This was the worst pizza I've ever had... $14 + personal pie with one topping, hard as a rock and barely anything on it. I won't be going back. Was recommended BUT not impressed at all. read more

We've tried everything from appetizers to pizza and pasta. I almost say this, but everything on their menu is delicious and fresh. Their delivery service is too notch as well. Will always recommend! read more

Great place for pizza!The owners are aces in my book!They support Veterans and Law enforcement! read more

Nonna's of Buchanan - Pizza Near Me - Buchanan, New York

This place is nasty I placed a big order one night. How was everything I ordered just nasty and poorly prepared. Never again will I waste my money read more

Puzzled by the low reviews. This spot is amazing! One of the best slices around, and the cheesy bread is . Really good pizzeria when you're in need of a slice. read more

Used to be good, used to have good delivery. Ordered a pie for delivery, hour and 10 mins later called to check status, said it's been busy, driver left with it 5 mins ago (didn't even ask who I was) and would be there in a couple mins. 20 mins later pizza arrived (I'm 5 mins away), stone cold...was obviously sitting on top of stove for a good half hour and sent the guy out with it when I called. Do the right thing next time, apologize and own up, make a fresh pie. Lost a long time regular customer, won't order there again read more

Our local area offers delivery from mostly two directions = Pizza/Italian and Chinese. Mostly it is mediocre, although by trying every place we narrowed down our favorite pizza and adequate Chinese. Until now... This tiny spot in a mini strip mall in Buchanan (next to poor Chinese and Dunkin) never made it on our radar. It took the gracious support of others sending food to us after a rough day and ER trip led to emergency surgery. We were sent Penne a la Vodka and Chicken Marsala. Grateful, and with no expectations, we dug in. Let me start by saying most Marsala based dishes suffer from lack of good Marsala wine and an overabundance of flour. This was simply terrific! Up there with fine Italian restaurant fare and my own home cooking! Fork tender chicken, bountiful mushrooms and a terrific sauce. A+++ The penne was cooked just a tad past al dente, but one again the sauce was terrific. Not watery or greasy, with fresh tomato and pork flavors, and perfect for some wiping up with the fresh bread accompanying this meal. We ordered the same again and served to friends the next night - we could not have been happier! Kudos to the chef - we look forward to trying more from the menu! read more

What is happening to this place? They used to be very dependable and the sandwiches were good and stuffed full. Now the sandwiches have a tiny bit of filling on stale bread. This is the second time my meatball sandwich has looked like this. 2 stars for great delivery, but with so many other options in the area this is the end of the road for me. read more

Nonna's of Buchanan - Tiny meatballs, teaspoon of red sauce and a dusting of cheese on dry stale bread. - Pizza Near Me - Buchanan, New York

Sub par pizza. We ordered stuffed mushrooms to share. Absolutely disgusting. We threw them out. One things for sure. These people who own the Buchanan and Peekskill restaurants are frauds. There's nothing Italian about them! da americano a italiano smettila! stai cucinando fa schifo! If you can't read this you're a disgrace to MY Italian Nona. read more

Convenient strip mall with a lot of parking. Decent amount of seating inside, small but cozy. The staff is friendly. The pizza is good definitely above average. The calzones are well seasoned and don't have too much cheese. They have very good sauce, which is where most of the flavor for pizza comes from. My personal favorite is the grandma's, they make a great grandma's. The kitchen food is probably good too. Not the best pizza in the world but it is a great option for the area. Check this place out if you want a solid slice. read more

Popped in here a couple times and I actually want to say they are even better than their original location in the beach shopping center. Which btw, it is supposed to be BEECH, and I think I may have mentioned this before because of the prevalence of beech trees and also because Harriet Beecher Stowe lived in on property across from it. Or maybe it was solely based on Stowe.. well whatever anyway pizza was pizza and their pasta was dandy too when I was in the mood for hearty eats read more

Best white pizza ever. So garlicky, so much ricotta. Seriously, you gotta try this white pizza. The rest of their Italian food is really good time. I've had the eggplant parm sandwich a few times, and it never disappoints. I've also ordered a bunch of different pasta dishes. The cheesy garlic bread is perfect and has tons of garlic. I recently moved to the area, and am so glad I found Nonna's! read more

I was here a year ago and I ordered a plain pizza. It took forever and there was no one there. When I got the food,it was burnt

Great food and friendly service. A staple in town. We love their sauce and the fun pizza variety.

Garlic knots were Amazing, but the calamari did not have as much flavor. The lemon helped tho!

Just had pretty fast delivery by a nice delivery guy of about the worst pizza I've ever had. A cheese pizza with garlic. It was soaked in oil and waaaaaaaay too much goopy greasy cheese. Inedible and I threw it away immediately. Never again. They used to be okay but today I realized why I didn't order from them anymore. Really gross. read more

From the pizza to the pasta to the meat entrees, Nonna's can do it all. This neighborhood place is far superior to the Subway that used to occupy the same space and is able to consistently deliver amazing flavor at great prices. In particular, I would recommend: - The salmon arugula salad (if you're being healthy) - The penne ala vodka - Really any shape pasta with the hearty bolognese - Any pizza read more

Love their pizza! Best pizza in the area. I usually call ahead and the person who answers the phone is always a delight to talk to. I had an issue the other night with my food and she helped me solve it and made me happy with what she could offer me. Any time I come to pick up they're always so welcoming and treat their customers like family. Love the food, love the employees even more. read more

I usually think of 2 stars as a pretty bad experience but I'm going with Yelp's "Meh. I've experienced better". Unlike Peekskill that has a few good places, this area lacks a GREAT pizza place...Nonna's does nothing to correct that problem. I had a stromboli that was kind of bland. Cheese lacked taste and I had a suspicion that it had been on display for quite some time. Pizza was fresh but the sauce was nothing special and the cheese - like on the stromboli - was nothing special. The one really lame thing was that the place was really hot. It was raining really hard out and there was an open table so instead of getting soaked I sat down to eat. Within 2 minutes, getting soaked was a better option. If you have a small dining area, the anticipation is that it will be a comfortable dining experience. And as pizza places go, this place is pretty expensive so I don't think I'm asking for the moon when I ask for a little AC. read more

Have been a good customer since nonna's opened in Buchanan. Don't know what happened but food quality and service has gone down the toilet... Will definitely be looking elsewhere. Ordered eggplant... sorry, breadplant and lasagna dinners, the lasagna was a spoonful of gravey, spoonful of meat and cheese with pasta thrown in a tin plate.. horrible Don't waste ur money AMC read more

I came in to grab a few slices and with the new mask mandate they have a sign up telling people to mask up, okay no problem but some of the employees aren't wearing masks, some working with pizza with the mask hanging near their chin and talking over the food. I've only seen 2 employees wearing the mask correctly and it's the girls that answer the phones. If you expect your customers to mask up when they come into your establishment, you should be doing the same!! read more

Friendly and quick service, despite how busy they were. We ordered a plain slice, grandma slice, and garlic knots. They were all very good, especially the grandma slice and garlic knots. read more

Maybe the best sausage slice in upper westchester, they use thin, long slices of sausage that we used to see in Queens and manhattan. Generous slice and topping, the sauce is boss. read more

Nonna's is the best. We've ordered from here probably 20 times and every time the food was bomb. Also ordered catering twice and everyone at the parties raved and took leftovers home. Grateful for Nonna's. read more

It's ok, not that special. Better days,so so days and hangover days. The order is always a problem to get to my house,seems the driver is coming from his 2 job,as a stunt driver. The cheese is always stuck to the box separately from the rest of the pie. Hit or miss read more

The first time my husband and I both dined in we were impressed. Finally good pizza in Buchanan, BUT our sentiment quickly died. I'm vegan so I always get the personal salad pizza. Hubby goes in and asks for a specific order, no dressing on the pizza please, how hard can that be right? WRONG! The person who took my husbands order came back with my pizza and tells my husband that although he asked NO DRESSING the chef put it on the pizza anyway and if that way ok? Seriously? I'm paying for my food to be served as I request and instead I get what they feel like giving me and top add insult to injury the chef begins cursing my husband out in Italian not realizing that my husband is Italian and understood every word he said *SMH* Really? Despicable way to treat your customers especially when it was YOUR error not ours. Tonight was the straw that broke the camels back. The female server who was working the May 17th night shift was far more focused on her cell phone and not taking my husbands order. Hubby ordered our daughter some very spicy buffalo wings and instead got something disgusting with no spicy sauce at all??? We will NOT be eating here again and I will be sure to pass the word around on my twitter, facebook, instagram, snapchat, and my blogsite. I sat outside in the car waiting and from my car watched one of their delivery drivers smoking pot inside of his car and the god awful smell that came from his car because my car was right next to his was unreal. read more

the food is nasty never again will I ever spend money on this place , please don't waste your money on that dump the whole place looked dirty extremely disgusting read more

Such a shame. Food used to be amazing but this is what $10 gets you.. I call and say I asked for provalone and the boss tells me I did not! Ok, I will not argue with a "BOSS". I'll eat the ten bucks on from this crap, He can enjoy an watching his costomer base walk away. This place is living off it's history, not it's worth. read more

Nonna's of Buchanan - $10 of crap! Not worth it. Not going back. - Pizza Near Me - Buchanan, New York

See all

Pizza was under cooked and not cut all the way through. When I pulled a piece, the whole top of cheese slipped off along with the toppings. There was DEFINITELY not enough sauce. I had to bake it for 15 minutes in the oven and, overall, tasteless. read more

By far the best pizza around. They make it look so good you feel bad eating it lol. Everyone is really friendly and the service is quick.

Fast, reliable and always delicious! The delivery men are also so friendly and nice when delivering our food. We order here at least 1x per week! Best pizza around. read more

Would have given them 5 stars but I had to take away stars because of the way the guy with the man bun handled my pizza. I watched him as he scratched and rubbed all around his nose and then proceeded to touch my slice without gloves. Gross gross gross. Needless to say, my slice was not eaten. read more

I tried their seafood paella and it was outstanding. It was loaded with shrimp, clams and oysters. I was surprised to see it on their menu, as I usually get their amazing pizza. Paella is one of my favorite meals, so I had to give theirs a try. I will definitely order it again. read more

This is our go to local pizzeria. Food is fresh and tasty. We haven't eaten anything we haven't enjoyed.

Came home from hiking all day starving. And not eating meat means not a lot of choices at these little places . But I ordered the pasta primavera and some of those little garlic knots/buns thingies....which were soft and warm. Both that and the pasta were very good and the portions are huge so it will be lunch tomorrow also. read more

This place has good food, big portions and pizzeria prices. Their pizza is not our fav but their dinners, wings and salads are great. We ordered from here last night for 2 families. It was ready quickly. They forgot an order of wings so o called them and about 15 minutes later they were delivered. Solid! read more

I love this place. The staff is so friendly and the restaurant is clean. The menu offers a lot of variety and everything always tastes on point. I go here often and I am never disappointed. read more

My daughter was here once before a week or two prior and said we had to try it. So this was my first time. The garlic knots are awesome! I love the crust on the pizza. It's crispy and not overly doughy. Looking forward to returning to Nonna's! read more

OMG I love this place so much they have the best pizza ever the cheese pizza is so good me and my moms girlfriend and my friend Mia and her dad we had the best pizza there I five you guys read more

Ok so first thing first. I love Nonnas. We order from there one or two times a week. My issue lately has been consistency. Some days you get an awesome meal...some days it's just ok. I always order the same thing. Chicken alla nonna with spinach. It's really hit or miss. The meal portion has dramatically decreased. Some days I get an awesome sauce. Some days...I get barely any. It's always different and not in a great way. Tonight my order came wrong and even the garlic bread I ordered was significantly smaller than usual. Sometimes the asparagus is edible, other times it's not. Tonight my meal was sub par and they gave me ziti...I don't eat pasta. Very small chicken portion and not even enough garlic bread to compensate. My son enjoyed his raviolis though. I think if nonnas can iron out the issues with consistency they have potential to be much much better. We are going to add Sunday to our list of nights not to order Nonna's. Sadly we're down to two specific nights of the week! read more