Peace Pie

4.5 (269 reviews)

InexpensiveIce Cream & Frozen Yogurt

Open • 11:00 am - 11:00 pm

Updated 3 weeks ago

Add Review

Call

Directions

Website

Order Peace Pie Takeout or Delivery

Order Takeout or Delivery

Peace Pie Photos

Peace Pie - Banana cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Cape May, New Jersey

Peace Pie - triple vanilla - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Cape May, New Jersey

Peace Pie - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Cape May, New Jersey

+305

Peace Pie - Strawberry Shortcake - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Cape May, New Jersey

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - Peace Pie

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.

Start your review...

Browse more easily on the app

Reviews With Photos

Nina L.

This is my favorite dessert spots in Cape May! I love that their classic flavors are nostalgic pie fillings This spot is a takeout window at the heart of downtown Cape May. I just went up to the window to order and got my ice cream sandwiches. Banana Cream: my favorite! Vanilla shortbread cookie with real banana filling and creamy vanilla ice cream PB Brownie: another fave! Vanilla shortbread with rich chocolate brownie and peanut butter ice cream Raspberry chocolate: tangy and sweet raspberry ice cream with chocolate cream

Carolyn F.

This place is so adorable! We have walked by it many times, but finally decided to get dessert here recently. Homemade ice cream cookies so delicious.

SO delicious! I had a blueberry cobbler sandwich which was blueberry ice cream, vanilla mousse, and graham cracker cookies. I will say, they are hard to eat neatly but that's ok!! Very very tasty! Quick moving line too, I think they pre make each sandwich so they just grab and go!

Stephanie L.

Super cute little shop with a window for ordering. There's no seating but sometimes I'll catch people sitting on the flower ledge in front. Such a creative and unique take on an ice cream sandwich. I had a vanilla ice cream sandwich in between vanilla shortbread, with custard cream and toffee pieces. It looks small but is filling. Cost $8

Deb F.

Ordered lemon crème-no lemon flavor. It was so vanilla that I went back and asked if she made a mistake. She said the Lemon flavor came from lemon topping spread on the cookie. I don't know about other flavors but this one was disappointing! It should taste like lemon if flavor is lemon crème or else change the topping to impart more lemon flavor.

Kate F.

Thankfully you don't know the ingredients when you are at the shop but we happened to grab some from the freezer at our hotel and I was SHOCKED. This is not ice cream. It is pure chemicals with a dash of dairy. But don't worry, they donate .05 cents from each sandwich to Doctors Without Borders. Unfortunately you'll need a doctor if you eat enough of these toxic 'ice cream' sandwiches.

Cindy M.

This Cape May gem is an ice cream shop that will visit for years to come. The small shop has a cool walk up window. The ice cream sandwich is tasty and tons of cool flavors to choose from. I'll be back

Kaitlin E.

Stopped by Peace Pie in Cape May and tried the Peanut Butter Brownie ice cream sandwich. The flavor was incredible--rich, indulgent, and packed with the perfect combo of peanut butter and chocolatey brownie goodness. It definitely satisfied my sweet tooth! The only drawback? The cookies holding the sandwich together were a bit firm, which made it slightly tricky to bite into and eat neatly. Still, totally worth it for the flavor and fun experience. The shop has a colorful, inviting vibe and a menu packed with creative options. Would definitely come back to try more flavors!

Jason M.

Peace Pie fell on my radar when researching eateries to try while in Cape May. The name piqued my interest, being a fan of pie and dessert in general I thought this place was right up my alley. Also, the Yelp reviews and recommendations of this place sounded great - so I made it my intention to check them out during my trip. While Peace Pie is not technically in the Washington Street Mall, it sits parallel to it on Carpenters Ln near several other businesses; it's very easy to get there if you're at the mall. There is no interior to the shop, rather it is a walk-up window with all of the production being conducted in a small structure. The exterior is really capturing to the eye - it's bright with an inviting aura. I quickly learned - and it's worth noting - that Peace Pie does not sell pies as in the baked good. Rather, they sell ice cream sandwiches - their signature being that each sandwich has a layer of pie filling in it. In addition to this location in CM, they have two other spots in NJ plus others in SC and FL. As I approached the window I noticed a menu with all of the flavors listed. They have a lot - but it really only lists the flavor name/combo without giving detail to the actual components of the sandwich; you would need to ask or consult the website to get that information. Anyway, the triple vanilla looked good so I went with that - it was vanilla ice cream with a layer of vanilla mousse between two shortbread cookies. The sandwich itself was good - better than a typical ice cream sandwich. Even though it was premade, the quality itself was higher than what I have found elsewhere. Service was fast - there was nobody else there when I arrived so I was taken care of right away. Overall, I was impressed with Peace Pie - it definitely fits in well with the whole beach aesthetic of Cape May, and I wouldn't be against returning the next time I'm in the area.

Michele C.

Had to try this spot. Got the cookie dough sandwich. I wish a little bit more cookie dough and wish the cookies that make the sandwich were a little softer, but overall it was good. Also the girl serving the ice cream didn't have too much of a personality. I felt like asking a question was a major inconvenience for her, but whatever.

Gloria L.

My husband and I love Peace Pie and always stop by here when we're in Cape May. My only complaint is that they have so many different flavors and variety that I have a hard time choosing one every time I go. They have two lines and are very efficient if there's a lot of people in line. All of the flavors I've tried so far have been great!

Lee E.

It's delicious! My wife and I had the banana cream and an apple pie (?). My only gripe is there's no north jersey location

Salted caramel brownie ice cream sandwich

Sarah G.

My 1st time at Peace Pie. I surely was missing out. Such a cute place and so vibrant and colorful. Love the peace signs in the front. The large flavor sign made it easy to pick a flavor and I love how every pie is $8. You can't beat one set price ! I definitely recommend the salted caramel brownie ice cream sandwich ! It was so sweet and the brownie was so gooey and delicious!

See all

Theresa G.

87

4

0

3 years ago

Lots of fun flavors. I had the key lime peace pie- Amazing cookie crust and key lime ice cream that had the perfect balance of tartness and sweetness! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Cory W.

2

28

4

5 years ago

Me and my sister really liked the place. It is a small gem with potential. I had the cookies and cream and my sister had the cookie dough. The only problem is that they are pretty big for me. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Alyssa R.

Elite 21

75

232

240

10 years ago

This place has such great curb appeal you can't help but stop in for something. They were open later in the evening of one of the nights my boyfriend and I were staying in the area. They had many great selections of ice cream sandwiches, it was hard to choose just one. They are $6 each so I was only getting one... I decided on the peanut butter chiffon which was an excellent choice. It was super fresh and the ice cream was very rich and creamy. There was no skimping on the peanut butter either (a big pet peeve of mine)! My boyfriend had some sort of brownie sandwich which also looked good and he seemed to enjoy it. The employee was really nice and helpful even though we walked in 5 minutes to closing time. I would love to see this place come to the Philly area as I would frequent more often! Definitely recommend it and yes it is worth the $6! *Let it sit a few minutes before eating to let the cookie soften (my Peace Pie wisdom) . read more

Peace Pie - Peanut butter Chiffon - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Cape May, New Jersey

Helpful 2

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Bridgette H.

52

50

12

5 years ago

We wanted ice cream and everywhere else was closed. They're open until 10 in the off season. Decided to try it. Very disappointed. We got 6 of them, all different flavors, and they were ALL freezer burned. If you're going to sell something like this at $5 each they should be freshly scooped. Pulled them right out of a freezer case in wax paper not even in a closed container. So lord knows how long they were just sitting in the freezer like that. I couldn't even tell you if any of them were good because we couldn't taste them over the freezer burn. BEWARE! read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Chris J.

50

41

8

11 years ago

Brightest take on an ice cream sandwich ever, this place is so good, and the flavors are amazing. They have a high quality, small batch feel. Not like the mass produced ice cream sandwiches we have all had. The cookies are light and crisp. read more

See all

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Daria D.

Elite 24

38

335

1870

6 years ago

This is such a unique take on an ice cream sandwich! My dad and I ordered the pumpkin spice ice cream sandwich and the salted caramel apple ice cream sandwich. You can view all the available flavors through the glass in the front and then order through the window on the side of the store. The ice cream was delicious and a great portion size (held us over until our next meal!). There are benches right across the street (or down the next block along the main street mall area) where you can sit and enjoy the sandwiches. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Thomas B.

0

19

1

6 years ago

Fantastic ice cream treat! This was an interesting take on an ice cream sandwich that tasted just like a slice of pie a la mode. The order/pick up window was perfect for a quick, safe dessert during the pandemic read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Mer C.

3

10

2

11 years ago

Holy. Crap. These are amazing. After enjoying hundreds of ice cream cones on the mall over the years, we came across this new shop yesterday and thought it sounded interesting. My husband and I tried the salted caramel brownie and coffee toffee, respectively, and were blown away. The salted caramel filling (in both sandwiches) is really something special. And the crunchy salty toffee pieces in the coffee toffee was perfect. The cookies are crunchy and a little salty (in a good way) and firm enough to stand up to the ice cream without crumbling to pieces. We cannot wait to go back to try the others! Seriously, my stomach is growling. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Marie M.

1

13

2

7 years ago

Awful experience. The teenage girl that was working the evening of 8/15/19 was more interested in her cell phone than her customers. We waited about 2 minutes for her to finish her text messages before she barely lifted her head and said hello (and the shop was empty). I had to prompt her to tell us about the product and she offered a few abbreviated sentences before returning to her cell phone. Again, I had to prompt her when we were ready to order. She was rude and lacked any knowledge of customer service. The "peace pies" were ok. There is no "pie" about it. They are basically an overpriced ice cream sandwich. Nothing great and certainly underwhelming after all the reviews we read in advance. We will not be returning to this establishment. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Grace Y.

32

11

9

7 years ago

2nd trip back from Atlantic City...Quick treat before next stop Wildwood. What a delicious find!!! read more

Peace Pie - When in Jersey! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Cape May, New Jersey

Peace Pie - ALL Yummy - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Cape May, New Jersey

See all

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Emma L.

1

17

37

5 years ago

This quick service Cape May ice cream cookie shop was incredible! The brightly colored walk up to stand is adorable on its own. There are so many flavors to choose from; we got peanut butter brownie, cookies n cream, and coconut cream pie. The ice cream was perfect in between the thin pie crust like cookies. The serving size was perfect and every bite was delicious! Definitely check this place out. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Sara G.

1

114

95

5 years ago

Honestly not impressed. The cookies were not that good (mine even still had tiny foil pieces on it) and too frozen. The ice cream was too hard and not that flavorful. Overall I was very disappointed. On top of that, the person working inside was also doing landscaping outside, maskless. When he saw us at the ordering window, he came inside, and then put on a mask and gloves. I'm not sure if he washed his hands, but if he did, it was brief. We definitely won't be back. read more

Peace Pie - I think this was Peanut Butter Cookie Dough but I can't remember it's exact name. - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Cape May, New Jersey

See all

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Janet J.

0

32

63

6 years ago

Who would have expected that I would willingly go back to eat ice cream sandwiches in 50-60 degree weather? I stumbled upon this place because it its cute decorated exterior at night and was surprised to see a line in November. There is a screen at the window and the shopkeeper wore mask and gloves when they were getting our items as well! They have a lot of different flavors but we got the raspberry chocolate, key lime, and strawberry chocolate and they were all so good! The cookies were firm and crispy and the ice cream was delish! I wasn't expecting chocolate chips in the raspberry and strawberry ones but they just made it better! Overall, if you're like me and visiting Cape May for the first time in the winter season don't pass on Peace Pie (at least you won't have to worry about it melting if you decide to grab it on your way walking back to your place like we did) read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Dana N.

90

62

180

11 years ago

Different is a good thing. Thin crunchy cookies filled with different flavored ice cream and fillings. I got the turtle cookie sandwich - chocolate cookie stuffed with a thick layer of caramel, nuts and chocolate ice cream. A miniature version for kids (and those with smaller appetites) might be a good idea. read more

Peace Pie - Night view! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Cape May, New Jersey

Peace Pie - The menu - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Cape May, New Jersey

Peace Pie - Customer's view of ice cream. - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Cape May, New Jersey

See all

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Marcella A.

Elite 26

156

529

1426

8 years ago

Amazing spot . The employees were really nice and explained about there making of the company. The ice cream peace pie cookie was really good. I gotten the apple vanilla ice cream and my fiance gotten the vanilla brownies carmal one . They were out if this world. The prices was just right as well. Definitely have to come here and try it out. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Ali Z.

Elite 24

14

107

27

6 years ago

Amazing selection of flavors, and great ice cream sandwiches. I had the salted caramel brownie, which was good but hard to chew because it's so cold and a bit hard because of the coldness. Friends had the creme brûlée and the Jersey Devil. All delicious and highly recommended, but that Jersey Devil was something special. Enjoy! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

B R.

0

7

0

4 years ago

When it's 1 degree feels like and 25 mph winds in February and the only ice cream in town is peace pie, you have to swallow your pride and get the goods. That's the cynical review. You don't need to swallow anything except ice cream packed inside delicious cookies. And you don't need to wait until mid winter! Strawberry with chocolate chips inside chocolate butter cookies really hit the spot. Many choices. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Shazia K.

0

38

72

7 years ago

I had the Orange Creamsicle Sandwich and it was super yummy! You had to wait for the ice cream to soften a little but it was really delicious! I wish the cookie had a bit more flavor though. The staff was really nice and helpful and the outside if the store is so colorful and great to take cute pictures! read more

Peace Pie - Orange Creamsicle - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Cape May, New Jersey

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Kristen F.

Elite 25

27

158

67

6 years ago

An innovative take on the ice cream sandwich is what this business promises to offer & that they do. I had the cookie dough sandwich. It was tasty & hit the spot. The cookie is more crunchy than soft and chewy. I'm more partial to the soft and chewy cookie. Not sure if all their cookies are on the crunchy side. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Jennifer K.

0

69

43

8 years ago

These are ice cream sandwiches with a layer of PIE FILLING! They are 100% deliciousness. The ice cream is so creamy, the pie filling layer so delicious, and the sandwich cookie part tastes like pie crust! read more

Peace Pie - Salted Caramel Apple - The Elvis - Jersey Devil - Caramel Coffee Toffee - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Cape May, New Jersey

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Gabriella S.

Elite 23

313

177

458

6 years ago

They have two windows on opposite sides of the building and plexiglass for covid. Ice cream was amazing!

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Karen C.

0

7

0

7 years ago

Delish!! Saw this cute place right as I was leaving and couldn't resist grabbing a quick cookies n cream sandwich. So very good!

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Anthony L.

378

16

18

8 years ago

Just Wow!! So yummy. Awesome selection of Ice cream sandwiches. Had the peanut butter cookie dough which was bomb!! Jerry the owner runs the shop and is super nice. Be sure to ask him the story behind the name :) enjoy read more

See all

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

S S.

0

17

16

6 years ago

Wow, where have I been? This ice cream sandwich is amazing. We ordered 4 different flavors and all were equally good. I would definitely come back over and over. It's worth that 30min ride on the peloton afterwards. If they offer overnight shipping I would order!! It's that good!! read more

Peace Pie - two ice cream sandwiches in wrappers - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Cape May, New Jersey

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

William C.

3

28

23

6 years ago

I love Peace Pie. An amazing variety of ice cream treats! A must visit location for every trip to Cape May!

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Kristy D.

4

2

1

6 years ago

Ice cream sammy + pie filling. What's not to love? So many flavors for everyone, but the banana cream is worth trying first. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Nicole V.

143

15

7

6 years ago

what a cute place!! it's right off the main street and they have window ordering. I got the salted caramel brownie and it was SOO good. definitely recommend!!! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Jennifer L.

135

1

0

6 years ago

Absolutely lovely establishment. Owners are great...so friendly. Sprinkled my ice cream because I was craving it!!!

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

C S.

3

56

24

6 years ago

Delicious!!!!! Worth the wait if there is a line! The s'mores sandwich was perfection, as was the salted caramel brownie.

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Matt G.

Elite 26

926

149

198

9 years ago

Tasty with a ton of sandwiches to choose from. The dude who works there is as cool as a cucumber

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

B H.

0

9

2

8 years ago

Delicious. A bit over-priced, but worth it for a vacation stop. A welcome and unique alternative to just another ice cream cone. Our family got the Orange Cream, Strawberry Shortcake, and Smores. All of them received rave reviews. The shortbread cookie had the perfect crunch and thickness and the ice creams / fillings were very flavorful. Glad we stumbled upon it. Only negative is that at $6 the sandwich seems a bit over-priced, but since we were on vacation we splurged and it was worth it for a one-time thing. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Doreen P.

0

7

2

6 years ago

OMG!!! You definitely must go to Peace Pie and enjoy the best ice cream sandwiches ever!! Don't forget to take some hone too. My favorite is the coconut read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Danielle B.

0

44

4

6 years ago

Delicious. Unsure how you can choose which ice cream sandwich to order because all the combos are outrageously tasty but I had the pb brownie and it did not disappoint. The outer cookie was sturdy and perfectly crisp. And there was even a surprising caramel drizzle that was a really nice touch. I'd love to go back to try other flavors read more

Peace Pie - Peanut butter brownie - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Cape May, New Jersey

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Caroline D.

390

3

5

11 years ago

Decided to try it out since it was a new place this summer... finally found the little shack close to the Japanese place by congress hall. All of the cookie sandwiches are premade. They all have the same shortbread cookie and are all different fillings. I had the Carmel brownie, it was delicious and would definitely get it again. Dad had the coconut cream.. couldn't really taste the coconut but it was still very good. Not much you can do wrong with an ice cream sandwich!! I can't wait to go back and try all of the flavors!! read more

Peace Pie - Chocolate Carmel Brownie!!! Yum! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Cape May, New Jersey

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Shaphali P.

32

39

13

7 years ago

Yum! Adorable little shop with mouth watering ice cream sandwiches. I tried the salted caramel with brownies...and they even cut it so I could share easily. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Marisa F.

Elite 21

362

264

57

7 years ago

So happy we finally got to try Peace Pie in cape May! We went on a Sunday night and the line was pretty long, out the door but went super fast. There are so many flavors it was overwhelming at first to figure out which I wanted. I think you have to see them in the case first before you can decide. We went with the Pecan Pie and am sooooo happy we did. It was amazing. $6 not bad. We split it because I don't think I could've eaten one on my own.. lots of ice cream, def big. If you're in the cape May mall area I would def go for this compared to a regular ice cream cone. Much better. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Barron N.

Elite 24

0

76

382

6 years ago

Five star! Not the typical dessert place and always a treat to have. Will be back soon!

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Matthew S.

0

6

0

4 years ago

Extremely good but they are way to frozen like harder than a rock frozen like mount Vesuvius hard like harder than a god damn Diamond

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Zach T.

8

16

0

7 years ago

Hard to eat. Great flavor though. I got the peanut butter and chocolate sandwich. Quick and easy snack for the whole family.

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Katrina B.

Elite 21

147

32

14

7 years ago

There aren't many places I'd say are life changing but this is. Stopped here on a whim. Oh my god. Got the salted caramel brownie. Truly can't get over how good this was. Individually the ingredients are all great. The ice cream and short bread cookie alone are excellent. Considering ordering these online because I'm not sure I can wait until the next time we're in Cape May read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Page 4 of 7

326 Carpenters Ln
Cape May, NJ 08204
Directions
(609) 435-5321
Call Now
Visit Website
http://peacepieworld.com

Full menu

Hours

What time does Peace Pie open?

Peace Pie opens at 11:00 AM on Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday, Friday, Saturday and Sunday.

What time does Peace Pie close?

Peace Pie closes at 11:00 PM on Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday, Friday, Saturday and Sunday.

Mon-Sun 11:00 AM - 11:00 PM

Payment methods

Does Peace Pie take Bitcoin?

No, Peace Pie does not take Bitcoin.

Does Peace Pie take credit cards?

Yes, Peace Pie takes credit cards.

Food & Alcohol

Does Peace Pie have catering options?

Yes, Peace Pie does have catering options.

Does Peace Pie have a drive thru?

No, Peace Pie does not have a drive thru.

Indoor Amenities

Does Peace Pie allow dogs?

Yes, Peace Pie allows dogs.

Outdoor Amenities

Does Peace Pie have bike parking?

Yes, Peace Pie has bike parking.

Does Peace Pie have parking?

Yes, Peace Pie has parking options. Street Parking

Other Amenities

Is Peace Pie wheelchair accessible?

Yes, Peace Pie is wheelchair accessible.

Does Peace Pie have free WiFi?

No, Peace Pie does not have free WiFi.

From the Business

Specialties

The Ice Cream Sandwich with a Layer of Pie Filling!

History

Established in 2015.

I still remember coming home from college for Thanksgiving in 2009. Walking into my father's house in Woodstock, he said, "Joe, you aren't going to believe what I just made." (I've learned to become concerned when he says those words) "I took your pecan pie recipe, put it on top of a shortbread cookie in a large baking tray, and covered it all with ice cream! I call it 'Pecan Pie a la Mode Lasagna!'" My less than enthusiastic response quickly changed after I tried a piece. And that's how it began. Now, the lasagna has become hand-sized portions, and is being produced and sold by the thousands (they also picked up a better name along the way). We know you'll enjoy them as much as we do! See you soon, Joe

Meet the Business Owner: Joe K.

Peace Pie is a family run business, officially established in 2015, but having roots back to 2009. For Thanksgiving dessert that year, my father created a "pecan pie, shortbread a la mode lasagna". Over the next four years, he went searching for how to make his "a la mode lasagna" into an ice cream sandwich. In the summer of 2013, my father enlisted my help in selling Peace Pies at a local farmers' market on Thursday mornings. They were a huge hit. Building on the success of that summer, in 2014 my father and I brought in the help of my mother and sister as we expanded into 9 farmers markets and many other local festivals. Realizing we had something special, we purchased a storefront in Cape May, NJ. The first Peace Pie store opened up on Memorial Day of 2015. Continuing to build, we have chosen Charleston, SC as the second location, and opened our Meeting Street location on February 5th, 2016. This story is just beginning.

Verify this business for free

People searched for Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt 2,769 times last month within 10 miles of this business.

Verify this business

Explore benefits

Dry Dock Ice Cream Bar & Grill

3.7(58 reviews)

1.3 mi

•$$

Deceiving. Ordered a medium sundae. Says it includes 1 topping, cherry, whipped cream…read more Receipt shows 1.50 added for my topping of choice (hot fudge) Same thing with my boyfriend's sundae, charged 1.50 for rainbow jimmies That's an extra 3 dollars for our order alone, if this happens for every order, that ADDS UP

Since my last visit there have been only positive changes! They no longer have a minimum charge…read morefor credit cards and now they accept ApplePay too. Fellow Yelper Dee M and I decided that Ice Cream for Lunch is now a thing when you're on vacation, so we headed over there after a morning of shopping in downtown Cape May. She got a milkshake and I got the 'Smores Sundae. Both were delicious, generous portions, creamy and just the right bout of sweet. Staff were friendly and worked quickly. They were slightly amused at my sheer delight in being able to use Apple Pay. It's the little things, people. Love this old school ice cream parlor, and hope they have many more successful years.

Photos

See all

Hours 8-2023

Kohr Brothers Frozen Custard

4.1(97 reviews)

0.1 mi

•$

My favorite soft serve ice cream at the beach! The line is…read moremoving quickly. Servers are expedient! Chocolate and vanilla swirl in a cake cone!

We stopped by for some frozen custard. It was a cute shop with soft serve custard. The girl behind…read morethe counter took our order. We got a small vanilla custard dipped in chocolate. The ice cream was good especially with the chocolate dip. The price however was a little steep for a small cone (over $7).

Photos

Frozen chocolate custard in a waffle cone with chocolate sprinkles. Yum.

The front of the store

See all

Pumpkin cinnamon twist

Fine Fellows Creamery

4.5(151 reviews)

0.1 mi

•$

Fine Fellows used to be my favorite ice cream place in town. It had that personal feel with the…read moreowners often working behind the counter, but now it's like every other place. I'm not sure if it's because there are so many people working there or because it's so expensive. Two small cups of ice cream were $15+. I asked for a unique flavor and tried their matcha which was good, but overall it's lost its Cape May charm. There are a lot of places to get ice cream, but this place doesn't set itself apart anymore.

Cute ice cream shop in Washington Street Mall in Cape May! I'll be honest I can't remember exactly…read morewhat the flavor was but I think it was salted caramel pretzel lol! Very good. You can try some samples while you're there too.

Photos

Death by chocolate

Raspberry truffle on a dipped waffle cone served with pride

See all

Uncle Charley's Ice Cream

4.1(117 reviews)

0.0 mi

•$

We stood in a long line, but it was worth it! An abundance of options, very clean establishment.read more

When there is a line out the door on a hot summer night for an ice cream spot you get on the line &…read morewait -- cause you know it's worth it! And we were right, a massive assortment of flavors & quite the substantial size cup -- all in all a perfect choice!

Photos

Menu

See all

Scoops On Sunset

4.5(38 reviews)

0.5 mi

•$

Very friendly staff, the ice cream was great. Been going here for years and hope other people can…read moreexperience the joy of coming here as much as me. The owner was fantastic and never takes a day off, has lots of jokes and very friendly with families.

The ice cream is amazing here and the owner is so nice. Right around the corner from our favorite…read moreItalian restaurant in Cape May. So after dinner we stroll on by have our dessert. Oh and they have gluten free ice cream cones. Great flavors.

Photos

Coffee and chocolate peanut butter

Scoops on Sunset -- storefront

See all

SUMMER HOURS -(i work here)

King’s Ice Cream

4.1(44 reviews)

0.1 mi

We both agree that this is a great place to get ice cream. We didn't think it tasted very "home…read moremade" which some other places are but their flavors are great! My husband had the Cookie Monster and it was delicious looking. I had one scoop of Ube and one of the Honey Lavender. The flavors were so real and didn't at all taste like any weird extracts were added. Aside from the flavors, this place is just darn cute! Beautiful decor and some cute little market items to buy.

Good ice cream not great ice cream. Ube flavor is…read moredifferent. Their methodology in serving and paying is very clunky. They need to keep one person at the register, and let the rest scoop ice cream. (Maybe 2 registers during peak season) This would cut down on lines and touching ice cream and money by the same person! (Cross contamination concerns!)

Photos

Taro soft serve

Ube Ice Cream

See all

Kohr Brothers Frozen Custard

4.4(14 reviews)

0.4 mi

I think about the mint/chocolate soft serve daily. Staff was friendly and location was great!read more

So good! My favorites are the orange/vanilla swirl and coffee (when they have it) with vanilla…read more It's expensive but so creamy and worth it !

Photos

I got the chocolate single flavor of frozen custard with the chocolate jimmies and a waffle cone. Thank you.

See all

$8 Cone

Rita’s Italian Ice & Frozen Custard

It was a very hot day visiting Cape May in May…read more Ordered a Blendini with Chocolate Custard and Chocolate ice with almond toffee crunch. It was too sweet for me. But it was a nice refreshing dessert.

While I normally love bringing my kid to get Rita's closer to home, my experience at this franchise…read morewas the worst. The owner decided to decried my 5 yr old about the difference between gelato and gelati. He was scared to even finish his order!

Photos

See all

Ben & Jerry’s

4.0(52 reviews)

0.1 mi

•$

Average Ben & Jerry place. It was clean. The staff was super nice. I had the milk and cookies…read moreand my mom had vanilla. I just can't give it a higher rating because it's just average.

Clean store, pleasant staff and a ton of flavors make this place excellent. The portions are…read moregenerous and the ice cream is rich and delicious. I had the chocolate peanut butter which was an excellent choice. Smooth and just the right amount of rich chocolate and peanut butter.

Photos

Fresh packed pint in front of Ben & Jerry's ice cream shop menu board.

A Ben & Jerry's freshly baked dipped waffle cone with sprinkles in front of waffle cone display.

See all

Waffle cone, cup and fresh packed pint in front of Ben & Jerry's ice cream shop menu board.

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

10 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Elijah S.

0

6

1

6 years ago

Worst ice cream. I went there last night with a friend and it was below average. There was no line which should have been a tip off since it is in the middle of the cape May shops. I was very excited and it looks delicious but it was not made on the spot they were pre-made. Mine was also freezer burnt as well. My friend got the double chocolate chip the inside was good but the outside was like cardboard. No taste and was VERY hard to bite. I got the strawberry shortcake and it was the same. It did not taste fresh at all. The one girl working was also sitting on top of one of the ice cream freezers on her phone while the other was doing all the work. I would recommend any other ice cream place in cape May other than this one. I am never one to write a review but I had too. read more

Keegan R.

66

91

49

8 years ago

Tried this place last night for the first time. We will definitely be repeat customers! These ice cream sandwiches are AMAZING! The staff was friendly and helpful when I asked for a recommendation. Expect to take a few minutes ordering though, there are so MANY choices!!! read more

Kelly F.

0

5

0

10 years ago

First visit to Cape May, first time here. Had the salted caramel apple pie sandwich--- fantastic!!! If you love pie and ice cream it is a must try! read more

Linda S.

0

5

0

11 years ago

The absolute best ice cream sandwiches EVER! Been to all the other ice cream places in Cape May and nothing else even comes close.

Matty I.

1

66

0

3 years ago

I would drive 2 hours for this. And I may this weekend. Do yourself a favor and get it.

Gary R.

4

10

0

4 years ago

Great ice cream except for the black hair in my ice cream sandwich.

Curt H.

29

4

0

7 years ago

Friendly staff and a great selection of ice cream sandwiches.

Brittany C.

1

14

0

6 years ago

These were amazing! Will definitely go again!

Sandy W.

0

30

0

7 years ago

Was really happy coming here for dessert

Nancy H.

28

14

0

11 years ago

Chocolate Lava Ice Cream Sandwich!

Peace Pie - icecream - Updated September 2026

People who viewed Peace Pie also viewed

Uncle Charley's Ice Cream

117 reviews

$

King’s Ice Cream

44 reviews

Kohr Brothers Frozen Custard

97 reviews

$

Fine Fellows Creamery

151 reviews

$

Sea Shell Ice Cream

151 reviews

$

Cone Crazy Ice Cream Shop

29 reviews

$

The Grand Scoop

9 reviews

Cione

49 reviews

$

Cool Delites Ice Cream

10 reviews

Kohr Bros Frozen Custard

30 reviews

$

Peace Pie

Order Peace Pie Takeout or Delivery

Peace Pie Photos

Peace Pie Popular Desserts

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - Peace Pie

Reviews With Photos

More info about Peace Pie

Payment methods

Food & Alcohol

Indoor Amenities

Outdoor Amenities

Other Amenities

Ask the Community - Peace Pie

Verify this business for free

Dry Dock Ice Cream Bar & Grill

Kohr Brothers Frozen Custard

Fine Fellows Creamery

Uncle Charley's Ice Cream

Scoops On Sunset

King’s Ice Cream

Kohr Brothers Frozen Custard

Rita’s Italian Ice & Frozen Custard

Ben & Jerry’s

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

10 reviews that are not currently recommended

Peace Pie - icecream - Updated September 2026

Best of Cape May

People found Peace Pie by searching for…

Trending Searches in Cape May, NJ

Browse Articles

Browse Nearby

Browse Brands

Related Searches in Cape May, NJ

People who viewed Peace Pie also viewed

Peace Pie

Order Peace Pie Takeout or Delivery

Peace Pie Photos

Peace Pie Popular Desserts

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - Peace Pie

Reviews With Photos

More info about Peace Pie

Payment methods

Food & Alcohol

Indoor Amenities

Outdoor Amenities

Other Amenities

Ask the Community - Peace Pie

Verify this business for free

More businesses like Peace Pie

Dry Dock Ice Cream Bar & Grill

Kohr Brothers Frozen Custard

Fine Fellows Creamery

Uncle Charley's Ice Cream

Scoops On Sunset

King’s Ice Cream

Kohr Brothers Frozen Custard

Rita’s Italian Ice & Frozen Custard

Ben & Jerry’s

10 Peace Pie reviews that are not currently recommended

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

10 reviews that are not currently recommended

Peace Pie - icecream - Updated September 2026

Best of Cape May

People found Peace Pie by searching for…

Trending Searches in Cape May, NJ

Browse Articles

Browse Nearby

Browse Brands

Related Searches in Cape May, NJ

People who viewed Peace Pie also viewed