Overall rating: 4.8 Made a reservation for a Sunday at 9:15am & it was definitely not needed. Should have just done a walk-in. The breakfast was delicious and felt very fresh. The staff was really nice given the morning, and I came with friends who also had a nice time. HIGHLY recommend the cardamom bun, delish. read more

See all

Food was okay! Everyone gets the egg sandwich but I felt like it was a pretty standard and basic entree. Not sure why it gets called out so much. I liked the fried chicken sandwich! They charge a fee of $1.50 if you can't finish your food and need to pack it up, which left a pretty bad taste in my mouth. read more

Came for breakfast on a Friday and there was no wait. My boyfriend and I shared: + Egg sandwich + added avocado - awesome + Crispy potato - perfect and they give you SO many + Drip coffee - meh can skip this + Morning bun - holy hell this was possibly the best morning bun I've ever had in my life??? Will be back to try their bakery next door - apparently the cardamom buns are also amazing! read more

See all

Stopped by this spot in the neighborhood for breakfast and sat at the bar since all the tables were reserved. Cute spot with lots of sunlight and plants. The breakfast sandwich was solid, but next time I'll try the lamb sausage--it looked amazing. The hot chocolate was tasty but disappointingly cold. Overall, a nice spot with great friendly service! read more

See all

Looking for brekky? Yeah, this place is it. Came here on a whim while it was down pouring rain and... left with a smile. I got a simple breakfast platter. Is that the name of it? Nope. But it had lamb sausage patties (these were the star), two eggs, sweet potatoes, and sourdough. What more could you want? read more

Otway - New American Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Go straight for the clam sandwich - you can't go wrong with it. Or pickled vegetables. Or their bread. Honestly, everything on the menu is epic. Loved this place. Pretty interior as well. Lastly, quick and attentive service. read more

I've been here a few times for dinner in the winter. I think it's a really nice restaurant that suits most tastes. Good cocktails and small plates; however, I believe it's more appealing to vegetarians and pescatarians. I'm not a big fan of the burger here or any of the meat options. They are okay, but the seafood and appetizers are the highlights. The staff is always very friendly, and since the place is small, they are very attentive. Good date night spot! read more

Cute ambiance, baby friendly, and yummy food! We were seated quickly at the bar without a reservation. Our server was friendly and efficient, and with a baby it was nice to get out for a quick brunch so efficiency was super helpful! Will come again :) read more

Otway - Otway Burger, Crispy Potatoes, Egg Sandwich - New American Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

We came for brunch/breakfast. Everything was cooked & seasoned perfectly. Whoever is cooking, they know what they're doing. Service was great too. We even came back the next day and the wonderful experience repeated itself. Great neighborhood spot! read more

After last night I need to shout out Otway again as my favorite little treat local restaurant. I have a monthly dinner date with a girlfriend and this always feels special. The drink selection, including mocktails, is fresh and interesting. The food is on point. We share everything so I got to try the clam toast and we split the burger - I don't want to know how much butter was on that thing but holy moses was it delicious. We almost never get dessert but we tried the semifreddo (to die for - but I didn't let myself eat all of it - this would be perfect to share) and the chocolate mousse which was a bit bitter at first but a delicious grown up type dessert. Service was relaxed and friendly but not like, we're besties (which is fine). read more

Classic americana food. Love their lamb protein option on the egg and cheese. The coffee is delicious. The staff is wonderful. I love this place! read more

I love both otway and the bakery! The egg sandwich was absolutely delicious (the scallion aiolii) and ofc the pastries were perfect. The ambience inside is cute and friendly. A simple menu, wonderful for a calm breakfast. read more

Otway - Morning bun, chocolate croissant - New American Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

The spread of baked goodies at Otway was great. We went for the mini chocolate babka and the calabrian chili twist. The babka was so soft and had the right amount of chocolate and sweetness. The chili twist was quite unique and was a good savory choice. Service was pretty fast. read more

Came here on a Friday night with a friend for Happy Hour. I had a martini and my friend had a gimlet. Cocktails and wine are $11. Great French fries. The staff were very friendly! On this cold winter is evening, the place was cozy, warm and inviting! I would come back here. read more

Otway - Gimlet and martini - New American Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Stumbled upon Otway on a Saturday around brunch time and decided to stop for a bite, as there were plenty of available tables. I ordered the deluxe breakfast with bacon and it was tasty -- the bacon and the crispy potatoes were particularly amazing. However, I did find the all-day food menu to be a little limited. This place seems to shine for its pastries and drinks, neither of which I tried on this visit. But with $10 glasses of natural wine and great deals on happy hour cocktails, I'll definitely need to come back. read more

Otway - Deluxe Breakfast - New American Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Yummy food and beautiful interiors with lots of plants and light. The cheeses, jam, oysters, trout and cucumber were all fresh and refreshing. Great date spot with happy hour. read more

See all

I really wanted to love and support Otway. When I ate there, the presentation and facade is so wonderful, but unfortunately the service and treatment of customers is deeply disappointing. I spent a couple hundred dollars supporting their Kickstarter campaign to launch. The promised thank you was a brunch for 4. I never received the brunch, so I reached out to Otway by phone and email. After a few emails, I was told certificates were mailed out. I said I have not received mine, but since then I have not received any response despite multiple emails and calls. I would be happy to update this once rectified, but in my eyes, any restaurant that is so disrespectful to its initial backers deserves a poor review. read more

Otway - New American Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Otway is a sweet, small-ish eatery that I definitely plan to return to! Absolutely agree with the rating of "best egg sandwich in NYC." The English muffin it came on -- whether homemade by them or by a supplier -- was one of the best I've ever had. Eggs were delicious and I had avocado added to it. Just perfect! Also want to give a shout out to the folks who work there -- super nice and helpful. Looking forward to heading back and trying other stuff. Definitely recommend making a reservation if you want to get in! read more

Otway - Isn't that just the yummiest egg sandwich you ever did see??? (Spoiler alert: YES) - New American Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

The server got mad at me when he got my order wrong. Proceeded to serve me old rotten shriveled up berries and then tried gaslight me and say they weren't rotten and he would eat them. Had to walk up to the bar to ask for my check because no one came to check on us once during the hour we were there. The people who work here need to understand that the food isn't going to save them from their terrible attitudes and hostile atmosphere. read more

I don't know what wizardry made these scrambled eggs so good but they were amazing, as was the morning bun and the potatoes! Service was great and it is so cute inside with lots of plants. read more

Otway - Table - New American Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Fantastic brunch with a beautiful ambiance. Had a great time catching up with friends here and the brunch items were very simple but elevated in flavor. The matcha latte had a pristine texture along with good coffee! I got the egg sandwich with a side of crispy potato, my party got the otway burger, eggs with crispy potato and a side / lamb mergeuz sausage and avocado. The fries were done really well and I must say the "crispy potato" side is not just 1 potato, it's the whole bowl of home fries! My eggs were done very fluffy to perfection and the cheese added the perfect creaminess to it. The lamb mergeuz patty was delicious and the bread was handmade and tasted so fresh and good. A perfect egg sandwich. My party also had very soft and fluffy eggs all cooked to perfection and the potatoes were all really good and better than most fries. The burger was super juicy and had really good flavor and honestly it was a picture perfect brunch both in taste and aesthetic. It was super filled up earlier but we ended up staying throughout the time and realized they actually close at 3/4 to prep for dinner time so that's one thing to note. Overall I can see why everyone comes here for Sunday brunch! It is THE best brunch spot in the neighborhood for eggs and toast :) read more

See all

Fantastic restaurant and bar. We arrived around 7 on a weeknight and were seated promptly. A few wines by the glass, a few bars, and a good selection of whiskeys. Good variety without being overwhelming. I opted for their red wine special which was a blend from Oregon; nothing fancy but reasonably priced at $13 per glass. We started with one of their specials. It was an onion dip topped with black and red caviar that was served with fried chicken skin to dip. Super creative. The chicken skin was a very bold flavor so it wasn't an ideal item to dip into caviar as it overpowered the flavor. I think the chicken skin crisps were great on their own and the dip was great too. Next, we had a charred cabbage served in a savory sauce and topped with parsley and dill. I believe the cabbage was slow cooked first to make it tender and then it was charred. I think it came out perfect. I'd highly recommend it. For the main course, I had the burger. It was served medium rare. It's a must order. Seemed like the majority of patrons were ordering it. Super juicy and savory. It's an all day burger. Served with some fresh cut fries that were crispy and seasoned on point. For dessert, we shared the olive oil semi freddo and the chocolate moouse with raspberries. I preferred the semi freddo. After dinner, I had a glass of the Glenkinchie 12. Haven't seen it before, so I decided to give it a go. Very long finish. Restroom was super spacious. It was gender neutral and handicap accessible. Service was very attentive and helpful. read more

Decided to finally try Otway for brunch and see if the experience matched the vibe the photos gave. I would give a 3.5 if half stars were an option. They use Resy as their booking platform and there's a $25pp cancellation fee. It gives you until a few hours before (maybe 6?) but that fee might've been why there was a ton of open reservations when booking the day before and a lot of people trying to come in as walk ins. One member of my party fell victim to weekend MTA disasters and was forced to bus transfer when their train got stuck underground, so we appreciate the Otway staff still honoring the reservation despite their delay. It was a weird experience to feel rushed by the hostess, but also like we had to beg for the servers attention to order. The restaurant could do with one less two top table down the middle, it's crowded and there's a lot of jostling. We were able to move to a wall table - definitely try for one of these. The chai latte was nice sized & not too sweet. The baked goods aren't automatically heated up and the person who ordered theirs as a meal received it immediately after we placed our order which was a little awkward for pacing. The egg sandwich was a nice surprise. It arrived a little underwhelming looking on a small side plate wrapped in foil, but the bread had a slight sweetness to it which really elevated the flavor. Some of the brunch drinks at tables around us looked worth trying and there was a good crowd mix in there. I think I'll try the bakery instead next time and maybe treat the restaurant more like a quick stop option (ie sitting at the cocktail stools at the bar) vs a sit down experience. One interesting flag, at the bottom of the menu it said there would be a $1.50 fee to take any uneaten food to go. That coupled with the reservation cancellation fee that costs more than most menu items was a turnoff. I understand to go supplies cost money and cancelled reservations make it hard to reach cover capacity, but when those issues are handled this way it comes off as a little cold. All in all, give it a shot - either make a reservation for a time you know you won't need to adjust and request a wall seat, or maybe go in slow and grab a seat at the bar for a drink and a pastry. read more

Otway - Egg Sandwich - New American Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Everything we tried was delicious!! And we tried almost everything:) Great wine selection as well! read more

Otway - Delicious wine - New American Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Don't go for lunch (or brunch as they say...) One server , I feel for her , she was nice eventually when came over and explain the menu ( the terrible QR - Enough !!!!! Pandemic menus obsolete) while trying to serve 6 tables ..... At least their (it was good to join their kickstarter) bakery few stores down , worth the time . The place was on my "to do" due to the bakery Ended eating next door eventually at the fantastic Bklyn Buro. read more

Otway was our second choice for brunch. Maybe I ordered the wrong dish but I thought it was very ok. I got the omelette. It was pretty boring--just cheese butter and eggs with a side of toast. It was a bit greasy and bland. My friend got the chiliqules and enjoyed it--but I'm not usually a fan of soggy tortilla chips read more

Otway - Omelette - New American Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Hey, if I want to spend $20+ on a fried chicken sandwich for breakfast, that's my prerogative. In my defense, it's one hell of a fried chicken sandwich. Big chunks of crispy chicken. Spicy mayo. Plus a crap ton of fries. It took a bit to come out, but I assume it's cuz they weren't prepared for someone to order one at 9am. Luckily, there's a ton of seating inside, and you can grab a coffee or pastry while you wait. read more

Here for happy hour and early dinner. food was fantastic. We had the oysters, cabbage, crab pommes paillason, beets, and bread. The sauces on the cabbage and beets were amazing, the flavors on everything were so well balanced. I've been living here 15 years and this was one of the best meals I've had in this city. read more

This restaurant has been on my list for a while. They have a great deal on the which is $20 for a dozen oysters. The oysters were shucked perfectly and were absolutely delicious. I also got a martini, which was perfectly made. Server and bartender were both extremely friendly & attentive. I can't wait to come back for a full dinner! read more

Otway - New American Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Otway is one of my favorite restaurants to get a burger!!! It's so delicious!! The fries are irresistible as well. Don't forget to get the Little Gem Salad because I can eat this every day. It's crunchy and the vinaigrette has the right amount of acidity. It's truly a hidden gem in Crown Heights. read more

Otway - Otway burger - New American Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Took an extra long walk for breakfast today and ended up at Otway. It's a cute, well lit atmosphere with lots of greenery and a full bar. I got a delicious fresh squeezed OJ that was nice and cold and the egg sandwich which was absolutely massive. It had gruyere and scallions with three fried eggs on a thinner bagel like bread. They have tons of pastries I'd like to come back and try like an everything bagel brioche thing, ham and cheese knot, and some sweet pastries. I saw someone eating the yogurt with granola and peaches and it looked great too. Would come back! read more

See all

Incredible food, amazing vibe, and the service was lovely! The eggs are so unbelievably fluffy and delicious. Highly recommend coming for breakfast and dinner, this place is the best! read more

Visited here over the weekend, hear me when I say the ENTIRE staff was unpleasant! I thought I was being punked. Long story short I won't be going back, it took everything in me not to call them out on their rudeness and their slowness towards customer service. read more

This is a really solid brunch option. We sat outside, but the inside is so cute and very minimalist and I would recommend either one. The both of them have great vibes. We got a few drinks and we ended up getting the deluxe breakfast which came pretty fast considering they seem pretty busy for brunch and the deluxe was breakfast was so good. The bacon was really perfectly cooked. Eggs were great. I wish there was a little bit more quantity wise. Potatoes were stellar and actually The toast was so good that I ended up getting more from the bakery next-door because I was so impressed and blown away. read more

Otway - Deluxe Breakfast - New American Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Always great service and pastries/bread! Love the mini babka and the seasonal pastry, a kimchi item was amazing.

*Safety Warning* I had the worst experience of my life last night. We've been going to Otway for the past three years all for my husband's birthdays and other special occasions. Yesterday, we went there again to celebrate his birthday.I ordered the steak and made it very clear that I am six months pregnant and cannot eat steak cooked medium or rare. I specifically asked if they could prepare it well done, and the server immediately agreed, assuring me it wouldn't be a problem.We were the only table in the restaurant last night, yet when the steak arrived, it was severely undercooked. I politely explained that I couldn't eat it because I'm pregnant, emphasizing that I wasn't trying to be difficult. The server took the plate back but with an attitude, which was uncomfortable. My husband and our friends waited for me to be served, but when the steak came back, it was even rarer than before, with pink juices leaking into the sauce. I was shocked. When I asked the server how this could happen, she responded with the worst attitude I've ever experienced. She insisted that the steak was cooked properly and that I could eat it. My husband pointed out the visible blood and pink in the meat, but she continued to argue and gaslight us. I had no choice but to leave the table and go next door to Sisters, where I ate alone. The staff at Sisters were so kind. Thank god. Meanwhile, my husband's birthday dinner was ruined. I can't believe as his pregnant wife, had to leave his birthday dinner. Of course, he and our friends left shortly after me. This wasn't just a bad dining experience; it was deeply disrespectful. Being pregnant and having my needs disregarded, along with the horrible attitude from the staff, was unacceptable. If you're pregnant, sick, or immunocompromised, I urge you to be cautious with this place. read more

Really can't beat the morning bun or the breakfast sandwich. Photo evidence of the morning bun attached. The bread they use for the sandwich (I think baked on premises) is perfectly soft on the outside and grilled crisp on the inside. Eggs a perfect scramble with scallions and a hint of garlic. Even the way they package it is nice. Strong recommend all around. read more

Otway - Morning Bun - New American Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

i love coming here for a WFH breakfast. the egg sandwich with lamb merguez sausage and an oat milk iced chai is my go to. the breakfast sandwich is out of this world. the eggs are so fluffy and creamy and the merguez sausage adds a depth of flavor. their chai latte is one of the best i've had in the neighborhood. they also make tasty crispy potatoes. the ambiance is great and they also serve delicious natural wine. read more

Otway - Egg Sandwich - New American Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Otway had been on my radar for some time. Mainly because of their breakfast sandwich. I am a big believer in breakfast sandwiches. After all, I am a New Yorker. However, while I do love a baconeggncheese (yes, it's one word), I love a sausage patty egg and cheese, so much more. So when I heard of the majestic lamb sausage egg and cheese, I had to have it. True to the legend the sandwich is phenomenal. They baked bread is solid. What makes it though is that lamb sausage patty. Excellent flavor. Loved every bite. At $13 before tip, it's a pricey sandwich though. Not sure if I'd buy it again. Worth trying out though. Hope to come back for brunch. read more

Waited 40 minutes to not receive eggs and potatoes. When I finally asked if the food was still coming, a person who seemed like a manager said they would go check on it and just never came back. I eventually told a server I needed to leave. They charged me four dollars for the single coffee I'd been sitting with for the better part of an hour and offered zero acknowledgment of the fact that they never even made the food and wasted my time. Accidents can happen, but it couldn't have been handled more poorly. It's pretty clear the place has a leadership challenge. The food is decent, it is not special, but it is overpriced. I've been a couple times before and noticed, as many others here have pointed out, that the hospitality was lacking and simple orders, even just a cup of coffee, took a very long time, but today was ridiculous. Never going back again. read more