**July 2025: Tuesday Afternoon Visit**…read more This was such a great charity shop to visit! It was a pretty hot summer afternoon so being inside a well ventilated and ac'd store was a relief. The store itself is styled like a boutique and is a long hallway with different rooms focused on different clients (ie. children's section, men's section, active etc). I did feel like many of the women's clothes were geared towards a more mature crowd, but I appreciated the fitting room to try everything on. Unfortunatley, the things I loved were probably meant for juniors/teenagers and were just a tad too small for me *cries* Nevertheless, I found some really great (like new conditioned) random things like a Superman BBQ Apron (perfect for the summer of Superman), and Michael Kors Mary Jane Pumps that will work perfectly for my Wicked outfit that I'm putting together. I didn't know at the time, but I suspect because I visited during the week of July 4th that everything in store was 50% off, which almost felt like highway robbery since everything was already very inexpensive already! My Mary Janes were $10 and thus $4.50 and the Superman Apron came out to $2.50. This is a great clean, organized and well priced charity shop that I'd love to support again on a return visit. Enjoy!

Great service fantastic vibe prices was amazing. Good values. I highly recommend visiting this…read morestore. It's what a thrift store is all about.

High end furniture consignment store very attractively decorated. Nothing junky here. Prices are…read morefairly high but these are quality goods sold here. Lots of rooms to explore chalked full of furniture,art work & odds & ends. Shop is located in the cute town of Elm Grove. Fun area to poke around in, have lunch & browse the little shops. Ladies in the shop are helpful if you have questions.

I had no idea this place existed!…read more Ottoman Society is a very large, nicely curated consignment shop. They've got tons of furniture, plenty of decorative items and lots to see. Everything depends on what they have at any given time but it's mostly upscale "Brookfield" style. Things are nicely arranged, it's not at all junky. Prices were pretty fair and the staff seemed knowledgeable .

Large selection of the gift to give anytime Thru out the…read moreyears to family and friends alike Very polite and humble well Being staff

This store really blew me away. They have a vast range of products, shelves upon shelves of…read morecollectibles and the such, and there wasn't a speck of dust! Staff are extremely helpful, checking up to see if you need anything from off the shelf. From Transformers to LPS to TMNT, they have everything you could possibly want in vast quantities--clearly labeled and organized--and easy to access. Prices are EXTREMELY fair. For a lot that would've likely cost me $200+ on Ebay, I paid $95 for it all. Please, do visit, and leave a good review! This business has many ignorant reviewers, and deserves all the praise it can get. Amazing place, will come again.

Don't recommend. Came here twice during posted hours, only to find it closed both times. Their…read morehours are all over the place. They're quick to blame the customer when asked why. "You should call" they said. No. You should run business hours as specified and not expect customers to guess when you're open or closed. Terrible customer service.

Much within is overpriced junk that can be bought new from local big box stores and online for…read moreless. Mostly old furniture, outdated electronics, and oddities. Nothing Goodwill doesn't already sell on discount.

Love this place. We discovered this store upon moving to the area were thrilled. The staff is…read morealways very helpful. They always have stuff in their back room that is fun to check out. I also find the quality here is bettetr than many boutiques. Happy shopping!

A gem in Mayfair Mall and maybe even the Milwaukee area! What a great store for the gal who loves…read morevintage-flair, feminine, baubles, and what cute shoes and boots! These black victorian-style heel booties with bows @the front of the store brought me in this week, and after stopping in a few times in the past, I had to divulge this time. Staff is friendly, and there are some unique items. Figure-8 scarves, purses, hair accessories, even some evening wear, and much of the store is reasonably-priced. Moto-bike leather jackets are trendy now and I noticed prices are lower than other stores. You have to check this store out.

Visiting family in Wisconsin to outrun hurricane Irma and stopped in this little shop while waiting…read morefor my grandma and aunt to finish bowling. Super cute, amazing prices and such a friendly and sweet owner! I love small businesses and a bargain so I looked through the kids section and found several steals for my 6 mo old daughter. The kids items were 5 for $8... and adult items start at just $1! She also has lots of jewelry, hats and other accessories! Stop in and support local!!

Super cute place with nice clothes! The owner is very nice and helpful. Highly recommend!read more

This Goodwill store is great. It's brand new (opened ~ a year or so ago) and it is quite clean…read more Love the new concept of the dressing rooms that are "self-service" that you can open and lock on your own; the locks indicate "Vacant" or "Occupied" on the outside. The prices can be a bit high at this store. I've seen pieces of Nike or other name brand clothes marked at $9.99, which is simply too much for a second-retail store. Maybe first time shoppers will love those prices, but not Goodwill veterans! On other name brand items, I have found excellent prices, and I've also had good luck in the $1.50 bins as well. *I wanted to make a review and note that there IS bike parking at this location. It's directly to the left of the entrance off of Oklahoma Ave.

I honestly love this Goodwill because I always seem to find something good. Clearly today was no…read moreexception because I left with a completely full cart! We all know Goodwill doesn't provide bags unless you purchase a reusable one, although sometimes they have boxes available. Today, however, the older man checking me out was extremely disrespectful, and I'm honestly disappointed that I didn't speak up. He asked me if I wanted a box for my things, and I politely responded, "Yes, if you have one, that would be great." He then replied, "If I ask you if you want a box, then I have a box available," along with some other comments he rambled on about. The tone he used was rude and completely unnecessary, so I just got quiet and said, "Okay." I stayed quiet until he asked if I had a phone number with them, which I do. I started giving him my number, but because it has a different area code than where we are, he interrupted me and said, "Area code." I repeated what I had said, and at that point I was just over the whole interaction. His overall demeanor and the comments he made were completely unnecessary. I'll definitely continue going back because I love finding things there, but if I see him again, I'll be making sure someone else checks me out.