Second visit to Williamsport for the LLWS, second visit to Vinnie's! We called ahead both times and the order was ready when anticipated. Basic cheese pie. Pictures are one year apart, consistency! Staff are friendly. Pie was hot, crust had a crunch. There is indoor seating. Standard pizza shop atmosphere. read more

Vinnies' Italian Eatery - a pizza in a box - Italian Near Me - Williamsport, Pennsylvania

See all

Vinnie's is great! The owner Juan and his son are amazing and friendly and the pizza and Stromboli are terrific. Lasagna was good too. And I love the name. -Vinnie read more

The food is pretty good at Vinnie's. I love their fries. The pizza is OK, but I've never heard of a cheeseburger being served on a hoagie roll and when I asked why don't you just put it on a burger bun he says because he makes his own bread. OK why not just make burger buns I can't wrap my head around this one sometimes people just want a regular cheeseburger. read more

The food here stinks and the bathrooms are not clean and the floors are dirty and so are the tables. The workers treat you like crap too. read more

Philly steak sandwich was awesome, sauce on pizza was awesome, friendly service, experience was amazing, an awesome place to seat and eat.

We stopped in Williamsport looking for a good pizza. We found it at Vinnie's Italian Eatery! It has a new owner who is very friendly and accommodating. Nice atmosphere. Delicious pizza. If we go through Williamsport again, we will definitely stop at Vinnie's! read more

Amazing!! The food came out super quick and pizza was amazing. Perfect crunch and cheese pull. I do recommend.

Great Italian food in Williamsport. Vinny took care of us, and brought us shells, lasagna, chicken park.... We were three hungry guys from New York and the food was top notch. read more

We love this place! The food is amazing and people are so friendly. Highly recommend the pizza, stromboli and cheese steak read more

Vinnies' Italian Eatery - Italian Near Me - Williamsport, Pennsylvania

I'm not sure.. lol seems like there are multiple cooks doing totally different things, couple weeks ago I got a cheese pizza with extra cheese and a cheesesteak on the pita bread and everything was awesome, next time ordered same pizza and the crust was half the size and I made the mistake in ordering sub on the Italian bread.. it's good don't get me wrong but the outside is to tough you have to like rip it apart lol just not my thing, still great on taste though, and the banana peppers could have more kick. read more

This was a to-go order, so I was standing right there as the pizza was taken from the case. I didn't appreciate the fact that the person picked it up off the tray with gloveless hands. He came from the back to wait on me & I don't know what he was doing with his hands before that. I decided to just cut the crust off at home that he touched to put it in the box. But...still...I shouldn't have had to. The pizza itself was just so-so. There wasn't very much broccoli on the slices at all, but I guess everybody is skimping on ingredients these days. I agree with another reviewer here that said that the size of the slices isn't consistent. So, I paid for 2 & got different sized slices. In addition, I was told that I could not have my receipt. Since I use the Fetch receipt app (for those who are familiar), I didn't appreciate that. read more

The BEST food in a clean pizza joint! Cheesesteak subs were full and so flavorful! The onion rings were perfectly crisp. And the fresh made pita bread was excellent! The new owner is friendly and committed to serving FRESH hand-made food! Great place to grab a quick bite without spending a lot of money. Our experience was so good I joined Yelp to share! read more

If I could give them no stars I would. I asked for my pizza well done and their response "wow you're asking for a lot tonight"... I should've just hung up and ordered from somewhere else because when I revived my food there were pieces of wood inside of the pizza that I found in my mouth as I was eating it.... this is the WORST place I've ever gotten food. I havnt gone back in to confront them but will be doing so today. This happened last night but just want to make sure everyone knows how unsafe it is to eat here before you order something. Stay posted read more

Vinnies' Italian Eatery - WOOD INSIDE OF MY PIZZA - Italian Near Me - Williamsport, Pennsylvania

I'm going to be honest here. This review is more for the customer service than the food. I've only ate a salad and bread here and they both were delicious. Okay so I'm a vegan, not many options when I walk into an Italian joint, I know. But here I am looking at the menu hoping to see some sort of plain spaghetti. I found it but the owner said there was meat in the sauce. He said to me "hey I'll make you a salad, you eat salad? Come on you gotta eat something man" he made me the salad and I got a pita bread on the side. It was actually one of the best salads I've ever tasted besides the iceberg lettuce. As I got up and paid and asked for a bread to go, he got the bread and told me not to worry about it. Told me to have a safe trip back home. If I ate pizza, I would have bought one every weekend if I lived in the area. For that guy's compassion and professionalism alone. read more

They raised the prices on cheesesteaks and it not cheap and I like will never go their again they like just lost my business

Okay. I gave this place the 2 stars because they were friendly enough and timely when delivering. Also, the food was hot and you can tell they tried on the wings, so that is always a good thing. However. Wow, the food was bad. When the large, hawaiian (ham and pineapple) pizza arrived, all of the toppings to include the cheese had fallen to one side and almost seemed undercooked. Then, even when we re-spread out all of the cheese and toppings, the crust was thin and crunchyish/chewyish, much like a frozen pizza. The pineapple pieces were massive pieces and each pizza slice had only 1 or 2 pineapple pieces per slice. They were so big, they were impossible to eat comfortably, so we had to either cut them up ourselves and re-spread them or just pull them off of the pizza before taking a bite. The wings were okay. Not good. But okay. You can tell they tried. Bbq was cooked on and spread well, but they were something you could just make at home. But that pizza..... Omg. Don't say I didn't warn you. read more

Vinnie is very personable and respectful of all his customers. I ate lunch there and was surprised at the price and the size of the pizza slices. One slice of his Slician pizza and you will think you have died and went to Pizza Heaven. I am not a huge pizza fan. But Vinnie's is the best I have had in Williamsport Area. Park Pizza.....not so hot. read more

I've never left a single review on this app... until now. Vinnie's pizza is BY FAR the best pizza joint in the Williamsport area. I order from here all the time. Not only is the service great but their pizza is to die for. I usually get the margarita pizza or the bbq chicken, both are amazing. My friends and I only order from Vinnie's, as all other places are subpar. I would highly recommend this place above all others in Williamsport. Thanks Vinnie's keep up the good work. read more

Overpriced. $1.70 something for a small (maybe 12 oz soda) and then they charge you $0.50 for a refill. Pizza was only "ok" Don't waste your money. read more

I wish I discovered this place a lot sooner! Got a coupon in the mail one time for pizza and breadsticks. Being a broke college kid at the time who ate pizza way more then I should have, I decided to give it a try. The pizza was pretty good, not the best I ever had, but it was defiantly was pretty good. What got me through were the breadsticks!! I don't know what they put on them, but I am obsessed. After finishing up school in Williamsport and now no longer living that way, whenever I am in the area I will stop there for some pizza and breadsticks! A must try! The setting and people are very nice too, plenty of parking in the back. read more

Vinnies' Italian Eatery - Italian Near Me - Williamsport, Pennsylvania

Ate there on the 29th of January, fairly well disappointed, pizza crust was good, sauce mediocre with little flavor added to the whole pie and toppings ok. Very small sized cups with 50 cent refills. Hot wings were unimpressive. Cannoli we're good though. Probably won't be returning. read more

Had a great experience! Employees were super awesome, helpful, and funny. Had the stromboli and it was really tasty... and huge... I could only eat half. I definitely recommend Vinnie's! read more

fast delivery, awesome food. we order from here all the time. The mozzarella sticks are great. The cheese steaks are wonderful. The pizza is not the best in the city but it's second best and this place has much faster delivery. read more

Order was wrong and when we called to have it made right we were blamed for ordering the wrong thing when they got the order wrong. The person answering the phone was rude and dismissive and actually told my wife that the next time we order ( as if there will be a next time .... There will not be) that she needs to be more careful when ordering again blaming her for ordering incorrectly.( Our pizza order has been the same for every restaurant for several yrs we do not change what we order as far as pizza goes ....EVER) at first we were told all they could do was offer us credit for one free topping on our next order . Then we were told that it would be 30-45 minutes before a replacement pizza could be delivered and again we need to be more careful and next time they would not fix the pizza. When I called back and asked to speak to Vinne to tell him about the disrespectful nature of his employee and how I do not appreciate how my.wife was treated on the phone he defended his employee saying he was standing right there during the phone call then lied to me as if I hadn't heard the entire conversation myself saying his employee was not rude that they did not blame us for ordering the wrong thing and that there was nothing wrong with how we were treated. Upon telling him that we would never order from them again his exact words to me were that's fine sir I don't care. All in all the worst customer service I have ever seen and the pizza was not good there is no consistency in the size of the pieces the cut was sloppy and the product was lacking in both taste and presentation. I would not recommend this restaurant to anyone and personally will never spend another dime at any business this man has a hand in. Absolutely disgusted with the service, the product and the owner if less than one star was an option they would get no stars read more

Got party pizza 20 wings and bread sticks and moz sticks.first the dilivery person never gives me my change (cents) and the moz sticks looked like they where ran over by a steam roller .also ordered ranch dip and did not get it.I would say they went down hill on service read more

Vinnies' Italian Eatery - Steam rolled moz sticks - Italian Near Me - Williamsport, Pennsylvania

Not a bad little pizza place...seems to be doing a good business...close to hotel and downtown

By far the best pizza in town. You can taste the real mozzarella cheese. His sauce is perfect. Wings are pretty good too.

I haven't had the opportunity to go downtown Williamsport in a while. I needed a gift certificate for a birthday and knew that the recipient loves Vinnie's. I showed up right around the close of lunchtime, got a pre-made chef salad out of the 'to go' cooler, and my gift certificate. While I was there, I thought to also get a small Stromboli for my evening meal. While waiting for the Stromboli, i sat to take a few bites of my salad...they offered breadsticks with it as I waited. I have NEVER had such a wonderful BREADSTICK as I did there! That alone is reason enough to visit this clean, decently priced, authentic Italian style restaurant. The gentlemen behind the counter were attentive and hard working. The food though, the food! What a surprising pleasure! The food is excellent! I will make efforts to go back read more

Omg... This place is a joke!! We have ordered from them for years and now they said our house is to far to deliver to. All because we sent our food back because our COLD hoagie was in the HOT bag with a pizza and breadsticks. WE WANTED A COLD HOAGIE!! THATS WHAT WE ORDERED!! A hour and a half goes by and our replacement food still hasn't showed and no phone call either. Great work ethic! (AN HOUR AND A HALF LATER) After calling them, we find out they are NOT redelivering our food! Told my husband who is a Disabled Vetran who doesn't drive. (that's why its delivered) TO PICK THE FOOD UP IF WE WANTED IT! However the true kicker is Vinnies delivered to the same address yesterday with no problem! Also, the only reason we ordered two days in a row is because on the 6th they put our COLD hoagie in the HOT bag and it was a warm and gross. The cheese was so soft and warm. I called and they said they would give us a free hoagie replacement. That was ordered today with hot food. Now we still have a free hoagie that they refuse to deliver! April 6, 2018 - Delivered April 7, 2018 - Delivered (returned) April 7, 2018 - To far to deliver read more

Found this place while traveling on business. Fabulous pizza just like you would find in Little Italy NYC. Had a medium veggie pizza with enough left over for another meal or two. Friendly staff! read more

I found this place while traveling for work. 30 mins for delivery, food was fresh and hot, and the delivery guy was very nice. I really enjoyed the cheese steak. read more

We were walking around downtown and decided to get pizza for lunch. Vinnie's just happened to be the first place we came to. The place was completely empty so we only had to wait long enough for our order. We got a supreme pizza to go and it was delicious! I thought the prices were comparable to other pizza places we've been to but unlike most of them, we will definitely be coming back to this one! read more

Absolutely my favorite pizza in the area. The pizza is amazing and fairly priced! The staff is always pleasant. It's the perfect Friday night pizza take out! read more

Only have ordered party pizzas and they are the bomb!! We just got delivery on a Saturday in 93 degree heat and they arrived just as they promised even living outside of Williamsport! Very polite and awesome pizza!! Vinnie and his crew are very friendly!! My go to for pizza!! read more

I just ordered a cheesteak hoagie on Italian Bread. It was prompt but the sandwich was more roll and lettuce than actual steak. I was surprised on the amount or lack or amount on my 5 dollar + sandwich. read more

In my honest opinion this restaurant has terrible service and bad food. I ordered chicken parmigiana, hot wings, a salad, and an order of fries. While my food took almost an hour to get here it also wasn't good. For example; the chicken parmigiana was cold, and cheese was disgusting, the salad which came with the chicken parmigiana wasn't the worst. On the other hand the wings and fries are what made this a deal breaker, the wings (we ordered hot wings) were not spicy, or warm there was very minimal chicken on the bone and they seemed burt. The sauce on the wings was like water with a little bit of hot sauce in it. The fries weren't the worst but were hard and seemed like they have been left out for a day, they were also cold but the seasoning was good. The staff was also rude and had an attitude when couldn't hear over the phone. Lastly the chicken parmigiana dinner was 14.50(way over priced) when you can get it from different places for way better price and better quality. I recommend you save your money and time and go to a better restaurant read more

Food is good for this town. Prices a bit high but delivery was very convenient

Stopped in with my wife for a bite before a show. I don't know what the rest of the menu is like, but we had one of the most flavorless cheese pizzas ever. We had to keep dumping Italian seasoning ground peppers on it by the tablespoon. I know it was just cheese, but I've had cheese pizza from a bunch of different places and this just tasted like cardboard by comparison. Probably not going back. read more

This is a go to spot for a quick lunch in downtown. Normally it's ok, but the women should really use hairnets, found a long black hair in my cheese steak ( the girl prepping it had black hair, I'm a brunette). They also pre- prep the lunch meat for subs which can be seen sitting on the 'line' beside the register. Pizza is good, by the slice or whole, however Vinnie had been known to forget your slices are in the oven and gives them to you partially burnt. read more