Good food, good prices, and good people! This is a solid place for a nice meal or a slice! Much larger than it looks, plenty of seating and tables are spaced well for privacy! Pizza is tasty and worth the price. I even tried a new flavor for myself chicken bacon ranch. Who would have thought. lol. And yes, NO PINEAPPLE! lol The staff were very friendly and quick with our order and drinks. This was a solid meal and I look forward to visiting again! Two thumbs up here! read more

First off plain slice was $3.75 and wouldnt mind the price that much if pizza wasn't burned! How can they serve me a slice so burned i couldn't eat it ? I took slice to go so i didn't see until i got to my car. Thumbs down Nonna's! Horrible! read more

Although experience is no longer that great, I must admit the pizza is decent. Far superior pizza, and super-nice people, can be found at Forno Trattoria, across from Barnes and Noble at Cortlandt Town Center. The Grandma and Old Fashioned Margarita pizza are the best I've ever had. read more

I ordered a pizza online and it took nearly an hour and half to arrive. I'm not sure why it went so down hill so quickly. I know they have new owners but it feels like they are staring from scratch. read more

Yummy pizza and chill staff. The restaurant was clean. Prices were fair for this economic climate.

Order the pizza margarita large came With a hard old crust Unable to eat Smothered in cheese little or no tomatoes It appeared an old pie that was lying around was given a splash of cheese and oil please don't forget this referral read more

Nonnas used to be the absolute best place to get Italian in the area, but over the past year the place has gone to hell, food isn't the same taste isn't the same and the service is terrible, instead of being notified of menu changes in advance, and after confirming what was included in my order I did not receive the spoken of item, then when called to notify them was told we don't do that anymore... with no offer of rectification. This place is a complete disaster and being ran by people who have no idea what they're doing, a complete shell of what it was I'd honestly say save you're time and money and go somewhere else at this point. This is coming from someone who used to celebrate their birthday with their family there every year for the past 7-8 years because it was absolutely my favorite place around. read more

One of my fave CBR slices, but the last time we went they definitely skimped out on toppings (you can see the difference)...maybe weekdays are off days and weekends are the only good times to go? Everyone there is very nice. Never tried their sit-down section in the back yet. Casual dining up front and sit down in the back! read more

See all

1.Placed an order 2.waited to pick up order 3. showed up to pick up order 4.Nobody knows what is happening 5. literally talk to the guy that took my order and confirmed it. 6. nobody knows anything still 7. I walk out with no apology explanation or solution. read more

When I eat pizza, I am always comparing it to pizza we used to eat I. The Bronx when I was a kid. Sorrento's pizza was insanely perfect. Thin crust, a little bendy, slight tang in the sauce, and stretchy perfect mozzarella. Nonna's pizza is as close to that ideal I have ever had in. My 60 years in this planet. Exceptional. 25 minutes from my house, well worth the drive. Cannot wait to get a whole pie there w/ my man Huddy. If you are from the Bronx, you need ti get here. If you're not, so do you. Great service too. read more

Good - pizza and gluten free pasta were good, free delivery was prompt and phone service was friendly Bad - no plates, napkins or cutlery Ugly - coupons not available on Fridays read more

I don't know what kind of white slice this is, but this ain't pizza. This slice is flopping as I pick it up. Great service. Nice spot. read more

Nonna's Brick Oven Pizzeria & Restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Peekskill, New York

See all

Three incredibly disappointing meals in a row, and rude employees/ owners! My family and I have been visiting this location for literally decades, and with the recent change of hands, Nonna's is NOT the same. First meal, rigatoni, broccoli, grilled chicken with garlic and oil... Two pieces of broccoli total. Second meal, grilled buffalo chicken wrap with avocado and fries. The restaurant called to tell me that they were out of avocado (nbd), and I asked if there had been an extra charge for it, they said no. I double checked online, and there is indeed an extra $1.50 charge for avocado, I was willing to let it go, and fries were ice cold. Third and definitely final meal, cobb salad. No dressing and avocado was ROCK HARD, inedible. I called and asked for a refund, as the salad was $16.00. I was first told that I would need to bring the salad back to get a refund, which is honestly just bad customer service, this is my third time ordering from you in one weekend, I feel like you can trust me as a customer not to lie...? I was then told that they "don't grow the avocado themselves, you get what you get..." What?? I'm pretty sure you are the one making the decision to USE the rock hard avocado? I begrudgingly went back, I explained my concerns again, and was met with nothing but attitude, and eventually told, "quite frankly, we don't care about your opinion or business" WELL, CLEARLY. For self preservation purposes, I need it known, that I am not a "food complainer", I eat what I have and am usually very content. But three times in a row AND that reaction?! I'm out. If you can, please move your business to Forno Trattoria at 3088 E Main St, Mohegan Lake, NY 10547 (Cortlandt Town Center)! They are the original owners of Nonna's and it has been so nice to have them back in action just under a different name! read more

Great customer service! Speed time and food excellent ! Looking forward to my next order ! read more

waited more than an hour for pizza and got burned pizza , was refused refund or ability to cancel my order read more

Nonna's Brick Oven Pizzeria & Restaurant - Burned hard pizza - Pizza Near Me - Peekskill, New York

I've been a longtime customer at Nonna's and have really enjoyed their food in the past, which is why I'm so disappointed to be writing this. I wasn't planning to leave a review--I actually called first to give feedback privately, because I got pretty sick about 16 hours after eating their salad pizza and wanted to let them know in case others reported similar symptoms. The salad pizza itself was already a letdown before I got sick. It was literally just raw greens tossed on top of crust and sauce, and not in a way that felt thoughtful or well-prepared. As soon as I picked up the slice, the entire topping slid off into my lap. There was no cheese (which I thought was standard, maybe I misread the menu), and the whole thing felt hastily assembled with little care. Given how poorly it was constructed--and that the greens were completely uncooked--that could easily explain why I got sick. When I called to share this, the manager at first claimed it's not possible to get food poisoning from salad items, which is factually incorrect. Leafy greens are one of the most common sources of foodborne illness, per the CDC. To his credit, he eventually calmed down, apologized, and said they're committed to safe food practices--but that initial defensiveness and misinformation was troubling. I still hope Nonna's takes this seriously. I've supported them for years, and I wouldn't write this unless I felt it truly mattered--for the safety of others and the quality I used to love. read more

Nonnas is my favorite pizza place in the country! And they have excellent chicken & eggplant parm! Try it when you're I. The area! You won't be disappointed! read more

Very disappointed. Use to be my favorite place. First I ordered 3 things and only received 2. I wasn't charged for the 3rd however. Pizza was soggy, very salty and a little on the burnt side. Love the crust on a pizza but this was not eatable. I'm usually easy to please but not this time. Sad. read more

I've been a patron of this establishment since 2006. I love their pizza, pasta, sandwiches and vegetables. There is nothing that I've had that I didn't like. The food is mouth-watering. The staff has always been friendly and polite. Literally the BEST pizzeria in Westchester County. read more

The food was delicious, even my picky teenager ate his food. The service was good the wait staff have a million things but are still attentive. The ambiance is a regular pizzeria though there is a eating area in the back we just ate in the front. Definitely will go again. The only reason they didn't get 5 stars is there was a bit of a wait cause but the place is going non stop so it can't be helped. Also I wished since we were sitting for dinner that we got offered a seat in the back like other small group that came in after us. Also I had to wait a while to get a knife to wat with dinner another staff saw my dismay and brought it over. Speaking to the attentiveness. read more

See all

Never returning. This night a Tall Caucasian girl with black pants , disheveled looking was working as the cashier. There were three people in front of me picking up /and paying for orders. She had on black food gloves the whole time while she was taking care of Customers. I ordered three slices no heat, She walks right to the pizza , places her thumb in to the pizza and in to the box the pizza went, I told her I'm not eating that, you never changed your gloves after you were handling that money. She rolled her eyes, slammed the box down ( she didn't disgard it) she put on a pair of new gloves and put three new slices in the box. I know the next customer will be served those slices. I've decided to never return,after just reading the board of health violations report posted on the yelp app. read more

A very tall Caucasian Woman was working at the register. I had three customers in front of me paying for their meals. I stepped up and ordered three slices. She turns around with those same nasty black gloves and grabs the three slices ( not by the end of the slice) she stuck her thumb right in the center, and put those slices in a box. I politely said to her " you were handling cash and touching everything up front at the register. Then you put your hand all over my pizza. She gave me a evil look, threw the box to the side, ( I know she put that pizza right back) and changed her gloves and gave me three fresh slices. My question is? How can you handle money and food in that restaurant? She never said a word, I'm sorry, no problem. I went home and the incident kept replaying in to my head and I threw the pizza in the garbage. I will never buy anything from Nonnas. read more

Eh didn't have a pleasant experience. Ordered 2 pies & the cheese tastes like kraft cheese. The crust and bottom of the pie was soggy. Maybe they were having an off day. read more

The Original Nonna's is back!! Mike the old owner is back and is bringing back what used to be great food. It's hard to believe but true. No more rude waitresses, no more asking for help from someone on their cell phone. AND no more Flavorless food. Welcome back!!! We are looking forward to some great food and the original family atmosphere. Bill S. Cortlandt Manor read more

the last time ordering this overpriced, terrible food..bland sauce, raw & overtopped pizza.. this place was good 10 years ago.. read more

I held off on this poor review in the hopes that recent poor quality was just a moment in time. But it appears whomever runs or owns Nonna's now has run it down to as far as I can accept. Been a customer since day they opened. But like all good things all good things must end. Got a white pizza the other day. Used to be layer of ricotta then mozzarella. This one was mozzarella and then a couple small islands of ricotta squirted on top here and there. Never saw a white made that way and was not good. My normal regular pie just doesn't taste right anymore either. Can't tell if cheese or sauce tasteless. Wanted to see if anything changed but only further downhill. I understand prices high for ingredients but they raised prices and ingredients went downhill anyway. I will miss picking up there since very convenient to my location. But convenience doesn't help if food no good. read more

Every time I visit my son, we eat at or from Nonna's. The pizza tastes like the pizza I use to buy in Ozone park Queens years ago. Very solid pies . The pasta dinners are enjoyable but I must say the lasagna was a bit too salty. The service is friendly and the restaurant is nice and clean. read more

Low quality hot food served cold. Completely disorganized sh#t show. Place not clean. Who runs/owns this place ?? Someone who's never been to pizza places in their lives perhaps ? A standard $8-10 hero is $13-14 here and comes with fries?! You can not order a hero here without fries!!!! ---Yes you read that correctly. Fries are served ice cold. I told the waiter right after he put my food on the table that the fries are ice cold and the sandwich was barely warm... he said sorry and walked away !! lol. How about ... I'll fix that for you, I'll get you another order... something ?!?! AND WHAT PIZZA PLACE SERVES FRIES W/ A HERO?!??!?! Sorry excuse of a pizza place. Go elsewhere!!!!! read more

I give Nonna's 5 starts because of my two favorite pizza slices. Baked Ziti and Bruschetta. read more

Nonna's Brick Oven Pizzeria & Restaurant - Baked Ziti and Bruschetta - Pizza Near Me - Peekskill, New York

Sad to write a poor review on a long time favorite, but time and time again they disappoint. How can you charge nearly $20 for a dinner that lacks flavor and looks unappetizing? Every time the pasta has been undercooked, chicken was dry, and sausage was raw. It doesn't take a genius to cook pasta. They try to make sense of the high price by serving a large dish with poor quality ingredients. Screams greedy management to me. Truly disappointed. read more

All the food is delicious! Some of their best items are the grandpa pie, chicken Caesar salad, and chicken cutlet BLT. Delivery is always quick and pizza arrives fresh and hot. read more

Nonna's Brick Oven Pizzeria & Restaurant - Plain Regular Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Peekskill, New York

See all

Incompetence at its best. I ordered for Sicilian slices. I must have waited 20 minutes at the minimum when I finally asked where my order was, they looked around for it and pulled it off the top of a shelf. I noticed that the pizza box wasn't even hot much less warm. Upon arrival at home, which is only 2 miles. I noticed that the pizza was cold, and the cheese on top was cold and hard. I was very disappointed and trust me. , I will never go back. To top it off once I heated the pizza up at home it was probably one of the worst pizzas I've ever tasted. read more

I love all of their dishes but to be honest I really don't like their pizza. We order from them all the time and love to sit in the restaurant now and then (especially because they give you delicious focaccia with tomato salsa bruschetta at the tables ). Their pastas are amazing, their marinara and "gravy" is awesome. Their parm dishes and heros (wedges) are great too (although their hero bread is not so great, definitely not Bronx bread as it should be). Sounds kinda negative so far but everything besides the pizza is spot on, original on many cases, done well, and just plain delicious. My favorite go to lately has been the baked ziti siciliano. My wife LOVES their Chicken parm. So minus the one star for their pizza. I tried again recently to give it another shot after a like 10 years and I could tell as they we're making it from looking at the dough and how they were forming it the pizza would not come the way it's supposed to. Maybe I will give it another shot in the future, but until then I will still swear by their pasta and dinner menu!! read more

I been ordering from here for a long time since they changed owners, the food is nasty I waited for an hour for a sandwich and mozz sticks and I'm located around the corner. I will never order from here again.no meat on the sandwich they have gotten cheap with that.. they lost my business and my co-workers..the food was cold they never bothered to call and apologize. never again!! read more

Always a little nervous about restaurants in shopping centers but Nonna's does not disappoint. The pizza is quick, hot and absolutely delicious. They have so many pies to choose from but I always end up getting the plain slice of pizza with a side of garlic knots. The garlic knots are so good and they are a great value!! Service wise, this place is great as well. The staff is quick to bring your pizza over and quick to clear as well as being very helpful while ordering. Nonnas is a great value, not the best pizza in Westchester but definitely up there. Looking forward to trying their delivery in the future. read more

Nonna's Brick Oven Pizzeria & Restaurant - Plain slice of pizza - Pizza Near Me - Peekskill, New York

What happened to Nonnas?! I work at the hospital, we order all the time. I just picked up my normal order and it's not the same people making it. Incredibly disappointed, my salad isn't even eatable the lettuce is so saturated in dressing. The dressing always went on the side. I never write reviews based off one time but the entire line of people were complaining. Please figure this out! Would hate not to order or dine in again. Waste of $50. read more

Worst experience ever! I am in a hotel, placed the order through yelp with special instructions of NO Pancetta and that I needed plastic ware. The software did not add my special instructions to my order and no one is standing by their product. Not yelp, not Grubhub, and not Nonna's. I wasted $30 and will never use this software or place an order for Nonna's again. Btw, I eat here every time I visit... never again read more

Oct 3 2023 Excellent spaghetti Marinara Sauce delicious Chicken parmigiana and white pizza on point Owners are friendly and Gracious read more

GReat pizzas and salads. That is all I personally had but they do have a full Italian menu I just have not tried it yet

Ordered a Caesar salad to go - got home and saw it was almost all iceberg lettuce, which is not a Caesar salad (should be ALL Romaine). Do better, Nonna's. read more