Even though I'm rating this at 3 stars, I'd really like to go back here and give it another try. Went with a group and we all got different things -- but one thing we all agreed on is that the food is heavy and in some cases greasy. If that's your thing, then 4+ stars! Will also give a big thumbs up to the decor -- loved what was on the walls and the floors looked like they'd recently been redone. Various dishes our group had included a breakfast sandwich with sausage; an omelette, which was probably the healthiest option of what folks got; a cheeseburger; someone else got a French dip kind of sandwich. French fries were fought over -- so also a thumbs up for them. Again, I was the outlier in our group and in other reviews so I do plan to return to give it another chance. Check out the menu and other reviews and maybe you'll give it four or more stars! read more

See all

Definitely slacking in the past year or so. The burgers and smoked wings are always good however, stay FAR away from the beet burger. It had been awesome in the past however the last two times it was inedible....there were 9 in my party and 3 of us ordered it. Needless to say, we left the slop in our plate. ALSO, they do not have bottled water. The water tasted and smelled like fish. I have never been to a food establishment that does not have bottled water of any kind. Any brand would have been fine. The service was good but Im not going to say there were any happy faces or joyful people working there. The outside needs a little face-lift. Knowing my customers were eating on rusty tables would drive me nuts. The place looks sad. read more

Lots of issues here. I will start with the good: The waitress was very nice as was the additional help. Now everything else: We ordered the cheese croquets. This might be just the taste, but nobody at our table liked them. Also - and this seems to be the specialty of the house - they were not particularly warm. We also ordered the nachos with the brisket chili. The plate was huge and the nachos were pretty good. Unfortunately, the chili was largely a rumor. Now for dinner. Oh boy. First the staff, including our waitress, brought us food for another table. We didn't realize it right away, because the other table ordered a couple of items we did. Then we did get our food. We had a couple of the brisket grilled cheeses. These were tasty, but again, with precious little meat in them, and not hot. We had a smash burger order - COLD. Two mushroom truffle burgers - also cold and one was severely undercooked. We were going to a show so we suffered with it. The fries were a hit by the way. I ordered the salt caramel gelato. I've had similar many times. This was overly salty. I was very excited to go here, but unfortunately, quality flew the coop at Birdsall. read more

Birdsall House - Nachos with MIA chili. - Venues & Event Spaces Near Me - Peekskill, New York

See all

What a fantastic place!! In the heart of Peekskill..we sat in the courtyard and had an absolutely Delicious lunch. Our server Vicki was fantastic!!! Wine was perfect and the food was amazing!! Definitely check this spot out and Enjoy!!! read more

See all

Better than average brunch especially for a pub. Loved the pie shaped hashbrowns and the corn beef hash. Solid mimosas. Knowledgeable bar tender who called out the highlights in their beer selection. It's a little divey, but that's part of the charm. Need to stop in when the weather is warmer. Soldi option for Peekskill. read more

We found this little gem of a restaurant after a four hour hiking in the bear mountains. Let me tell you, we were starvinngggggggg. The reviews look great so we decided to give it a try. Upon arrival, I was first grasped by the arty theme, some unique carving and paintings on the wall, give you a Wild West feel. We were immediately waited and did not have to wait too long for our food to arrive. In terms of the food, I absolutely loved my double patty smash burger. Juicy and yummy. The appetizer lentil soup was soothing, perfect for a Fall day. read more

See all

Best bar in Peekskill. Great beer selection. Great bartenders. Nice art on the walls. Live music on the weekends. Nice patio on the side of the bar. And the food is amazing! You have to try the SMOKED chicken wings. Fall off the bone tender. read more

Birdsall House - Heady Topper - Venues & Event Spaces Near Me - Peekskill, New York

Food was very good and place had a very nostalgic vibe. Nice bar and great atmosphere.

Cute local spot and surprisingly not busy for Sunday brunch. They have a $30 prix fix menu for brunch that includes a beer, bloody mary, or mimosa, appetizer and a main. Great value! The chicken liver mousse was decent and the biscuits with Memphis style gravy was ok. The gravy tasted cheesy, which I was not expecting. Like a lot of small businesses now, there is a fee that they clearly state on the check if you pay with a card. Service was great! read more

Birdsall House - Biscuits with gravy - Venues & Event Spaces Near Me - Peekskill, New York

I walked into Birdsall House on a Thursday night with my wife. This place looks so unassuming. The inside feels like a bar like atmosphere. The menu seemed interesting. The food was really terrific and worth every penny. The service was quick and very friendly. I would definitely comeback here again. The bartenders are really nice and they make really great drinks. I tried one of the local craft beers that they let me sample. It is a place I would highly recommend. read more

Birdsall House - Menu - Venues & Event Spaces Near Me - Peekskill, New York

Highly recommend Birdsall House for great craft beer, decent cocktails and delicious food! I recently tried the vegan seitan gyro and the vegan cauliflower wings. For house-made seitan made at a non-vegan establishment I was pretty impressed! It is a bit spongey but super flavorful and if you're vegan dining with non vegans I think you'd be satisfied. The cauliflower wings were delicious and even my non-vegan husband loved those. Next time I can't wait to try their jackfruit crabcake Po' boy! The cocktails were OK- not bad just maybe a bit bland. The wine on tap was delicious and you can't go wrong with a draft beer. The inside is a bit outdated but the patio is delightful. It is on a busy street so can get noisy. Overall I think if you're vegan Birdsall House is definitely worth a trip. Update* I also recently tried the vegan jackfruit po boy sandwich and it was also delicious! The vegan remoulade was perfectly balanced and had a little kick! read more

See all

Ok. Sooooooo. Our Server Amanda. Is AMAZING and an absolute wonderful person!!! She was on point and crazy helpful!!! No pressure and very patient. Thank you!!! The place is very clean and inviting. They have outdoor seating and plenty of room. Don't get that crowded rushed feeling. Not at all. Very relaxed!!' Food was DARN Good! Smoked wings were sooo yummy and they bring out three sauces for you. Mind you the rub it's already cooked is was very tasty! House fries yummy! Smash burger was awesome as well as their Maple burger. Beer selection is outstanding! My only disgruntlement was my drink didn't have BIG ice!!! lol. Snob! But all in all this was a darn good eat and drink. Two thumbs up and absolutely, I'll be back!!!! read more

The perfect smash burger doesn't exi-- Yes It does, and it's here. I'm not typically a huge burger fan but this was so so good. Two patties, good amount of cheese ratio, and a yummy sauce inside. Melts in your mouth! All of their sauces are house made: the ranch & mustard were my fav. Also, these fries are just about the most perfectly salted, crispy but soft fries out there. So so good read more

See all

A neighborhood staple with a large, ever changing beer list and great food. Easy place to drink with friends or go to lunch with the family.

Great food, ambiance, and service. Love that they make their own homemade ketchup and mustard too, and that you can sit indoors or outdoors depending on the vibe you're going for. read more

Food was good limited menu sat indoors I think most folks sit outdoors for better ambiance.

Good pub-type food with nice outdoor seating. 4 of us went for dinner around 7pm on a Sunday. The inside is pretty run-down looking but the outdoor area, where we sat, is nice and shaded. They have a good assortment of local beers on tap and in bottles/cans. Two of our party ordered burgers (Birdsall burger and Smash burger). Both said they are good, straight-up burgers, cooked just right. They really liked the fries. Another person got the reuben. Again, it was good and she said the fries were great. I tried the special pork belly sliders, three small sliders on nice, soft potato buns. They were excellent. I also got the beet salad. It was very large and had lots of goodies. The service was very attentive and the prices seemed reasonable. All in all, thumbs up for Birdsall House. read more

Food is great and fun, casual vibe. Especially like Eating outdoors when weather is good and listening to music. read more

We ate there on Sunday 3/8 at the recommendation of my son in law. When we first walked in I was surprised at how dark it was. It was so dark you could hardly read the menu. The food was really good. We shared a quesadilla and a grilled cheese brisket sandwich. I'd go back just to have that sandwich again. When I went into the ladies room I thought omg when was this last cleaned, I mean really cleaned, like with bleach. It was old and in disrepair. So much so that when I went to use the soap dispenser it literally fell off the wall. I was disgusted. I couldn't help but look around when I went back to my seat. I was seated at a table for 2 in the dining area across from the bar. Along side of the wall where we sat was a decorative wrought iron divider. It has probably never been cleaned or dusted. I took my cloth napkin and dragged it across the base of it and the napkin was full of dust. The booths across from us were also dirty. The floor was dirty. Even the bottle of windex on a table leading out to the beer garden was dirty. They need to hire a cleaning service to rip that place apart and do a deep clean. It was a filthy restaurant. read more

Amazing food, attentive service and artsy atmosphere. Great find for a road trip. Highly recommend both the beet salad w the date purée and the best Reuben sandwich and fries I have had in a while. read more

Birdsall House - Beet Salad - Venues & Event Spaces Near Me - Peekskill, New York

See all

This place is a gem!! Great service and ambiance. Menu is vegan friendly. Definitely will dine here again! read more

See all

I like this place. Nice outdoor seating and great service. My beet and quinoa burger was so delicious and the fries were yummy. The house made ketchup was a refreshing change as was the house made mustard. You MUST try the house made pickles too--really really good. Overall a very pleasant luncheon experience. read more

Birdsall House - Beet and Quinoa Burger - Venues & Event Spaces Near Me - Peekskill, New York

See all

The bread pudding. Enough said. To add to this review - this is a hidden gem in Central Valley. Fresh ingredients and good, friendly service. Small space, so call ahead for reservations! read more

Birdsall House - Bread Pudding on 8 October 23 - Venues & Event Spaces Near Me - Peekskill, New York

I think that was the best burger I've ever had.... will be back. cocktails were delicious and creative, service was great, outdoor patio was delightful. 10/10 read more

The service was very good and helpful. The food in general was good and had nice flavor. One rare burger came out raw. The other rare burger was fine. I had the roasted pulled chicken sandwich. Which was really tasty. The chicken wings were flavorful and had a nice smoky flavor. The sides and sauces accompanied food nicely. read more

Due to covid, the outdoor section was available for dining! There's plenty of seating and spacing between the tables! The wait staff were light hearted and friendly (also we'll had face masks while serving). Bathrooms were also open to customers. They also have a touch less pay option! Scan the bar and pay on your phone. We had just finished backpacking for 2 days and were ravished. We thought the burger and cubano were FIRE. Ask for your fries well done and you won't be disappointed--crunchy with sea salt. The burger was cooked perfectly and had nicely pickled jalapeños and onions. Foos was prepared quickly d service on point. read more

See all

Food was great. Had wings and the beet salad. Beautiful looking dishes. Service? Not so good. read more

Likes: Some of the bartenders are so chill and fun to talk to Beer is always rotating and they often have really solid sour and gose selections, albeit only a few compared to the huge IPA array Fries are a hefty portion for the side and can be shared Bocce ball out the side yard is my fav Dislike: Only one women's bathroom stall Sour beers always kick first Idk who thinks giving ONE quesadilla to a group of 20 dart players is sufficient food.. STOP BEING SO CHEAP!! All the other dart home games offer ample food but this places blows on hospitality in that respect read more

Birdsall House - These sours got a homegurl litttt - Venues & Event Spaces Near Me - Peekskill, New York

A good place to meet for lunch. One of us had a burger, two of us, the Reuben. Delicious. We didn't imbibe in the craft beers, being a work lunch, but I guess that is a big part of the allure. They also have an outdoor space for dining Al fresco. That's a plus in my book. http://birdsallhouse.net read more

Wow! Best Reuben sandwich I have ever had. Flavorful meat, outstanding kraut/slaw, tasty bread, not at all greasy or overstuffed. The smash burger was also absolutely delicious. It's rare to get such good food in any restaurant. Love the wooden booths, beautiful bar and frozen in time vibe of the place. read more

Came on a Sunday with a 12:30pm reservation for brunch. The wait time to sit and get our food was very decent and reasonable. There's a bunch of vegetarian options and some that can be made vegan. I had the beet and quinoa burger which came with a chive goat cheese spread on one bun and honey mustard on the burger, arugula in burger, and fries on the side. This burger was amazing and one of the best veggie burgers I've had in such a long time! The cries seemed hand cut and so fresh! Love that the ketchup and mustard are housemade!!! Also, the sloop (no) pumpkin IPA was amazing and I highly recommend! Would definitely come here again when visiting this area! read more

Birdsall House - Beer 8oz - Venues & Event Spaces Near Me - Peekskill, New York

See all

My friend and I visited Peekskill for the day and decided to have lunch here. It was a beautiful summer day so we opted to sit outdoors in the lovely backyard. There was a nice crowd already outdoors but it was still spacious and comfortable at our table. My friend ordered the sangria and I played it safe with a ginger ale. LOL. I did try some of my friend's sangria which looked better than it tasted which was just OK to me. The waiter was cool and attentive and we had no issues with service. My friend ordered the Birdsall Burger and fries and I had the Buttermilk Fried Chicken Sandwich with sriracha mayo with a mixed salad. We both enjoyed our meals and didn't leave anything on our plate. The bathroom was clean and we both enjoyed our overall dining experience. read more

See all

Well Happy hour not as advertised ! Only 6 beers ! Nothing else and no food as advertised when one looks up HH ! The beer we ordered at the bar which is the only seating for HH was good read more

I want to like Birdsall House more than I actually do, like Robert Pattinson's Batman. And as the movie does, Birdsall House takes a thing I like a whole lot and changes it for no apparent reason into something I enjoy less. For example, I love a good burger. BH has a specially seasoned brisket blend that intrigues at first bite, you kind of enjoy a few bites afterward, then quickly tire, wishing it just tasted like a regular burger. I think even their ketchup is some sort of "artisan" seasoned not-quite-ketchup. Half the menu is burgers, so, if you're sick of the meat blend...ah well... The buttermilk chicken sandwich is good and spicy, but there's something I struggle to put my finger on there, too. I think the gripe is similar- the sauces and seasonings take too much away from the meat and therefore become the focus. Same with the mac and cheese. You can tweak a good thing and it's still good, but there are limits. The nachos are great. Here, unlike the burger, I think the brisket in the chili is a welcome addition. But then again, chili is meant to be incredibly spice-heavy. Don't get the wrong impression, I eat here quite a bit and don't hate it. I appreciate unique flavor profiles and food creativity. But I don't need to be bludgeoned by it in every dish. If you're a proud parent and want to show me a picture of your kid, you don't have to tape it to your knuckles and punch me in the face, you know? To beat a tired analogy into the dust: Some people love Pattinson's weird take on Batman. I somewhat enjoy the movie, but have to be in the mood. read more

Amazing find. Found this place on Yelp after hiking on bear mountain. It was amazing!!! I strongly recommend it. read more

See all

It's like walking into a dirty antique store. Nothings been cleaned renovated or replaced in 50+ years look up to the skylight and see pieces of siding and roof and a little sky. Nice waitress food was decent cheeseburger was ok wings crispy read more

Probably would not have stopped in if we hadn't looked on Yelp for a place for lunch. From the outside, it looks like a dive bar. We went in and sat outside because it was such a beautiful day. The list of beer on tap is great. They have beers I have never seen before and I went with a smoked beer. It was sour and Smokey. Very different and delicious. For lunch I had the New Yorker which has porter glazed onions, white cheddar and pickled jalapeños. I added some applewood smoked bacon as well. The onions were sweet, the cheese mild and the jalapeños had a slight bite to them. A great burger. It came with fries, which were fantastic and home made ketchup and mustard. The ketchup was a little sweet for my taste but the mustard was fantastic. A grainy honey mustard. We asked if it was available to purchase and the server said no so we would have to come back to have more. My wife had the Beet and Grain Burger. The side salad she got was fantastic. The burger was mushy and didn't have very much of a taste. She covered it in the delicious mustard but wound up only eating a quarter of it. You win some you lose some. The rest of the experience was a win. read more

Birdsall House - New Yorker Burger - Venues & Event Spaces Near Me - Peekskill, New York

See all

ALways a great time at Birdsall! thank you for being around so long. always have a nice time sitting outside with my mates on a summer night. One night I saw a fried bleach witch I hate here sitting at the booth and I dumped a drink over her head and ran away to the waterfront. read more

Love grabbing a drink here, kitchen is open late too which is a huge plus. so many beers on tap. Also convenient because it stays open till 2. Bartenders are extremely friendly. I've heard burgers are good and my chicken quesadilla was fantastic last weekend read more

Excellent salad and an outstanding steak sandwich. And Kevin the bartender took good care of us.