I was visiting family in Old Bridge and wanted to bring over some Pizza. So glad I did. I got two large pizzas, one Plain and one Buffalo Chicken. The Buffalo Chicken was gone first. Everyone loved it. The plain was quickly enjoyed and gone soon after. This reminded me why NJ has some of the very best Pizza in the country. Thin yet crispy crust, The right amount of tasty sauce and perfect amount of cheese and toppings. I placed the order through Yelp and it was hot and ready when I came to pick it up. They were busy but friendly and helped me right away. This place is clean and they take pride in making it a local place to come, sit and enjoy a meal. I used to come her growing up, several decades ago, and it has only gotten more updated and nicer since then. If you want great NJ Pizza I recommend stopping in and getting some. And yes, single slices are available. read more

10/7/25 - Had a break in between appointments today and saw a nearby pizzeria so I figured what the heck. Old Bridge Pizzeria Restaurant is located in Old Bridge, NJ in a strip mall on the Rte 9 northbound side. The staff here is wonderful and super attentive from the moment you walk in. I ordered two plain slices and received them piping hot from a pie they took out of the oven upon my arrival. Unfortunately, the outer crust was the best part of the slice. It has a great pizza dough flavor and is both crispy and moist. The slices looked absolutely delicious but sometimes looks dont match the taste. And that is the case here. The sauce is tangy but lacks flavor beyond the tangy tomato taste. I am relatively certain that there is very little Italian seasonings utilized if any. The mozzarella is premium but without seasoning, it lacks punch. The biggest problem here is the slices are limp. They use a lot of sauce which is definitely preferable. But when you combine heavy sauce with a limp undercarriage, it adds up to a sloppy mess. The cheese slides right off and its extremely difficult to stay clean while eating. It was all over my hands and sadly stained my shirt as well. Overall Rating: C read more

See all

Pizzas were ok, nothing spectacular. Ordered margarita pizza, received plain instead. The chef asked if we all good - I said this is wrong pizza, and he just shrugged - claiming the order he got was for a plain pizza. read more

Their food is my daughter and I's favorite pizza in our whole town (and there's a million different pizza places). Besides from how good their pizzas and food are, the staff are some of the nicest, most genuine people I've ever met. My daughter likes plain pies and I enjoy toppings usually. I ordered a plain pizza, and as I picked it up I pointed at how delicious one slice looked, and the generous worker gave it to me gave me multiple slices to try. 100% would recommend, 10/10 experience, as per usual. read more

Old Bridge Restaurant & Pizzeria - BBQ Chicken Pizza - Large 18" - Pizza Near Me - Old Bridge, New Jersey

See all

They have really good food other than pizza also. I can always get my food really quick. Will be back soon!

Food is great but they always forget my honey mustard, gotta triple check when you get delivery.

Good pizza. I especially like the white Sicilian pizza!! Good service and easy to order.

Quick pizza or great chicken parm meals. Generally don't eat in restaurant mostly take out. The ambiance is good. Counter service helpful as well read more

sausege and pepper sub if there was one half a sausege sliced in this sub id be shocked, ive eaten here for 27 years, must be new ownership, diminished quality, mediocre tasting food overpriced for what you get, hidden delivery fees, make it a rip off. if my sub cost 1 $ to make i would be surprised and i paid 14$$ onion rings tasty and hot delivery was quick the days of 20$ plus pizzas are over folks !! read more

Soooo good. Had two slices the other day, a Sicilian and a margarita. And they were soooo good. Will be back for sure.

This is our to go for pizza. Always fresh, and their Stromboli is great also. Can't wait to try other things on the menu as well. But we are kind of addicted to the pizza now, read more

We've been ordering from Old Bridge Pizza for years, and just recently realized they make pan pies!!! Ugh, they're sooo good. Half margarita and half vodka is our fave. A little disappointed that their online ordering system has been down, as customers are supposed to receive 10% off. I had to call it in, and after going back and forth with the young man, they honored the 10%. We look forward to more future orders! read more

Nice place, recently remodeled for their 60th (or 70th?) anniversary. So, it's been around for a while. That being said, I was a bit surprised about the quality of their pizza. My party ordered a medium pesto w/ mozz pie and a medium margarita pie. The pesto itself needed WAY more garlic, there wasn't much taste to it at all. The margarita pie was ok, but the crust and dough was on the softer/rubbery side, which made the whole pie a little lackluster. Server was great and helpful, place looked good, but the food could definitely be better. read more

Courteous staff, food prepared with fresh ingredients, pizzeria restaurant food at its finest. Their pizza crust is everything you hope for in a quintessential Jersey pie. Crispy and crunchy on the outside, and consistently cooked to perfection. Plentiful, premium quality toppings and perfect sauce; not too sweet, not too acidic, just a delicious, smooth tomato sauce. Try the buffalo chicken pie for a spicy, tangy treat, prepared with their own in-house prepared cubed breaded chicken cutlets. All white meat. And their chicken Cesar salad is heaven. Try any item from the menu and enjoy. read more

Always good food!! But even better experience today I had to share. I ordered a to go order, but when I got home, found they gave me the wrong sandwich! Called and told them, and they DELIVERED the correct sandwich!' Excellent customer service!! Although dinner cost an extra $5 (tip), will continue to be a loyal customer!! read more

Uber eats off Old bridge. Stay away from delivery. Delivery charge plus 3.5% if u use a card. Overpriced garbage. Pizza is good but management sucks read more

We ordered 3 different pasta dishes. I hated my chicken parm. The cheese was terrible and there was as much chicken as there was breading. Wife's tortellini tasted weird, but the alfredo sauce was good. Kiddo's penne vodka was the best of the 3, but nothing amazing. I liked their garlic knots. The best thing was the oil and vinegar dressing for the salads. That's not saying a lot. Maybe the pizzeria is better, but the restaurant is average at best. read more

Never had a bad meal there. Best pizza in old bridge and the nicest workers too! Very nice atmosphere.

We had the food at another party and decided it was so good to use them when we moved to the area for our house warming party. James was the man who organized and helped take my catering order. He was nice, joking, professional, calming and very easy going and flexible. He was really the best part of the whole thing. Thank you James! The food was fantastic and so was the service read more

I ordered a few different items. The pizza, wings and mozzarella sticks were very good. The veal parmigiana hero was horrible. The veal was tough basically unchewable. It was so bad that I threw it in the garbage. read more

I have to say this pizzeria/restaurant does not get their due !! They have been a staple in this community for as long as I can remember. They are always delicious, consistent and the best customer service . They are really the best and I for one am grateful they have made it through every new foo foo pizzeria that shows up . I can remember when sandy hit us they were there feeding us and giving us a sense of normalcy. If you are not a patron I highly advise . read more

Just came back from having dinner there. The place was not busy and we were the only ones in the back dining area for quite some time. The food was really good but it took over an hour to get it. We dined in and the waitress was the worst ever! Had to ask multiple times for everything, they gave us ,no lie, about 5 oz size disposable cups each for a pitcher of soda. They were something you'd give a toddler at a kids BD party. Took 40 min. to get our salad, had to ask for bread, a bowl for shells. The waitress didn't know that with the meals you get a salad. A few days earlier my son and Dad went there and walked out after waiting a 1/2 hour and still was not waited on. Its sad but this place is really only good for take out. read more

Our family has been getting pizza and other dishes like the eggplant parmigiana from here for many years! The pizza has maintained a level of quality that is always appetizing! The dough is firm and the sauce and toppings are great! We usually request a "well done" pie and they cook it right every time! There are a lot of options when it comes to pizza, but you can't go wrong at Old Bridge Restaurant & Pizza!!! read more

This place is great! Conveniently located on route 9 with a large parking lot. Lots of comfortable tables and trendy banquets inside. The place is clean and the ambiance is casual. All the staff are friendly and helpful. I went with my son and we shared a few slices - the white with spinach, plain, and Sicilian. All three were delicious! Would absolutely return. read more

i am boiling mad. i've ordered from them before. food is good. today september 29th they totally proved them selves to be money greedy scum. i orderered 2 personal pizza with toppings & a sheperds salad. with blue cheese dressing. the delivered the food. no blue cheese dressing. i called spoke to SAMANTHA & HALEY when i placed the order. i called the manager and spoke to some guy i admit i was angry i said could u sen 2 small containers of blue cheeses dressing. which probably cost them a $1. these cheap money grubbing said i would have to pay. how do keep customer satisfaction with cheap scum owners like that. boycott this place and bankrupt them. money greedy scum. I had already paid via credit card for the food. read more

The girl on the phone had no people skills, super rude. The food is over cooked and tasteless. Literally waste of money and energy.

This is hands down the best pizza in Old Bridge and closest to NY PIZZA. The guys who work there are always very friendly and accommodating when we come in with lots of kiddies. read more

What is going on OB pizza? You used to be so good. My last few experiences have been subpar. Particularly with takeout pizzas. The crust is just not the same. What happened?? I noticed that when I eat in the restaurant, the crust is better. But when I bring pies home or have it delivered, it's different. So I think the issue is consistency - it needs to be good whether eating in or taking out. Question is: Why is it different? Are the crusts pre-made?? Because they have really been lacking in flavor, are too tough, or too thick, or are burnt. Could be round pizza or square grandma style. Doesn't matter. And the grandma tastes different lately - way too much garlic last time (tasted jarred, too). And the round pies are always cut weird with all different size slices. Something has been off for a while now. Need quality control. Need consistency. I'm really upset about this because I love you guys and am a loyal fan. Please, if you're doing something different or cutting corners on take-out pies, please stop! Why mess with a good thing??? I want a good, tasty crust, fresh tomato sauce, fresh toppings, and melty, stringy cheese. And delivered hot! Is that too much to ask? One more thing... I never had a problem in the past with customer service but whoever answered the phone for delivery had a major attitude. Didn't even say goodbye when she hung up. Clearly she is not happy there. Will try again in the near future and hope for the best. Grazie! read more

Absolutely amazing pizza. The buffalo chicken pie is unlike any other I've had. They have a lot of specialty pizza options and great service behind the counter. The wings are also very good As well! read more

My family orders from this pizzeria quite often. I am very disappointed in the pies! I'm surprised these pies made it through the pizzeria doors. The pies are floppy, wet, and raw. The pictures will speak for themselves. Disgusting. read more

See all

First time here yesterday and was pleasantly surprised. Not u normal pizza parlor. Very clean, tastefully decorated. Pleasant staff. But, most important of all, the food is good, the choices of slices during lunch time make it difficult to choose because there r so many delicious looking slices. I chose grandma style thin Sicilian and it was every bit tasty as it looked read more

We ordered pizza cheesecake and mousse chocolate mousse pizza was Slade all of the cheese was just slid all over the place one half of the pizza didn't have cheese on it cuz it was all to the left of it so the driver obviously wasn't easy on delivering or driving the cheesecake had a pretty good taste to it that's the only reason I put up one star I wish I could put up zero because when me and my husband got to the chocolate moose it was loaded in green fuzzy fungus so there was mold all over the Moose it was all over the sides we dissected it found a huge patch of it in the center or more towards the bottom so basically my family was fed moldy chocolate mousse I don't know how this place stays in business when you serve your pain customers moldy food that is disgusting and never again will I eat there and I will tell everyone to stay as far away as possible and definitely show them the pictures it's going up on my Facebook it's going up on my YouTube channel it is going everywhere on how you fed your customers moldy food that's just pure laziness that is not an accident that is because you were too lazy to check your inventory out or check your expiration date or you wanted to save some money and figured nobody would realize they were eating fuzzy moose never again don't buy from this place whatever you do read more

See all

I had this place During Special Olympics 2019. This help me with my Energy and have the best pizza out there.

We were served cold pizza. The pizza itself was pretty ok. The chicken parm was really dry and very little parmigiana. Very disappointed . read more

The Old Bridge Special!!!!! You have to get it. Yummy!!!!! It has all the toppings and was awsome!

No words. Just incredible. Lots of amazing options, all with amazing flavor and quality. Everything here is handcrafted, to the point where you can see them making the pizzas right in front of you. The line can get a bit overwhelming on busy nights, but it is definitely worth the wait and your money. Five star service, food, and staff. Will be coming back very soon. read more

We were Krispy patrons and decided to try Old Bridge Pizza after reading the reviews and the place is closer to home. Perhaps I ordered the wrong thing but my eggplant with angel hair was mediocre. The sauce did not compare at all to Krispy and my eggplant was burnt and tasted awful. My husband ordered suasage and peppers and he said it was just OK. So back to Krispy we go. The staff was very friendly tho. read more

This place serves delicious pizza. As a NJ native who has eaten perhaps millions of slices in my life, I feel qualified to tell you that their plain and pepperoni slices are about as good as it gets. Or maybe I'm just especially hungry every time I go there. There is another pizza place right down the street, in the Shop Rite strip mall. That place has very good pizza, as well. But Old Bridge pizza definitely has them beat. They've also got some new gluten-free pizza options (for any of you out there with an allergy). I had the spaghetti and meatballs w/ meat sauce once. It was also delicious. read more

Ordered pizza for pickup. Pizza was good. But, blonde cashier could use a lesson in customer service. Rude. I ordered a pizza not an attitude and eye roll. read more

great crew and food. one small complaint. you used to be able to come in here at lunch time and dinner time and maybe time a pie coming out of the oven and get a fresh slice. something has changed. now it's and old pizza getting recooked and then the slices possibly going back in the oven for a third cook. one of the great pleasures in life are those fresh slices. pizza nevere tastes the same when it's recooked. at peak hours get more pies out there that are right out of the oven. you used to work this way. please, pease go back to that practice.. thanks! read more