Food is absolutely delicious. Wife and o have to choose Italian with pizza due to my kiddos limited things he is willing to eat. So it comes down to pizza or pasta for my kiddo. We've been to tons of Italian places...from mainstream to mom and pop. I I gave this restaurant 5 stars: quality taste, friendliness, well covered and dog friendly. The food: wife had the ziti with chicken parm, o had penne à la vodka, my kiddo had the pizza, all three wheee top notch delicious. To add, I waited for dessert to seal the deal. We have the tiramisu....5 stars for the win. We did not expect this in Williamsburg va. We came on a Wednesday for lunch (1-3) and apparently they have bottle be at 50 percent off...not expensive. We have the Ruta 22 Malbec, $14 for the whole bottle. Yeah, a must if you are in the area and thinking of Italian restaurant: read more

Olde Towne Pizza and Pasta - Penne à la vodka - Italian Near Me - Williamsburg, Virginia

We stopped in after a long day to enjoy some pasta. The portions are the same as other places. The calamari pasta was not great. The calamari was definitely overcooked and rubbery. My husband enjoyed his lasagna. Our friends really enjoyed their dishes especially the lemon chicken pasta. The food, for me, was average. The restaurant was informal, good for families and the server was great and attentive. I would probably try something else if I ever had to come back if I was with a group but would probably try somewhere else if I had a choice. read more

See all

Enjoyed this family-friendly spot near the outlets. The spaghetti and meatballs hit the spot, sauce was not too sweet which I appreciated. My friend had the seafood pasta and she said the pasta was perfect but much of the seafood was overcooked. Would come back and try something else next time. read more

Olde Towne Pizza and Pasta - Seafood Combo - Italian Near Me - Williamsburg, Virginia

See all

We are visiting the area so we have no idea who is good or bad. After reading about 15 yelp reviews of various pizza places we decided on Olde Town Pizza. Good choice we got the medium veggie added anchovies and it was delicious. It was a little pricey but the service was great the pizza was perfectly cooked and arrived hot. Nice quiet place to eat. Lots of families and they serve other Italian items as well read more

This Italian restaurant offers a warm and pleasant dining experience with soft lighting and tasteful decor. The food came out quickly and we enjoyed everything we ordered. The flavors were tasty. Service was good. We saw many small families with children and even larger groups enjoying their meal. This is a wonderful date night option, as well. Glad we chose Olde Towne Pizza and Pasta for our dinner tonight! read more

See all

Very friendly staff and the food is pretty good. I did enjoy their pizza, but my one complaint is I requested two substitutions on the pizza but got charge $8 for additional toppings. So that ended on a little sour note on an otherwise nice experience. read more

See all

Picked up a large pepperoni & sausage pizza after a long day in Williamsburg. The pizza was Excellent! However $34 for a large pizza is a bit steep IMO. read more

The food and service were great! We had a family of 6 to feed (4 adults and 2 kids). There was more than enough food and we had leftovers to take home. This will definitely be added to our list of favorite places when we visit Williamsburg. read more

See all

Visited this restaurant in July while on a family vacation. The food was tasteless. There were 4 of us. We tried different items: Shrimp in Marinara Sauce, Lasagna, Spaghetti w/meatballs, & Chicken Marsala. The sauce on each item was watery & tasteless. There was no seasoning at all (not even salt & pepper). The ones with pasta included had pasta that was way over cooked. I was so disappointed because the reviews were very good. Would never visit again. read more

Our waitress was very friendly and attentive. The food was decent. Was it the best pizza I've ever eaten? No, but it was good. I would try this place again. read more

Pizza to go for a hungry crew after a full day of water slides. We got a meat lovers and a gluten free with pepperoni and mushrooms. My kids ate both without even noticing the mushrooms. Muahahaha! I call that success, even though the pizza was also delicious. My sister commented on how exactly what she wanted the regular pizza was. I was happy and satisfied with my gf. read more

took 20 minutes to make a medium white pizza, which wasn't even good. they don't have alfredo sauce which was my original choice (??), only thing that's good is how the inside looks but i'd rather like the food, mid ambiance. DO NOT RECOMMEND read more

A local favorite and yes I'm glad I stop in. The meat lovers one word wow. It's full of flavor and well there's plenty to go around. The staff were quick and friendly. read more

See all

Pizza was delicious! We had a large pepperoni, sausage & bacon. We also had Italian salad. Perfect salad with Provalone & salami... cucumber, tomato, carrots, red onion. We also had garlic bites. Baked to perfection... nice & crispy with marinara. Wait staff was very attentive & had the order down perfectly. Nice location & atmosphere. read more

Food was amazing. We came with a very large group of people. All staff there were very accommodating, super friendly and the pizza was in my top 5 for best ever and may be number 1. Great place for some great food and a reasonable price. Thank you guys for doing a great job. read more

Olde Towne Pizza and Pasta - The whole group silent bc they are stuffing their face with some great food - Italian Near Me - Williamsburg, Virginia

The atmosphere was lovely at this restaurant are large group of nearly 20 people arrive last minute with lots of kids. The staff was excellent very attentive. They surprisingly got all of our meals out in less than 20 minutes. And had us back on the road and our long trip home. Couldn't read this higher. The food was excellent and very generous quantities. We highly recommend it and return. read more

I really wanted to like the food. I'm visiting Williamsburg with my husband and daughter and tonight was my night to pick! I spent almost an hour looking for an Italian restaurant that had something we each would like. Hubby ordered the chicken Marsala. WAY too much wine. It was watery and flavorless. My daughter got the chicken Alfredo. It was descent but the chicken was rubbery. I ordered a pizza with sausage and mushrooms. Blah. Definitely not New York style. The crust was boring and the cheese was tasteless. The mozzarella caprese was pretty good. The focaccia bread had no flavor and was served with marinara sauce. Oil & vinegar would have been more traditional. Definitely disappointed in the food. The service was good and the ambiance was nice. Except for the 1970s easy listening they had playing. Made no sense. Clientele were all under 50. Would give less stars, but service and ambiance deserved 3. read more

We went back to this restaurant while in Williamsburg for vacation. The food was delicious and the service was top notch. We will go back next time. read more

Look folks, this place is a hidden gem. Great food. Large portions. Even the napkins were huge. To top it off, we got a military discount. read more

Olde Towne Pizza and Pasta - Meat Lovers Stromboli for 2. - Italian Near Me - Williamsburg, Virginia

This review is based on the one and only menu item we tried, which was the Philly Cheesesteak. The husband was craving one and this came up in a Google search as the 2nd best cheesesteak in the burg, but sadly it was not so good! Btw, the first place was closed! First off not much meat and it was kind of tough. Also not enough cheese. The bread was also not that good. Overall a huge letdown, especially when you are hoping for a good cheesesteak. read more

Olde Towne Pizza and Pasta - Cheesesteak - Italian Near Me - Williamsburg, Virginia

See all

My school visited from California and the food was so good. i really like the pizza and pasta, the service was really good everyone was nice and the food came quickly. the inside was nice and big and roomy thank you! i recommend going read more

You will ordinarily find good food here, their prices are above standard. $35 for a large pizza is excessive. read more

Olde Towne Pizza and Pasta - Hawaiian - Italian Near Me - Williamsburg, Virginia

We stopped in for lunch before outlet shopping and are so glad we did. The food is good and the portions are large (even the lunch specials). The staff were all very friendly and attentive. Plenty of parking available and while a little off the path, you could walk from the outlets to this restaurant if needed. Also, make sure to save room for dessert - the zeppoles are so delicious! read more

See all

ugly ceilings first of all. feels like a school cafeteria past the trim. service was good the people are very sweet it's not on them. it's the fucking system. paid 57 including tips for 2 sodas, 7 mozzarella sticks and a medium margarita pizza. The food was decent but not nearly worth the price. mozzarella sticks lost elasticity after 3 minutes, and the pizza had a distasteful flop and way too much cheese. A DISGRACE to New York style pizza. The music is awful as well it's horrible minimalist covers of pop songs. Go somewhere else for your Sysco read more

Great value, Italian meals. The pasta is top notch and the sauces are good. Yes you had better, but eating from here makes ya feel you're not being scammed on taste, portion, or quality. The service was better than expected for pizza restaurants and I feel you can feed a family of four on multiple options under $100. read more

We have been trying different pizzas in Williamsburg, and Olde Towne Pizza and Pasta make a good pie! We like thin pizza with a somewhat sweet sauce. My husband describes it as a wonderful New York-style pizza. Friendly and welcoming staff greet you with a smile. When they say to pick up in 20 minutes, they will your pizza hot and ready to go on time. We use the 10% off coupon that looks like a ticket, and you can find those coupons at hotels and various shops in the area. While we take out, our neighbors like to dine in after bowling (a bowling business is next door). They also really like the full meals and service. I wish I had a photo to share, but we dive right into the pizza each time! read more

We needed an outlet break and this was perfect. It's not in the outlets, but right across the street; short ride. It's in a strip mall with a paint store next door. The atmosphere is generic 90's Italian restaurant. Old fashioned booths with acrylic water glasses. We came for lunch and the lunch menu is decent. I ordered a slice of pizza with house salad. The salad was tiny, but pizza slice was large. Pizza was not amazing, but good. My daughter got lunch pasta with tomato sauce and meatball. She enjoyed it, although she still said my spaghetti with meat sauce is better. That is super sweet, but I want restaurant food to be better than what we make at home. My younger one ordered kids pasta with Alfredo. Somehow that is actually $11.99, which is more than all the lunch items. Order fail on my part. She liked the dish; it's very rich and creamy. I gained 2 pounds having a few bites. Overall, solid lunch choice. read more

See all

I decided to stop here after shopping at the outlets and took a look at the menu beforehand. I was happy to see they served stromboli. I ordered the meat lovers stromboli and some drinks. I didn't want too much due to it being lunchtime. This stromboli was surprising big and full of meat, cheese, and sauce. You don't need any extra sauce but they will give you a side of sauce if you ask. The cheese and sauce were delicious. I wish this place was in Richmond so I could visit more often. Service was great. Our waitress was knowledgeable and attentive. The restaurant was super cute with unique decor such as the wine racks on the walls above the lamps. read more

See all

Pizza and pasta were excellent. Every dish was cooked to perfection. Service was spot on.

Hands down the best pizza in town!! I love this restaurant. Their salad and slice of pizza lunch special gives you a generous amount of food. Seriously, it's the best pizza I've ever had in my life. Bravo to the chef and his kitchen crew. We'll continue to come back each time we visit Williamsburg. read more

Great local Italian restaurant. Food and service excellent. Large portions. Would eat there again. read more

See all

Let's go ahead and get it out of the way, it's pricey BUT well worth it. The food was absolutely delicious and I wouldn't mind paying that again. The service was great and kind to my kids and the ambiance of the place was very family oriented. I wouldn't mind paying recommend to any and all for good pizza and pasta!! read more

Went here because I had eaten their pizza at a birthday party and loved it! We went last night after work. One good thing about this place is they work/stay open till everyone is gone. Coworkers wouldn't stop talking about how great this place was. So we all ordered something other than pizza to see the rest of the menu. The salads were big and the chicken and eggplant Parmesan were liked by the coworkers. Me? I ordered a meatball sub and it tasted like nothing. And I actually mean that, nothing. They have garlic powder, Italian seasoning and some other stuff on the table. That was the only taste I had. Big bread, not many small meatballs and nothing other than some minimal cheese and sauce. We maybe back to pick up a pizza but I won't order anything else from here. The one thing that ticked everyone off was that this place decide to charge 20% gratuity without mentioning it. We had all gotten our tickets and we about to start signing stuff when I realized that my $13.99 sandwich bill was for around $17. In Va you can charge that for 6 or more at a table. There were 5 adults eating. They must have counted the 2 month old breastfeeding under a blanket as the 6th. Dear place you should have let us tip you. You would have made out so much better. We were all talking about what we were giving when we were surprised with the checks. But the surprise added gratuity was all you ended up with. If we end up coming here again it will be for a pizza and because there is nothing else open. read more

Went on a Saturday night. They were slamming busy. We ordered to go. While we waited they have a tv where you can watch them in the kitchen making the food. That was cool to watch. 20 minutes and we were out the door. The food ..... AMAZING. If you're in the area .. stop on in read more

We are from Richmond but in town for the weekend and decided to DoorDash from this place based on the reviews and the menu. I ordered the shrimp Alfredo with angel hair pasta, broccoli, and I told them to make it spicy (idk what this meant but I'm always down for spicy and it was a free option) Upon arrival, the portion was huge! Very heavy. Loaded with shrimp broccoli and all the fixins. Spicy meant adding more red pepper into it and I was here for it. 10/10. We ordered the mozz sticks. Regular degular, nothing to write home about. 6/10 My husband ordered The Godfather cheesesteak. He gives it a 9/10! I tried the meat in it and it was seasoned to perfection. Would def order from them again during our mini vacay! read more

We had such a wonderful experience with family here. We started with garlic knots. The garlic knots were delicious, and an awesome portion size for 6 people. The garlic distribution on the garlic knots was outstanding. Our food came out super quickly and everything was incredible. The calzone was a huge portion and so tasty, the pizza cooked to perfection, and the table favorite was the alfredo. Our server was attentive and made us feel at home. I would recommend Olde Towne to anyone looking for a lovely atmosphere and epic food. Will be back! read more

I've eaten here a few times this is my first togo order, got a cheese pizza to take back to our room. The pizza is very good stop in and give it a try. read more

See all

I paid almost $10 for a Greek Salad that basically came in a side salad to go container and was missing olives. The small pizzas are basically personal pan pizzas as well. Now knowing that the prices are high and the quanity and quality is low, will not be going back. read more

The aroma grabbed us before we got in the door. It was fantastic. we we're welcomed in and seated. Our only struggle was trying to decide what we would eat. My lasagna was so delicious, I highly recommend it. I loved the the chocolate cheesecake. My party couldn't eat all of the large meat lover pizza. It was so good. The staff stopped by several times to check on us, our glasses were never empty . Everyone was so friendly and courteous. I highly recommend Old Towne Pizza & Past, try it for yourself, you won't be disappointed!!! read more

Visiting Williamsburg and needed a good pizza since the kids wanted dominoes. After reading reviews on here and Google, we grabbed a pizza from here on our way to Alewerks brewery. Pizza was great and do recommend this place. Crust was excellent with just the right amount of doneness and chew. Meats chosen were fresh, sauce 2 thumbs up. Please give this place a try for their pizza. read more

Olde Towne Pizza and Pasta - All meat pizza - Italian Near Me - Williamsburg, Virginia