It's great pizza minus the crust. I wish they had a more traditional crust, but it's just too buttery/greasy for me. The toppings were great, good flavor and cheese, I pretty much liked everything but the crust. It's too bad, I probably won't be back. I do appreciate what they're doing here though. Just not for me. read more

Sat outside on the patio with the intention of watching the Falcons game. Sat down, TV was not working. A guy (who may or may not have been a server) came out and looked at it and said something about the cord being unplugged. Looked at us, then walked back inside. We sat for about 5 more minutes waiting on either the TV to work or someone to bring us water, a menu, or even acknowledge our presence. Nope. Got up and left. TV on patio was dirty anyway, probably couldn't watch anything on it if it was working. This place is a neighborhood joint that obviously doesn't care to do anything more than the absolute minimum in effort. Bummer. read more

Pizza was burnt when delivered through UberEATS. We've ordered from here before and they've been hit or miss. read more

Pepperoni’s Tavern - Burnt cheese pizza - Pizza Near Me - Alpharetta, Georgia

See all

Great fluffy pie. I live in NYC but visit my parents down in GA often. This place makes me not FOMO over NYC pizza. Kudos to this join, will be back~ read more

I was there with my husband a few days ago, and today I was checking my account and I got 2 charges for different dates and different amount, that was my first and last time going to that place, be aware, and ALWAYS CHECK YOUR ACCOUNTS! read more

A multi-faceted restaurant with so much to keep anyone you're dining with you; your spouse, the kids, or your buddies. They have a pool table, dart boards, Keno, and plenty of TV's. We ordered to the lemon pepper and thai curry wings and an order of fries. Not only would I return for the specialty pizzas but I would head back for is the lemon pepper wings. The waitstaff was very friendly and attentive, so that's a plus :) Always a pleasant experience. Thanks Bob! ... read more

Best pizza I've had in a while. Wings were outstanding as well. Came the other day with a big group from work and we received excellent service. Strong recommend read more

great food but 90 bucks for 20 wings a few mozzarella sticks and a large pizza? what a price gouging rip off for bar food. read more

This place exists for the sole sake of lack of dive bars and or bars in general in the Alpharetta area that arent high class, fancy or overpriced. Great for drinking away sadness, anger and or other types of drinking if they exist. read more

I have been going to Pepperoni's for almost 15 years. I went there with my wife this past weekend. It was as consistent as it was from the first time I went in there years ago. The cheese loaf is really good and the pizza is the best to me. We have not found a better and more consistent place than this. We will keep making the 15+ mile trip to support them during the pandemic. We also are doing it because we LOVE their pizza. read more

Amazing food. We drove over an hour to come here and it was worth the drive plus to kids. Lol He pizza was cook perfect and topping were amazing. The wings were order x x x crispy and they could have not been cooked any better. Thank you for always keeping it the same. read more

I came here 3 times for lunch. Their pizza is great and they have drink specials. No one at my table complained about their food.

Decided to give Pepperonis another try. Still not a great place. I realize all the homesick Michigan folks are rabid for this place but this southern girl is unimpressed. The seating and decor are nice but they have raised prices and you will now pay $16 for nachos. Now these are not your ordinary nachos. They have no real cheese, just that fake orange nacho cheese like you get at a high school game. But the fun doesn't stop there, they put OKRA and GARBANZO BEANS on your nachos along with enough iceberg lettuce to choke a horse. They do leave out the meat, however. Not one bit of any meat on them. This culminates in a pretty nauseating dining experience. Top this with far off games dominating the screens even when UGA is playing Tech (you know, the biggest game in our area). We actually left at halftime to go to a different place. read more

Went out to Lunch yesterday and was very impressed with the food and the staff was very friendly/attentive/helpful. Will definitely visit again. read more

Mmmmmm....good pizza. Crust was chewy, thick, and a tad crisp on the edges. I got the personal pan pizza and still had a ton leftover. I liked how they had more of primo toppings and didn't charge extra for it (ie sundried tomatoes and artichoke hearts). The "small" salad is huge. Big enough to split between 2 people. It also comes with a side of bread which was a pleasant surprise. Definitely a bar-sy sort of vibe. Not really my scene, but I'd order pizza on the go here. read more

I play poker here. They have a really good Italian Sub. The spaghetti is decent and you can eat off it for two days. The wings and fried meatballs are good appetizers and the pizza here is good. read more

Do not do the specials....Ordered Italian beef....YUCK! Cowboy beef jerky...extra dry, ajus was salt water and cold. Cone for the game and beer. Forget the food they have gone down hill to the valley below sea level. Need to hire a new cook. read more

Right around the corner from where I live - walking distance already gets a positive note from me! The ravioli appetizer was great! I also love that their patio is pet friendly - can't wait to visit on Sundays for the Cowboys games ;) I wish I liked their Martha's Vineyard salad (it sounded so good!) - but my husband thought it was okay. read more

I have been living in Alpharetta for over 16 years, I really wanted to tell everyone how pleased I have been with Pepperonis. They have the best, freshest pizza anywhere. I have met the owner and he seems to be very focused on using only top quality fresh stuff and I can tell as I have never had a bad meal here ever. I enjoy the game atmosphere and the old fashioned tavern-style bar. If you want a nice casual place to relax and have a meal and a drink this is the place. Sincerely, D. Wilk read more

Great Food! Even better pizza!! The people have very nice and it has a very comfy feel! Everyone is always into da games! Great Place!!! Can't wait till Saturday to catch the Michigan Michigan State Game!! So come on out and enjoy some football!!' read more

Pepperoni’s Tavern - The Bar - Pizza Near Me - Alpharetta, Georgia

Tried this place out last night. I ordered their tavern burger and It tasted like (old, tasteless & soggy) cardboard so I couldn't even finish half of it. I get home and I'm having severe stomach cramps. I've been up all night, sweating and using the bathroom. If this is something you would NOT like to be doing on a Friday night I recommend you to not go here. read more

I went here for a late-ish dinner last night. It was perfectly fine. We were seated immediately and had our choice of tables, which I liked. It was a tad on the loud side, but that's to be expected at a sports bar. I ended up getting the Martha's Vineyard salad. I think I finished half of it. It was tasty, but no different than any other blue cheese, nut, & lettuce combo I've had before. Unlike what was mentioned in another review, I didn't find any zing to it. The bread they brought out was tasty. My dining companion was a little unhappy that they didn't have his first choice beer on draft, but it didn't seem to be that big of a deal. If you really want a wide variety of beers, that's what Taco Mac is for. It was a hair over $30 for two of us pre-tip, so reasonable for a dinner out. read more

I'm having mixed feelings about doing this review. First of all, Pepperoni's is where I go if I want a quick drink with the gang after work. What knocks the rating down to 4 stars is that the service depends on where you sit. If you sit at the bar, you have all the attention you could ask for. Fast drinks and never waiting to be served. This was my most recent experience. Sometime last year was different, however. Same server, different vibe. I was in the dining area next to the bar this time where it was a little harder to find the bartender. Overall, they have decent Shortie specials, the food is good (house salad is massive), and from my last experience the service was better. Like I said, if I need somewhere to go grab a drink, this is the spot. Tip: expect smoking after a certain hour. read more

Best food and service. The staff are amazing and it's the place to go for football and most games. The cheesie bread and wings are my favorite. Most of my friends and family now ask to come here when they visit. Been coming here for ten years and always will until they close! read more

Good food, try the grouper sandwich, and nice people.

The Great White pizza has been my favorite pizza ever since I grew up going to the Duluth Pepperonis location. Best pizza I have ever had. We drive to this location now just to get it. What a great place to take the family. Eat at Pepperonis! It is worth every penny. read more

Stopped in to get something to eat after working 2nd shift on a Monday night. They were one of the few places open that wasn't fast food. I was pleasantly surprised. I ordered a pizza to go and had a couple of beers while I waited. The was some very lively karaoke going on as well as the Chiefs/Rams Monday night football game. Nice crowd for a Monday. The very busy bartender did a great job keeping up with everyone. My pizza was good, nice crust and plenty of toppings. I'd like to have had a little bit more pizza sauce on it but I'll know to order it heavy next time. I'll definitely give it a second try. read more

I've actually lived in the area (Georgia in general) for 5 years now but never tried this place out until last night. The pizza tastes good. It reminds me red Barron's rising crust frozen pizza only 75% more expensive. Which is great because I love paying more for items that taste frozen. The crust was definitely thicker than I thought - I thought it'd be more New York style. Cute place tho, nice people, I can see it being a chill place to dine out. No qualms but sort of nonplussed As an updated note after reading the hidden secret vault of real-deal reviews, I am horrified. read more

Probably the worst dining experience I have had in the last ten years, no joke. Service awful, our dinner came before our appetizers after we ordered them. Oh and dinner came 40 minutes after we ordered it. My kid got spaghetti and I swear the sauce (if possible) had gone bad. Our food was clearly all from the frozen food section. Guess it must have been hard to unthaw... Anyway please never go here. I went 9 years ago and it was a decent place, not sure what happened. read more

Having visited twice now I can give Pepperoni's two thumbs up! The food is delicious, the staff is friendly and just the right amount of attentiveness and it's open late! I have visited with my husband and a small child as well as a larger group and both times we've had nothing but great food and service. We've tried the pizza, salad, burger, fried mozzarella appetizer and fried ravioli appetizer. The salad was fresh, well chopped, the dressings were homemade and was great to share with the table. Both pizzas were expertly prepared and great even for leftovers! The black and blue burger was perfectly cooked and just the right amount of blue cheese. The appetizers were crispy and enjoyed by all. You'll be seeing us again! read more

This is a great place to go and watch a game or play some trivia. They have tons of tvs and a great staff too. I really like their bread sticks and pizza as well as their salads. We'd also had their spicy chicken sandwich which was good and their sausage sub. All in all, the food is good and the atmosphere is fun so we like it. It's not too expensive either which is a plus and the menu selection can please most anyone. We will definitely be checking out some UGA football here in the fall. read more

Their pizza rocks! And they make an amazing cannoli! I always get the fire roasted veggie pizza, and they put really cool toppings on there like artichoke and broccoli. The crust rocks. It's got oregano and garlic....mmmmm.....one of my favorite pizza places, but it's not cheap! read more

We tried to get into Pasta Vino, but there was a long wait and there was nowhere to stand and wait except outside (where it was 29 degrees). We had the kids with us, so we decided to venture out to see what else might be open down the road. This is how we ended up at Pepperoni's Tavern. The hostesses told me they could seat us right away and they were very sweet. Our waitress was really nice and attentive as well. The menu is sort of all over the place. It takes a while to read through it and figure out what you want to order. I am not really a fan of deep dish pizza (coming from Chicago, this is a sin, I know), and I was glad to see that you could order a thin crust if you wanted. I ordered a basic chicken sandwich with teriyaki sauce, pineapples and Swiss cheese. It was decent, but nothing mind-blowing. The fries were my least favorite part of the meal, as they were the battered kind that taste overly processed and artificial. I am hopeful that this trend will pass and restaurants will one day go back to serving basic french fries, but it's not happening soon enough for my liking. The kids had pizza and it was good, but nothing out of the ordinary. My wife ordered the potato skins and they looked decent, but again...like every other time we've ever seen potato skins. The value was the best part. The price for our whole meal came to less than $40, which was a great surprise. Overall, PT works in a pinch and the service is really great. The food is sort of average and expected, not bad in any way (other than the fries). We weren't wowed by anything, but didn't have any complaints either. read more

Came in on a weekend for lunch. As soon as we stepped in it smelled of an ashtray and spilled beer. Gross. The only reason we stayed was to try the wings. My husband loves wings. The wings were dried out and appeared to have sat for awhile before coming out to our table. We had ordered fried pickles and raviolis as a starter. Both came out hot/warmish but not crispy fried like you want fried pickles or raviolis. The waitress couldn't provide a beer or wine list and couldn't tell me what kind of wine they had???? I can honestly say we'd never go back. So so gross. From the smell to the food. There are so many other options, save yourself the time. read more

Love, love, love this place!! We go here at least once a month & would go more often if we lived closer. We always get a pizza with the parmesan crust - sooo yummy. And despite what a previous poster wrote, it's *not* deep-dish pizza. It's a standard thickness crust/pie. One of our fav toppings is their black forest ham. Really good. For starters, we like the onion rings (tasty dipping sauce), the cheese &/or garlic bread selections, and the fried meatballs. Their cheese sticks are good, but you can find those anywhere. I would avoid getting the potato skins (dry & not very tasty at all). When my mom goes with us, she always gets a salad & raves about it every time - can't recall right now which one it is. I've always had good service here. Drinks are refilled often & the servers check back to see how things are. Request for management (if you read your Yelp reviews): pls, pls, pls go back with restaurant.com. Was so sad to see you dropped out of their program last year. :-( Or at least offer dine-in coupons somewhere! :-0 read more

To me when you hear the name Pepperoni's you think "their Pizza must be great!" But their Pizza is not their selling point in my opinion. I've been a regular there for nearly three years and just can't get into their pizza. Their wings, calzones, lasagna and burgers, fish sandwiches are their selling point for me. I also like the friendly servers and ambiance. So there is enough there to keep me a loyal customer a long time, along with their monthly specials to switch things up a bit. If they made pizza that appealed to me, i would have given 5 stars. read more

I've been coming to this great establishment since the day they opened. Great food, great T.V. setup for multiple games, and an all around great atmosphere with a very friendly staff. read more

Pepperoni’s Tavern - Pizza Near Me - Alpharetta, Georgia

This is a great little sports bar that I consider something of a hidden gem in Alpharetta. Pizza and wings are always amazing! My boyfriend is from upstate New York and he says the food reminds him of back home. The decor is a nice change from the usual "all UGA all the time" you get in a lot of sports bars... Plenty of TVs if you're there to catch a game. I've gotten take-out a couple times and dined in a couple times, and service has always been relatively quick. No complaints from me! I wish more people knew about this place! read more

Pepperoni’s Tavern - Large pepperoni pizza. Can't go wrong with this! - Pizza Near Me - Alpharetta, Georgia

People are friendly good prices unlike the hell hole taco mac across street. The pizza is good the beer is cold it is,a Michigan bar though. Yikes read more

Pepperoni’s Tavern - Pizza Near Me - Alpharetta, Georgia

Came here with a family friend and their kid who goes to UMICH for a gameday. It felt like a sports bar on a college campus. Everyone was into the game. The atmosphere was family friendly and still intense enough for diehards. The food was great we ordered a pizza and the crust is unmatched with how soft yet crisp it was. A couple people have said the service was lacking and while it wasn't the greatest it certainly wasn't THAT bad. I give the servers some leeway because the place was packed. They were constantly moving and obviously trying. If I went on a slower day I'm positive that the service would be top knotch. I will return to see some more gameswith my family friend and hopefully will get to see their kidon one of the many bigscreens. read more