Hubby and I stopped by OddFellows in the Terminal Building and immediately ran into a problem: too many great flavors. Italian Cookie Crumble, Sea Salt Pistachio, Hummingbird, Brooklyn Blackout, Coffee Crunch, Hibiscus Cherry Chip... decision paralysis. Solution: the 6-sampler pack. Best idea ever. It comes in a little tray so you don't have to choose. Every flavor was great, the staff was friendly, and it's the perfect stop in the Strip District when you're hankering for something sweet. read more

Oddfellows Ice Cream Company - 6 scoops of deliciousness - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

Shopping around the strip and walked into Posman books...as soon as we entered and I saw ice cream I knew I had to try it! There was a long line, which boded well, and it moved pretty quickly. I was able to sample a few flavors and each one I tried was great! They have a lot of unique options and several vegan choices as well. They even let me do a split scoop, which I so appreciate. I ended up going for a cup with vegan coconut pandan and miso peanut butter and jelly. Both flavors were fantastic and I thought they paired well together. I have daydreamt about that ice cream multiple times since having it...highly recommend. Posman is a cute store to browse around as well so it was an all around lovely experience. One that I would like to repeat for sure :) Thank you, Oddfellows! read more

Oddfellows Ice Cream Company - Split scoop - half miso peanut butter and jelly and half vegan coconut pandan - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

Amazing ice cream! The flavors here are top notch, super interesting and unique, and they all actually taste like what it's described somehow. It's definitely a little pricier ($7 for a single scoop) but it's worth it for the fun flavors, plus amazing variety of vegan options too! read more

Oddfellows Ice Cream Company - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

Cute ice cream that's in the corner of a book shop in The Strip. I was craving a sweet treat on a hot day, and this was the perfect spot. read more

See all

Yum yum yum!!!! This is my new favorite ice cream parlor in Pittsburgh. Not only do they have nearly equal numbers of vegan and non-vegan flavors on their menu, they also share space with a charming book store in The Terminal. My single scoop of vegan grass hopper and chocolate chunk ice cream with a sugar cone was the perfect way to top off a meal in The Strip. read more

Oddfellows Ice Cream Company - Ice cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

I love: - it's inside a fun bookstore - they have vegan flavors- several! - they had chocolate vegan ice cream that was tasty! - it's in a great walking area with other places to browse and eat - unique flavors! Could be better: - I got a cone and the ice cream was simply placed on top, not in the cone. Glad I also got a bowl because the ice cream fell out of the cone immediately - ice cream texture was a bit crumbly - a bit pricey for the amount read more

Oddfellows Ice Cream Company - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

See all

Like the name suggests, Oddfellows has some odd and unique flavors, in addition to your usual ice cream favorites. I tried a sample of the wasabi chocolate chip, and while I wouldn't want a whole scoop of it, I was pleasantly surprised! I ended up ordering a scoop of the peanut butter s'mores which was really good! They also had a ton of vegan options. The worker was so friendly and sweet, but I thought the serving was a little small for the $6+ price. read more

Oddfellows Ice Cream Company - Single scoop cake cone - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

See all

Based on the location don't expect it to be "cheap" ice cream. A double scoop in waffle cone came out to right around 10 bucks For Pittsburgh ice cream the flavors are defo "adventurous" and that's good given it's in the strip. This place is a franchise from NYC and I believe currently has 4 locations other than here. Random it's in Pittsburgh but it'll do well here for sure Me personally. I wasn't blown away by the ice cream itself. It's aesthetic and has diff flavors than what you get at most places here but for the price it's eh... Inside was fun. It's in a bookstore which I like so it's a good date if you like to read. Can grab someone a book AND ice cream what's not to love The waffle cones themself were the star of the show. They weren't the typical break in 20 different pieces when you bit into them. They had a little chew to them which is LOVED and wide throughout Peanut Butter Pecan: 7.5/10 - Peanut butter swirls were bomb and not too sweet Pink Marshmallow Dream: 6.5/10 - Good vanilla sweetness, not a ton of marshmallow going on Peanut Butter S'mores: 6/10 - 6/10 PB flavor, not much inclusions read more

Oddfellows Ice Cream Company - Left: PB Pecan and PB S'mores Right: Pink Marshmallow Dream and PB S'mores - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

Of the ice cream flight flavors, I felt the Grasshopper (mint) flavor and coffee sticky bun were my favorite! This six scoop flight was $11. Worth it to try so many tasty flavors! I shared it with my partner. I picked three and he picked three. I look forward to bringing my vegan partner back here because they had lots of vegan flavor options! This little ice cream counter is inside of a bookstore. They make their own waffle cones. I leave off one star for terrible parking situations in that zone. The parking garages are all super expensive and over $10 on the weekends because of the events happening in the area. read more

Oddfellows Ice Cream Company - Ice cream flight for $11. Lots of vegan options! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

I've been satisfied with this place every time I've been! Some of their flavors can be a bit much (e.g. putting too much miso) but I applaud them for their creativity and appreciate the diversity and uniqueness of flavors. Texture is nice and creamy, which tbh is hard to find in Pittsburgh I feel like this city really specializes in soft serve. Would definitely recommend and the fact that it's in a super cute bookstore makes it also a fun and chill vibe! read more

Oddfellows Ice Cream Company - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

Little ice cream shop tucked within a bookstore. They've got an amazing selection of unique flavors to choose from. A one scooper was fairly sized which I appreciate. I settled on pistachio and it was solid, but the way I describe the appearance, texture, and flavor of their ice cream is matte. A bit difficult to describe. It's not super creamy, it's not overtly sweet. It has a harder consistency with undertones of the flavor. Overall, it was something I ended up really enjoying. I was tempted to get the flight of 6 scoops for only $11 to try a bunch of different flavors, but maybe next time! read more

Oddfellows Ice Cream Company - Pistachio - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

Great icecream in a prime location. They have an assortment of unique flavors and have allergens clearly posted in the menu. I ordered a single scoop of the frosted chocolate in a cup. Prices are on par with Jeni's/Millies. read more

Oddfellows Ice Cream Company - Frosted chocolate single scoop - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

See all

Great ice cream in an unexpected place! They have some flavor combinations i would have never dreamed of! I went with the cookies and cream/mint and apricot/pistachio. Totally Impressed! read more

We came for the ice cream and would have stayed for the books, but we were headed to show, and also there weren't any section headings, so we wouldn't have known what we were looking at. So we joined the line snaking though the displays. The Oddfellows staff were all really friendly, and we appreciated the ability to taste the flavors before making a decision. I got the spiced moose tracks, which was good (second choice was the chocolate chunk, which was more chocolaty than I was in the mood for). My partner had one of the few options without chocolate, as he has migraines, and also liked it. Solid option for a cold, sweet treat in The Strip. read more

Oddfellows Ice Cream Company - Spiced eggnog - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

This is a small ice cream shop inside the bookstore. They have about 12 or so flavors and can also do shakes and floats with those flavors. This place is a hidden gem with nice staff and fair prices. We actually came here twice because we liked it so much. When you order a float they give you a whole soda bottle that goes along with it so you can keep adding more soda to the float once you drink some of it. read more

Original high quality flavors, good service, clean, it was easy finding a spot to sit.

I loved this ice cream spot located inside of Posman Books in the Strip. They had a lot of different flavors to choose fro. The staff were very friendly and polite. I can't remember the exact name of what I had but I think the name was Blackout. It's chocolate ice cream and brownie pieces. It was delicious. read more

Oddfellows Ice Cream Company - I think the name was Blackout. It's chocolate ice cream and brownie pieces. - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

I fell in love with this adorable bookstore with the most amazing ice cream last weekend. I was at the Pittsburgh Taco Festival, and afterward we decided to shop around the area. The bookstore was packed with lots of shoppers and the ice cream looked delicious and the line was a little bit smaller. I got the strawberry jam ice cream in a sugar cone, and it was some of the best ice cream I've had in a long time. I would love to go back and take some more time in the bookstore, buy a book, and get some more great ice cream in the weeks to come read more

See all

Not a vegan but the vegan Coconut Mango Sticky Rice was fantastic. It's gotta be in my top five ice creams. Not too busy on a Saturday night on Labor Day weekend, tho these location is almost hidden inside a small book store. Service was quick and friendly. Would definitely go back if in the Pittsburgh area again. read more