My wife and I had the pleasure of dining here Saturday to celebrate my nephew's engagement. We started our delicious meal with chips and salsa. Good chips and decent salsa. I had Sierra Nevada pale ale and my wife had a Ciderboys bottle. We ordered 2 large pizzas and they were on point. My wife ordered half shrimp and sriracha. I ordered half pine and swine. Very good choices. My nephew ordered half chicken gouda and his lovely fiance ordered pesto. All four of our choices were served to us in a timely manner with great taste and the crust was amazing. I've enjoyed this location several times and look forward to trying either a sandwich or one of their other delicious pizzas. read more

Pies & Pints - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

I've been to this location twice now. Each time the service was great. They have a great beer selection and I loved the unique pizza options. I got the grape rosemary pie with vegan cheese and a balsamic reduction added really good. If you're wanting a basic meat pie maybe consider somewhere else. Everything is pretty unique. Would recommend. read more

Pies & Pints - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

I used to loving eating at pies and pints. Their food use to be great. I haven't had their pizza in while. So, I order their pizza yesterday and boy was I disappointed. their pizzas were terrible.Pizza was paper thin, burnt you couldn't even bit into it. It was so hard. i could have gone to Marco's pizza instead,way cheaper and better quality pizza. Sad to say, but we will not be going back there. read more

grilled wings are good but the pizza pies SLAP !!! many to choose from or create your own. one can even do two different pizzas in one (half & half). solid craft beer draft selection. so many to choose from !! read more

I will have to say that the experience at pies and pints varies. I've gone at times and had a great experience and not much so others. I have gone there, and they put the sauce on top of the pizza, and other times it was underneath. I've had the wings where they were cooked right and when they were still raw in the middle. When the moon has aligned just right with the other planets in the solar system, this place is pretty freaking awesome. I love how they cook the wings with that crisp crunch you get when you bite into them. The savory flavor is on point, and they are still quite juicy when you order them to be cooked well done. The pizzas are pretty good when they have prepared the dough the way it's supposed to be prepped. You can tell when it's been sitting around longer than it's supposed at times when you get that pizza with the crust that hasn't quite risen. The sauce and the cheese combination is fantastic when paired with their savory, chewy crust. Service has been pretty good here for the most part. I had one bad experience where my food wasn't prepared right and the server just looked at me like, "What do you expect me to do about it?" read more

This was my second time at this location. The food tastes good but it is sooooo sllllooooowww. This time our server was training someone so I should give her some leeway but it was still pretty slow. We sat down and started by looking over the beer list so we ordered a round of waters. About 5 minutes later the trainee dropped off the waters and we didn't see anyone for another 5-10 minutes. When the server made it back around we saw that as our window so we ordered everything at once. The three of us each ordered a beer then we got the chicken wing app, a small spinach salad, a Cuban pizza and a Hot Mamma pizza. The beers came out right around the same time as the wings. I'm not sure if that means the beers were slow or the wings were fast. The wings only come in one flavor and it's more of a rub. They were really good. There's a sauce on the side might of been ranch but I didn't try it. The salads come in two sizes and we ordered the small but it was still big enough for the three of us to split. We went with the balsamic dressing instead of the other option and it was really good. The pizzas were really good too. I thought the Cuban was spicier than the hot mama. The pepper on the hot mama had a little kick but they weren't too bad. They reminded me of jarred/canned peppers. The jalapeños on the Cuban gave that pizza some extra spice. If I was just going off the food I would have given 5 stars. I just can't believe how long it took both times I was there. read more

We ordered food via Door Dash - had to be cold when it was picked up because it was delivered timely. Pizza was cold. Potato skin pizza looks like it was from last night. When I called they were rude and hung up on me. read more

Some of the best pizza in Columbus, great service and awesome beer selection. The atmosphere is open and bright and just had an upbeat feel to it. First and foremost the pizza is amazing. Absolutely full of flavor with unique toppings from unique craft/gourmet pizzas my wife and I love to simple cheese and pineapple pizza that our daughter loves this place cannot be beat! This place is worth making a long detour to check out. Let me take a minute to talk about the service. My wife, daughter and I used to go here a ton (we haven't in a while for no particular reason we are excited to go back) and the service is A+. We often have Donna taking care of us (not sure if she is there anymore) and she immediately remembered our daughters name and was so engaged. She works her ass off and is just the sweetest lady. Our daughter actually asks if we can go back to see her! If Donna still works there please tell her Madison wants to come back soon! Much of the 5* review is because this plays has managed to hire awesome people that work hard and create a cooks atmosphere. Like most things in life, it's the people that really make the difference. More restaurants should focus on that like this place. The beer selection....amazing. One of the best I'm Columbus. This has become one of our favorite places and I'd definitely recommend stopping by! read more

We visited for the first time yesterday, and we really enjoyed it. The caprese pizza was amazing and the service was very friendly and prompt. read more

Sit at the bar and have Robbie serve you. There is no better bartender in Columbus. I know it's a pizza place but they have one of the best Italian Hero's around. Reminds me of the one that Flatiron had so many years ago. It's loaded with meat and the bread is crunchy and delicious. read more

Pies & Pints - Italian Hero - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

Tried their street corn pizza -different than anything I've tried before and very tasty! Beware it's somewhat on the spicier side with the jalapenos. They have a Large selection of very reasonably priced beers! The one drawback is they don't accept reservations. Went outside of the usual dinner rush (9pm) and still had to wait 45 min for a table. Otherwise would return again! read more

In my opinion, slightly on the pricier side for pizza but you do get what you pay for! Delicious NY style pizza in a great location!

Really good pizza though. I want more of it, but I think sometimes maybe I eat too much pizza. Our service was excellent as well. It's the Hot Momma or however they spell it, it's really good. Man, are they still open? I mean like right now? I had a salad for dinner because of how much pizza I eat but now I just want pizza because I'm still hungry. Maybe I'm just destined to be overweight and then die before my time. Is it better to live a life of gluttony that ends too early or live a life of moderation that isn't as fun but lasts longer? Which is better? Can someone please tell me? I NEED TO KNOW WHETHER TO ORDER A PIZZA OR NOT IN THE NEXT TEN MINUTES. read more

Yum! I was in the mood for pizza and came across this place in my search. We ordered takeout and were super pleased with our experience. The time they quoted us was accurate and the food was hot and delicious. We ordered the pine and swine pizza, the chicken Gouda pizza , and the spinach salad. Everything was incredible. I will be back next time I'm in the Columbus area. read more

I must say this place is big and open and clean! The pizza was delicious! The beer variety On tap was great! The only reason I didn't give it four stars is I spent a whole lot of money for a beer and pizza. Yes, it was delicious but all in all very overpriced. read more

Pies & Pints - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Major Yikes. Place was dead, server sat behind the bar chatting with another server and rarely checked on us. No drink refills (went to the bar for a second beer), brought out pork nachos (with no pork on them) 35 minutes after ordering the app without plates or napkins. Food was good, service was a -5 out of 5. Will not come back to this location. read more

Tried to order a pickup order on the phone in a Sunday evening and first got put on hold for six minutes. Gave up finally and called back in and was immediately put on hold again for 5 minutes and then gave up. I then went in and the place is 3/4 empty so not sure why no one could take my call. Then I was told by the host to go to the bar to pace my order. Then the bartender gets to me and I tell her I want to pace a pick up order and the en she has to go get a server to take my order! Why all the extra steps. Then I have to wait 40 minutes for my pizza and salad. End result is I won't be placing a pick up order here again. It's obvious this location doesn't have the leadership or infrastructure to handle a simple phone order. Morning like having to spend over an hour to just get a pizza and salad. read more

And this is how cheese on a pizza is supposed to taste. We often forget that in our run-around busy lives full of merely good pizzas from quick joints all over town. But when you go to a gourmet specialist like this Easton stop, and you have that first bite you remember what you miss. My dinner mate and I clashed on our choice of pie. So we compromised and went with a 16", half Hawaiian and half garlic mushroom--garlic being my favorite spice in the world. (You could cajole me to kill a wife-beating husband for a good garlic mushroom flatbread.) The garlic mushroom had pizazz, yet delicately balanced perfectly it was soft jazz in my mouth. It's a swoon inducing serenade of ingredients. Other than the aforementioned feta, the portabellas are roasted so rich; they have a couple different textures which adds a variety to the mushroom music. It has caramelized onions that hits the top of your mouth making harmony with the mushroom/feta melody. Olive oil and a host of herbs back up the trio with the freshest chords. The crust is done well too. I am not a fan of pineapple, but that half looked as well done as mine. I brought home leftovers; so pineapple or not I will eat it for breakfast. That's how good the cheese is. As other have said the place offers lots of beer. The menu for it is a binder bigger and better done than many business plans handed to bankers. They have something of any craft you desire. Our server, Jazmen, deserves a hardy shout out. Great service, so friendly and bubbly; she knew her stuff. My friend is still in the brew dark ages, a pagan at the altar of Bud Light. Jazmen attempted to proselytize the gospel of the IPA. She handed out serval samples to us both. I settled on a nice one. As for my friend, failure, didn't like. I guess, like the saying goes, you can bring a friend to top brew but you can't make them drink. Great place! I agree with most of the reviews below. read more

See all

Love their pizza. It's one of the best pizzas in Columbus,Ohio. The staff is always super friendly. Highly recommend trying the Chicken Gouda Pizza! read more

Went in on a Thursday at 545 for happy hour, patio was packed but plenty of tables inside. Service was quick, draft and bottle beer selection was great! Tried the Victory Twisted Monkey, fruity and sweet, but not too sweet. Recommended doing the beer flight. read more

Pies & Pints - Twisted monkey draft - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

Went for lunch, our first time there. Being senior citizens, hubby and usually split, which we did. Got the Italian hero, with side salad. Pleasantly surprised that you can do a smaller version of any of their salads. Food was fantastic!! Waiter was very friendly young man, working on his stand up routine, he was funny! We will go back!! PS plus we each had a beer, great selection and the bill was under $30!!!! read more

chicken gouda pie is so good! i always order some chargrilled hot wings along with it. If taking out to eat, then make sure to put the pizza and wings in the oven for a little bit so you can thoroughly enjoy it, otherwise you're not doing it justice. Service is always great here. read more

Our first visit to Pies and Pints. We were ignored when I asked if we could have a booth instead of sitting at a table under the big white elephant. I had my six year old with me, so it appears to me we were placed in the kiddie section as the other patrons in this area also had infants or young children. No prices on the menu! Garlic bread was tasty, marinara was meh. My youngest and oldest ordered a pepperoni pizza they both ate their entire pizza so I guess they enjoyed it. I had the steak sub, meat was delicious, tender and juicy. My daughter ordered the Cuban sandwich. They were out of pork, so she opted for chicken. I ended up trading her sandwiches as the Cuban was extremely spicy due to the sliced jalapeño peppers. Chicken didn't cut it. Their Cuban is not a traditional Cuban, I don't recommend it, might be better with a beer. Draft root beer was good, we ordered a pitcher, cost $12. They don't serve it with ice, be prepared to go through it quickly with no ice. Over all not bad. Wait to get entrees not horribly long, but it could be a substantial wait if there were more customers. Restroom cleanliness and deodorizing needs improvement. read more

See all

Great beer, very cold! Great service, smile included! Incredible beer selection. They even have cider. Nice, quiet, good samplers too. Tried Seventh Son and loved it! read more

Pies & Pints - At the bar! - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

The chicken gouda was tremendous. Pine and swine was ok. And the brownie was to die for honey

So far...so bad......waited at the hostess stand for 7 minutes with no one even acknowledging us. Finally, a lady comes up and (rudely) says there is a 40 minute wait .. even though there are tons of empty tables. Must be short on servers... So whatever. We asked about sitting at the bar and she said yes go ahead... There were seats there for us. Bartender says "hi" tosses some menus at us and says she will be back. Just waiting on her to get back so I can order a drink. .....so far not thrilled with things, but the hubby wants to stay and try the food. Will update with how it goes. Lol... Just watched a male server and the same rude lady that told us we could sit at the bar have a discussion about some customers that must have just seated themselves. He said he will not serve them because they did that. Well...... It's prob because they got tired of waiting to be seated by a hostess. Hmmm....and the rude lady might be the manager... Will have to find out! read more

The one at easton here in columbus ohio very clean very friendly. Patio is very nice.

Hands-down, best pizza place in the area! We got the mediterranean shrimp pizza and created our own cheese pizza with roasted mushrooms. They literally pack on the toppings, it's wonderful! I didn't get a chance to take a picture of what we got because we started eating it so fast! The reason I'm giving 4 stars is because it's pretty pricy. Other than it's great! read more

Had a Friday late lunch. We received a pleasant greeting where the hostess provided a layout of the restaurant since we'd not been there before. The restaurant was clean and comfortable. Ordered the Italian Hero and a side Greek Salad. The oven baked sub was tasty and the salad fresh with just the right amount of dressing on the side. Our server was attentive and the courteous and the wait time minimal. The beer selection has nice variety and was priced appropriately. read more

Pies & Pints - Italian Hero and side salad - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

Great summertime atmosphere! Drinks were en pointe. Loved my Sangria and the dude was happy with pints on tap. Split black bean pie and classic pie. Classic was ok..... I've had better and wasn't a big fan of the red sauce..... too tart. But the Black bean pie was a win!! Tasted like Mexico on flatbread! Deliciously spicy with great balance of cheesiness. Will definitely revisit for other palatable opportunities read more

I am a huge fan of Pies & Pints. They have a fantastic menu of pizza, appetizers, salads, and sandwiches so everyone is happy. There are plenty of specialty pizzas and create-your-own. The appetizers, salads, and pizzas are meant to share - we love to do the wings, salad, and a pizza or two for the table. Service is always good but be aware that the pizzas are made to order, resulting in a longer waiting time than a traditional restaurant. A huge draw for this restaurant is the incredible draft and bottle list, as well as root beer on draft. This restaurant is nice enough to impress your out-of-town guests while enjoying a fantastic meal. They do get busy and it can be a long wait for large parties. We prefer to go early to avoid a wait. read more

I ordered a white pizza for carry out. This pizza is great! I highly recommend it. I will be back.

Easily our favorite place in town for lunch or dinner. The best of Ohio craft beers on tap and the best from around the country. Not to mention some hidden, bottled gems. Pizzas are great, of course, but the wings are the best in town! Even the salads are fresh and tasty. (Be careful, a small salad will easily feed two). The bartenders are very knowledgeable about the beers on tap and are spot on with recommendations. We're there at least once a week, if not more. Tip: If you get the grape and gorgonzola be sure to add bacon. read more

Pies & Pints - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

This was an overall pleasant experience. This is a popular place, so you may have a wait... that's the only downside that we experienced with the visit. I was with a big group so we were able to try quite a few things. I personally tried the pizza skins, Thai pizza, and mozzarella caprese. The flavor profiles danced on my tongue. The pizza skin is moderately self explanatory - the potato portion of the skin was mashed, but the rest was standard - bacon, sour cream, scallions. My order was made vegetarian for our table (bacon on the side), which made it a little bland in my opinion -- this is obviously not a fault of the restaurant. Although a little bland, I still really enjoyed it. My FAVORITE: the thai pizza. The flavor palate was SO complementary. The best part, it was just as good the next day as a lazy day brunch. The shrimp was cooked to perfection, and the sauce was flavorful while not being over powering. I really enjoyed the caprese as well. I love caprese salads, so I was extremely excited to try this one. It delivered exactly what I wanted: a solid flavorful pizza -- shockingly not my favorite of everything I was able to try, but definitely good. I would enjoy ordering this again. There's one weird thing about this place: the staff..... they're all gorgeous! They offer fantastic, attentive service too, but man are they attractive! Happy dining read more

Noon on a Saturday, only a couple tables even have people seated with the vast majority being clearly open and we are forced to wait. Won't expect this place to be open much longer if they can only seat 2 tables at a time. read more

Pies & Pints - Just a couple of the many empty tables while we wait to be seated even though the place is empty. - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

We originally wanted to check out Melt-but with a 45 minute wait, we opted for this place. The server wasn't able to make suggestions for a beer on tap. The Cuban pulled pork was amazing, I'm allergic to jalapeños (forgot to order without them) but i pulled them off the sandwich and it was so good, I didn't want to trade with my husband (my mouth was getting numb and tingly). Worth it. My husband and daughter seemed satisfied with their pie and sandwich. Nicely decorated and a lot of suggestions for beer, just wish our waitress would have paid more attention to her tables and had more knowledge on the beers and menu items available. While it was good, compared to similar restaurants, it's a little overpriced. read more

Pies & Pints - So many goodies on top. - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

It's taken way too long for me to try this place. There's been so many pizza places popping up in Columbus that I just pushed this one to the way side, saying I'll get there when I get there. I knew there was one opening in Short North soon, so I figured I'd just wait for that. Luckily, my buddies suggested checking it out after our hockey game on Sunday, and I'm very glad we did. Without realizing it, we had them seat 6 of us 20 minutes before close and felt really bad, but they were more than welcoming when we suggested going somewhere else. Everyone that helped us out was very friendly. The place itself is clean and new, and the taps at the back of the bar all lined up in a row looked very sleek. I was pretty excited when I saw they had sour ales on tap and ended up getting a Flemish red ale (I think it was Duchesse de Bourgogne). It was so good. On top of that, I ordered the Hot Mamma pie, which had large pepperonis and their special hot peppers on it. This actually turned out to be one of the best pizzas I've had in Columbus. The flavor was awesome, and the crust was cooked perfectly with a perfect ratio of light and chewy. I had a 10" pie to myself struggled to finish it (and this was after playing an hour of hockey). Everyone in my group seemed to really enjoy their pizzas as well. If I'm at Easton, I'm definitely coming back and bringing friends, because this is a stellar pizza joint. It's made me all the more excited about them bringing a location to the Short North. read more

Pies & Pints - Hot Mamma - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

I enjoy Pies & Pints, but on my last visit I was a tab confused. I ordered a pizza and like most Midwesterners I asked for ranch. The server that I had said they didn't have ranch in the establishment, but said the pizza came with it's own kind of special sauce. I was a tad confused, but for a moment I went with it even though I found it hard to believe that they wouldn't have ranch. I then saw someone with a salad, that seemed to have ranch. Now, if the server just wanted me to try something different I can understand that, but as a patron, if I want ranch, just give me some ranch! I still haven't figured out if they have ranch or not. If someone finds out let me know lol. But seriously if they have ranch someone please tell the server it's about what the customer wants and nothing else. Also, you have to get the New Holland's Dragon's Milk. Best beer around read more

I want to love you, Pies & Pints. My visits here just always leave something to be desired. The food: The rosemary and roasted garlic flatbread appetizer is my favorite. The flatbread is served with warm goat cheese and a balsamic drizzle. The portion size is great, and they do not skimp on the goat cheese. I've tried the Pine & Swine and the Cuban Pork pizza. Neither tasted that good to me. The Cuban pork was a bit too spicy because it was loaded with jalapeños. Both pizzas lacked toppings and flavor. Maybe I just haven't found the pizza for me yet? They do have a good beer selection. The atmosphere: My bf and I have sat in the same area each time we have come here. There is a seating area by the bar. Seats on one side of the tables in that area are very close to the bar. My bf's chair kept getting bumped by servers and patrons trying to walk through to order a beer or deliver food. It was really annoying and took away from our experience. There was constantly someone standing right behind him for the entire meal. I'd be willing to wait longer for a table in another area. With the extremely long waits at dinner time and a mediocre experience with food and atmosphere, I'm not sure that I will be back to this location. This might be a good place if you are already in the area, but I definitely wouldn't drive across town to get here. read more

Pies & Pints - 10 inch mushroom garlic pizza - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Very cool atmosphere and amazing service! I ordered the Caesar salad and a piece of the Classic pizza. They were both good. I like thin crust and that's exactly what it is. Overall good place for a small group to get together and split food! read more