We booked a family concierge master swim up suite for 11 nights. I signed up to the paradisus playa del carmen la esmeralda -la perla Facebook group and researched early on. Lots of great info there.
I saw that Jonathan was the number 1 recommended butler. I also saw mixed reviews on family concierge as a whole. Some felt is was a waste of money. I noted the names of the butlers that people were raving about and time and time again, Jonathan came up. So we requested him and several others that frequently came up as back up. We were lucky enough that he was available for us. He really made our vacation extra special for our 3 and 5 year olds. Prior to arriving, to be honest, I completely regretted booking this resort due to the beach. When we went, the water was murky and brown, but overall it was swimmable. Definitely the least pretty beach in Mexico that I have been to. That said, the service, the food, the drinks, the accommodations, the water park and the resort were the best that we have had at any all inclusive. We visited Iberostar paraiso maya 4 months earlier and while their beach is much nicer, that is literally the only thing that they did better than paradisus. Food presentation is nice at iberostar. Taste is not. The food is very mediocre. I lost weight on that 10 night vacation. Their drinks mostly tasted odd to me and their liquor selection was not that great. Their rooms were nice, but dated. Their resort was just too big; you had to wait for golf carts everywhere. We thought we would.like a larger resort. We were wrong. Their service was great, paradisus' is fantastic. Their landscaping and architecture are fantastic. Okay, they beat paradisus on those 2, but that's not what is most important to me. I feel paradisus spends their money more wisely, in areas with more impact for sure. At least for me, personally. Iberostar is showing some wear too, but so is paradisus.
Just little repairs needed around both resorts. Broken shower heads and foot sprayers at paradisus' beach, a loose light and shower head missing its tube casing at iberostar. Those sorts of things.
The pools at iberostar are massive and they do have the bar under the waterfall and the icecream shop. Those are definitely pros over paradisus, but still doesn't put it in the same league. Paradisus has an awesome, brand new water park. It's deep, so it is nice to be in for the adults too. Versus the ship park at iberostar with less than 2 feet of water (1.5?). Paradisus has a pirate ship pool as well. My kids enjoyed that one. They could reach the bottom while standing. It's about 3 feet deep with a pirate ship that has a look out and slides coming off of it.
The swim up option at paradisus is such a great option too. Iberostar does not have that. At iberostar, you will not get a Jonathan or anything close to a Jonathan.
Overall, we were disappointed in the beach, but everything else was just so much better here that we would choose here over iberostar maya if we go back to one.
Jonathan sent us the daily schedule of activities, moved our reservations as needed, made tons of balloon art for the kids, left them.a treasure hunt, a special bubble bath, food for the turtles and fish (several.times, as we requested) and sent us champagne. Full disclosure: the house champagne was horrible. Otherwise, drinks were good. Try the mango margarita, the peach daiquiri and a mojito. All were yummy. Avoid building DD if you have a young child that naps. It is the main activities pool and it gets super loud during the day. If you don't have a napper, it is an excellent location.
Tip: If you have the included transfers from booking directly, be aware that they completely gouge you for carseats. They charge $20 per carseat, each way. We needed 2. It would have been $80. And it is a shared transfer. Even though we had the "free" transfers, we ended up booking "cheap transfer cancun" for $85, including both carseats and *private transfers. If you're a total beach person, I would skip this hotel. If not, it is an excellent option and I found it to be priced accordingly to make up for the beach. For this level.of resort with a nice beach, we were looking at about $150 more per night. Plus there is a beautiful, but cold cenote about 3 minutes walk down the beach. See the picture of my son in it. It is a local hangout though, so it's really only this peaceful early in the morning. It gets busy and loud later on.
Overall, we were super pleased with our stay and would definitely consider returning. read more