As a former New Yorker, I consider myself an aficionado of great pizza. Anytime I'm near Haddon Heights, this is my go to place. The pizza is the best I've ever had! Their Sicilian slice is airy and crispy with an amazing sauce. Their plain slices are just as good. A very impressive selection of pies and an excellent staff make this a must try. I love this place. read more

Hands down, absolutely, the best pizza and Southern Italian food in South Jersey, maybe all of Jersey. The owner-chef has an inspired take on everything from pizza to steak sandwiches to his amazing wings, as well as a Caesar salad with some of the best homemade dressing I've ever had. His menu even includes an elegant assortment of full traditional Italian dinners. As an Italian American myself, who misses his Nonna's nearly lost own homemade "gravy" every Sunday, I can honestly say we are very lucky to have such an extraordinary, nationally recognized culinary experience in our little but grateful town! read more

Finally stopped by to try the "Upside Down". Use to actually eating it in Brooklyn. This one was just about as good as it can get. Comparing it to what we know I would say that " When not traveling to Brooklyn, there would be no problem to be closer to home. The staff were really very nice and even gave us a few samples. Not many places would do that. Very personable So. We will be back. Try it out !! read more

Finally stopped in to check out the pizza! Good selection of slices and pizzas. Dinners, sandwiches, appetizers as well. We ordered and sat in the dinning room. Room could use a little love, but nothing bad. Service was super friendly and brought us some garlic knots while we waited. They were tasty. We got a slice of the Sicilian with the hot marinara, pepperoni, ricotta and hot honey...very tasty. Our pie was brought out and had a super thin crust. (Extra cheese, half pepperoni and onion) The pizza itself was delicious, ooey gooey, cheesey, greasy (in a good way) floppy slice. Definitely a place to try. Only caution, is they put Italian seasoning or oregano on pie, so if you don't like that let them know. read more

See all

These cheesesteaks are AMAZING! They are Stuffed With enough meat and cheese to fill the hangriest person in the room. The seeded rolls were perfect! The garlic knots were fluffy in the middle and crunchy on the outside smothered in garlic deliciousness. We will definitely be back, and we will be bringing more people. The bonus was how nice and accommodating the staff is. What a nice surprise!! read more

See all

Don't sleep on Brooklyn Original in Haddon Heights! Fed the office their delicious pizzas. Everyone was happy! The pizza with garlic and onions is delicious. The tomato pie is scrumptious. The (customized) honeymoon pie was soooo flavorful. I'm still full! Friendly staff. Fun, upbeat dance music playing in the clean eat-in dining room. Owner Felipe is your host with the most. I'll definitely be back! read more

See all

I visited Brooklyn Original pizzeria this past Sunday after moving to the area last year and seeing it featured on Instagram and hearing so many great things. From the moment I walked in, I was impressed by how beautiful and clean the space was. I was greeted immediately by friendly staff who were eager to help and offer recommendations on their most popular slices. I chose a slice from their freshly made morning selection and mentioned in passing that it was my first time visiting. A few moments later, one of the young team members kindly offered me a complimentary slice to welcome me--such a thoughtful gesture and a great first impression. I ended up bringing home a ribeye pinwheel, (also highly recommended by a staff member) and what I believe was a square Grandma slice topped with pepperoni, sausage, and fresh basil. For my complimentary slice, I selected one with assorted Italian meats and fresh burrata on a fluffy focaccia-style crust. Everything was absolutely delicious and bursting with flavor. Overall, the service, atmosphere, and quality of the food exceeded my expectations. I'm already looking forward to my next visit. I have no doubt every encounter I have with this place is going to be top-tier, gracious, and worth every penny! read more

Brooklyn Original Pizzeria - My 3 goodies that went home with me! - Pizza Near Me - Haddon Heights, New Jersey

See all

Stopped here after following on Instagram for a while. This is a hard review to write. We were given a complimentary plate of garlic rolls and tomato pie slices before our Brooklyn pizza and white with mushrooms arrived. The good: the marinara served with the garlic rolls, the garlic rolls, the pizza crust, the sauce, the cheese. The service was super friendly. The bad: just too greasy, especially the white pizza. The oil was swimming on the pizza. The crust was great but also too greasy. I would not order pizza again unless it was with very little cheese but would try the cheesesteak which looks incredible. I also found the crust a little too salty. We were offered an espresso on our way out which was nice. We don't drink it so we declined. Expensive pizza not to be perfect. 3.5. read more

Brooklyn Original Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Haddon Heights, New Jersey

See all

They won't disappoint. The crust is so good. The staff is friendly and keep things moving. Orders are easily placed on line and you will also get a pick up time as well. They have the best pizza in the area. read more

Brooklyn Original Pizzeria - Large pizza with mushrooms, peppers, and onions. - Pizza Near Me - Haddon Heights, New Jersey

I've heard nothing but rave reviews for this place. I walked in and the owner was so friendly and nice, chatting with everyone. Everything looked good, but decided I'd grab a fresh hot cheesesteak. The first thing I noticed was how nice the bread was - a nice crusty and seeded roll, soft and pillowy inside. Very meaty and well seasoned and of course, my favorite, Cooper Sharp cheese. They did not skimp out on either the meat and cheese. These suckers are huge, so I finished half and brought the other half home for later. (PRO TIP: Microwave for one minute, then throw in the air fryer at 350 for 5 to 6 minutes until the bread is back to crispy and the cheese is nice and melty again.) read more

Brooklyn Original Pizzeria - Excellent cheesesteak - Pizza Near Me - Haddon Heights, New Jersey

The complimentary bread is enough to make the trip, but the food is top tier. They take the time to make excellent food, they are pleasant and warming. The establishment was well kept, it is a wonderful family friendly restaurant. read more

Brooklyn Original Pizzeria - Half broccoli and half pepperoni pizza (the good cup pepperoni) - Pizza Near Me - Haddon Heights, New Jersey

See all

Easily my new favorite spot for pizza and cheese steaks in SJ. Service is always great and fast. read more

See all

Lot of options, but we thought the pizza was just OK, our parents liked it more. A little pricey compared to others in the area, and a little greasy even for deep dish. A lot of people seem to like it though, so maybe it just isn't our style or something. Service was fine ordering/picking up. read more

The owner, the food, and customer service are amazing! I only came in for a cheesesteak, but when the owner saw how I was excited for the pizza, he gave me a slice. The pizza and the cheesesteak were amazing. This is exactly the place you actually want to support. All the staff appeared happy. The ambience is cute as well. I like how they display their pizza. They bought the property next door to provide seating. I sat and ate there. It was nice and quiet. I will definitely be returning! read more

See all

I was looking for something good yesterday after leaving an appointment in Moorestown, NJ. Pizza was on my mind and I had tried Brooklyn Original a few years ago, so I decided to head there again. I ordered "The Works" and made it a large + square pizza. I'm so glad I did. I arrived, waited for a 5-10 mins and grabbed my pizza to go. Of course, I opened the box in the car and tried a slice on the way home. I couldn't let the smell of the pizza and temptation of a fresh Sicilian slice pass me by. I absolutely loved the buttery taste of the crust and the perfect combination of the cheese, pepperoni and sausage. None of the ingredients overpowered the other. The second slice was even better. The sauce to cheese ratio was perfect. I could taste all of the ingredients in every bite. I was also impressed that the pizza was cooked all the way through. That's something that I have seen some pizzerias fail at. So, thank you Brooklyn for a fantastic pizza experience. I'll be back AGAIN! read more

Brooklyn Original Pizzeria - The Brooklyn Works Pizza ( Square 18 x 18) - Pizza Near Me - Haddon Heights, New Jersey

Dude, it's Pizza! You guys aren't constructing a gourmet masterpiece, it's just pizza!!! There is absolutely no reason to have customers wait over an hour on top of the 90 minute wait time from ordering! Get your shit together and if it's going to take 2 and a half hours for a pizza order then tell the customer...or maybe limit the amount of orders you take so you can have the food ready in a responsible time. The pizza is good but again, it's just pizza. You just lost another customer, I won't be ordering from Brooklyn again. read more

Hands down some of the best pie I've ever had. Grandma pie and original pepperoni on point. Very friendly staff and great service read more

Brooklyn Original Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Haddon Heights, New Jersey

See all

First timers from Pittsburgh who are out here visiting my mom. Saw a video of this place on IG and had to try. Delicious! The menu had so many tasty options so it took us a long time to decide. We ordered buffalo chicken pinwheel, The OMG pizza, and Chicken Parm pizza. Prices are a little high but once you see the size of the items and the taste it makes sense and is worth it. Staff and owner were so pleasant and welcoming. Owner let us sample their espresso and my husband loved it. We will definitely be back. Small parking lot in back and street parking. A few tables and hightop inside for sitting. read more

Brooklyn Original Pizzeria - The OMG Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Haddon Heights, New Jersey

There are few pleasures in life as universally loved as a good slice of pizza, but the pizza place I recently discovered has completely redefined my idea of what great pizza truly is. From the moment you step through the doors, you can tell that this is not just another restaurant--it's an experience, a weekly tradition in the making. The combination of incredible food, warm atmosphere, and top-notch service makes this pizza place easily one of the best dining spots I have ever been to. In fact, it's so good that I've already decided I will be attending once every single week. The first thing that stands out is the irresistible aroma that greets you the second you walk in. The scent of freshly baked dough, melted cheese, and perfectly seasoned tomato sauce fills the air, wrapping you in comfort and anticipation. It's almost impossible not to smile when you smell that combination--it immediately makes you hungry. The decor adds to the charm, with cozy lighting, rustic brick walls, and friendly chatter that makes you feel right at home. It's the kind of place where families laugh together, friends gather to catch up, and everyone feels welcome. Of course, the real star of the show is the pizza itself. Every single bite tastes like perfection. The crust strikes the ideal balance between crispy and chewy, with just the right amount of golden-brown char from the oven. The sauce is rich and flavorful, not too sweet or too tangy, clearly made from fresh tomatoes rather than anything processed. And the cheese--oh, the cheese--is melted to gooey perfection, stretching with every bite like something straight out of a commercial. You can tell the ingredients are high quality because the flavors blend together beautifully, creating a pizza that is not just food, but art. Their menu offers something for everyone, from the classic pepperoni lovers to fans of creative gourmet combinations. The Margherita pizza, with its fresh basil and mozzarella, tastes simple yet elegant. The barbecue chicken pizza bursts with smoky flavor, and their veggie pizza is loaded with colorful toppings that make it as beautiful as it is delicious. Even the specialty crust options--stuffed, thin, or gluten-free--are made with the same care and attention to detail. You can really tell that the chefs here love what they do, and that passion translates directly into every dish they make. But what truly sets this pizza place apart is the service. The staff are genuinely kind, attentive, and always eager to make sure you have the best experience possible. They greet you with a smile, remember your favorite order, and check in just the right amount--never intrusive, but always there when you need them. Whether you're dining in or grabbing takeout, they make the whole experience smooth and enjoyable. You can feel the pride they take in their work, and that positive energy makes the food taste even better. Another highlight is how this pizza place brings people together. Every time I've gone, I've noticed groups of friends laughing, couples sharing a meal, and families enjoying quality time. It's the kind of place that makes you want to stay longer than planned, talking and laughing over another slice. It doesn't just serve food--it builds community. That's one of the reasons I decided that I'll be attending once every week. It's not just about eating pizza; it's about taking time to enjoy life, relax, and be around good people in a great atmosphere. Even beyond the pizza, the restaurant offers fantastic sides and desserts. Their garlic knots are warm, buttery, and seasoned to perfection, while the salads are fresh and crisp. And if you have room for dessert, their chocolate lava cake or cannolis are absolute must-tries. Every part of the meal feels thoughtfully crafted, making it impossible to leave disappointed. To sum it up, this pizza place isn't just good--it's exceptional. It combines quality food, amazing service, and a welcoming environment into something truly special. It's rare to find a restaurant that consistently delivers excellence in every category, but this one does it effortlessly. That's why I've made the decision to come back every week. It's not just a restaurant I enjoy; it's one I look forward to. Every visit feels like a reward, and every slice reminds me why it's worth returning to again and again. In a world full of fast food chains and forgettable dining experiences, this pizza place stands out as a shining example of what happens when passion meets perfection. Whether it's the incredible flavors, the friendly staff, or the inviting atmosphere, everything about it is simply outstanding. I can confidently say that it has earned a permanent place in my weekly routine--and honestly, I couldn't be happier about it. read more

Went to Brooklyn Original Pizza for lunch with my daughter. We are pizza connoisseurs. We ordered a spicy Wise Guy square pizza and a thin and crispy pepperoni pizza. The owners gave us complimentary garlic knots to try, they were the best that I had. The dough was not heavy but light and fluffy and delicious. The wise guys square was next. One of the best square pizza crust I have eaten, many of these type of pizzas have very heavy dough and thick, this pizza was light and airily and very tasty. Love the heat in the sauce. Next was the thin and crispy, my favorite! It was nicely done with a great crust that crunches. The pizza was tasty. You can tell quality went behind every pizza. The finest ingredients and taste. Love and care in every bite. I will definitely go back and encourage everyone else to give this place a try, you will thank me. Enjoy read more

See all

Best pizza in the area. People that care about their product and customer service. Also they're open later than the other pizza places in the area that are too lazy to work past 8pm. Thanks guys I'll spread the word! read more

Came in on a Saturday night, Frances took great care of us, and the pizza was great. Classic spot, can never go wrong.

The best pizza in all of south Jersey hands down . It's a must try they won't disappoint trust me

Best Pizza in South Jersey! Whenever I'm having a party or people coming in from out of town, we order Brooklyn Pizza! Besides the fact the place is always busy with a line of people waiting for their pickup (which you know is a great sign) you can tell that every pizza is thoughtfully crafted and prepared by this family owned and operated joint. Our go-to pizza is the Honeymoon Pie and the Drunken Grandma, but amazing in their own way. The honeymoon pie is a fresh, NY take on a square pepperoni pizza. The crust is slightly thick (but not too thick) and placed in a large square pan for those extra tasty corner pieces which are my favorite. It's got the perfect balance of sauce and cheese to go with a smothering of those tasty cupped pepperoni slices. Then they go over the top by adding a drizzle of spicy honey which ties all of the saucy, cheesy and meaty elements together so perfectly. The drunken grandma is the perfect pie for the cheese pizza lover or those that can't eat meat. Again, made in that square pan, this pizza is made with a vodka style sauce and a healthy amount of mozzarella cheese. It's rich, it's delicious, it's royalty in every bite! Damn, just writing this up is making me want to go place an order! Check them out, you won't be disappointed! read more

I am from Northern CA & we don't have a lot of authentic jersey pizza Italian restaurants out there, especially without paying a pretty penny. We had the Brooklyn Pizza, pepperoni pizza, cheesesteak, garlic knots, Caesar salad, & vodka sauce rigatoni pasta. Every bite we had was exceptional! I absolutely loved every bite of every piece of food I devoured. I usually have ranch with my pizza but there was zero reason I needed it. The pizza by itself was phenomenal. The service by Sophia & Filipinowas fantastic & each person we spoke to was fabulous. I would recommend anyone who lives in the area or if your a tourist to come to this place & experience this food. Thank you for such an amazing experience here. We appreciate you & wish you could come to Northern California. read more

Brooklyn Original Pizzeria - Front & inside building! - Pizza Near Me - Haddon Heights, New Jersey

Had the taste for real pizza as we were traveling from MD to NJ. After doing a little bit of research we came across this gem. We arrived and the young lady behind the counter helped us make a decision because we were definitely unsure of where to start because everything looked so good. So she gave us two of their top pizzas and told us we could do half and half. That's all we needed to hear. We also said we wanted a order of garlic knots and she said that comes with the table since we were dining in. First off the garlic knots were cooked perfectly with a garlicly marinara sauce. Then the pizza had the perfect buttery crunchy crust. Which to me makes the pizza. All ingredients were fresh. I don't remember her name (she had two braids) but the service was 10 out of 10! We will definitely be back! read more

See all

The pizza is always delicious, and the staff is always so kind. Thank you for being our new favorite pizza place!

We really enjoyed! Some top class pizza in the area and the meatballs were excellent. Feels like an old school pizza parlor. Happy to see how heavily staffed they were, no one ever had to wait. read more

Always looking for a take out pizza shop between the Jersey shore and home for Sunday dinner. Saw this place mentioned on FB and made a mental note. Finally stopped for take out yesterday, 18 inch traditional pizza. It's a bit pricy but what isn't? God pizza, good flavor, place is clean, ample cheese and sauce and the dough was very good. Phone and counter workers were very accommodating. I'd order again. read more

Delicious pizza! Our food is always hot, the owners are very kind, and our family has many happy memories from dining in here. We always love all the new pizza creations too! read more

The garlic knots are phenomenal. I do not recommend the Roman Style Suppli Arancini. I love that the small pizza is equivalent to a large one at other chains. read more

Brooklyn Original Pizzeria - Bella Sophia Pizza (small), Garlic Knots (6), Roman Style Suppli Arancini, and San Giuseppe Zeppoli for $53! - Pizza Near Me - Haddon Heights, New Jersey

There are times that I will mention restaurants that are flat out stealing money.... Brooklyn Original Pizza is one of the last pizza businesses that would be described that way. First observation walking in is just how welcoming, friendly, organized, and professional the staff is. Then after a few more steps in, looking at all of the amazing pizzas slices behind the glass, the decision of what to buy gets somewhat hard to make. All good choices, but you can't possibly buy everything. While the square grandma pizzas there is the bait that reel everyone in, there's plenty more on the menu to enjoy. The Stromboli's are one of the items that I enjoy, and come in several varieties. Their unique well seasoned oven baked wings are a must try. Place two orders. Besides a seriously endless list of pizza to order, pasta dinners, salads, paninis, and desserts round out their menu. Go often. It's gonna take awhile to try it all... read more

Hmmm, I'm not sure if I can justify my $40 large pizza of 1/2 Boardwalk & 1/2 Bella Sophia's price. The crust was slightly burnt and luke warm when it was delivered. Side note: weekends is an 1 hour + wait. Im not kidding. Locals pretty much are willing to wait it out, even if its carry out. With all that said, 4 star is generous BUT the pizza is really pretty good. The owners are also really nice folks too. Ive had better slices pre-2020 when you can go in, sit and eat. For me, if I order again I think Ive decided on just plain pizza. read more

Brooklyn Original Pizzeria - 1/2 boardwalk & 1/2 Bella Sophia - Pizza Near Me - Haddon Heights, New Jersey

This was a lousy cheesesteak, greasy roll steak was burnt and old tasting so disappointed and for $17.00 you guys best stick to pizza .....

We loved it here! Super friendly and welcoming staff. The pizzas were delicious, and the tomato sauce was to die for!

Stopped in as I had been wanting to try this place. Ordered a whole OMG round pizza and the blend of red, vodka and pesto sauces seemed like a nice blend. As I was looking at some of the Sicilian slices, I was offered one to try while I waited. Wow. Tremendous. The dough looks like it could take you down with one piece, yet this was the most light and airy (in a great way) slice I have ever had, and the red sauce and cheese/basil leaf on top were just the perfect toppings. Simple, yet lights out good. I ended up also buying a couple more Sicilian slices to take home with my OMG pizza. The OMG pizza itself was very flavorful and had a light and crispy crust too. Wife said maybe a bit too much sauce but I think it was just right. I will definitely come back for some of the other pizzas/pastas/sandwiches. Kudos to the team there - very welcoming and friendly and they understand good customer service. In a 5-mile radius of the area I would say conservatively there are 100 pizza places - put this one on your list! read more

Nearly 40 BUCKS for a pizza is sickening enough, but both me and my boyfriend got sick after eating it. My boyfriend got it worse than I did. He spent the whole night running to the bathroom with diarrhea, then when he had it for breakfast again this morning he spent the rest of the day with his head in a vomit bag, with hot flashes and chills. We will NEVER eat here again, and I highly recommend no one else eat there either. They should give him a refund! read more

Delicious fresh baked bread for sandwiches. Need I say more? Ok, I will.....we had the caprese panini & cheesesteak on seeded roll and wow it was tasty. Portion size n price didn't disappoint either. read more

The pizza was fresh and a good size for it to be small. I loved the white pizza size with broccoli. read more

Brooklyn Original Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Haddon Heights, New Jersey

Great pizza, reminds me of NYC pizza. Great thin crust and amazing flavor. Every time I'm in this area, it's a must go.