My neighbor, his wife, and I come to this place once a year. We order the same menu items almost every time: Wings, Rings, Shrimp, Soup, Quesadilla, and Chili. And we drink a lot of beer. Don't get me wrong. The food is excellent, provided it comes out HOT. The Chili never has the shreaded cheese completely melted, it must be sent back, the same with the soup. The (rather small) Wings are OK, and so are Rings, and the Quesadilla. During our most recent three (3) visits, the place is cold and a bit noisy. We can deal with the noise - it is a local gatherers fun bar, but cold - nah. read more

Ordered for delivery since the restaurant expanded delivery area due to Covid 19. The specials are very reasonable and we enjoyed dinner. I would pass on the pizza next time but the cheese steaks were good. Thanks for delivering to the far reaches of Southampton. Will order again soon. read more

Love this local dive bar. We go here about once a week. The wings are great and we have never had anything, but great service. I would give it 4.5 starts if I could only because they change their IPA's out frequently and they don't always have one that I like. read more

This place is awesome I love their wings and their salads are absolutely amazing! Super fun little place, cold beer and good service! There are times when bands play and there is even trivia night read more

Disgusted! Went there this past Sunday, we ordered burgers. We got dry, nasty meat on a stale bun. I returned mine. It was obviously pre-cooked and heated up upon ordering. For $13.50.... with 10 tatertots that looked like mush. How they allowed this out of the kitchen is amazing. A nasty, dry burger. Not kidding, but a McDonalds $1.00 burger has more juiciness and flavor. Thankfully had wings to hold me over. The wings were good. The 3 of us were asked, blue cheese or ranch? Got the bill, and they CHARGE $1.25 for a small cup of blue cheese and ranch. Seriously???? And the flies.... Never again. The place has gone downhill in the past 6 months. read more

This is a nice little local place. The wings are actually 2 piece wings per wing; not pieces so you actually get 12 wings with an order a 6! We like this place will probably go back just know that it's a very very local place with a dirt parking lot read more

So I'll be totally honest, we left a soccer tournament and were hoping to go to piccalilli. There was too long a wait so we kept driving. My husband found this place on his phone searching for another option. We have passed it a dozen or so times driving back and forth to soccer but never considered as it presented as a dive bar that maybe we shouldn't take the kids to. I was adamantly against going in. We were starving though and I acquiesced. Right when you walk in you're greeted and seated. I was still hesitant and maybe a little grouchy that I got outvoted and absolutely freezing from the game. Our waitress whose name I wish I remembered came promptly to take our drink order. The menu was quite impressive and not your typical bar food. We ordered cordon blue bites for an appetizer and it did not disappoint. For lunch we ordered rodeo cheesesteak, one more steak sandwich (that's what it's called) and chicken quesadillas. Everything was FANTASTIC!! The salsa with the quesadilla was homemade and honestly the best I've ever had. They should bottle it!! I'd drive the hour to pick it up. Moral of the story, don't judge a book by its cover. This place was so good and if I stuck to my guns I would've never experienced it. I highly recommend! Thanks for a great lunch!! read more

Small place. Very good food and really nice staff. Place seems to attract locals as the place was full and people were waiting for seating early on the Saturday night. read more

One More Bar & Grill - Mushroom and Swiss Turkey burger with fries upgraded to tater tots. - Bars Near Me - Tabernacle, New Jersey

This is one of the best hang-outs in the NJ PineBarrens. If you are in the area for camping, canoeing, driving past on way to AC, or just in the area, you can't go wrong stopping in for food and drinks. Their wings are some of the best in NJ and souls are delicious. Rocky and Jason are alright too. read more

Ordered a chicken Caesar salad to go, and 3 hours later I have awful food poisoning and 102 fever. Sick for 2 days and call letting them know. Told me they would give my information to owners & owners would call me back. Month later no call and not even a refund. Never again read more

If I could select 0 stars I would have. We walked in with a large group and the 2 women who "greeted" us were very rude. They made us feel unwelcome and as if we were a bother. There were maybe 6 -8 other people total in there at a couple tables. A few of us asked to sit at the bar and we were told no and were directed to 2 tables because it would "be easier" on them. We were then told they closed at 6 (we walked in at 3:50pm) After a few of us finished the beer we ordered during all of this commotion we decided to finish up and head out because the unwelcoming atmosphere was too much and killed our mood. We ended up at another establishment a few miles down the road who pleasantly welcomed our pack and fit us in despite their very full house. We went on to enjoy a $520 meal so not all was lost on a bad start to our dinner plan and I'm sure our amazing waitress enjoyed her tip! It doesn't take much to just be nice. read more

Avoid at all cost especially if you have family or young children. Staff is extremely rude and refused to serve me because I would not buy the drugs they were selling. I just wanted to order a drink and some food but they refused to acknowledge me when I declined their offer for drugs read more

My boyfriend, Raphael, and I love it here. Whenever we're in the Pine Barrens, we try to stop by. The staff and clientele are very LGBTQ friendly. read more

Good spot, Amy is a trip! Good appetizers and good. Good drink specials, a regular stop for us when riding. Skip he Pic and head here! read more

Great local bar, best wings in the area. Friendly staff and environment. They're very convenient for curbside pickup as well. I will continue to support this business as they continue to provide top notch service with great food. read more

Might just be "one more bar"to you but it's friendly conversation,cold drinks,great food and a wonderful staff to us. Never lets us down.

Excellent food and atmosphere, fun and welcoming bar with an extensive menu of pizza, salads, and sandwiches. The staff was attentive and fast. If your in the area stop in for a beer and burger. read more

Great little bar but it's good to have small group parties before the band starts to play

Really nice place. The staff is very nice and down to earth. Really good food too at reasonable prices.

Used to love this place. Food has dropped off a bit. But had a bad experience where I called ahead to see if a game was going to be on. Answer, yes no problem. Arrive to find a bartender who wouldn't put said game on. And was very callous, saying "I dont know who you talked to". As if she didn't know who answered the phones. Otts or PJs is a better bet... read more

The staff is stellar and friendly. Matches well with amazing home made soup and wing sauce that rules!!! Garlic parm wing sauce is second to none. read more

Went for the first time last night. This is a sister restaurant to Piccalillis. I got the Devils Sampler with garlic parmesan sauce. It was supposed to have the scallops, but mine came with like one and a half. I let our waitress know and she brought me three large ones. Fantastic craft brew selection. Extensive menu. My son got the rodeo burger and ate it so fast! He loved it! We'll be back! Only concern is that there's not a lot of seating. read more

The food was ok, but the quality of service my family and I experienced was horrific. We were seated and within ten minutes placed our orders. A large party was seated on booths on either side of ours ten minutes after that. We proceeded to wait almost forty five minutes to be served our food. The party around ours however was given their drinks soups salads and food all before we even received our food. That was completely unacceptable. Then when the food was brought out my order was completely incorrect. The wait staff claimed they were slammed with orders however other than our side of the room where my family and I occupied one of the three booths the rest of the building was sparsely populated. I am disgusted by the level of treatment we received. And the lack of control exhibited by management to allow a large party comprised mostly of children to climb all over their table and the back of the booth. The danger and the possible accidents that presented themselves was mismanaged on their part. When asked to speak to a manager none was provided but instead the meal comped. That is disgraceful. I hope you as a service establishment can rectify the situation and resolve it. Until then I refuse to return. read more

I was on my way back home after visiting someone at Ancora Psychiatric Hospital and was feeling really hungry when I saw this out-of-the-way bar and grill. Decided to stop in and was so glad I did! I had probably the best Caesar salad with grilled shrimp I've ever had in my life! Lettuce was truly fresh, flavorful, and crisp; shrimp was perfectly grilled with a little crunch around the edges; home-made croutons we're buttery and crunchy without being break-your-teeth hard. Truly delicious and priced very fairly. I will definitely be stopping in again the next time I visit Ancora. read more

My new name for this place is No More. Last visit, got skunk beer....food horrible...most, but not all bartenders, are lazy and disappear. Food ordered from one...didn't write it down...didn't get the order right.. My veggie wrap was barely steamed baby carrots (whole by the way)...barely cooked onions, good broccoli though. no mushrooms as I asked for. When I reminded her, I got a cup of ice cold canned ones. Tap, beer not cold enough yet the AC in the place can keep raw meat from spoiling for a week. read more

I used to really like this bar because it is close to my house and I'm a vegetarian & this is one of the few bars that has good food for me (I always order the black bean burger). However, I have to say that the "vibe" of this place sucks & people are rude if you aren't "local". I will not return and if you're not a "local," I wouldn't suggest coming here either. read more

We have ordered delivery quite a few times from this place and every time they get it right! It is hot delicious and fresh. They definitely have awesome customer service too. Every time we call they're friendly and treat us like friends. We love the steak strip sandwich---amazing!!!! We still standby their burgers--definitely on point! You can also sign up for text alerts to receive info on promotions and upcoming live entertainment. read more

Very good bar food. No complaints and would gladly come here again. Surprised that the personal pizza had a good unique taste and not like a frozen pizza. Meatballs on the pizza especially good. Had the wings (spicy and garlic Parmesan) and they were very good and just a little smaller than the Pic wings. I had the Patty Melt and would rank that as good as any one I ever had. Not a lot of tables so I'm sure it's busy during peak hours. read more

Ordered for delivery - was a little cold but boneless chicken with buffalo was still tasty and fries were good too.

Every time i call everyone is SOOO sweet. You can't say that about most places!! I love ordering from here! Thanks for the great customer service! Ps the food is always delicious! read more

Not gonna lie this place always seemed like a grand slam bc it's based on a pic a lili ownership. Only problem with being in the middle of nowhere is your clientele really has to have some committed regulars. The food was solid although unfortunately buffalo mozzarella were lukewarm to cold. All other things were pretty normal pic a lili staples (tails and egg rolls). Unfortunately this place seems pretty greedy. I had over 7 dollars in up charges during this visit. If you want extra sauce for your tails it shouldn't be a charge. Marinara should come with buffalo mozz or at least ranch since its buffalo. Never even got the marinara. Hot sauce for 2.49 is a travesty. Kitchen closes way too early for being open till 2. Not many local craft selections on tap. Will probably not be back here and stick to pic 3 or pic a lili. read more

This place is the BEST. My partner and I reside in Northern NJ and every time we are down South we make a point to stop in. Always great and affordable drinks & food. The wings are to-die-for and the service is exceptional. read more

A very small place. Don't be disappointed if you have to wait for a booth. Service is very friendly and attentive. I had the one more burger. Was expecting a big sloppy mess. It was anything but. It was absolutely delicious and I would highly recommend. The chicken Parmesan sandwich is also very good. I would highly recommend this bar for a nice atmosphere and good food and drinks. read more

Ordered take out, after a little mishap with mixing up my order they went above and beyond to correct. Great customer service. Great food and great customer service read more

The bartender told a 30 year old woman, that not one, but both of her IDs were fake and refused service. The bartenders down the road at Pic-a-lilli were competent and confirmed her ID was legitimate. Avoid for incompetent bartenders. read more

Great wings, cold beers, always new seasonal selections for beer, the base for all the sauces is mild so order mild wings with all sauces on the side and dip away. Thank me later. read more

The mild wings were entirely too sweet. My fiance got their Gut Buster burger; it tasted like the meat was old and undercooked, and he wound up puking it up in the parking lot. I also was sick after drinking their oversweet cranberry juice. read more

The best bar in the area! Must try all the food! And all the beers! And drinks! Awesome service and homey atmosphere

I love the simplicity of One More! The prices are very reasonable, the food is good, the atmosphere is simple, and the service is good. I especially love Trish -- she's very personable! The live music is always a good time too. read more

Four stars but the service stinks unless you're a local. Chicken wings were great. Everyone around me was offered 50 cent wings. I was charged full price. Kinda weird but after I informed her she apologized and correctly it. read more