*Reviewing for us picky Americans abroad*…read more Food and service was fantastic! Ordered the seasonal vegetable soup, the wild boar pappardelle, the ribeye, and Nona's tiramisu. 10/10 for everything!!

First Impressions - we did outdoor seating and it was a late dinner so not much available. Nothing…read moreabout it stood out to me. The host was very nice and welcoming. It was outdoor seating so it seemed romantic. The Noms - Bruschetta: tomatoes were very fresh. I could taste the herbs. I ordered a second healthy because it was so good. Steak: hubby ordered the steak, it was hard as a rock Ravioli: overly sauced, yet still dry... how did that happen? I don't know. In Conclusion - would not recommend unless you just want the bruschetta.

We were lucky to hear of this gem from some locals, and we were not let down. This was a wonderful…read moreexperience in every way- the ambiance was charming, the hospitality was excellent, and the food was beyond. We got the bistecca alla fiorentina, which was beautifully tender, flavorful and juicy, and the seafood risotto which almost brought a tear to my eye. Additionally, one in our party is gluten free, and they were helpful in pointing out which items would be safe. All in all, a great find and one of our favorite meals while in Florence.

Wow! Wow! Wow!!!!…read more This little restaurant delivers big on flavor and hospitality! A butcher recommended this place to us and we are so glad we went. We have the peasant ravioli and the Florentine steak. You must eat the steak rare. Omg THE BEST STEAK I HAVE EVER HAD IN MY LIFE!!! I am going to be dreaming about this steak. The ravioli was so fresh. The peasant filling was perfect. Our server was very kind and patient with us bc we couldn't speak Italian, she spoke English so our experience went smoothly. I hope we make it back to Italy soon.

We came here as part of a tour and had a fixed menu of bruschetta, lasagna, and chianti. Since our…read moretour called in our participation in the optional lunch in advance, we arrived, got seated immediately, the wine and bread was already on the tables, and the bruschetta and lasagna came shortly after. They were very efficient and we were in and out of there within an hour. All bottles of chianti were gone over good conversation and we were on our merry way walking through Florence. I would definitely return.

Nice place off the beaten path. The food was inexpensive and fresh. The service was fair however it…read morewas a little busy so I may be ranking this a bit low.

Came here for dinner and enjoyed a delicious dinner and glasses of wine. The Ribollita and the…read morePappa Al Pomodoro were both hearty and comforting which was perfect for the cold weather. The soups were all well prepared and the medley of ingredients were just absolutely enjoyable. It was the first time I tried these traditional Tuscan soups and I'll be looking for more in the future. As for the pork dish (Arista di Maiale), the meat was very tender, savory and so tasty. I chose to get a glass of red wine to enjoy with the meal and I like their model where they bring you a newly opened bottle and only charge you by what you pour. Smart on them since of course I poured myself more than one glass so really it's a win win for both. Reservations are highly recommended and there are no English menus available. Thankfully, one of the staff flagged down another worker who spoke english and was able to walk me through the menu. He was very friendly, helpful and patient. I cannot wait to go back and try the other traditional Florentine dish, the 1kg steak :)

Got lucky and got in without a reservation, I guess thats a perk of visiting Firenze in winter…read more Seated immediately, ordered 2 glasses of surprisingly excellent Prosecco (at any price but these were a very reasonable 5e each). Ordered the fresh pasta ravioli with pears and the baked tiramisu. Excellent, both of them. The people next to us had such a good meal they planned to return the next day for lunch. Five stars! But make a reservation or prepare to be disappointed...

Just came back and was saddened to hear Alessandro was no longer there. Although the Chef remained,…read morethere was something that was just off. Food was still very good but not as great. Should have known something was off as we walked in and place was empty on an afternoon. Wish them the best of luck

This place...incredible. I feel like it's a hidden gem in Florence. We had pear ravioli and salad…read morepaired with wine. The ambiance was so great and traditional Italian! The service was great too. I would make this a priority during a trip to Florence as we'll definitely be back one day!

Came for dessert at end of night and loved it! Only had tiramisu, but it was incredible and I'd…read morelove to come back for food. Really fun atmosphere inside too!

Delicious food, excellent service, great wine list. Make a reservation. It's worth it!read more

I cannot beam about this restaurant enough, and I would give over 5 stars if I could. I have a tree…read morenut allergy, and our first lunch in Florence was at Trattoria La Madia with Ryan as our server. He reassured me that what I ordered would be free of my allergens, and each time we dined here (yes, we dined here three times during our two days in Florence), my food was free of tree nuts. Ryan made our experience a million times better. He was detailed, kind, and patient as I navigated the menu with my allergy. He replaced dirty napkins as my partner ate a Florentine steak, and he ended up knowing us my first name by our last day. I am eternally grateful for Ryan and the attention to my allergy he assured and that the restaurant provided. I wish we could dine here everyday, but truly our experience here made our trip more magical. I also have to highlight that we went to Venice, Florence, and Rome during our trip and the pizza at Trattoria La Madia was THE BEST of all the places we dined at. The service definitely was, as well, thanks to Ryan. Also the restaurant is beautifully and authentically decorated! If you are in Florence, this restaurant is A MUST!

Tucked away in Florence, this small Italian restaurant was exactly what we were hoping to…read morefind--authentic, welcoming, and absolutely delicious. We were looking for something a bit lighter and ordered the salted, crusted sea bass, which was perfectly cooked and full of flavor. It felt like a dish made with true care and tradition. Our kids went for the classics--carbonara and gnocchi--and both were fantastic. You could really taste the freshness of the ingredients and the attention to detail in every bite. One of the things that impressed us most was the service. Not only was the staff warm and attentive, but they were incredibly thoughtful with our daughter's food allergies. They listened carefully, reassured us, and modified dishes as needed so we could all relax and enjoy our meal. We felt completely at home from the moment we walked in. This is not a tourist trap--it's a true, authentic Italian dining experience where you feel like part of the family. Highly recommend!

Probably my favorite restaurant in my two week tour of Italy. The service was so attentive and our…read moreserver so kind. It's a very busy place, so I do recommend making a reservation. My daughter and I just had primi but the pasta was fantastic. I had their famous lamb ragù with parperdelle homemade pasta. The flavors were scrumptious. I'm still dreaming of that sauce. My daughter had a meat sauce too and hers was delicious. We had spinach for a side and it was perfectly cooked and flavored. Would recommend to anyone in Firenze. Thanks Il Giardino!

The pizza Is incredible. The service is smooth. The ambiance is okay. I would definitely come here…read moreagain.