Amazing food as usual! Staff is always Friendly and personable. Best pizza in Natty! Nothing else compares!

The pizza was excellent any just as ordered. Excellent volume of toppings. Sevice was friendly and helpful.

I had some high hopes here and found them to be higher than they should have been. The Buffalo Wings were good. Baked with seasonings and topped with a good heat sauce. Cooked with a little char from the high heat oven House Special Pizza was good but nothing super special. Had some good flavor with a bit of weird after taste. Perhaps the pre-cut onion & bell pepper was the culprit but not quite sure. Didn't have much spice in the sauce but the pepperoni/sausage combo was spot on and just the right amount of cheese. Thought about dessert but opted not. Overall I like the amount of toppings to the fresh made pizza but the lingering after taste needs to go away. Better to use the fresh sliced toppings for these pizzas. Pre cut just doesn't have the same flavor. read more

Peggy's Homemade Pizza - Six Piece Buffalo Wings - Pizza Near Me - Natchitoches, Louisiana

See all

Dine in area is ratty and broken down. Seat cushions are torn. For homemade, the pizza, calzone and sauce is mediocre at best. Not sure why the calzone had a butter taste rather than authentic Italian flavor. read more

We ordered via delivery service. Got 2 large cannibal pizzas. Cost via Uber eats was $96.87 for 2 pizzas. We ordered from Peggy's because of high reviews. Was a mistake, as the pizza was not very tasty/favorable, and it was dry and bland tasting. The crust was not very good either. We ended up eating only one of the pizzas that evening. One positive, it was delivered quickly and arrived hot. Just was not what I was expecting. Maybe others will like it! read more

The food was awesome!! Ashley was super nice!! My middle son said it was phenomenal!! read more

See all

OMG!!! Our first time to visit Peggy's and it was fantastic!! The service was excellent and the food was outstanding. We had the cheese bread with garlic and spinach with marinara sauce... One medium Canibal pizza add bacon... One small shrimp, onions and pineapple....don't judge until you taste it!!! Oh yes extra cheese!!! Just see the pics and know they taste as good as they look!!! Will definitely be going back!!! read more

See all

Pizzas were off the charts fabulous again this year for our annual NWLA Basket Makers Retreat. Best pizzas EVER!

We were in Natchitoches for a few days and decided to try Peggy's on our first night. The pizza was amazing - quite possibly the best we've ever had. Pizza is actually cooked in the oven the entire time - not steamed in a bag like chain pizza restaurants. The crust was fantastic. The restaurant itself is a quaint little place, and the waitress was very friendly. We liked it so much we went back a few days later to try the lasagna. It was a hit, as were the triple chocolate cheesecake and the cherry cheesecake. read more

Ordered from the web a few nights ago and finally finished up all of my food today during the Superbowl. For starters: the ordering process was very easy on the web. No issues whatsoever. We ordered some cheddar and mozz cheese bread with jalapenos. It was amazing. The edges were crispy, cheese was a little burnt, but it was great. The bbq chicken pizza was cooked well, plenty of cheese, wish there had been a bit more sauce. But there was a ton of chicken. We also ordered a heart attack pizza with alfredo sauce. Also very good. A ton of bacon. Again wishing there was more sauce though. Lastly the stromboli, ordered with mushrooms, sausage, and banana peppers. Easily the star of the entire order. Bread was cooked very well. All ingredients were plentiful. Highly recommend eating everything the day of while it is hot, due to the lack of sauce - it does not reheat well and cold it gets very dry. Maybe having a cup of marinara to add or douse in ranch would be good. read more

Peggy's Homemade Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Natchitoches, Louisiana

Great hometown pizza! Love the cheese sticks and variety of pizzas! Highly recommend.

Amazing pizza! Cooked perfectly with tasty toppings that exceeded my expectations. I will definitely be coming back to Peggy's on future trips to Natchitoches! read more

Go, just go! Looks like a house, seems a little off, just trust it! The food was amazing and the service so was so good! It's a super small place, but they are in the kitchen making magic happen. Only complaint is that I'm miserable leaving the place because they fed me so much! read more

See all

The staff was absolutely GREAT, and the pizza was awesome. They gave us a wonderful dining experience. 5/5

The pizza was one of the best I've had! Ordered right before closing and didn't expect this. Fresh ingredients. Delicious crust! Cooked to perfection! read more

Best Pizza in natchitoches! Pizza so good! You want to slap your momma! * Caution when you slap your momma run, run . Pizza that good! read more

Tried the mozzarella & pepperoni cheese bread and the Meat Market pizza with extra cheese, extra sauce, & extra jalapeños. Definitely one of the best pizzas I've had!!! read more

Peggy's Homemade Pizza - Meat Market - Pizza Near Me - Natchitoches, Louisiana

absolutely fantastic pizza and service here! we loved it! Great service and the pizza was amazing! read more

Peggy's Homemade Pizza - pizza! - Pizza Near Me - Natchitoches, Louisiana

Set up in what looks to be a residential house but the food is pretty great. Only other pizza I prefer other than johnnys

Excellent pizza! Perfect combination of crispy and soft crust. The waitress was so kind and helpful. Love this spot! read more

Peggy's Homemade Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Natchitoches, Louisiana

Finally got to try out this small pizza joint. I was not disappointed, it was great! Although a small joint they were busy the entire time time with so much traffic coming in and out to pick up pizza and it looked like they were making deliveries as well, as well as the tables inside staying 50% occupied. The service was good and the pizza was great. We ordered the heart attack and was allowed to substitute the red onions for pineapple. We also ordered one to our liking, a small calzone, and to start it all off an appetizer of mozzarella, spinach, & garlic breadsticks. Everything was good. Really enjoyed the crust on everything! Toppings were fresh and plentiful. Also it self serving soda/tea bar with refills!! Can't wait to go back and try some other items read more

Peggy's Homemade Pizza - The Heart Attack (Alfredo sauce with chicken, bacon and pineapple. The pineapple was substituted for the red onion. This is the 12 in pie. - Pizza Near Me - Natchitoches, Louisiana

See all

This place was amazing! It was super packed and took forever for our food. But.... Most of the electricity had been knocked out in town due to horrific storms that had come through the night before. It's not a large restaurant but it was obvious they were doing everything they could to accommodate everyone. They pizza was well worth the wait! read more

Didn't know what to expect....everything was GREAT!! Jennifer and team did an exceptional job. PIZZA, SALAD and CINNAMON STICKS all freshly prepared and delicious!! I had either the Cannibal or the Meat Market and added jalapenos, purple onion and garlic!! read more

The pizza is great if you like classic, old school parlor pizza. Not much for atmosphere but you aren't going there for that. You're going for good, inexpensive pizza and they have that. read more

Quaint place yet amazing pizza!! We were traveling through and looking for dinner - kid friendly options but not fast food. Thank goodness for yelp! We had two half and half pizzas: the New Orleans and Mommas favorite and the kids Cheese and Pepperoni. Crust was perfect amount of crispy and soft, toppings were a perfect balance, I've never had shrimp with Cajun seasoning on a pizza ... they got this right! Oh and the salads were fresh. We would definitely go back, even my parents were impressed with the food. Parking is slim but if you're towing a trailer and a RV there is a bank with a huge parking lot just across the street. By the way, we had left overs and it was finished the very next day at the hotel instead of the free breakfast buffet!! read more

Peggy's Homemade Pizza - Medium Cheese and pepperoni - cut into squares! - Pizza Near Me - Natchitoches, Louisiana

See all

I've passed this place countless times; the building is easy to miss. Brought the family for dinner. Calzone, Salad and pizza were all delicious. Individual sized pizzas offer plenty for one. Friendly staff and pleasant little dining room. read more

Peggy's Homemade Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Natchitoches, Louisiana

See all

Always great!!! Top shelf homemade pizza that has just the right amount flavor and toppings!!

The Perfect Pizza! I was stopping on my road trip for gas and food. This place is conveniently located off the interstate. The service was superb and the pizza delicious. I got the "Poor Man" (wish the name was different) yet it satisfied what I was looking for a pizza with a small amount of toppings and good price. I will definitely eat here again. read more

Peggy's Homemade Pizza - Poor Man's pizza, had to eat them photograph - Pizza Near Me - Natchitoches, Louisiana

TAKE-OUT TAKEAWAYS: 1. Sweet, no-frills, mom & pop with a big take-out business. 2. Unusually high topping psi coverage of almost 90%, see my pic. 3. Fountain drinks have unlimited refills. 4. Unfortunately there is no combo deal. So, given that a small iceberg salad with a few tomatoes is $4, my personal 8" with drink was over $15 before tip. read more

See all

This best place in a small town this would be above average in any city but this is where it is.

Peggys pizza is THE BEST. We've been here several times and the food is always delicious. The servers are great, clean place. The food takes a while to come out but that's because it's made to order with actual humans making it in real ovens with real ingredients. It's well worth the wait. No fake food in microwave ovens here!!!! Love Peggy's pizza! Will ONLY come here for pizza craving!!! read more

Get the calzones or the strombolis!!! My friend and I visited my boyfriend and he took us to Peggy's to eat. We looked over the menu, but pictures on Yelp showed delicious pictures of the calzones. You get three toppings of your choice in the calzone/stromboli. I don't know if it's written in the menu but adding an extra topping is 75¢. I got pineapple, Canadian ham, onions, and mushrooms in mine. Delicious. We were confused about the difference between a Stromboli and a calzone; basically it's the shape and the crispness of the shell. Strombolis look like a giant hot pocket and are super crispy. Anyways. The staff was SO friendly, and the food was piping hot - you could tell it was fresh made. Don't come here if you're in a rush because they hand make everything (therefor takes a while), but this was an amazing restaurant. read more

Peggy's Homemade Pizza - 1 Stromboli, 2 calzones. All three are 8-in. - Pizza Near Me - Natchitoches, Louisiana

I didn't really know what to expect when I decided to try out Peggy's...but it was cozy little pizza place that met and exceeded my expectations. From the outside (and inside), it looks like an old house that has been converted into a restaurant; however, it wasn't cramped or awkward like some who attempt this type of make-over. We sat in a booth close to the door and were immediately greeted by our waiter. In typical fashion, I asked what the crowd favorite was (and what he likes). He offered some suggestions, but they weren't anything uncommon. I decided to go with an 8" calzone. They offer both an 8" and 12" versions and also offer both whole wheat and regular crust. I went with a regular 8", and my dining companion ordered an 8" whole wheat Stromboli. Both were great! The calzone came with melted butter on the crust which gave it a nice taste. It was also crispy, cooked well, and the toppings were generous and fresh. I was so full that I saved half of my calzone for later (glad I got the 8"). If you are wondering the difference in the calzone and Stromboli, see my pictures. The waiter was very friendly and helpful. We enjoyed our time and we're well pleased with the experience. If I were a local, I'd definitely add this place to my rotation. Good place for families, and they have enough space to move tables together for groups. Happy dining. read more

See all

This was such a treat! Best pizza I have had in a very long time. We had the Hawaiian and the I'm Hungry. Both were just amazing! Fresh pineapple covered the Hawaiian and the cheese they use (part - skimmed mozzarella ) was perfectly melted. Everything on the I'm Hungry was fresh and although it was loaded the crust supported it. Service was friendly! Highly recommend!!! read more

Peggy's Homemade Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Natchitoches, Louisiana

I just want to say that my first experience with this place was totally amazing!!! We ordered the "I'm Hungry" and OMG it was soooooo good. I mean, if you are hungry, this will knock that feeling right out the door. It was just the right amount of everything. Looking forward to trying another of these great pizzas. read more

Been here a couple of times. Good service, great pizza and a casual atmosphere. Seriously, the pizza is spectacular. No beer or alcohol is served but you can BYOB. Beware tha 12" pizza or calzone is enough to feed two people. Any time I'll be in town I'll make an effort to eat here. By the way, you must ask the guy at the counter what a small cannibal is.... read more

Best in town! Flat out. Thanks to the Beaudouin's. Hey wait, that's not Italian,? lol. read more

It seems that I've eaten pizza all over the Midwest and South, and most pizza is generally adequate. There are times when my taste buds catch a flicker of excitement like when I had Pizza Luce's in Duluth, Davanni's in Minneapolis, Damgoode pies in the Little Rock area, and Square Pizza in a Kansas City suburb. For some reason, I'm thinking Lawrence. Nevertheless, I have always lamented to my wife that we are unable to get good pizza in the Shreveport area. They are improving as I think Rotolo's is pretty good, but I want pizza that leaves an indelible mark on my psyche. I want a pie that will brand its excellence on my mind. I think I found one of those gems in Natchitoches. I never imagined I'd find that place essentially in my backyard. The place was recently relocated to what used to be a residence. It's nothing fancy, but I'm never looking for fancy. I'm looking for food. The thin crust surprised me as there was an outer crust to hold. Apparently, they curl up the edges to make a nice handle. The toppings were of excellent quality and were in a nice ratio. Ever have the pizza with too many olives? It can have a deleterious effect on you. I was satisfied with just pizza, but the family wanted to try the cinnamon sticks. Never have I sampled such a treat. The dough is folded, so there are actual layers within the breadsticks. The outside is crunchy while the inside is toothsome. Very satisfying as you dip them into the icing. I tend to be critical of the food I eat, whether it's at a restaurant or if I beat myself up the rest of the night because I get distracted and cook my steak medium rare instead of rare. (That really raises my hackles.) Peggy's is easily one of my top 10 favorite pizza restaurants. We are still in town, so we might swing back for some more cinnamon sticks. read more

Peggy's Homemade Pizza - Pig out pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Natchitoches, Louisiana

See all

I am in town for a business trip and try to eat as locally as possible. Peggy's had a great selection of pizza for the meat lovers and the vegetarians! I ordered Mama's Favorite Breadsticks. They are layered with cheese, artichokes, and tomatoes; the perfect combo! Not too much cheese and perfectly garlic-y. I also got the chicago-style, which was spinach, mushroom and garlic. Again, it was the perfect size for one person, thin crust, and cooked to a browned perfection. This is a great place to support your local vendors. They are super nice and helpful, and even have a dine-in area if you want to get out of the house/hotel room for a while. The swinging kitchen doors create that mom-and-pop feel while you can see the owners in the back. They offer pizza, pasta, breadsticks, and salad. I would highly recommend stopping! read more

Peggy's Homemade Pizza - Mama's favorite bread sticks - artichoke, tomatoes, garlic, cheese - Pizza Near Me - Natchitoches, Louisiana

See all

I visited this restaurant based on other great Yelp reviews. I was not disappointed. I ordered the New Orleans pizza and from the first bite with cheese stringing as far as you could reach it was really very tasty. On another trip I had Peggy's Supreme and it was also very good even if slightly over cooked. Not fancy but comfortable for a few people. They are open late while many restaurants in downtown close after lunch is over. Prices are reasonable. read more

Peggy's Homemade Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Natchitoches, Louisiana