that it's a block from my work. Uber convenient on those days where I don't bring a lunch. The second is the fact that despite being a take and bake place, they still offer slices at lunch time. It's about 8 bucks for 2 1 topping slices and a pop. Not the best deal in the world but after 2 slices and a coke you're stuffed so you're getting a full meals worth. The pizza does taste a little quick cooked, if that's even a term. I guess what I'm saying is that you can tell they only cook cheese pizzas in their little ovens and then throw toppings and more cheese on slices and sell them. The pizza was still pretty tasty, but you get that "this whole thing wasn't cooked and given to me right away" vibe. Still though, it's pretty swell pizza. When I don't want to walk far for lunch in Boulder this is usually my jam. I've yet to try their take n bake pizza, though I hope to in the future. ALSO: check in here to get some free wings. read more

I don't think there's ever been a moment where I've craved pizza. I guess it's just not one of those hit-the-spot goodies for me. IF I did ever crave pizza, I would say that Nick-N-Willy's would do. I really like their non-traditional toppings and quick and friendly service. My favorite part of pizza is the crust. Theirs didn't really do it for me. I think if the crust was tastier for me then it would be super stellar, because I like the toppings they put together. read more

Online this place says "take and bake style pizza but for delivery". So do i get a baked pizza or do i pay retail rates for a "bake at home" pizza? Is there such a thing as regular pizza deliver from this business? Who knows! the website is equally confusing having a "menu" that says "Welcome to Nick-N-Willy's online menu! We are delighted to share our many choices with you, including a full selection of fresh made pizzas, starters, salads and desserts." But your main page says you do take and bake pizza only. Until this place is clear I'd say don't bother, there is as good a chance you'd get a take and bake pizza paid and delivered at retail cooked pizza prices. I really have to say this place is totally confacta! In PA i can guarantee this place is well into consumer fraud violations. You can pay 4 dollars for delivery, then at prices well over any pizza place in Manhattan for an UNCOOKED PIZZA delivered to your home. This place needs to get offline cause right now its a lie read more

The ingredients did not seem fresh and the pizza was underwhelming, tasted like hot lunch. People were nice.

Nick & Willy's was a staple in my house growing up. We consumed dozens of Thai Pies during my childhood. It was nice to revisit this spot and find that virtually nothing had changed, except that they now offer rotisserie chickens (whole- $10, half $5) and soups. Slices are between $5-7 bucks, while an entire pizza is only $12-17, but obviously you have to bake it yourself and that leaves room for trouble (the parchment paper getting all wonky in the oven, the crust bubbling up and burning). Taking and baking is not problem-free, which is why we opted for in-house slices this evening - some kind of white pizza and another slice loaded with fresh broccoli, onions, tomatoes, mozz, and chicken. The only complaint I had was that the toppings weren't as hot as I would have liked- but the crust was perf. It's always disappointing to find out that a place that I thought was unique to Boulder is actually a franchise, but nevertheless, I think the Pearl St location is the best. read more

Swinging back through Boulder, I got a hankering for my old Nick-n-Willy's favorite --- large Aegean, bake at home. Called in the order, swung by Alfalfas to pick up salad fixings, and pulled in next to Nick-n-Willy's. The inside seemed more dour than I remember; two people behind the counter, lit largely by the glass-front cooler cases of salads and beverages, fridge compressors and radio providing a "get in and get out" soundtrack. Not a place I'd care to linger. Convinced the employees that I was indeed the same person who'd called for the pizza, and yes I wanted to buy it now. Tried for the check-in offer of wings, but they weren't having any of it --- "We don't do that, it's a franchise thing." Your mileage may vary. Pop it in the oven, and half an hour later --- delicious. Good salty feta, firm-but-not-too-chewy sundried tomatoes, tender spinach. And a good, simple crust. Maybe even better than I remember. Pizza? 4 stars. Atmosphere and experience? Lacking. read more

PERFECT PIZZA The gluten free are delicious. The veggies, the cheeses, the regular hot slices are all delicious. If you get a chance, grab a Grapefruit Izze, 2 slices of cheese and toss on a little of their proprietary hot sauce. MANOHMAN, it's just awesome! read more

My husband and I were walking Pearl street and needed a quick snack towards the end of the walk... low and behold - Nick 'n Willys! This is definitely a 'grab and go' type establishment where a sit down meal or proper date might not be a good agenda. I liked the prices and the awesomely diverse list of ingredients - just like you would expect in Boulder - they cater to many different dietary needs. The staff was friendly (it was dead so they were busy prepping pizzas for the day) and it only took about 10 minutes from the time we walked in to the time we were sitting down chomping on our slices. I would say - good for a walking snack or maybe to take home. read more

I am appalled at the mere existence of this place. Who sells ingredients of a pizza and on top of that so expensively!! Are you serious?! This place needs to be marketed as take and bake. Horrible, and a waste of time and money!! read more

Great staff, great pizza and great wings! Greatest wings I have had in 3 decades! Definitely recommend this place. read more

Nick-N-Willy's Pizza - The Aegean Pizza. Simply the best - Pizza Near Me - Boulder, Colorado

Great pizza for sure. Thin crispy and real good spicy chicken. Would recommend winger chicken as a topping for sure :)

Amazing pizza! The take and bake is incredible. They def use some olive oil in the dough that makes that ish POP! the slices are my fave. Cheapest lunch in boulder. Always grab a big cup of ranch and a cheese slice and it costs me less than $4. Takes less than 5 minutes anytime of the day to grab a quick bite. The owner is amazing too. 6/5 IMO for boulder pizz read more

Exceptionally good service by the lovely crew ar the Downtown Boulder location. I have been eating here since its opening and the BBQ Chicken does not disappoint. The service is fantastic. I would highly recommend the carry out pie as well. Try the penny lane, or the pizza pile and bake it in your oven at home to the optimal crispness. Delicioso Lucy and her team did a great job!!! read more

Excelent, fresh food and friendly staff. Definitely will come again. Back for best pizza in Boulder read more

Great people and awesome pizza. They don't hold back on the toppings. A must, every time we're in Boulder. Mark & Suzanne, Jacksonville, Fl read more

I've been going Nick-N-Willy's for the pizza for years--always consistently awesome. I take home the Aegean or the Penny Lane, or grab a slice or two at lunch and enjoy the outdoor seating. I just went in for the wings over the weekend for the first time, and they were delicious. Willy and his crew are always friendly, and I like supporting this local, independent business. Five stars! read more

Awesome basic real authentic food and experience. It's the down-home, "we've been doing this forever" feeling that I love. The food reflects this: the homemade chicken, the fresh salads, the take and bake pizza, all extraordinary. They have gluten-free crust now! read more

As pizza goes in Colorado - most disappoints me. I am from Chicago though, in a neighborhood where you could eat pizza 7 days a week and never get bored. Nick-N-Willy's is better than most I've tried out here. I appreciate their selection and the fresh tasting ingredients. Good for veggie eaters, meat eaters and even Gluten-free. read more

Ok, I have to say that this is great pizza, especially for Boulder. The Agean is my personal favourite but there are many more creative concoctions. They PILE ON ingredients, and they are FRESH. I think they serve pizza by the slice here, but it's a small location and they only do take-and-bake. Trust me, it's worth taking home one of their pizzas for the Broncos game :) If you like sun-dried tomatoes and a little spice, try the AGEAN. Amazing. read more

27 years and this is still The very best pizza I have ever tasted. No one does fresh like nick n willys. My favorite is the underground earthborne but honestly there is no going wrong. And don't even get me started on their chicken wings read more

Nick-N-Willy's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Boulder, Colorado

Awesome pizza, well worth a little wait at peak meal time. I had the mountain goat, so good! I was not expecting this restaurant to be so kid friendly! I brought a 6yo, 3yo and 2yo who were all tired and hungry. I was braced for disaster, but they were well entertained by dough balls. The staff and other customers were kind and accommodating! read more

Best BBQ pizza I've ever eaten. Quick and absolutely delicious. Love the 2 guys working there and great music too. Overall, great experience. 100% you have to visit and grab a slice read more

Great customer service and it was really quick. My slices were fantastic. Highly recommend.

Really over priced low quality pizza. The owner or manager seemed nice but the guy making our pizza wasn't wearing gloves, after he was done I saw him reach into a trash can twice to grab bags to put the dough in? The trash can looked old and dirty. The ingredients on the slices looked old and not very fresh. My husband and I didn't finish our pizza because we were afraid we were going to get food poisoning. It cost us 20 bucks for two slices of pizza and a cookie. Don't recommend this place at all. read more

Nice place, the sandwiches were great, cheese pizza slice would have been better if it didn't have that much cheese on it(I know I know!)