Did I have the best lobster I've ever had in my life, here at this spot? Why yes, yes I did. Our family we were staying with lived just down the road from this joint, and they let us know that we could not leave until we came here. It's exactly where you would want to get your seafood from: out of a tiny shack right by the water, enjoyed on a picnic table. Maybe I'm getting better at my lobster-cracking, or these were a lot easier to eat! I was told that they have soft-shell and hard-shell lobster. With the platter, you'll also get a large ear of corn, dinner roll and cole slaw. And lemme tell ya.... It's A LOT of food!! But you can get it by itself or substitute sides, as well. I'm so glad we got to come here to mark 'eat a Maine lobster' off of our list. I can't think of a better place to do it!! read more

Pemaquid Seafood - Seafood Near Me - Pemaquid, Maine

See all

Pemaquid Season was Excellent! Do yourself a Favor and visit this restaurant during the season they are open! The Seafood platters were a nice size portion and Fish was very fresh! Would definitely visit again!!! read more

This is a super lobster joint! Tucked away in pemaquid there are plenty of picnic tables on the picturesque lawn. Service was quick enough and we never found it overcrowded. A summer stop for sure. read more

Pemaquid Seafood - Lobster with dog - Seafood Near Me - Pemaquid, Maine

The site is nice and the view from terrace exceptional. Lobster has become so crazy expensive now, that we chose other foods. Apparently they allow BYOB as the table beside ours had wine bottles, but only sodas were for sale. read more

Fresh seafood! Wow and so much of it too! Our friends invited us to join them for lunch and it was worth the 1.5 hr drive! YUM. It was so serene sitting outside. The menu is pretty straightforward - a lot of fresh seafood available - I chose the haddock sandwich - It was a FULL haddock filet that makes the full size bun look like a tiny dinner roll. LOL! Definitely a fork and knife sandwich! It was so fresh - no fishy taste at all. For a few that were with us, that weren't feeling like seafood that day, they had a decent cheeseburger and a massive cheesesteak sandwich. Both were satisfied with their meals as well. The view of the ocean from the outside picnic table area is so peaceful and beautiful. The way the wind was slightly blowing made it so quiet too. The eating area was packed, yet you couldn't hear others talking. It was amazing. There are two bathrooms outside - not port-a-potties but outhouses with plumbing. They were fine, but the person in front of me was gross. Not the restaurant's fault at all. I highly recommend this place if you are in the area. If you have a larger group for a special occasion, call ahead, you might be able to reserve some tables. Not guaranteed, but worth a shot. read more

See all

Killer seafood. It's where locals eat and they serve an 18" long lobster roll made with fresh local lobster from the Pemaquid area. read more

See all

We very much like coming to Pemaquid Seafood. The food is consistently excellent and priced Ok. The outside picnic tables offer a great view of Pemaquid Harbor and the fort area. There is no service to speak of, as you order at the register and pick up yourself. The only negative that I can think of is that it can be crowded at times, and Like all Maine restaurants, it closes too early. Oh, and it's BYOB. read more

Great Lobster Roll. Not sure why it takes so long to get through the line to place your order. I think we were about 45 minutes in line behind maybe 6-7 other orders, Food came out fast enough once we ordered and it was excellent! The lobster roll was viewed by some as better than McLoon's or Red's. I would say it is very comparable to McLoon's but Red's is still the best. Seating and views are tremendous. Parking is easy enough. The staff is very friendly and since this is a BYO type of place it's pretty convenient to pack up a few items and set up a picnic. Bring refreshments and a friend to keep you company while in line and you won't mind the wait. If you're in this area you definitely will want to experience Pemaquid Seafood. We will be back often for sure! read more

Pemaquid Seafood - Big lobster roll - Seafood Near Me - Pemaquid, Maine

Wow! We have been eating Maine seafood all our lives and I can truly say that these folks do it right! Nice light coating, perfectly cooked, very fresh, not greasy seafood! The Captain's Platter was perfect for 2. The coleslaw was good, the staff were excellent, even the free water was good! We will be taking rides down there again! read more

See all

We visited this restauarnt again and soon learned the cupboards were bare of their desired fare. Why you might ask? Seems Auntie was not in the mood to make the clam chowder that morning and they were currently out of crab salad. In spite of departing in a huff and a puff we could not bring this lobster shack down. read more

Pemaquid Seafood - picnic tables with a view - Seafood Near Me - Pemaquid, Maine

This is the best seafood restaurant on the peninsula! I've been multiple times and have never been disappointed! All of the seafood is fresh and delicious! The cashier is always patient and kind when helping you place an order! Besides the amazing food and service you cannot beat the ocean views! Can't wait to go again next year! *Keep in mind- it's BYOB and a seasonal restaurant* read more

See all

Pemaquid Seafood is a hidden gem. The restaurant is in a beautiful location on a hill above the bay. The seafood is fresh, local and delicious, and much cheaper than better known places. The counter person who served us was a retired lobster fisher who was friendly and welcoming. Almost all of the plates in the parking lot were local, which says a lot. And they let you byob. I've been looking for an old style seasonal spot like this for awhile. I found it. read more

Great, fresh, well prepared, clean seafood in a classic scenic Maine location! Friendly staff! read more

BYOB. Fried haddock dinner is large enough for 2 people. Ask them to skip the roll, totally unnecessary and store bought

I had single lobster dinner. It came with cabbage, bread, corn. Lobster was good, fresh, and delicious. I wished the lobster was bigger, though (compared to other lobster places I've been to). The outside seating was great and had a great time. read more

Once again, Pemaquid Seafood does not disappoint! The chowder is the best we southern New Englanders have ever had. It's literally the standard by which we judge all others against. The staff is always so nice and quick witted, love it! Tradition to kick off our week vacation in the area is dinner here the first night, followed by purchasing lobsters for my birthday on the 4th. Every year we leave with love in our hearts for the family that owns Pemaquid Seafood, longing to return again next year! read more

Pemaquid Seafood - I devoured it! Beautiful way to start vacation! - Seafood Near Me - Pemaquid, Maine

Came here after a sailing ride for dinner. A big parking lot with indoor seating and outdoor patio seating. The outdoor seating overlooks the harbor. The restaurant is a little dive-ish and do not expect anything upscale, but the people and service are awesome. I ordered the lobster dinner that came with corn, a roll, coleslaw, and butter. The lobster was good, but nothing that totally amazed me. For the price, I think you could get a better dining experience elsewhere. read more

Pemaquid Seafood - Lobster dinner - Seafood Near Me - Pemaquid, Maine

Came near the end of the season on a foggy day and walked right in. Had some good old fashioned, authentic waterside seafood. Best oysters I had this trip. Our crew of 4 enjoyed clam chowder and lobster bisque, a lobster roll, steamers, fried clam strips and more. Not fancy, hit the spot, as good or better than any place further south. read more

See all

Fun experience with our friends eating our deliciousness overlooking the River/ocean. It's beautiful and peaceful to sit and watch boaters and people enjoying the water. The place is big enough to sit our party of 10. Their service was great, server answered all our questions regarding daily specials as seafood options. I tried their Pemaquid oysters with simple horseradish, hot sauce and lemon juice and it was so fresh and delicious I was a little hesitant to share with my friends jiji. But hey! I needed them to experience what I experienced eating these fresh oysters as well. I was told these oysters are special because they're grown where the fresh water meets the salty ocean so they have a different taste than other oysters....it was great! I also tried their blueberry mojito, it was tasty minty, not too sweet and not overwhelming with alcohol which was great because we still needed to finish a hike afterwards. read more

Pemaquid Seafood - Pemaquid oysters - Seafood Near Me - Pemaquid, Maine

See all

Top lobster roll of our weekend lobster roll crawl. Views, phew. Our roll was $50 but massive. The foot long roll was chock full of briny sweetness. The steamer dinner was so tasty!! The place is clean and service flows efficiently. read more

Great atmosphere looking out over the bay along with the freshest lobster possible. Nothing fancy that's the point.

Fabulous boiled lobster for a very reasonable price. For $2 extra we upgraded to 1 1/2 pounders. BYOB which we forgot. The view of Pemaquid Harbor is incomparable. Highly recommended! read more

Fresh, delicious seafood. The quality was even better than some other places we tried locally. Lots of outdoor seating making it great for the kids. The portions were also huge, I shared a combo platter with my 2 kids! Would recommend going early because it does get busy with lines forming out of the building! read more

Not the best for seafood. Lobsters came out sooooo watery, way more water than I've ever had. Also oddly salty. Steamed clams were not cleaned prior to being served so they were very gritty. Fried fish and fries were just meh. Place was slammed when we got there. Nice views otherwise food isn't worth it. Also byob. Went here cause we've been going to shaws for the last 30 years and wanted to try a new place. Wish we went to shaws. read more

One point off the bat for the beautiful setting. The food then takes us the rest of the way. I was feeling peckish so I got a lobster roll and a crab roll. Both excellent. I could really taste the freshness of the seafood. Bonus: massive pile of addictive chips with both rolls! read more

Pemaquid Seafood - Crab roll and lobster roll - Seafood Near Me - Pemaquid, Maine

Amazing. BYOB. Great view. Can get crowded and hard to find a table. Sometimes parking is overloaded. But it's all well worth it.

I really want to give this place more than a 2 star rating. Their location is stellar. However, we ordered two blackened haddock sandwiches and they were so incredibly salty we couldn't even eat them. We aren't able to eat fried foods so they offered us this option which sounded fine. We love blackened seafood but the salt content was over the top! The 2 stars are for the yummy coleslaw and the view only. Bummed. read more

After Yelp research, we decided on the 45 mins drive to Pemaquid Seafood. Boy, was it worth the drive (5miles) from Boothbay. We stopped at Hanley's market (gas station) to pick up & dined al fresco. Seems like a local spot (w occasional NJ/NY/MA tourists. We got in at 5 pm, ordered entirety of their menu and was not disappointed. Large roll was delicious w toasted roll and lots of lobsters little Mayo. Lobster stew was buttery creamy and chunks of lobster bits. Oysters were fresh, wish it had some variety to choose from. Beautiful spot near the lighthouse; would recommend more than any other touristy area. read more

See all

We stopped here on a Sunday in June while we were in the area, going to see the lighthouse. They have a good amount of parking available, a large outdoor space with picnic tables and umbrellas and a great panoramic view of the harbor. Their menu is what you'd typically expect: chowder, lobster, lobster rolls, and various fried seafood dishes. The prices are reasonable, staff is friendly, place is clean and there were a good amount of families enjoying. We got the fried clam strips and fried seafood platters. They both came with French fries and hone made cole slaw. The cole slaw was clearly home made and wasn't out of a jar or soaked in mayonnaise, which I appreciated. The meals were fresh, good, well seasoned and crispy - everything you'd want and expect from a good seafood spot with fried seafood and lobster roll offerings. It wasn't amazing or out of this world, and there isn't anything extraordinary to note, but it's a decent spot and we enjoyed. read more

Out of the way but hidden secret. Great prices for lobster dinner and onion rings. Lobster and corn steamed when ordered. Nice view.

Excellent seafood. Bought the scallops from them and they were flavorful and fresh. Would go there for all my seafood needs.

Great lobster, great views. Very low key. Order at window and pick up. BYOB. Reasonably priced.

Great seafood and beautiful location. A little hard to find but worth the effort. Will be coming back whenever I'm in the area

A great, casual spot for getting your lobster fix. We were lucky it was a really nice night out or the crowds would have all been inside. Thankfully we were able to use their many outdoor, shared picnic tables for our lobster dinner. Food was tasty and quick. Views are fabulous. It is BYOB, which we didn't realize until we got there, but wasn't a problem. read more

See all

Delicious local caught fish and lobster! No frills, all delicious! The Fried Haddock was incredible read more

Oysters were fresh and awesome Lobsters are very fresh Chowder was unique but not for me Everyone else enjoyed lobster read more

We are refugees from perhaps the more notable and touristy lobster restaurant on a dock in New Harbor. A once impromptu encounter with a local at the 'Seagull Shop' on the point, we learned about Pemequid Seafood back when it was a co-op. This quaint and somewhat spartan restaurant has a kinda 'cult' following and is located off a pleasant neighborhood drive to a location that overlooks Pemequid Harbor high up on a rise. As native Mainers' residing 68 miles inland...other than price, the food and service for the 'Shore Dinner' is the real draw. Add in the BYOB, and the fact they are pet friendly as a well mannered 'Fido' is always welcomed when dining 'Al Fresco' makes for an overall delightful experience. We typically Lobster dine 2-3 visits a season and in the last seven seasons have never been disappointed except on one singular occasion when they were closed on a Wednesday arrival. read more

The best place in coastal Maine for lobster with outside tables and great views. Took the grandkids this week and they loved it.

Almost afraid to give it 5 stars - want to keep one of my go-to lunch stops quiet and uncrowded. But must admit, food is very good and reasonably priced. Lobster roll is as good as Reds and cheaper. Fried haddock sandwich is yummy. It comes plain, but they'll add lettuce/tomato/onion if you ask. Setting is beautiful and serene. I could hang here all day just looking at the water. read more

Look at my photo and you'll see that this is the best lobster roll and sides imaginable. Other offerings just as good (not the fries). Site is spectacular, service very good. As to the 2017 comment about the corn, what sort of person would order corn in early June and expect it to taste like anything? The prices are fair for the quqlity. I know a guy who catches crabs locally that go into the crab rolls. read more

Pemaquid Seafood - Giant lobster roll full of knuckle meat (the tastiest), home made onion rings and potato chips. - Seafood Near Me - Pemaquid, Maine