Delicious food, friendly service and great ambiance. The french toast and sausage were especially good!

Love Peekskill Diner! Friendly, great service, food, and awesome old pics of downtown. Real diner French fries. Not those breaded frozen ones most diners serve now. My favorite is the chicken cordon bleu wrap w the yummy honey mustard sauce. read more

Peekskill Diner - Diners Near Me - Peekskill, New York

Great new addition to the neighborhood. Very friendly staff and they are still working out the kinks. Be patient. They will be a great diner in time. Parking is very tight but the space is small. They have about 15 tables and four TVs tuned to News12. Lots of great old photos of Peekskill Remember to tip well. read more

See all

The diner was a very neat and clean cafe setting. Service was prompt and very friendly. It felt like I was being served by the owner and his family and they cared about good service and good food. I had a simple breakfast of eggs, smoked sausage, toast and potatoes. All really well prepared read more

Peekskill Diner - Perfect cafe breakfast. - Diners Near Me - Peekskill, New York

The food was delicious, seasoned perfectly . The owner overheard it was my anniversary and we got an extra surprise. I recommend it as a new favorite comfort food stop. read more

See all

Delicious breakfast sandwich, nice pancakes. Coffee was just right. Service is professional, friendly and considerate. The diner is airy and very clean. We don't live in the area but if we did I'm sure we'd be regulars! read more

My wife insisted we try this spot and I have to admit very glad we did! It presents outside as a tiny location which is actually very deceiving. The inside was larger than I would have thought with multiple booth, chairs and tables. A very comfortable environment. Staff was friendly and outgoing but the real gem was the menu offerings and the food presentation. Far better than any " diner " that I am used to. I admit I ordered a mixed plate of appetizers instead of a meal, I was not disappointed. My wife ordered a healthy type sandwich. She loved it. There was enough that we had to take some home. Desserts show in a case were very tempting and will look forward to having one next visit. Yes will definitely be a next visit soon. Their burger selection is extremely temping and being 5 minutes from their location we plan to make this a regular dining location for us. read more

Peekskill Diner - Great sample type platter of all the things I shouldn't have LOL served with three lovely dipping sauces. - Diners Near Me - Peekskill, New York

See all

Food and service were great. My new go to spot for breakfast. Will return!!!! Diner has parking. Diner was super clean read more

See all

I ordered a grilled shrimp wrap with French fries it came with peppers,tomato and avocado. It was delicious and healthy option for Good Friday. read more

New hidden gem! We have had dinner here a few times now. All fantastic and super reasonably priced. Stuffed sole Florentine complete dinner, $20!. Great specials. Huge tuna melt, $9. Our new favorite place!, diagonally across from downtown fire station. read more

It was good. Not great. The pancakes were rough. That was the thing that makes me wanna take this from 4 stars to a 3. They were doughy. Not undercooked. They were cooked through and through. But it was still doughy; which tells me that how they mix their batter is the problem. I also got the Peekskill Diner Omelette. It was decent. 4 out of 5. About as good as any omelette from any surrounding diner. Unfortunately, the home fries were pretty mid. I wouldn't say they were undercooked because the potatoes were soft, but they were definitely not roasted long enough. I'm guessing they were boiled before roasted; which is fine, but they just need to roast them a lot longer because boiled potatoes absorb a ton of moisture and need the extra time roasting. Service was fine. Waiter was always on time. Water and coffee refills were on time. I would say 4.5/5 on service. Nothing wrong there. The manager was attentive, and looked like he was dedicated to making this Diner work. He's the only reason I'm giving this place a 4/5 and not a 3/5. I'm sure he'll be reading this review, and I'm sure he will work to make the food better. The actual restaurant itself is small. It feels a little cramped. Not as bad as the worst I've seen, but it does feel tight. I won't deduct any points for this because they're working with what they got. If they make the food better, they can go even tighter, and I won't complain. All in all, I think these guys are stretching themselves too thin. They wanna do the standard NY style Diner, but I think they'd be better off finding a niche. It's a small space. It doesn't need a menu that big. We need less variety and more quality in this area. All our diners in the area are mid. All of them. Westchester, 202, Mohegan, etc.... we don't need another mid diner. These guys will not last if they're gonna give us the same mediocre food we can get from bigger diners with more comfortable seating. At least the rest of them got better pancakes. If you're the manager and you're reading this, trust me when I say this. You may be busy now, but that will end. Start planning for a change. I recommend going down to City Limits Diner in White Plains to see what they're doing; if you really wanna stick to the NY style Diner vibes. Otherwise, find a niche. Find the thing that your head chef is passionate about, and let them make the best fking food in a 20 mile radius. read more

Small space with very friendly and courteous staff; owner/manager came around to check on everyone which was nice. The place was clean and tidy, I appreciated the historical photos of Peekskill around the dining area. The menu is not overly ambitious, but plenty of choices; the food was very good, portions not skimpy and definitely not over priced. I hope they do well; I would recommend and will definitely be going back. read more

What a surprise when I came upon this new gem of a diner in Peekskill! Very welcoming staff, delicious food and no one rushing you to leave! We will definitely be back! read more

I just got a pastrami sandwich about 2hr ago, it was cooked very well, but it had just a little too much cheese and meat, I was overwhelmed with it. But I will give it another try later. read more

Peekskill diner has excellent food, fair prices and wonderful service. Peekskill diner is a hidden gem!

Old school diner vibe. Good service and food. I would not recommend the Monte Cristo though. ‍‍

Excellent place. Super clean, friendly staff, delicious food and awesome prices. Will be back and wishing more success to the great staff here! read more

Yummy yummy. My favorite is the chicken and waffles. My husband loves the California wrap. And the flan! It's excellent. Service is always friendly and helpful too. Try it! read more

Absolutely wonderful experience. Staff very friendly. Service and food excellent. Ambiance is great.

Enjoyed an AMAZING breakfast here! Our Huevos Rancheros(his), and French Toast with Bacon(hers) - delicious! Service is excellent. Coffee is great! We will be regulars for sure! read more

Food was delicious. I ordered the Surf and Turf. Service was very attentive. Decor is very new, clean, and nice. We will be back!

Beautiful new diner. Great staff! Delicious breakfast. Cant' wait to try lunches and dinners!

My son and I are there for lunch today. Small but homey feel to it. Greeted immediately and seated. The service was excellent and the food was delicious! I had plain chicken wings which were crispy and moist. My son had the Jack Daniel's burger with French fries. Smelled delicious and my son said it was too. French fries were perfect. Their coffee was not like the typical diner coffee. It had such a nice flavor and not bitter. Very clean place and we would highly recommend it. read more