I grew up within 10 minutes of Palermo's but, as far as I can recall, never knew it existed before recently. I'm visiting family in New Jersey for Christmas, so it seemed like a good time to place an order with them. We opted for delivery, as my mom is sick and I'm a terrible night driver, but I would not do that again. Their online ordering system was pretty confusing. At first I landed on an online ordering menu that I don't think was the correct one as it gave zero descriptions on anything. I backed out and then clicked into the correct one. Based on the layout, I assumed I was ordering delivery direct through the restaurant rather than an outside partner, which I prefer to do. Nope. It was DoorDash. Had I realized that, I could've used a DoorDash coupon or ordered elsewhere. Instead, I spent $9.99 for a delivery fee, plus $2.99 service charge, tax, plus tip, and the order was essentially double the cost of takeout. It wasn't obvious that it was an outside partner until the tracking link was emailed. Plus the delivery driver made a stop along the way, so my food was lukewarm on arrival. Ugh. It also took an hour to be delivered compared to their website estimate of 25 minutes. Delivery aside, the food was pretty good. I really enjoyed my slice of cheese pizza - the sauce was perfect! The cheesesteak was also delightfully cheesy and cooked perfectly. I probably wouldn't order the tuna club again. I think I overcharged myself, as it didn't have a description so I couldn't figure out what came on it. As such, I added bacon and assumed it'd have cheese as the site referenced "substituting" cheese, so I didn't add that. Turns out - no cheese (so sad) and now bacon on two layers, so I assume they added extra. My mom had a cup of their chicken noodle soup, which she deemed "tasty." High praise from her. Since I overall enjoyed what I ordered, I'd likely go back sometime on a future visit. Though I do feel minorly ripped off by the online ordering experience so I'm more likely to try other local spots first. read more

The food is good, but expensive. Their steak sandwiches and pizza are excellent. We've been eating here our whole lives. It is close which is the main reason we eat here a few times a month. read more

Completely EXCEEDS "New York standards". My boyfriend and I loved this place! From the large yet tasty food portions, to the Valentines Drink menu, to the live music; it was such a great experience for our first night in PA. read more

Palermo's Pizzeria & Restaurant - Rose given on Valentine's Day & my salted caramel martini. - Pizza Near Me - Williamstown, New Jersey

Second 1 star review. Should have learned my lesson. Unless you want Raw Pizza dough, I suggest you go somewhere else for your game day Pizza. Not the first time this place let me down. Overpriced for what you get. read more

Palermo's Pizzeria & Restaurant - Raw pizza dough. - Pizza Near Me - Williamstown, New Jersey

My family loves Palermo's! Their pizza has been our Friday night meal for years! We also love their cheesesteaks too! read more

The service was very kind and the restaurant is very nice and clean inside. The pizza has a delicious sauce and the crust is fairly good, - but a bit doughy for my taste. But it certainly hit the spot... I asked for it extra baked. It was a perfect quick bite before hitting the outlet shopping with family and kids! Thank you! read more

first time trying them today, DELCIOUS! Great crust and it even sat for about 20 minutes in my ride home but was STILL DELICIOUS! the guys in there are chill and the atmosphere is nice and spread out for dining in. they were very fast too. the pizza was very filling. a large pizza fed two adults and a child and still had two slices left read more

Palermo'S is decent. The sauce is tasty. The pizza is good The people are friendly. The atmosphere is nice! It's a place I can run into and get a really good slice. so I would recommend this place.! read more

One of my favorite pizzas in the area. Steaks , eggplant parm- all good. Can eat in or take out. read more

the pizza crust tasted like cardboard..just awful.the pizza turnover greasy and wayyy too much cheese. just ashame that the pizza dough was not as good as elios out of a frozen box! read more

Palermo's is a great Williamstown establishment. Great food and very consistent. Their service is always top notch.

My normal go to for pizza, it has changed over the past few years where I'm willing to try a few different places that have opened. But for a close to home pizza spot I would most likely call Palermo's. read more

15-20 minutes means 45 delivery service cost is outrageous so don't even think about it. The pizza is mid for the area, much better shops around with better quality and quicker service read more

My family loves the pizza. Weekend goto service, ambiance and food always great and easy pick up location.

Sorry, I haven't discovered this hidden gem before. My picky sister travels to my house and past a few diff family favs to grab their Round pie which is cooked perfect. The cheesesteaks and their customer service steal the 5 stars. Always fresh and cooked to just the right temperature & still a crunch in their crust. Happy Holidays! read more

Someone has to be handling your food improperly or they might be sick, my boyfriend and I both ate your pizza, we are now both sick. This is the only common denominator. Your onion rings, loaded fries and pizza are tasteless. Is all pizza in jersey this tasteless and hazardous? read more

Unless you live in or close to town, you've probably never heard of Palermo's and that is perfectly fine. I was introduced by my girlfriend who grew up in Williamstown. From what I know, Palermo's has been around for a bit now. They certainly pre-date Pat's and may just be one of the town's best kept secrets sitting quietly in a plaza along the Black Horse Pike (Rt 322) whose main business from the street appears to be a CVS. Now, I've had a lot of South Jersey pizza and most of it, albeit good, tastes the same to me, but something about Palermo's pizza is different. It's better and still maintain's the old school neighborhood pizza vibe that so many other's of it's kind have lost. It doesn't try to be anything it's not (in fact, its Internet presence is practically limited to Yelp) but it will continue to serve hungry people from the neighborhood when they are craving that perfect slice. The crust is thin but not paper or cracker thin, yet has the right amount of depth to support the sweet tomato sauce and gooey cheese. Pizza is something that should absolutely be cherished here but there is another hidden star that, although on the menu, must be ordered a specific way. This item - is the fried pizza turnover. Some of you may be shaking your head thinking, but isn't that just a panzerotti and you know what, you would be correct. But because Palermo's does their own version, they cannot call it that. What makes a Palermo's panzerotti so special? Well for one thing, you better be hungry when you order. This turnover is the size of a baby, and I'm not joking. I've never seen a panzerotti this big. Size does matter here. It's large and in charge and will keep you coming back for bite after bite. Yes, it needs to be cut up and eaten, preferably with at least one partner, as this behemoth is not for the faint of heart. By now, you should get the point. Neighborhood pizza joint with a small sign, tucked deep back into a small unassuming plaza churning out delicious pies and fantastic 'fried pizza turnovers.' Come hungry. Leave Happy. read more

Just moved to the area and wanted to try the Pizza. This place did not disappoint! My whole family enjoyed the pies! Will come back for more :) read more

Don't know what Panzarotti is but Caca. I think I order pizza or pizza turn over but no. Very wet and greasy.

I been buying from Palermo's my whole life. Food is now over priced and not family affordable. The food is never consistent. Fries are either soggy or greasy, sometimes they are made right. Just very upsetting this use to be my favorite pizza spot in town and now I question myself on if they are a place I want to even go back to anymore. Everything is expensive and over priced very sad to see what they've come to. read more

43 minutes ago Long strand of black hair in food and would not refund my full meal! Yuck! Will never ever be back read more

Oh I picked up a cheesesteak and a slice of pizza and a soda at first I thought it was a little bit pricey but he after consuming the cheese steak not so much it is in the top five cheesesteaks that I've ever had and I used to own my own deli excellent job highly recommend read more

Best pizza I've had in the area so far. Sicilian pie was delicious. We got half margarita, half bbq chicken and both sides were tasty. The sweet chili wings were also very good. Last, the cannoli's were authentic and perfect! Also, very friendly service! read more

Palermo's Pizzeria & Restaurant - Cannoli, very good! - Pizza Near Me - Williamstown, New Jersey

Definitely a 5 star experience. As per another reviewer, ask for extra sauce on your pizza. The boneless wings, pepperoni pizza, and huge chicken wrap were excellent. But the fries were out of this world (included with wrap). And there were enough fries in one order for 3 people. Palermo's often has specials so just ask. read more

Amazing Service, Great Food, Loved the Environment and Ambiance of the Restaurant. Definitely Recommend to Anyone that wants an amazing experience eating out ! read more

This is the 4th time they messed up my order. I ordered the chicken texas and requested the BBQ sauce on the side. They completely omitted the cheese. It happens every time. We frequent this place because it's super close but, will not be ordering from here anymore because every single time, they mess something up. I'm over it! read more

You can't fo wrong with Palermo's! Ask for extra sauce on your pizza... thank me later! Best pizza in this area!

Great stuff!! Love their Sicilian Pie, cheese steaks and their chicken parmigiana is awesome!

So i ordered from this place for the 1st time last night and it was HORRIBLE !!! We go a large pie the dough was like it wasnt cooked all the way it was discusting! I also got pizza fries cheese wasnt melted on top or the fries werent done completely underneath them ! Definitely wasnt worth 40$ worth of food the boneless wings are ok . Will never order from them again !!!! read more

Amazing pizza and the sandwich a great too!!! my brother and I found this place when we first moved to Williamstown 23 years ago and we wouldn't dream of going anywhere else!! Life's to short for shit pizza!!! Plus going here supports a small business and puts money back into the community! read more

Another great stop for pizza in williamstown nj!!! I had a good stop there last night 2 good pizzas Guys keep up the good work williamstown loves having you !!! read more

We love this place. I grew up in the NYC pizza zone, so my tastes in pizza are particular and well honed. Although the pizza is not exactly what I grew up with, it is the only Williamstown pizzeria I will patronize. The traditional round pies are great, as are the Sicilian pies. My husband loves the turnovers, too! read more

Best pizzeria in Williamstown by far! Food is always made to perfection. The pizza tastes excellent, way better than Bella. Sauce melts in your mouth. Never fails with the topping choices especially extra cheese. You can see it! Their buffalo chicken cheesesteak wrap is amazing. Melts in your mouth buffalo taste filled with flavor. Their grilled chicken Ceasar salad is huge with homemade dressing. Always our go to spot on Sundays. Tnx Palermos! read more

Palermo's Pizzeria & Restaurant - White broccoli & pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Williamstown, New Jersey

I love this place! Their pies are huge and such good quality. I've had two of the pizzas and both times the ingredients were super fresh. The service Is great too, if you want something to eat fast, this is your spot! Definitely recommended read more

Palermo's Pizzeria & Restaurant - Pizza cheese fries and wings so good!! - Pizza Near Me - Williamstown, New Jersey

I no longer live in Williamstown, but I still come here for Palermo pizza and their tasty French fries! Everything about their pizza is great - cheesy, not salty sauce, and perfect crust. Service is good, only ate in once or twice, mostly just take out. I just wished they delivered! read more

I was very pleased with my Meatball Parm I ordered from this restaurant. I ordered takeout and was told it would be a 30 minute wait for a family of 4's orders. The food was ready in 25, hot and ready to eat. I assume the other members of my family enjoyed their meal, as it was all eaten that night. I also ordered a side of french fries, which are the generic fries, nothing too special. My Meatball Parm was hot, the bread wasn't soggy, there wasn't too much sauce or too many meatballs to blow out the bread. There weren't any odd spices or sauces that came with it either. It was a regular meatball parm, but it was quite tasty. Since the food was the usual (as expected), I rate 4 stars. Had the food blown me away, I would give 5, but unfortunately I was not blown away. I would recommend eating here though, and I will be eating here again in the future im sure. read more

All around quality. I have never gone wrong here. Quality service. Pizza, cheesesteaks, wraps, burgers, chicken tenders, garlic knots, and everything else I've ever ordered....all delicious. Always worth while. read more

Palermo's Pizzeria & Restaurant - the menu - Pizza Near Me - Williamstown, New Jersey

We love Palermos! Great hometown establishment. Delicious sauce and amazing pizza. This place is our go to for Friday night pizza night!

Everything I have ordered is delicious. Haven't had a bad meal! Can't wait to try something new! The buffalo chicken pizza was to die for!

This Italian Restaurant and Pizzeria is a hidden gem in Williamstown NJ. It's in a large shopping center tucked away from all the other stores. This is quite honestly the best pizza in town. Super thin slices with great flavor and taste. They are always consistent with the quality of food. The shrimp parm and chicken parm will literally melt in your mouth. Coming from NY I was quite skeptical to find such good food. Whatever they are doing they are doing right. Thanks to all the cooks and chefs. Don't take my word for it, stop in and try it for yourself. read more