Fantastic dinner this evening at Olivo Mediterranean Fare in Pine Brook (formerly Don Pepe's Steakhouse). Very impressed with the beautiful, modern, and inviting bright and airy atmosphere; as well as the attentive, friendly, and welcoming service. Thank you to our server Tony for helping to make it a memorable dining experience. The food was outstanding! The grilled octopus and shrimp in garlic appetizers were absolutely delicious. My entree of Filet Mignon Medallions, grilled and finished with mushroom sauce was a home run. Tender, juicy, and mouth waveringly delicious!! Also came with sides of mixed veggies, saffron rice, and Spanish potato chips. Certainly would order it again. The whole Branzino, seasoned with herbs, Olive Oil, and lemon, filleted at the table, was also off the charts. The baklava w/ice cream, Crème brûlée, and cappuccinos finished off a perfect meal. I would certainly give this place a high recommendation! Thank you to Ann and Nick Grossi for the invite and enjoyable evening. 05/28/2026 read more

See all

Excellent service in this bright, new. Welcoming restaurant. We were HUGE fans of the now closed Dom Pepe ll so we're excited to try this. We understand the new owners bought both Dom Pepe Steakhouse (this location) and Dom Pepe ll around the corner. Olivo has Mediterranean fare similar to the old Dom Pepe ll. The food was good but not great. We preferred Dom Pepe ll. The service was excellent- the best. Balanced out I gave 4 stars overall. The lobster in both mariscata and paella was tough. Shrimp were smaller than jumbo shrimp we are accustomed to. Veal francais was tender, but kind of boring. The white sangria was orange (not white) and very strong didn't taste like sangria at all. All in all good, but 3 people for lunch was $132 before tip I want than just good! read more

See all

Celebrated my dad's birthday here with a group of 6 on a weekday. Parking on site; when you enter you really feel like you have stepped into vacation mode and out of NJ which is wonderful. Staff is friendly and space is pretty open with great lighting and tons of seating options for groups large and small. We ordered a bunch of apps and the paella along with the sangria which was YUM! Ok now doe the breakdown Chorizo (5/5) really solid option and the table enjoyed it Lamb chips (5/5) super juicy and tender really flavorful and a great option Broccoli Rabe (1/5) really bland kind of a fail for me sadly Paella (3/5) it is definitely more of a 2 person sharing option if you were only eating this. We had a number of apps and sides so it fed our table well. On its own it was fine but not spectacular in terms of flavor and rice was cooked fine. No major issues just not wow for me personally. Sangria (5/5) really great refreshing and I would recommend the pitcher! Dessert we got the crème brulle which was yum and we also ordered the baklava with iced cream which was delish! Menu is substantial but not overwhelming, value is there and pricing is respectable without breaking the bank. I would come back with an eye towards drinks and apps :) read more

See all

Outstanding! This newly renovated restaurant which is now the new home to the old and closed Don Pepe ( new name ) is amazing. The restaurants atmosphere is bright and airy. Very comfortable. The bar/lounge area is also large, fresh and inviting. The 2 1/2 lb steamed lobsters were cooked to perfection. Soft, juicy and tender. Very fresh. The bone in rib eye was perfectly cooked to medium rare. Soft and very tender. Side dishes of fresh cut potato chips and mixed vegetables topped it off. A very nice complimentary portion of fried zucchini slices with Parmesan cheese started us off. The mature d and service staff were not only professional but polite, attentive, engaging and very sincere. Excellent service. Plenty of easy parking with valet parking on the weekends. read more

See all

Make reservations! They have complimentary valet which is nice. This is a great restaurant for just about anything.. birthday, anniversary, girls night out, date night etc. Their espresso martini is exquisite! It's made with REAL espresso unlike some that make it with coffee liquor. The red sangria was close to our homemade lol! I had the Kobe pork chop and it was cooked to perfection juicy and delicious. Hubby had the swordfish and again cooked exactly the way he likes it. We didn't order any apps since they give you vegetables, some yellow rice as well as homemade chips. Unfortunately we were too full for dessert, but the choices looked quite decadent. I promise you will enjoy it here. read more

Third visit in 45 days - definitely our new favorite! Celine at the front is always friendly and the staff is attentive. We had 2 separate, unrelated reservations that she was able to combine into one on a Saturday night - impressive. My wife swore she was going to try something different but ended up with the Shrimp in green sauce she's ordered every time - loved it so much. I tried the scallops and they did not disappoint - nice sear on outside, tender on the inside. Interesting choice to pair with mashed potatoes - I would have liked more flavor in the potatoes. The grilled octopus is my new favorite appetizer. The Mariscada is probably the best overall dish on the menu - IMO. The outside seating is finally open - we were inside in the dining room to the left near the bar as this has the biggest table. Love the modern, light decor. My only negative is still the same - it's loud. read more

Olivo Mediterranean Fare - Shrimp in red sauce (spicy & good) and Mariscada seafood dish. - Mediterranean Near Me - Pine Brook, New Jersey

We only did the takeout here so far but the paella is out of the world. They packed in so nicely for us and it can easily serve 4 people. Maybe they use red palm oil? Either way, I am sold! It is hard to find solid Mediterranean options sometimes. The price is reasonable. The interior looks fancy so it could make for a nice sit down dinner too. read more

Olivo Mediterranean Fare - Mediterranean Near Me - Pine Brook, New Jersey

See all

This place was seriously good. Everything tasted fresh, full of flavor, and the service was great. Definitely a spot you have to try. read more

Had not been here since it was Don Pepe. Same food, same employees, different owner. Place looks amazing and the service was great from hostess to valet and in between. Our server was Oliver. He obviously knew his stuff, made good recommendations and made us feel at home. Try the garlic shrimp, chargrilled octopus. You won't regret it ;) Name is a little confusing. Place is Spanish food, which I know could be Mediterranean but it's more like paella and sangria Spanish. ;) read more

Service was amazing from door to table to valet parking. Our server Oliver took good care of our table. Food was fresh and well presented.

Came here for a guy's night and this place did not disappoint! It's a Mediterranean restaurant so there was a wide range of different flavors and many aged meats. Decent beer selection and it had been a while since I had Mythos (Greek beer) so I had to order that and it brought back many memories. Bread and olive oil was brought to our table to start things off. We decided to share a bunch of tapas for appetizers and went with the thick cut bacon, ham croquettes, grilled squid, shrimp in garlic sauce, and the chorizo. Everything was amazing so we couldn't wait to get our mains. Since we were a party of 5, we split a Rib eye steak and a paella valenciana. Super tasty and flavorful. The desserts were fantastic as well. We ordered a wide assortment but our favorite was the Basque burnt cheesecake. read more

See all

We were a party of six. No complaints with the food. Everyone was happy with the food and service. We were seated in the party room. It was very noisy but still, everything else made up for it. read more

Starting with the good: the restaurant is stunning, and the service is warm, they make you feel like a vip! But...in a place where the Iberian may be the best in the US I expected more. Don Pepe has a legacy in NJ of authentic delicious Iberian cuisine and to me this fell short. The pulpo a la gallega, a standard Spanish dish was not crispy at all :-( the pan con tomate another favorite had good flavor but was not toasted. Thankfully the paella was better with all the flavors you would expect. I hope that it was just because they just opened and will improve! read more

See all

On Thursday, my boyfriend and I decided to visit the location that was formally known as Don Pepe Steak House. The location is under new ownership and is now called Olivo. I remember clearly what it used to look like inside since I had been there a few times. Now all I can say is wow! What was once a caterpillar has blossomed into a gorgeous butterfly! The new owners have totally transformed this location into the most amazing restaurant. From start to finish, my boyfriend and I had an incredible evening. The ambience is spectacular! We arrived for dinner and it was still daylight outside. There are now huge windows in the whole restaurant enabling natural lighting inside. In addition, there is also a skylight in one of the dining rooms. Under it sits and olive tree. It really is a beautiful centerpiece when you walk in and see that. We ate in that dining area, which was right behind the bar. Our server, Miguel was very nice and knowledgeable about the menu and the wines. He suggested wines according to my likes and went over the menu and gave us his recommendations. We decided to try a bunch of appetizers even though I originally went in to try the bacon steak. There were so many apps it was so hard to pick just one. All of the appetizers had were excellent! The bacon steak did not disappoint! The Greek salad was very refreshing. For our main entrees we decided to go with fish and steak. Might as well have the the best of both worlds! LOL! The baked Branzino was very fresh and had a light taste, not fishy at all. The dry aged Porterhouse was huge and they sliced it for us before it came out. I had the filet side and it was super tender and juicy. For sides we had Spanish potatoes, saffron rice and mixed veggies. We had so much food left over! Of course my kids devoured it when we got home. I'm not sure how I had any room left for dessert but as stuffed as I was I just had to try the Burnt Basque Cheesecake which Miguel highly recommended. He was not kidding when he said it was so creamy and unlike any other cheesecake around. When you go to Olivo, please do yourself a favor and have this cheesecake for dessert. You will be hooked. You can thank me later. My compliments to the chef for preparing our excellent meal! The service was as spectacular as the food. Miguel was da bomb and Eduardo, the manager visited with us several times throughout the evening. He made us feel so welcome and at home. He was very gracious and thankful that we chose to dine there. He invited us back and back we will go. My mom is turning 81 and I already reserved a table for a small group of us to celebrate with her. It's a surprise! Shhh... don't tell her! I highly recommend a visit and make a reservation. By the looks of it, Olivo has it all and they will be doing very well. read more

See all

This is a wonderful restaurant for either lunch or dinner. They have the best paella around. We have been here a number of times. Our server Joe was the best and very attentive to our every need. The place is lovely and the food is delicious and the service is superb, I just wish it was closer to where we lived. read more

Olivo Mediterranean Fare in Pine Brook, NJ, is a fresh and exciting addition to the dining scene, bringing a perfect blend of Mediterranean flavors with a Spanish flair. From the moment we walked in, the warm ambiance and attentive service, led by our fantastic server Tony, set the stage for a memorable meal. Every dish we tried during the soft opening was outstanding. The octopus--a notoriously difficult dish to perfect... was incredibly tender with a beautiful char, ranking among the best we've ever had. The tapas kept exceeding expectations, each one better than the last. By the time the entrées arrived, we wondered if the meal could get any better... and it did. With valet parking available and a menu this strong, we predict Olivo will quickly become a hot spot. Make reservations early because this place is bound to be packed. Huge thumbs up from our group, and we wish the team the best of luck with this new venture. As always, support local businesses, you won't regret giving Olivo a try! @vinopotato read more

See all

An amazing fine dining experience. From the valet that takes your car, to the warm welcome by all the staff, as well as a beautiful dining atmosphere. Usually you'd have to go to NYC for this but now it's right at your front door. Compliments to the chef on all the amazing food, highlighting the octopus, paella, and baked branzino. Excited to come back and try their dry aged meats! read more

See all

Don Pepe's resurrected & reimagined. Modern decor, upscale cocktail menu, new swagger, great food and service. Would highly recommend.

1st time there, had the saganaki & Octopus was very good. Sangria was so good Entrees stuffed lobsters (2) and seafood Paella which was excellent and could easily feed 4 people. We have a new favorite restaurant and Beatrice was our server and she was top notch!!!! read more

"Olivo is always an excellent choice! Once again, I celebrated my birthday there and had a wonderful experience. The food was absolutely delicious, Oliver provided outstanding service--truly a 10/10--and Eduardo, the manager, was incredibly attentive and professional. Thank you so much! I highly recommend it!" read more

Had dinner at Olivo and it was an experience. The food was genuinely good. Fresh flavors, nicely presented, and a step up from what the previous spot in this location used to serve. The decor is also much improved. Think modern Mediterranean chic, with a touch of elegance that makes you feel like you're in the right place for a great evening out. Olivo might be perfect if you're planning a dinner with people you have nothing to say to. Conversation is basically impossible unless you're fluent in lip reading or have mastered semaphore across the table. The noise level was so high I started to wonder if there was a "Who Can Yell Louder?" contest. I love good food, but I also like to hear the person I'm dining with. Call me old-fashioned. So, if your ideal night out is delicious food, stylish surroundings, and the comforting silence of not being able to communicate with your dinner companion, Olivo is your spot. Personally, I prefer a place where I can enjoy both good food and good conversation. read more

We went for my birthday. I had a huge lobster, husband had branzino, daughter had filet mignon. All were perfect. Our server Joe Ferreiro made the evening extra fun with a drink recommendation and a crème brûlée with a candle on the house. Noise level high but it was a Saturday night after all. The seafood salad appetizer and Caesar salad were also very good. Highly recommend. read more

Olivo Mediterranean Fare - 4 lb lobster. - Mediterranean Near Me - Pine Brook, New Jersey

We were pleasantly surprised! The food was very good and the service was attentive and experienced. They did a great job remodeling, helping the vibe immensely! We'll be back! read more

A beautiful newly renovated restaurant. The ambiance is bright & inviting in shades off white & neutrals. Attentive & friendly wait staff that supply excellent service. All the food & drinks were delicious. We drank red sangria, shared fried calamari. Our entrees were the veal Marsala, filet mignon medallions in mushroom sauce & grilled lamb chops. All were so good, tender & cooked perfectly. We ended the meal with cappuccinos & crème brûlée. Valet parking, tables are well spaced & not cramped. There's a lovely room for a party & the bar looked inviting. We can't wait to go back! read more

See all

The place is modern looking, the food ingredients are very fresh and service is so efficient and friendly. I highly recommend this restaurant ... read more

Very good food are a reasonable price for the quality. Nice ambiance and very good service. The prime porterhouse was great and served three of us. Oysters were fresh, large and juicy. Have been back 3 times and will return again. read more

I was visiting the area and wanted to take my hosts out for a nice dinner so we picked Olivo. It was lovely. There were 4 of us and we ordered drinks and appetizers to share, the garlic shrimp, grilled octopus and a Caesar salad. Complimentary bread was also very good and it was hard not fill up. Then the 4 of us shared a chicken cutlet dish, a seafood paella (big portions!) and a skirt steak that was a special for the evening. Even though we were pretty full and had leftovers to take home we just had to have dessert! A flan and a tiramisu to share and some coffees to finish up. Everything was delicious and the service was excellent. I would highly recommend Olivo. read more

First time we visited Olivo. We had an amazing experience. We could not have asked for better service. All the staff were friendly, accommodating, respectful and responsive to our needs. The food was excellent and the presentation of each dish was exceptional. The atmosphere is very pleasant and inviting. We highly recommend this restaurant to anyone looking for a great dining experience! We will be back many more times with friends and family. read more

See all

Great atmosphere, appetizers were delicious, veal Marsala was on point. Great sauce, mushrooms. The veal was tender.

Wow! Their dishes were so tasty!!Im so glad we came here with h our friend recommendations. We will be back soon!! read more

Food was good, bus service very good, but the waiter was un attentive. The worst part we had a table right by the door, they have soft closing doors and it was a very cold and windy night, so was cold every time someone came in which was ALL the time. Worst seat in the house and the hostess was NO help with the situation. Lastly, VERY loud. table of 4 and had a hard time hearing the conversation. Who every did the design and acoustics, did not excel, unless they want noisy! Food was good, so only plus...will not be back. read more

Love the new decor. Food was great! Lunch portions were a great size. Super flavorful. Will definitely go back!!

I was extremely disappointed Visited town weeks ago and again tonight ! The same waiter, Unfortunately,,,please didn't understand it's absolutely ridiculous , asked insider and over when we placed our order. And when I asked question about a meal ,,, he didn't understand So ,,, we order drinks they take forever Ask for extra something. Never came ,,, had to ask someone else who saw and heard us Then your meal the tomahawk steak was horrible all FAT !!!! I am extremely dissatisfied,,, and very disappointed!! Don't think I'll be wasting my money there anymore read more

This restaurant earned my repeat lunch business. The night menu here is satisfying. The kitchen creates meals with superior components. The team provided genuinely outstanding assistance. Flavorful menu and the setting complements it... read more

Good food, but not particularly Mediterranean. Staff was excellent and accommodating, making certain my dining experience was good.

Had dinner there on a Friday night. Valet parking is mandatory. Ambiance is very nice as the place is beautiful inside. Dining room was definitely loud and not overly intimate. I ordered the scallops and was disappointed. They arrived over polenta (I think as menu didn't state that). The scallops were cooked fine but were tasteless. Not seasoned well at all. The polenta was tasteless as well. My friend had the steak medallions which he said were good. Desserts were good and so were the drinks. read more

The restaurant was redone lately.. Beautiful space.. Food's very good and service is very good

A visit to olivo was an incredible experience! From the moment we entered the restaurant we were made to feel welcome. The staff at the front desk were courteous & friendly as was the Maitre d' who escorted our party to the table.The food was an extravaganza presented in such an appealing manner that only enhanced the taste. Chef Jose outdid himself with the Calamari , the Sea bass & the Seafood Paella. The Calamari was crispy and the sauce had a nice kick to it. The Paella had huge pieces of seafood and fish & the rice absorbed all the flavors in the Paella.The Surf & Turf made us glad we didn't choose steak or seafood but chose both since each was perfection in its own right. The wait staff all gathered around to sing Happy Birthday to my grandson as a superb end to a fantastic evening. We will be sure to return to Olivo! read more

Absolutely beautiful on the inside, they really out did themselves with the ambiance. The service was great, very attentive. But the flaws were in the food: much of it seemed under seasoned and no salt anywhere. I asked for some lemons to brighten the octopus and got lime slices instead. The paella was pretty good but that also was missing something bright. The wine by the glass was limited but decent. read more

Great Tapas, beautiful ambiance with a Mediterranean flair. Great service. The Octopus and Garlic shrimp was delicious as well as the Scallops. The Tiramisu was very good also. Loved the "Beso" drink! Definetly will come back soon. read more