We are here from upstate New York, gathering with family, to celebrate the life of my late brother. Late yesterday, I showed up at the restaurant, hoping to order 10 of 12 pizzas, to take to the family home in Muncy and ended up ordering 4 giant (24 cut) pizzas, salad and a calzone! Wow, we love these people and their food! When I returned to pick up the food, they even loaded the tailgate of our SUV with everything! 5 stars does not even seem like enough for this wonderful restaurant, that I plan to visit every time I am here! Perfect! Paul D read more

In town for work, figured I'd give this spot a try since they had a little of everything and the locals said it was good. The store was empty. I ordered a buffalo chicken sub and after waiting 30 minutes I was asked what I was waiting for only to find out it was on the oven the whole time. Food was not worth the wait read more

Calzone was tasty; however, despite the restaurant calling to confirm the ingredients we wanted (which was a nice customer service move), they still included ham, which we asked them to exclude. We ordered from this restaurant twice. They got the order wrong both times. Won't order again. read more

Very good pizza I ordered three pies for a work event and they delivered. The pies were fresh and hot and delivered on time. I will use Them Again and again. read more

Spent 70 dollars on dough pizza. When OIP is known for their bread. The four cheese sticks we order were 4 dollars a piece of bread, there were only four. The pizza was so doughy we couldn't pick it up and had to taster oven it. Also, it wasn't cut! NEVER GO HERE. Go to Allenwood or Montgomery OIP. read more

Original Italian Pizza & Restaurant - Doughy almost uncooked pizza. TERRIBLE !!! - Italian Near Me - Muncy, Pennsylvania

See all

First time Trying the OIP at Muncy, pizza was Very Good! Crust was thin and Crispy! The sauce had a hint of a sweet taste to it and was Excellent! The Waitress was very Attentive. The place is Clean and was decorated for Christmas! The only thing I didn't care for was the Italian Dressing, it a vinegar after taste, just my opinion not saying anything is wrong with it! read more

Original Italian Pizza & Restaurant - The Pizza we Enjoyed - Italian Near Me - Muncy, Pennsylvania

See all

We are not from the area but because of a family member being in the hospital we would order out on several occasions and had no problems the first three visits. Usually before ordering takeouts we would call to see if there were any specials. Every call on previous Wednesdays we were told that our order would be a specific price and would not change for the foreseeable future.On our last order upon arriving we saw the price had increased quite a bit. We asked the worker if our previous price would be honored since that is what we were told in the past. Before we knew it the owner came over and began to berate us for asking about the price change. He then said why don't we go to Weis to buy our food and then in a threatening manner continued to embarrass us for simply asking what we thought was a simple request. This situation had nothing to do with money as far as we were concerned.Never have we seen a restaurant owner act in such a furious manner `about what could be a simple conversation. As we were leaving he continued to throw his arms up as to say get out and don't come back. I wanted to say buddy you don't scare me with your loud outbursts but our return to the hospital was more important. We actually felt sorry for his workers who have to work under such a hot headed disrespectful owner. If the food would be free we would never return to such a volatile owner. read more

Ordered online (use their own website vs Yelp/GitHub and save yourself some $$) as I was out this way and ours in Montoursville is closed Mondays. The folks at the counter were very courteous and helpful, and the veggie pizza was awesome! It was somewhat smushed into the smaller box, but it was stelllar pizza! read more

This place is a gem. You wouldn't know that they had really good NYC style pizza . And the guy running place, Frank is really nice and knows what he's doing. I ordered a large Pepperoni pizza and was the most beautifuliest thing I'd had ever seen. I'm from Manhattan and I know a good pie when I see it.. The crust was perfection. Simply made with flour, salt, water and yeast... It was baked Thin with perfect leoparding (charring)underneath. The sauce had great flavor and was generously applied. Pepperoni is locally sourced from an Amish market and was delicious. I could've eaten the whole pie in one sitting if hadn't had restrained myself. My only complaint was that they didn't sell Coke, lol. Just Pepsi. But I'll be back to try more pizza pies. read more

Original Italian Pizza & Restaurant - Large Pepperoni Pizza - Italian Near Me - Muncy, Pennsylvania

See all

Pizza way over priced charged over $7 for one slice with 3 toppings. The amount of topping was scant.

they took forever to get our pizza out and they were talking trash about us behind the counter,and they were bad mouthing there own co works and the pizza is really greasy and the cheese falls off , the plates are dirty as hell and there are flies flying around this place .they could improve on the prices and making the service faster . don't recommend read more

Menu incorrect. Condiments brought to the table on top of the plates we were to eat off

I would give this place 0 stars if it was an option. I was hung up on and verbally assaulted by the owner--when my order was prepared incorrectly at fault of the staff. I understand people make mistakes, I was not mad about that. I did not want to have to wait for them to reprepare the order correctly for me and have to go out to pick it up. I'm trying to limit my covid exposure at this time and I should not be inconvenienced due to fault that was not mine. I was given two options wait for the item to be prepared, and drive to the restaurant to return the incorrect order or I could get 10% off my next order. When I expressed to the owner those two offers did not seem fair to me because I was not at fault in this he yelled at me and told me YOU WANT FREE FOOD.. And then he hung up on me. I would have preferred to reorder the item at a later date but 10% off my future order would not have even monetarily equaled the item I originally ordered. To get one thing straight--I would have thrown away the order I received that was incorrect, as no one in my family eats that. In the end I returned the item that was prepared incorrectly and got my money back per my request. The first thing that was said to me when I walked in the door was WHAT YOU WANT. When I attempted to explain why I wanted what I wanted I was cut off and yelled over top. The owner continued to make condescending remarks, insulting my integrity behind the plexiglas and when I would try to explain my side as the customer he did not want to hear it and threatened to call the cops and kick me out. I will never be back and I will encourage other patrons to give their business to other small businesses in the area every chance I get. read more

May 2020 I used to love coming to this OIP. I would tip extremely well because of the services I would receive including getting my Gnocchi in Red Vodka Sauce. They have the absolute best besides Stonehouse. I tried for 3 weeks to support local on my pasta and for three weeks received the same answer of getting the Gnochhi in Red Vodka Sauce. This deeply disappoints me and I will probably not order from this OIP further as there is no reason to go out of my way when the other OIPS have the same stuff and are closer... Update 9.4.2020 Went back 30 days ago and the owner himself apologized and said absolutely anytime i come in they would make this. Went back last night drove specifically to this oip for gnocchi with red vodka sauce as I was told absolutely. Sat down and the waitress took our orders and I explained the gnocchi situation and what I have been told by the owner last time I visited, she comes back with our drinks and tells me the Manager said no they are not and won't make that and I had to choose something else. After years of coming here and giving the another shot after being told by the owner they would do this, I am beyond agitated with the level of customer service. I kindly told our waitress cancel our orders and we will be going somewhere else. As I went to pay for the drinks, one of the management staff asked if anything was wrong I said yes, I'm tired of being lied to and driving to this restaurant after talking to the owner and being guaranteed you would make gnocchi with red vodka sauce when I come and your team failing to accommodate consistently. Management has a bad attitude and the level of service at this restaurant just increasingly goes down unless the owner himself is in the building. Unfortunately after years of patronage and trying to be understanding I have had it with trying to get meals here and going into of my way to eat here. Very disappointing and a bigger let down that staff refuses to uphold what is told to customers directly from the owner and was relayed via the waitress. 3-6 meals that will be purchased at other locations moving forward. read more

This establishment is one of my favorite places to eat in Muncy. The food is always fresh and they have a large menu. The owner is very nice and personable and he and the staff make you feel welcome and comfortable. The service is very fast and the prices are reasonable. Anytime I want good pizza I choose OIP Muncy. I will definitely continue to support this local establishment and I recommend their food to anyone in the area! read more

My parents and I come to OIP in Muncy on a pretty regular basis, and everytime I order something it is off-the-charts-good! The service is good, the wait staff is friendly and efficient, and the food comes to the table fresh and hot. I am especially impressed with their chef salad and cosmos. They also make the best bread for their subs. They also give you a massive amount of fries when you order a "large." They are the best place in town for traditional italian family dishes and subs and they have the best prices. The establishment is clean and well kept, and the employees are the same. We've been going there so often that we've come to know Frank personally. I highly recommend going there, as they are open late every night and you are sure to be happy with your experience. read more

Food is not standard at all. Over priced, cold and just not good anymore. My kids used to eat here all the time when they came home to visit. They stay far from here now. Sad. read more

Been going here for a long time only because they offer gluten free food. Hard to find. When you eat in your refill for soda is not free. So your paying well over $2.50 every drink. I eat the gluten free hoagie bun and it used to be $1 something but it is now $3.20. ARE YOU KIDDING. on top of a $8-$9 hoagie? It's just not worth it anymore. For about the last dozen times we've ordered subs to go they mess up every time. This passed time I asked for everything except hot peppers and light oil. When we opened it up at home it had meat, cheese and yellow peppers. No lettuce tomorrow onion or mayo. It's just not that hard to get it right. I won't be ordering here anymore. read more

Great subs and pizza. The fresh baked rolls are delicious. I really like the cheesesteaks and turkey & cheese subs. Salads are good too, and house italian dressing is tasty. read more

I noticed a sign advertising Chicken Fettucini Alfredo as the night's special as we walked in and was pretty excited as I didn't know they offered that meal on the menu. This was only our second time ever coming to this restaurant. My son ordered the pizza and I was even more excited about the prospect of my dinner when the bread arrived, still warm from the oven, and the side salad was served on a really cute square plate. My dinner arrived and it looked fantastic but as I started eating it I realized it had absolutely no flavor, with the exception of the chunks of chicken which did of course taste like chicken. I set my plate aside intending to ask for a plate to have a slice of my son's pizza instead. A waitress stopped by the table and asked if I wanted a box for my dinner and when I told her I did not like the dinner she snatched the plate up and disappeared. I never had a chance to ask for a plate. The owner/manager came out of the kitchen to tell me "don't do that again. Don't come in here and do that again." and at first I was pretty confused. He returned to the kitchen but then came back out on 2 occasions carrying the plate of fettucini to yell at me about how his food was fresh and he thought tasted good. I did eventually get a plate but after two bites of pizza,when a waitress showed up with a pizza box and threw the rest of my son's pizza in it, I realized they wanted us to leave because I did not like my dinner and we packed up and left...stopping at the register and of course being ripped off for the poor food and even poorer service. Unless you are up for an evening of more entertainment than nourishment, because honestly our night felt like we'd stepped into an episode of Kitchen Nightmares, I don't recommend eating here. read more

Awful. Brought salad and entree at essentially the same time. Dilemma - eat salad and while entree gets cold or eat entree and leave the salad? Entree only luke warm to begin with. Entree of only mediocre quality at best. Had to go to the counter to ask to pay the bill as waitress never came back. Would have enjoyed a drink refill and warm food.... I see reviews on other sites are similar to mine. read more

We were looking for pizza, as visitors to Muncy...something in town, without having to drive to thd mall. The reviews were only average, but we loved the pizza! Packed with cheese and toppings. Employees were very nice, too. We will go back! read more

Best buffalo chicken pizza in the area. Even better than the other OIPs around. Really good sandwiches too. I drive from South Williamsport to come to this one specifically. read more

Great restaurant for quick and fast service. I usually takeout but the dine in experience is great as well. Very friendly staff

I went into this restaurant for the first time. I was unsure whether to seat myself or wait to be seated, so I waited around the front counter to make sure. Workers behind the counter kept staring at me. Finally after about a minute, a fella in his fifties who was either upper management or the owner walks up to me and asks me what I want. I say that I would like to eat here. He tells me to sit down. As I walk away, I hear him say very contemptuously to the other workers "That is what the freaking sign is for". Ooooookay. Sorry to have bothered you? Turns out, there WAS a sign telling me to seat myself, about the size of a postcard, and buried. I had overlooked it, but it is far from obvious. But did he really think that I would not hear that? The attitude was entirely unprofessional. Every OIP I visit in the central PA area has people with terrible attitudes. If you order here, order take-out. Not friendly. read more