The food is great! And they were the only place in Winter Garden that celebrated Halloween in 2025…read moreso they will always have my heart. Service has always been excellent as well!

The pizza and wine were amazing, but Maria was even better. Great service !!!. She was really greatread more

Michael's Ali Coal Fired Pizza, located inside Plant Street Market, downtown Winter Garden is a…read moregreat place if you are looking for pizza. Their menu is pretty large and they cook their items in the coal fire pizza oven. I like that since it gives it that crispy crunchy pizza. Their location is inside Plant Street which has a ton of food places. The best thing about Plant Street is that everyone can get what they want. There are tables throughout Plant Street and Michael's Ali Coal Fire has a few bar seats at their location as well. They specialize in pizza but do have additional options such as stromboli's, wings, and sandwiches. There are some specialty pizzas on their menu but you can also create your own, which is what we did. Next time we will probably go with a specialty pizza just to try it out, but we went with pepperoni and bacon. It was also topped with a little basil. The bacon was pretty much nonexistent but it did have a slight saltiness to it, so I'm sure it was there. My wife loves bacon on her pizza so she definitely wished there was more of it. Overall it was a great pizza. We actually ordered it to take home since we had already had some food at Plant Street. However, it was good and hot and fresh, we ate the entire thing. The pizza is not overall large, I think about 6-7 slices. We shared since we were trying a lot of things. The crust was also really crispy, and not overly charred as sometimes coal fire pizzas can get. Another item we wanted to try but were too full, was the Cheesy Bread which has Roasted Garlic Oil fired with Prosciutto, Mozzarella, Provolone & Gorgonzola. We saw someone else get it and it really looked delicious, very cheesy and really good. The team who works here is also really nice. They were friendly, let us take our time, offered to answer any questions and were just nice. They had a little game going and would ask a question as you paid. They were keeping track of answers. Overall, this is a great spot. I would come back anytime we felt like a pizza. Very great food! ACES!

Michael's Ali Coal Fired Pizza is located inside Plant Street Market in downtown Winter Garden. It…read moreis a local pizza spot serving really great food. They actually have a really large menu for a small spot. They are closer to Crooked Can. There are some seats at their spot (similar to bar seats), but most people get their food to go and eat around Plant Street. Plant Street is a market that has tons of permanent vendors, most of which are food. This spot is truly Italian specializing in pizza but there are other options as well. Some of those options include stromboli's, wings, and sandwiches. They have a few different specialty pizza selections but then you can also create your own. We like to create our own but all their specialty pizzas sounded absolutely delicious. Next time, I think we will pick one of the specialty ones. We went with just pepperoni and bacon. The bacon was hardly present but did give a nice saltiness to the pizza. The pizza was on the thinner side which I love, it was crispy on the edges and just a really great pizza. We actually ordered it with the intention of taking it home for the next day, but it was so good, we ended up eating it all that night. Something we wanted but we were so full from other food options at Plant Street was the CHEESY BREAD which has Roasted Garlic Oil fired with Prosciutto, Mozzarella, Provolone & Gorgonzola. This is something we will for sure be getting next time. It sounded so great! For pizza we will be getting the BUFFALO CHICKEN which is Hot Wing Sauce Base, Roasted Chicken, Gorgonzola, Provolone, Mozzarella...Finished with Celery. Their options are just really great. The servers were super friendly as well. They will take your phone number and text you when its ready. This way you can go walk around, grab a table, grab a beer from Crooked Can and wait for your food. This is definitely a spot you need to try out when you are at Plant Street! Great food, great employees and a fun atmosphere.

This place has new owners and the interior has been refreshed…read more Have been multiple times and the food and service have been excellent each time. Lasagna, baked ziti, meatballs, stromboli and garlic knots all were delicious and the owners and staff were very friendly and helpful on each visit. Prices are very reasonable and portions are generous. We will be back!

I just found out that Italian Garden Pizzeria has closed and this is truly sad news not only for…read moreWinter Garden, Florida, but for all of us in the Orlando, Florida area. Italian Garden Pizzeria had some great pizza and the service was always friendly. The ambiance was nothing fancy, but no one ever said that pizza was ever supposed to be anything akin to high-end dining. This is sad, but I do wish all involved the best of luck in their future endeavors.

I came to the Plant Street Market recently to see what all the fuss was all about. I decided to…read morestart getting one thing from each stall of interest until I had what I considered a good amount of food. In my ordering frenzy, I ordered an item I actually don't run across too often in the suburbs of Orlando. I ordered the Italian Beef Sandwich. A regionally legendary sandwich that always draws me in. Maybe it's the soggy bread that always inevitably disintegrates. Maybe it's the generous portion of beef that is always moist and juicy. Maybe it's the giardiniera that adds a Massive pop of freshness, crunch, and acid. Either way, it was delicious. It was excellent. The service was ok. They found some kids that were willing to work for cheap, I guess. No extraordinary customer service, but nothing negative, either. Overall, a five star sandwich, and I will have a few more of these before the end of all things.

Pros: Another great little shop in the great Plant Street…read moreMarket. Pretty quick service compared to the other shops in the market. We had our food very promptly. The sandwich was stacked with meat, not skimpy on the portion size at all. Cons: None. Just be care. The inherent moist nature of the sandwich we ordered means it WILL fall apart and be very messy. Tips: Get the Chicago Italian Beef. Maybe ask for a little more giardiniera on the side.

We came here with family for lunch and really enjoyed our time here!…read more There was amble seating both inside and out, and had a lot of space so you didn't feel like you were on top of other groups. The service was prompt and our waiter was very friendly! All of our food came out quickly and correctly. Our meals were good, we all enjoyed the food. The true highlight for us were the truffle wedges...I wish I would have gotten a photo but they were gone so quickly!! Definitely a must get if you come! I really enjoyed coming here and will definitely come back again in the future!

Came in with my husband on a Friday night, last minute decision. The indoor dining area was almost…read morefull but we were seated immediately. Alyssa our server was friendly and checked in with us. When she didn't know something, she got us the answer promptly. I love that some options on the menu are locally sourced and grass fed. The food was great, the environment was lively and service was top notch. Can't ask for more!

This is one of the most unique places to get a pizza on the west side. This is my second time…read morecoming to Pinottis and it does not disappoint. Interior feels high-end and the dining experience there is very elevated, but the service and vibes are down to earth. It's just like your classic mom and pop shop only a little fancier feeling. This is a great place for both a date night and a family gathering. I got the large pizza and pal, vegetarian zucchini and half chicken. The staff is really nice to let me know that that's an option and who doesn't love a little variety. Be prepared their prices for a large are a bit up there and this ended up being close to $40. It's definitely delicious and was checking out. Dig In!

Pinotti's Pizza isn't just a local favorite in Winter Garden; it's a culinary experience waiting to…read morebe discovered. This independent pizzeria consistently tops the charts as one of the most popular spots in the city, and a single bite reveals exactly why locals are so loyal. Forget the chains and immerse yourself in the authentic taste of Winter Garden by trying their acclaimed dishes. Whether you're a long-time resident or just passing through, a visit to Pinotti's promises new favorite flavors and a true taste of local pizza perfection. Pinotti's Pizza no es solo un favorito local en Winter Garden; es una experiencia culinaria por descubrir. Esta pizzería independiente encabeza constantemente las listas como uno de los lugares más populares de la ciudad, y un solo bocado revela exactamente por qué los lugareños son tan fieles. Olvídate de las cadenas y sumérgete en el auténtico sabor de Winter Garden probando sus aclamados platos. Ya seas residente de toda la vida o solo estés de paso, una visita a Pinotti's te promete nuevos sabores favoritos y una auténtica experiencia de pizza local.

This place was good! To be honest, I think I built up my expectations because of the whole melted…read morecheese experience everyone talks about. It was delicious at first, but once the cheese started to harden, it wasn't quite what I had imagined. My recommendation would be to eat it quickly while the cheese is still hot and gooey to get the full experience. That said, the food was still good overall. The service was great--everyone was friendly, welcoming, and attentive throughout our visit. The ambiance was also really nice, especially being located in Plant Street Market, which adds to the overall charm and experience. Definitely worth a visit, just be ready to enjoy that cheese before it cools down!

Really good cheese plate. Didn't think to take a picture before we dove in but love the fact that…read morethere is no blue cheese involved and the smoked Gouda is amazing.

Without a doubt the best prime rib ever. Fed 10 people and everyone agreed. I also got pork ribs…read morefor 4th of July and have never had better. Hats off to Jr. and Robbie

I've been coming to the Plant St market for years now. This has been one of the only consistent…read morevendors. I decided to give them a try. They specialize in butchered meats and prepared foods that you can make at home. I got half a pound of chicken salad. It was a little over $6 and came with crackers! It was an amazingly delicious lunch high in protein that was really cheap for the quality! I love that it's not mayo heavy and had mostly chicken and very few added vegetables and fruits. The butchers deli is located in the market, so seating is shared with all vendors, so it gets very crowded! The staff were super kind! They gave us a sample of the chicken salad before buying it and helped us with h our options to eat it there! I'll definitely be back!