*** UNDER NEW OWNERSHIP*** We have been to Catania's twice now in the past week. The first time, we had pizza. It was delicious! Tonight, we had a chicken parm dinner, Cajun chicken over cheese tortellini, and pasta with meat sauce. Everything was fantastic! We greatly enjoyed our meals. The owners are nice guys. We will definitely be back. read more

All these years and I just found a gem of a restaurant and I am glad that I did! The food was fresh, flavorful and clearly made with care. The atmosphere was cozy and welcoming and the service made it even better. Definitely one of those places you almost want to keep secret- but it's too good not to share! read more

We had the absolute best cheese pizza. The sauce was delicious. We also tried the Philly cheese steak empanada. There were so many kinds of empanadas. We will have to go back soon to try them all. Great service. Thanks for lunch we will have to stop again soon. read more

See all

9/17/19-- back DOWN to a whopping 3 stars. Don't go late at night to Catania's. I'm now discouraged. Won't be back so quickly THIS time. Wasn't informed they were soon to close. Got served a doughy, dried under heated slice of pizza. Only to reheat once I arrived shortly home. I called them back-- no sorry for the inconvenience or receive a better one next time. He said" well you knew we were closing in 5 mins Not professional in the true sense for this place. Had he been a LITTLE more receptive on the phone, I'd be back in a heartbeat. Staying away read more

I used to like this place but it gave my friend and I food poisoning the other day. We ate both slices and empanadas. Later that evening we paid the price! read more

Fantastic pizza. Crust is a perfect balance of crisp and chew; delicious to the last bite (even for those who don't usually finish the crust)! First time here, we ordered the "Pizza Extravaganza," since it was advertised as "all of our standard ingredients" and we were hungry. The result was fantastic and every bite was delicious, but it seemed we might be missing some of the "everything" ingredients. Nothing green, for example. Guys? Adjust your "Extravaganza" listing to be specific about what ingredients will be on the pie. No worries. The pizza was delicious and we will be back. +++ P.S. There were some early reviews here on Yelp about rude staff, slow service and takeout order failures that almost stopped me from visiting. I did not experience any of these issues. I was welcomed from the start and thanked again (more than once) at the end. Owner: Be sure you address these potential issues straight away. read more

Pizza is outstanding. Sauce is so delicious. Staff very friendly. Calamari very chewy. Almost inedible. Fix that and man, you'll be out of this world! Please? P.s. Try Novecentos calamari. Tender and crunchy at the same time. Your sauce and pizza are better though! read more

This was my go to place for the past 3 years, unfortunately no more. 3 weeks ago I was given the wrong pizza and an employee told me I was wrong and that was the pie, so I let it go, We all have bad days! Tonight I order a Sicilian Pie and it was hard as a rock! read more

Empanadas are delicious. Pizza is one of the best for the area! Crust was chewy and perfectly done, and the cheese was flavorful. A great meal for the family! read more

I am very sad I didn't try this place sooner. Was looking for some delicious eats during COVID lockdown and... WOW Catania's is phenomenal. Trust me... get the Veal and peppers calzone in addition to whatever else you're ordering (they're mini). I will be ordering from here regularly moving forward. Cheers Catania's! read more

Went there for wings and pizza and when I got home, one of my wings had so many feathers on them they probably could've flown away. As you can see from the picture, there's no way you could've missed that in the cooking process, and that's exactly what I was told that it was taken out of a bag and put in a deep fryer and probably went unnoticed. . When I complained, the owner did absolutely nothing for me and barely even offered an apology and so I will never be back to this place. . Also, the pizza is average and certainly not any of the best that I've ever had so I don't know where these other reviewers are getting that from. . The owner is rude and unfriendly. So I'm done . read more

Catania's Pizza - Mohegan Lake - How do you miss that? - Pizza Near Me - Mohegan Lake, New York

See all

Best pizza around hands down brings me back to my child hood when pizza was pizza if u havent tried these guys yet i suggest u do so .. Great customer service I live about 25 min away and gladly drive past all the other pizza places to Catalinas ... Keep up the good work guys read more

Fantastic pizza. Fantastic delivery people. Our new favorite spot. Thanks all!!!!!!!!

I read a lot of good reviews about this place so we decided to give it a try and ordered meatball calzone and chicken Parm calzones. Neither my husband nor I liked them at all - the filling was basically just chop meat for the meatball one - I felt like I was eating some kind of weird tasting sloppy Joe. The ratio of filling to crust was not right and it wasn't even warm! We will not be back. read more

Catania's Pizza - Mohegan Lake - "Meatball" calzone - Pizza Near Me - Mohegan Lake, New York

Can't say much for the food as even though the website told us our order was delivered and the money was taken we certainly never received it. It was halloween, we were having a few people so I pre ordered this pizza before noon the day of so it would arrive in time... it didn't. The door dash app told me that they do their own deliveries and so had to call them, we called and called and called al evening and no answer. I would read some reviews citing the same type of thing on other days and that they were told they were actually closed but it was a computer glitch- maybe this is the case but if it has happened before you would think you would try to avoid it happening again. I don't like to leave negative reviews but my advice would just be to call to place your order and have a human confirm it will come. read more

Pizza is amazing ! Love the cesar salad Wings are bomb And the mini calzone to die for read more

Delicious pizza! I've come here a few times since they opened. I had the broccoli rabe and sausage roll recently. Very good!

I'll upgrade when they actually use wood in the wood fired oven. This is gross misrepresentation. Wood fired food has a different taste then gas. They have a huge clearly written on the boards WOOD FIRED MENU. That's a big no. Pizza people look for wood fired. You just opened up in area that has more pizza places then gas stations. Good luck. Let the public know when you are actually using wood. read more

Catania's Pizza - Mohegan Lake - Pizza Near Me - Mohegan Lake, New York

Stopped in on a Monday night around 7 PM. Honestly not much in the display cases. Will say the staff was very friendly and willing to make a whole pie or a sandwich if we wanted. We had a half of a chicken Parm Stromboli and a half of an eggplant rolls Toni Stromboli and a meatball calzone which was more like a meatball empanada! Everything was good. With the amount of pizza places in the area I think you need to be great! The interior was a bit dingy. I'm not sure about social distancing since there was only one other customer other than us in there that night. It did not look like they wiped down the tables after customers left and there was no hand sanitizer. Would be interested to try their pizza before I make my final decision. read more

WOW! The specialty pizzas such as Grandma, regular, White and Old fashioned are so delicious! The calzones are YUMMY too!

They don't even deserve the one lonely star. Ordered at 5:23, it got here at 7:10. Do I live in Albany? No. Do I live in a menacing lair accessible only by riding a shark? Nope. I live 6 minutes from the place. I called at the 1 hr mark, the hour twenty mark, and the hour forty mark. Each I time was told it would be there " momentarily ." Of course, when the pizza arrived it was cold, with congealed cheese and a crust that tasted what amazon packaging must taste like. And....they got the order on one of the pizzas wrong. Late, cold, and wrong. That's the Crap Pizza Trifecta, baby! They eventually refunded the charge, which was a okay thing to do. A ever better thing to do would be to run your business competently. This is an AVOID. Don't even make eye contact with the store. Drive past quickly and ignore the cries and pleas from the sad pizzas inside. read more

Personal cheese pies are delicious. Owners are really cool, always making sure the pizza is cooked to my liking before being shoved out the door like every other pizza place. Plus they are the only place around with lobster bisque! Give them a try 10/10 read more

A great addition to the neighborhood. The most amazing calzones you will ever have! You could sit outside on a patio and have your slice of pizza or delicious Italian food. Support your local businesses ! read more

So we went to check out the famous calzones. Were they delicious - absolutely. Great flavor and filled with cheese. They were also TINY and cost $4 each!! Calzones at other places which are at lease 3 times the size are $6. I wont call it a rip off since they were fabulous, but people in Yorktown are notoriously cheap, so I doubt they will have repeat business. As for the pizza. Meh. Sicilian was sub par. Dough was dense. Sauce lacked flavor. Other slices were just ok as well. Heard that they finally have a larger menu but didn't see one. Might try again. I think that when you have have a TON of competition, you need to amp up the flavor and price it right. But good luck to them. They are on the right track. read more

Stop there today and and was very pleased with the service and the food I tried there empanadas the variety was awesome I tried the seafood and the bbq brisket and the philly cheese steak very very good I will be going back oh and of course I also brought there calzones witch are delicious definitely worth the stop so glad I did read more

I've went to their Yonkers location once before, a few years back. I had their calzone, and it was unforgettable. When we saw that they were opening up on Mohegan Lake, my wife and I were overly excited. Their calzones are still amazing. Yes, the are small, but they are the perfect amount of thin crust, and overly stuffed. One or 2 will fill you up no problem. Their margarita pizza was great. Nice, thin crust. We've also had their Mushroom Truffle pizza, and it was delicious, although the crust was a little more doughy than I expected. It's not Neapolitan style like we expected. Not the fault of the restaurant, but we thought it would be more like the margarita pizza. I REALLY liked their wings. Wood fired, nice and crispy. Sauce was good too. If I had to have any complaint, it would be the restaurant itself is a little bare. They are (from what I understand) still in their soft opening, so it makes sense. That and their menu is a little bare compared to the other pizzerias in the area, but again - soft opening. We used to go to Nonnas in Peekskill all the time, but since we've moved to Mohegan Lake, this pizzeria gives it a run for its money. The pricing is better here though! read more

Pretty quick delivery and they didn't have to call for additional directions . Pizza (non-cheese) with veggies and pizza sauce did the job . We ordered the truffle fries (newbies didn't know it came with parm )... the few I devoured were yum. Will be ordering from here again (hopefully they can hold the parm on the fries)! read more

I've been waiting for this place to open. I've visited their Yonkers location and was thrilled to have another location so close to home. Their veal calzone is delicious; pizza is better than most local places and their are very friendly. Glad to finally have quality pizza in the neighborhood. Other locations should be on noticed! I'll be a regular read more

Catania's Pizza - Mohegan Lake - customers in a restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Mohegan Lake, New York

Soooo delicious! Everything I've ordered from here never disappoints. The only thing I would say is that they take forever to have your food ready. read more

Finally a great pizzeria in the area! Very friendly staff and warm environment. The food is great! The specialty wings and calzones are my favorite! Can't wait for the bar to open. read more

Catania's Pizza - Mohegan Lake - chicken wings with sauce - Pizza Near Me - Mohegan Lake, New York

Placed an order over phone for 20 mini calzones to take to a work function. They said needed an hour. Went to pick up the hour later and order was never even started. Amateurs. read more

I don't like to put places on blast but when your kid goes to work and puts in his hours they deserve to get paid and it's wrong what you did Catinias pizza mohgan lake he works hard and not to pay someone is wrong read more

First time ordering and won't be back. Completely disappointed. Ordered chicken parm entree, got home and realized it doesn't come with any pasta ? First time that's ever happened to me at an Italian restaurant, called and was made aware you can add it on for an additional cost (so had to make pasta at home lol). Also ordered the chicken wedges which were completely tasteless and had one thin piece of chicken on each wedge. Truffle fries were soggy, undercooked, tasted like frozen fries and charged $10!! Customer lost for owners overcharging and being totally cheap on the portions. read more

Food is amazing ate there a few times and am never disappointed. Best pizza around and I have eaten all of them.

A lot of the pizza in the Cortlandt/Peekskill/Mohegan Lake area is very average, in my opinion. Catania's makes a good, solid pie that stands out from the rest. The mini calzones are what they are known for at their Yonkers location and they are pretty good. My favorite is the meatball calzone. The wings here are also surprisingly good and they make a clam pie that can hold its own, although you must dine in when you get it because once it goes in the box it loses its luster. Catania's has established themselves as my go-to pizza joint. read more

This place is the real deal. Great atmosphere, friendly staff, and by far the BEST PIZZA in all of Northern Westchester. read more

Catania's Pizza - Mohegan Lake - a heart shaped pizza in a box - Pizza Near Me - Mohegan Lake, New York

One of the pizza in the area. Reminds me of the pizza i grew up on in Brooklyn. The sauce is fresh and seasoned perfectly, The Cheese is also freshly made. And this is Key If im not mistaken the water comes from the NYC water supply and not locally, and water is everything when it come to the making of the dough. Pluse it come out piping hot. read more

Moved up here from Yonkers in 2012, and I grew up on Catania's in Yonkers and the Bronx. You can't beat Catania's pizza, calzones, and rolls. Best Salad pizza you will ever get. When they opened in Mohegan Lake, I thought I was dreaming when I first saw it. Finally! A real deal pizza joint up here, these guys are the best, hands down. read more

Hands down the best pizza in all of Northern Westchester! Friendly staff and a great loyalty program that's super quick and easy to sign up for. Located right off Route 6 - definitely worth checking out! read more

Used to order from here all the time, loved the food but recently it's like kids took over and they got my order wrong 2 times then I went in to place a order I told the kid what I wanted he listen and then goes "alright I'm gunna have to have u repeat that in a minute" walks away take 3 people's order that walked in behind me so I just walked out ... the kids seemed too lazy to place my order ... their loss, I used too order from here like 1-2 times a week haven't in a month now. read more