We were on our way home and needed to grab something quick! A cute little place at the end of a strip mall. They DID NOT disappoint. The girl behind the counter was very helpful in giving suggestions etc and getting the most bang for our buck! The burgers were delicious! We will def be back read more

I'm in town from California and just checked into my hotel and feeling hungry for a burger. I opened my Yelp APP and searched for a burger establishment. NY Burger Shack popped up and the menu looks good so I'd thought I'd give it a try. I went with the NY smash burger special with fries and a drink. In the words of Samuel L Jackson, that was a "tasty burger!" The fries were crisp and delicious as well. The shack is really a shack. Very small interior but decorated nicely. read more

See all

The absolute BEST burger I've ever had! It's also so easy to order at their kiosk, food came out quickly And exactly as ordered. The 4oz burger was HUGE! I got just regular burger, with American cheese, white onions, Ketchum and their spicy mayo. I'd definitely recommend this place 100%! It's adorable inside and apparently they have A LOT of amazing different kinds of milk shakes. Def will be back! Yum! read more

Enjoyed eating here for lunch this past weekend. They have many options for everyone. I got a grilled cheese with curly fries, both of which were excellent. I shared a baked mac and cheese which was amazing too. The vibe is nice in there and I can't wait to come back! read more

NY Burger Shack - Baked Mac And Cheese - Burgers Near Me - Medford, New York

See all

Delicious food. Not healthy but yummy. Had the Brooklyn combo. The curly fries were really good, the burger was very tasty, especially the cheese sauce, and the shake (Snickers) was also very good. Quick, helpful and polite service. Ambiance - small place, metal chairs and tables, good decor and clean. read more

See all

Hands down one of the best burgers on Long Island. Stopped by NY Burger Shack and it did not disappoint. Juicy, flavorful burger perfection, plus the garlic parm wings that were loaded with flavor and the mac & cheese bites that were crispy on the outside and gooey on the inside This spot officially hit all the cravings. If you're on Long Island and love comfort food done right, this is a must-visit. read more

See all

What a hidden gem. Great burger selection. Some pretty unique burgers. They also have a chicken sandwich menu that I can't wait to try ( all of them). Truffle fries were on point. They use crispy seasoned fries . It's a very clean place to eat. They have a nice selection of ice cream that they make sundaes with. I had the Bronx burger and my wife had the Brooklyn.... My daughter " made " her own.... And our little one had a kids burger. The flavors of all of them with each having a unique tastes is what will keep me from coming back. read more

See all

Pretty good ordered a long island burger on uber eats bag was staple sealed (good) no sticker seal for the drinks (bad) the cajun fries could be spicer other that nice place classic millennial burger joint. read more

The burger was excellent (I'm a burger snob)... The portions are super large and very affordable for the price, cheaper than fast food with 200% the qualit and freshness! The wings were super meaty and tasted incredible! The restaurant is spotless when it comes to cleanliness, and the staff are super friendly/ helpful! I would 100% recommend this place and I will sure be returning many times in the very near future! read more

NY Burger Shack - Small fries to reference the portion size! - Burgers Near Me - Medford, New York

We ordered to go, and we got the Bronx burger, the Brooklyn burger and the pesto grilled chicken salad. He got curly fries and I got Cajun. Everything was great! Deff a heavy meal; but tasty. The burgers were not overly greasy at all; the patties are thinner so they were a smidge overdone but the whole of it made up for that. Fries are the mealy kind; they reminded me of kettle cooked potato chips in terms of flavor. Not super salty or greasy at all. We both thought they were good. Salad is nice and fresh and a good portion as well, chicken cooked nicely and I liked the lemon dressing. The staff had the order ready quite quickly and were very efficient. Inside is modern, nicely done and looks very new. You can build your own burger as well if you don't like the specials. They have a really wide selection of toppings and ways to make it your own. Pricing was moderate, but in line with similar types of places. Give this one a try! read more

Not a fan at all. For a burger shack the fry's and burgers should be amazing and they were not. Their website created in 2025 which leads me to believe they are a new establishment , claiming they are dedicated to serving the best burgers in town. I mean I wish that vision statement was true because they may try to be ,but they certainly are not and will not be- especially if they keep on serving-undercooked / mediocre food. The basic frozen fry's they load up your take out container with are certainly nothing to be excited for - neither are the parm truffle fry's which are not worth it at all- Tasting like cheap truffle oil and low quality shaker cheese. The burger titles are creative and I'm sure they are good but I wasn't impressed with anything on their menu read more

If you live in the area and haven't tried their CINNAMON SUGAR FRIES... YOU NEED TO!! This place is awesome! Glad I didn't stop at a big chain burger joint! Burgers are awesome as well! I love that you can customize them ridiculously! Next time I'm in the area I have to try the fried chicken sandwich. read more

Only three or four tables . no bathroom. drinks only in cans . takes a long time for the food to come out. food is as good as indiana burger place read more

Very unhappy with this place. First time I went there in person and they gave ne the wrong order. I've placed orders through Grubhub and they were still wrong. I ordered a burger well done, and it arrived with no burger on the bun. I also ordered coleslaw from the starters menu which goes for $8.40 and got a small container. The food is overpriced and you don't even get what you ordered. read more

well, you can smell meat grease as you approach the place. of course, because it is a burger joint, but it smells like grease not meat. ok past that. inside is barren. not very inviting. the electrical boxes out in the open make it pretty industrial. you dont really get any "vibe" for the place. no personality. the tv had some cops reality show on which didn't help, all you heard was get off me, put your hands up, i didn't do anything etc., not particularly dining entertainment. there were leaves all over the floor that had blown in from outside. what would it take to sweep up a little. now, not a complete loss. the burger was tasty. the bun was toasted maybe with butter and added a nice flavor. the fries were fresh and the onion rings were crispy so all the food was fresh made. the fountain soda was not working yet so you have to choose from bottled drinks. not the end of the world. in the end, it was as good or better than the local diner but, hamburgers are everywhere, they need to step up their game. read more

Great food. Great service. My new go to spot for burgers. Next time I think I'll try a milkshake

We've had the burgers several times and they are always very good, ditto the fried chicken sandwiches. The fries, both straight and curly are top notch. I'm so happy this place is nearby! read more