The Calzone was amazing! I had Chicken in mine and my friend had spinach. Comes standard with a cup of Marinara. Very tasty with a crispy garlic olive oil texture. Tons of cheese...stuffed! Tables were a little messy from prior customers. Staff must have been busy making more of those delicious Calzones. Would recommend this place! read more

Their pizza is the best. I started in the early 80's on The Ave by the UW. Now Kenmore is my local shop. Thecrust, the cheese, sauce with enough garlic and not too much sugar - all good! They goofed, we all do, and they made good with a $20 card to make up for it! read more

Love pagliacci and this is a great location. The service is wonderful. We have been customers for a long time and they sometimes give us little free things (and sometimes a free pizza!) They are quick to fix things that are wrong when that happens (though it doesn't happen much). The pizza, while expensive is worth it. Great thin crust, chewy pizza, locally sources boxes and fantastic sauce. The breadsticks that they added the last year or so are a big big improvement over previous breadsticks that they offered. And the salad is delicious. DO NOT MISS THE HEIRLOOM TOMATO PIZZA in the late spring early summer. It is one of my favorite pizza's ever. read more

Great Pizza and Friendly service. I ordered pizza by the slice to go. I order three slices and they put the slices through the oven. When I got home the cheese and ingredients were hot. Three slices cost $10.21 prices vary by slice. I had pepperoni, pesto primo, and grand salami primo. read more

See all

Last night, I ordered two pizzas for delivery for $54. I tipped the driver $6. The pizzas were not fully cooked. We popped them in our oven to slightly brown the cheese on top and finish cooking the crust. After baking the pizzas, they were okay, but nothing special. I have never had to finish baking a delivery pizza before....I will not be ordering from Pagliacci again. read more

Ugh....worst pizza we have EVER had! The gal who took our order was nice, as well the delivery, but oh, man....it was so horrible, we couldn't eat it. We wound up dumping it and having tuna fish sandwiches...yeah, THAT's how bad it was. I wish I could give it NO STARS, but you can't, and they do not deserve even this lone star. read more

I have been a regular customer of Pagliacci's since my college days and always thought their service was good...until now. I moved to Bothell a year ago and ordered mainly from Pags because it's the only place that will deliver to my house. Delivery was generally speedy. Two weeks ago I ordered and the driver couldn't find my place, so I cancelled my order. The dispatch center seemed to care and sent a $25 gift certificate. Great, so I ordered again. Two hours, many calls and two missed deadlines later, no pizza and total lack of help from their dispatch center. The driver showed up over two hours later with the cancelled order and we refused it. My advice to Pags: hire drivers from Washington State (I noticed she had California plates), hire a driver who can speak English, and please don't send the same driver a second time to the address she screwed up at the first time. I will never order from Pags again. Much easier to drive to Jet City Pizza or Papa Johns for pick up. read more

Ordered on line for pick up. Really good staff. The pizza was ready within a few minutes of the promised time. Hot and fresh out the kitchen. Traditional pagliacci salad, large cheese pizza and a large Brooklyn. I have been eating this pizza since 1982. It is still so darn good, and has a very consistent flavor story . I hate that the toppings slide off, but I forgive it. It's also really expensive. The above meal was over 74.00. Two pizzas and a salad. I mean.... read more

This place serves very good pizza with fresh ingredients! Since it was my first time at this place, I wanted to try their most popular pizza which ended up being something similar to a supreme pizza. So I asked Amy the lady at the front to show me a popular pizza that was out of the norm and I ended up with a combo of AGOG Primo and Chicken Primo for my wife and I. Our dinner that night was very delicious....Thank you Amy for the selection! read more

Awesome Pizza, always willing to make my salad half spinach half lettuce, most other locations wont do this. Single slices available and a punch card for a free slice I come in at lunch for a beer and a slice read more

AGOG Primo, yum! I had them cook the tomatoes vs. adding at the end. Just a tremendous pizza

We did receive an email from the corporate office and shortly after a gift card. We gave it another shot this time through delivery. The pizza was still good, however the service was still subpar. read more

The pizza is okay. However, I don't think its worth the $25 bucks it costs! Their flavors are kinda different almost like a Garlic Jim's but not as creative. Their restaurant is a unique design, but the staff is sometimes lazy and doesn't clean up very quickly. I wouldn't recommend this place, and I wouldn't say they're horrible. I just wish they had more to offer since they are trying so hard for a niche. To be fair, I do like their spicy pepperoni it is tasty. My husband swears that this is the best pizza he has ever had, but he is always starving when he goes. read more

The pizza isn't bad, kind of greasy, but it takes FOREVER to get our food every time. We've been at multiple different times of day, same service. Quiet, slow staff made up of kids and one middle aged man. I'm literally not coming back here. read more

Very good food- but terrible service. I ordered a salad (for delivery) at around 3 expecting it to come at 5 [when their delivery starts]. First off, the first time I called I was thinking about my order... And they hung up on me. How rude. I finally got around to ordering a party size salad. At around 5:30 I hadn't gotten my delivery so I called them. (FYI I had to leave the house around 6:15 that night). When I called they said they never put the order down and it would be about 40 minutes till it would arrive. I couldn't do that. I was pissed off because I wanted a damn salad, and I had been waiting for 2 hours. They never apologized either. That's my terrible Pagliacci experience. read more

Everyone in the area seems to rave about Pagliacci, so we decided to try it. Eating the pizza was a little reminiscent of watching Natural Born Killers; everyone raved about how great it was, but after experiencing it for myself I was only left disappointed. Don't get me wrong, the pizza is decent, maybe even good, but it doesn't deserve the hype. They have a good crust, but the toppings are pretty standard fare. To me great pizza has super fresh, quality toppings, homemade sausage & the like. And for the $30 price tag, I'd rather go with an equally good, cheaper pizza. read more

I think I've only done one yelp review before. But tonight needs commenting upon. We called in an order at 6:39 tonight and were told it would be 40 minutes. We arrived at the store at 7:05, too early for the order to be done. We checked in, paid for the pizza, and were told it would be ready in 15 minutes. That would have made it right on time. At 7:55 still no pizza. It was by then 35 minutes late and the new estimate was 10 more minutes. We did get the pizza at 8:05. This was 45 minutes late or more than double the original 40 minute estimate. We appreciate them giving us a $10 gift certificate for the inconvenience. And I've worked in food industry and know you sometimes get slammed. But when that happens, honesty should be part of the solution. Either the phone-in line didn't properly estimate the time (meaning the company has a logistics problem) or the store at 7:05 couldn't project it's own timeline (meaning the store has a logistics problem). I'm going to choose to assume people were not "shining us on" with the time estimates. It would have been easier for all to just be given a closer to realistic estimate. The store staff likely would have felt less stressed from all the frustrated customers. The company would have saved money by not having to give out apology gift certificates. And we would have saved time by running other errands if we knew the realistic estimate. We won't be using the $10 gift certificate, however, because I doubt we'll go back for a long, long while. read more

Pagliacci's makes a great pizza. It is a little pricey compared to the national chains, but the taste is better. At some point in the last several months this Pagliacci location started offering pizza by the slice. This is awesome. It let's me enjoy a Pagliacci's pizza without committing to an entire pie, something that my wife and I can't finish alone. read more

Decent pizza place. I dined in and ordered the spicy pepperoni pizza. They use Salumi pepperoni--pretty good. The salad and breadsticks were nondescript. For over $40, I have had much better. read more

Love this deliver pizza! Always quick and yummy. I recommend the Pagliacci salad too. Consistant, great delivery pizza~ thank you!

They're always friendly on the phone. Good customer service skills. I haven't had any bad experiences here with the service or the food.

Pizza is generally good, but the one in Kenmore tends to undercook it so I end up having to send it back for more cooking time.

Sorry I strayed today and ordered a dominos pizza and I will never do that again!!! The pepperoni pizza I ordered from this location was 100 times better!!! read more

Honestly... I was very disappointed with my delivery last time I ordered. I remembered loving the breadsticks in store, so I ordered those along with baked pasta. The pasta was burnt, but still somewhat okay. Breadsticks were dry and not good. :( Maybe I will try a pizza delivery next time... I hate to only give two stars.. but when I tip well only to get shitty food, I'm not too happy. read more

Good pizza but overpriced. Worth maybe 2/3 of what you pay and they just raised their prices, again. There is excellent pizza elsewhere for half the cost. Do yourself a favor and go somewhere else. Their customer service wasn't good either. Won't bother complaining again in the future I just won't be back. read more

The name sounds Italian but the pizza doesn't live up to the expectations. No tasty 00 flour dough, more like a thin American version of a deep dish. Expensive and the experience wasn't worth it. read more

I order slices here at the Kenmore location when I'm too lazy to cook at home for the family. They usually have 4 choices. I like their crust and the cheese and pepperoni pizzas seem pretty good to me. I have occasionally ordered a whole large pizza and thought it was expensive. Their beer selection is pretty weak. They have a few bottles, but it's usually the macro-micros, nothing very interesting. I go here twice a month, so obviously, I like it and so does my 5 year old. read more

For the past few months, it's been my family's go-to food when we want something quick, somewhat impressive and somewhat cheap. Well, it's not cheap but a little goes a long way for pizza party weekdays. For a chain, they have some really unique flavor combos and higher quality ingredients. Being able to drive this pizza home ourselves within minutes is an added bonus. Deliveries tend to result in a soggier crust and their crust is amazing. It makes for great leftovers too and wins my award for best cold pizza. read more

Pizza is tasty! You can walk in and order from pizza selection made & enjoy it right then or order off menu and wait. If they have what you like out, I would do that. a small pizza is more than one person can eat in one sitting. Very good, kinda pricey though read more

Good dine-in experience! Order at the counter, and they bring it to you. The servers are always really pleasant, and there are always fresh flowers on the table. The Caesar salad was a hit, and the pepperoni pizza was a seasoned classic, if a bit on the spicy side. The verde primo is also a must-try for goat cheese lovers, and my guy swears their Hawaiian is unsurpassed... even rivaling our "regular" in Italy. I'm not impressed with their Pagliacci's dipping sauce, though, but if we're just talking pizza they get an A+. read more

My order arrived on time and looked and tasted great. The driver had to run back to her car to grab a pen, but it was fine because she was cute! I have never had a bad experience with this location. Hope this helps someone. read more

I must admit it took me awhile to like this place but i do crave it now. Love the chop salad & the people couldn't be nicer. :-)

I was not at all impressed with the food. I went in very excited because I am from Idaho and we have a place back there who does pizza by the slice that they warm up too. But the pizza here was nothing special at all, was kinda greasy, and the crust (which is arguably my favorite part of pizza) was hard, tasteless, and very much reminded me of cardboard. I will not go back. For what they charge you for their pizza I can think of a million other places I would rather go with MUCH better food. read more

Mmmmmm, I love this place! My favorite pizza :) lots of options, the staff is friendly, and they deliver! Only down side is its a little on the spendy side, but so worth it! read more

Great experience today! My families first time coming in and everyone was super nice and welcoming. The pizza was delicious! The chicken primo pizza was amazing! We will definitely be back again. read more

Awesome calzones and marinara sauce. I got spinach and mushrooms. Great pizza too. Had the Italian salad with a hint of tarragon in the dressing - fresh, healthy and good sized. Food is medium priced and a good value. I prefer eating there and getting the food right out of the oven. The restaurant has nice decor and the service was friendly and fast. They have a nice selection of bottled beer and wine. read more

I go here for slices, $15.99 plus tax and sometimes tip is way too much to pay for pizza. The only problem is 9 times out of 10, the slices are hella old because they sit out on the cold slice bar. They heat it up in a small oven on the counter, but still, old pizza is old pizza. Yesterday, on Saturday, the slice bar was EMPTY at dinner time, 5:40 pm. I couldn't wait 10 minutes so I went to another location for a slice. Today, Sunday, I was able to get a slice and guess what? Yep, it's old. (laughs) read more

Overcharged my debit card! Pizza was priced at $17 but was charged $34! That's 2 Times The Price Don't trust with them with your card. Bad Experience. Good pizza but not for double the price. :( read more

I just love pagliacci pizza! I usually don't eat pizza crust, but I have no problem finishing their crust, maybe because it's hand tossed. Absolutly love their pizza. Thanks Pagliacci!!! read more

So nice to have Pagliacci in our neighborhood. Consistently good and the staff are always friendly. It's always clean and fairly quick service. Delivery is also quite quick, though I do live close by. At Christmastime they were very accommodating and worked with me to deliver for a fairly large party on a Sunday. read more