8/8/25 - There's a pizza shop in Parlin, NJ called Pizza Heaven. I took my son there about 15 years ago. The pizza was pretty good but the place was a complete dump. Worn out dining area. Dirty tables. And the deathknell, it was completely empty. Fast forward to 2025.... the place has a new owner and a brand new dining area. And it's wonderful! The pizza is in the neopolitan style. It's crispy and flavorful. The cheese tastes premium. Great sauce. The sausage is not cut-rate. They have completely turned this place around. And the dining room had a lot of people in it enjoying the food. If you are in the Parlin area, it's definitely worth your time. So my daughter told me that I need to start rating these places. I hesitate to do so because I dont want to be compared to that other guy who in my opinion is a complete nasal drip. I review places for one reason.... out of love for the products. I love stadiums. I love arenas. And most of all, I love food. So I'm not doing this for clicks but to give my friends and family a roadmap of places to visit and my experiences with these places. So Pizza Heaven gets a solid B+ read more

Pizza Heaven - Front - Pizza Near Me - Parlin, New Jersey

See all

Staff is very unprofessional... New owners and drivers aren't the same... I went in and there was fighting and screaming going on beyond the counter... I walked out read more

Ordered pizza and wings for delivery, and the pizza was so-so and the wings made me sick either bad handling or they were bad but either way I was sick as a dog after eating them read more

I had half white and half margarita vodka pie . The margarita vodka pie was pretty good. read more

Pizza Heaven - Pizza Near Me - Parlin, New Jersey

This was not good pizza. We did a honey roni Sicilian and a hot honey bbq chicken. I know it says home made hot honey, but I could barely taste it on either pie. The honey roni had a terrible distribution of both sauce and ronis. So some pieces were wet and floppy, others were nice and crispy, some had 15 ronis, and some had 3. It was a mess to eat, and not particularly good. I liked the bbq sauce they used on the bbq chicken pizza. That's about all I can say for this one. The crust was white, like the pie never saw the inside of an oven. No crisp. I had to bake it at 400 at home to crisp it up, and that turned the crust into a crunchy brick. No air in there at all. Overall, hard pass. read more

Love this local pizzaria! Been going their since i was in middle school! soo over 10+ years. It never disappoints. love their fresh warm slices of pizza. my go to is a big old slice of vodka sauce slice with sesame seeds on the crust. the employees are always pleasant and sweet. They have recently updated their tables and lay out of the pizzaria. it has comfy and plenty of seating! read more

New ownership took over and it at first things seemed ok.... However when my girlfriend ordered a salad and mozzarella sticks and got charged $36 they tried to claim she asked for shrimp on the salad when she didn't... They then offer a $6 credit so we ordered a pizza and then tried to og ore is about the credit and then still charged almost $16 fprmthe pizza . Scam artists read more

Been coming to Pizza Heaven since I was a little kid all the way through college! Definitely one of the best pizzerias in the Parlin/Sayreville area. Old school vibe, friendly service always. My go to slice shop when I am in visiting family. read more

Pizza Heaven - Vodka with sesame seed crust - Pizza Near Me - Parlin, New Jersey

I've always loved pizza heaven, it was my favorite pizza spot for years. But these new workers are just terrible. Every single time i come here which is only once every few months now since it's always such a bad experience, the cashiers (especially) and cooks are so blatantly rude and ignorant. If you order over the phone, they will literally lie to you and say they have stuff that they DONT have just so that you'll still come in and buy their food. I think there's also a new recipe or something for the pizza. The slices are much smaller now & taste different. I would recommend Mancini's in east brunswick or Angelo's. This place isn't the same! read more

The website is not the easiest to navigate and does not have a way of customizing menu items. On phone order, the person either cannot hear me when I'm ordering or is learning the job. One item was Chicken Piccata. The chicken was dry and overdone. The pasta was fine and the second order was good. Delivery time was good. My husband said if we order again, the only thing on the menu he was pleased with is a cheese steak sandwich. read more

Best penne vodka in the state. Fettuccine Alfredo is awesome and love the round pie. The owner John is a gentleman. Great family owned restaurant. read more

Good food good service very welcoming check out the vodka pizza it's slamming definitely recommend

Since new owner took over I think the food is better quality and staff is friendly however they definitely mess orders up. Need a better phone maybe? Anyway definitely double check your order before leaving with your food read more

I know it's a pandemic. But counting 12 French Fries in a order I think is a little crazy. Gotta do better than that. read more

Pizza Heaven - a sandwich and french fries in a styrofoam container - Pizza Near Me - Parlin, New Jersey

This is a small order of chicken fingers. When I called up to let them know about the order, they were very rude. Bad customer service is enough to ruin ones day and that's what exactly pizza heaven did to me. Paid $9 for this and would be ok with an apology to the least but alas! No more support the local for me read more

Pizza Heaven - Chicken fingers - Pizza Near Me - Parlin, New Jersey

Under new ownership and so much better now. The food was delicious. I love their sauce. The portions of food always leave me with leftovers. I'm very happy with the changes. Great customer service. They go above and beyond to make customers happy. read more

Good food, but was surprised that the man behind the counter was not wearing a mask, and the patron he was speaking to was not wearing a mask either. read more

I'm not a big cheese guy, however I love getting my once a month large pepperoni from Pizza Heaven, I love the sauce, it's great on the tongue. Love it here. read more

This pizzeria has been around for ages. It use to be my family's go-to place for pizza. Unfortunately, we had forgotten about it over the years. Tonight, although it was pretty late on a Sunday evening and they were closing soon, Pizza Heaven was accommodating and delivered to us in such a short period of time. The Margherita Pizza was absolutely delicious! I'm so happy we remembered and I can't wait to order from them again! read more

Pizza Heaven - a pizza with cheese and spinach - Pizza Near Me - Parlin, New Jersey

I can't even rate the place yet other than by via phone service...which was to say, less than poor. The first time was rude, the second time I wans't even sure I called the correct place. The last two times I have called for delivery...well before an hour within close, I have been summarily refused/dismissed. I am relatively new to the area, and I have had some acquaintances talk the place up. I called tonight, at about 9:50pm (they close at 11pm) and was basically dismissed regarding my order. If you say you're open 'till 11, and deliver 'till 11 on a Sat night, then you should probably honor it...especially more than an hour before you close. Each time I have called, whomever I spoke to seemed to give not a damn about the prospective business. Being in the restaurant industry, I would not leave a negative review based on a single occurrence, but back-to-back (within 3 nights?) is unacceptable. Perhaps it's that I'm from the midwest, but in a well populated area, before 10pm on a Sat, with a LOT of competition...one should probably honor their advertised hours. Please, advertise delivery hours vs hours of operation, and that would alleviate reviews such as mine. If this place is nearly as good as people say it is, it surely isn't because of their customer service. read more

THE ABOUSTLE BEST PLACE IN TOWN! Recommend for you family pizza night And also your catering needs! 10/10 never upset !

The foods always amazing ! I've been to this place since I was little and now we go with our kids !

The food was old, and the service is horrible. The place is dated and the owner is beyond rude. The prices listed is not the price they charge. The charge a service fee when you pay by credit card, and there is no sign posted any where stating this. read more

This local pizza joint is great all around. The sicilian pie, cold hoagies, baked ziti, and cheesesteaks are all fantastic. The pizza is a bit on the oily side compared to other pizzas I've had but that only makes it taste better. The prices are reasonable too! I've had delivery a few times where they forgot my drink and I don't really care to make the driver come back just for a soda so I've taken a few losses there. All in all a great go to spot for a meal or a slice. read more

I haven't eaten here since I was a kid, and this place is still amazing. This is one of the few pizzerias in the area that serves deep dish pizza which is amazing. read more

Grew up in Sayreville, which has a large variety of great pizzarias to choose from, and Pizza Heaven is definitely up there with some of the best. Their pizza comes in the traditional thin crust, or some a little bit thicker (though not quite deep dish). Every slice I've had has been great, I especially like the taste of the sauce. Probably one their finest items, aside from the pizza, though, is their cheesesteak (surprisingly)! I lived in Philly for 2 years, so I know what a good cheesesteak sandwich should be like, and I still think Pizza Heaven's version is up there with the best! My favorite one comes loaded with hot peppers, so each bite gives you a nice kick! read more

Went here with some friends - we were looking to kill some time before meeting up with someone in Parlin. The person at the counter was really rude and just kind of grunted at us and ended up messing up my order and giving me 5 garlic knots instead of 1. Whatever. The garlic knots were pretty good - very garlicky, which is a +. i also ordered the 12" provolone/pepperoni sub, which was really good. Half of it kept me full all day. I took the leftover half to my friend's house, and when he went to eat it later we found that it was soggy - it soaked through 2 paper bags. We had to toss it. Strangely enough, my friend's leftover hoagies, prepared the same (mayo/oil/vinegar) weren't soggy. I'd go back if I was in the area and needed takeout - but I would just get the 6" hoagie. read more

Still love this place and need to stop every time I visit my hometown. And bonus, they now deliver! Too bad they won't deliver to South Jersey! read more

Chicken Cheesesteak are great. The staff isn't always the best at customer service but the food is good. read more

Pizza Heaven - Pizza Heaven - Pizza Near Me - Parlin, New Jersey

Really good local, near-by neighborhood pizza. A little too oily/greasy, but the cheese, crust & sauce ratio is pretty good. Employees are nice, restaurant is clean & well-kept. Would recommend if in Sayreville area & looking for decent, casual good pizza. They also have a baked ziti pasta which I heard was good. read more

It needs to be cleaned inside. Very outdated looking, but that doesn't really matter, but it needs a good cleaning. If it's dirty where I sit and can see, I don't want to see how dirty the kitchen is. Please clean! read more

Best pizza place in NJ hands down. I've been going here for over 20 years and will continue for another 20 more! Some of my favorite things to get from here: Sicilian pie, plain pie, cheesesteak & baked ziti. You will not be disappointed read more

The pizza was so delicious, I had to give it a 5 star review. The staff was courteous and helpful too!

My favorite go to pizzeria in town. The pizza here is pretty good! Although I must say them best is their crumbled sausage pizza! The sauce is sweet! And the sausage is cooked to perfection! The only thing I noticed was that this time around the pepperoni was just a little greasy. This is the first time I've experienced that after 17 years so I won't hold it against them! All around great pizza! I typically take out but the dinning area is decent a couple of booths and than some tables and chairs scattered around. read more

Had been coming here off and on for years (since the late 80's), and the food was formerly dependable. Lately, I've been disappointed repeatedly, but for nostalgia's sake, kept returning. No more. A few days ago I was charged $55 for four ham, salami, and provolone subs and one large pie. Felt high, but with Covid season, just wanted to get out the door. I scribbled my name at the bottom of the receipt, grabbed the food and split. Upon returning home, I went online and checked the prices; it didn't add up to more than $43. Mistakes are made, right? When I checked my bank balance this morning, a tip was added!! NEVER going back, and telling anyone I know to avoid this dinosaur. read more

Thank you for the prompt delivery. Pizza was basic. Nothing fancy. However all gone when hungry. Would order again if hungry and in town

It's a good place ! The atmosphere is pretty chill, the staff are friendly, and the pizza is good. I've been coming here for years and, although I don't have a "favorite" pizza place, this is one of the best places for pizza and garlic knots! read more

I love their plain pie with extra cheese! They're kind of expensive, and sometimes not too fresh- but if you order delivery on a Friday night then you know it's fresh. read more

This is definitely one of our go-to local take out places. We love the chicken cheesesteaks! Their regular pie is good, but our favorite is the pan pie! Worth the extra wait! read more

AVOID THIS PLACE ! Never going back there after what I heard today. I was sitting there when a Veteran walked in to pick up his order and politely asked if there was a military discount, he was about 85 y/o and wearing his Marines hat with medals. The cashier (bald Italian guy), then proceeded to mock him and told him that they didn't offer military discounts and said, "No, what about a punch to the face". After taking the credit card from the Vet, the casher then came back and said, "You should have asked for an Italian discount," again, in a mocking way. After the Vet left quietly, a guy and his girlfriend walked over to the cashier to pick up their order and the same cashier yelled out," What, do you want a military discount to?" The guy ended up saying ... "sure i'll take one since I just graduated boot camp". The cashier remained silent and didn't know what to say or do, except laugh it away. I also noticed there was a guy sitting there with a Marines tee shirt on waiting for his order and who was very annoyed at the cashiers behavior, as was I. If this is the way our military gets treated at this establishment, then I will not be supporting pizza heaven any longer. Id rather take the longer ride and go to NUNZIO's where people are respected and their work and sacrifice is appreciated. I'm work in law enforcement and hope all military personnel and LEO's think twice about ordering from these rude and disrespectful people. I've also heard the owner make less than appropriate remarks at this place from time to time, so it must run in the family because i'm sure these two are related. AVOID THIS PLACE ! read more