I was recently in DC for a few days on vacation with my husband and my in-laws, and I knew I wanted to try a Jose Andres restaurant or two. As a lover of Mexican food, Oyamel was an obvious choice. Unfortunately, it was a huge disappointment.
We started with the guacamole freshly made to order. The texture was good (is there anything worse than a pureed guacamole?!), but it was under-seasoned: where was the acid and the salt? The waiter asked if we wanted mild, medium, or hot, and we chose medium. It tasted more mild than the mildest salsa. It was just bland.
We tried the ceviche rojo (sliced Hamachi with cucumber, hominy, and corn nuts tossed in a guajillo chile sauce, garnished with avocado and radish). It was all right. The Hamachi was beautiful. The guajillo hominy and corn nut mixture was served under the Hamachi, and it was interesting, but the dish didn't read as ceviche to me. The Hamachi didn't taste of any acid (I thought the only meal needed more acid - it's all about the lime) or any marinating at all really. It wasn't anything to write home about, but it wasn't the worst dish either.
We also got the Nopal asado con salsa molcajete (grilled fresh cactus paddle served with a salsa molcajete of grilled tomatoes, tomatillos, green onions, cilantro, and green chiles). The taste of the nopal was okay, but so slimy! I've cooked nopales at home and have eaten it at restaurants across Texas, and I've never had such slimy nopal. I know the slime is part of eating nopales, but there are ways to cook it that will decrease the slime. And this was slimy and pretty unpleasant to eat (if this was my first time eat nopal, I'm not sure I'd eat it again).
We tried two of the bean dishes: frijoles refritos con queso (slow-cooked refried beans stuffed with melted Chihuahua cheese, served with Mexican cream and fresh tortillas) and frijoles rebosero (heirloom rebosero beans, fresno chiles, and seasonal vegetables in a "mulato chile" dressing). The frijoles rebosero were not impressive. The seasonal vegetables were broccoli and green beans, and they didn't work with the beans at all. The frijoles refritos were possibly the best thing we ate all night. The refried beans were smooth and tasty, and I'd never had refried beans served this way before (sort of a large quenelle with the cheese inside), and the crema worked perfectly with it. The tortillas were good as well.
And two chayote squash dishes: chayotes guisados (grilled chayote squash, broccoli, and cauliflower with a tomato-arbol chile salsa, watercress, and pumpkin seeds) and ensalada de chayote (Mexican squash salad with house-made requeson and crushed peanuts, hibiscus dressing, and peanut praline sauce). These were good, because the chayote squash was beautiful.
We also tried the tamal de mole poblano (shredded chicken tamal with a poblano mole sauce of almonds, chiles, and a touch of chocolate, topped with crema, sesame seeds, and onion). It was okay, but I didn't think the mole sauce was very balanced.
And, lastly, we got some tacos. One cochinita pibil con cebolla en escabeche (Yucatan-style pit barbecued Rocky Holly Farms pork with Meixcan sour orange and pickled red onion) - okay, but too wet, and the tortilla didn't hold up. A $4.50 taco has to be perfect, and this was just all right. We also tried two of the chapulines tacos (yes, grasshoppers). The menu describes the taco as sautéed grasshoppers, shallots, tequila, and guacamole. I didn't taste shallots or tequila, and, unfortunately, the guacamole in the taco was just as underseasoned as the guacamole we got as a starter. If I'd had some lime, it would have gone on the taco. Because I didn't, I added some of the pickled onion from the tamal to the taco.
To be honest, I wasn't crazy about the restaurant either. The butterfly décor seemed childish and tacky, the restaurant was super loud, and the bathrooms were pretty gross for such a nice/expensive restaurant (I think the air conditioning in the bathroom wasn't working, which gave the bathroom a pretty terrible smell). The service was fine, but not worth noting.
Sadly, there wasn't anything that stood out about this meal to me. The food wasn't anything special, and neither was the experience. Of the food experiences I had while in DC, Oyamel was the greatest disappointment. I definitely wouldn't recommend it over other restaurants we tried over our five days in DC! read more