Pies & Pints in Ohio delivers excellent customer service and a great atmosphere. The staff is attentive, professional, and clearly grateful for their jobs. Their attention to detail is perfect across the board. The pizza and beer match the Fayetteville, West Virginia location exactly -- same quality, same flavor, same experience. Other restaurants should pay attention. This is what pride in ownership looks like. This is how you run a restaurant. Great job hiring such inspiring individuals, and thank you for the outstanding service. Pies & Pints in Ohio delivers excellent customer service and a great atmosphere. The staff is attentive, professional, and clearly grateful for their jobs. Their attention to detail is perfect across the board. The pizza and beer match the Fayetteville, West Virginia location exactly -- same quality, same flavor, same experience. This is what pride in ownership looks like. This is how you run a restaurant. Great job hiring such inspiring individuals, and thank you for the outstanding service. read more

Pies & Pints - Barkside, Ohio - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Kyler and Sherri were more than friendly and accommodating to my time there. Great conversation and warmth from them was more than enough. Will be back definitely. The Nashville hot chicken Pizza was delicious and their Cheesecake was perfect to cool the spice of the Zaa. read more

Pies & Pints - Cheesecake with a dark chocolate and raspberry drizzle. - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

This was our first time eating in the restaurant. Good experience, love the customer service. The pizza was pretty good, it had an authentic taste to it. And the ciderboy strawberry cider....pretty...pretty good Highly recommended read more

See all

The pizza is excellent, but the attitude is harder to swallow. They proudly advertise on their menu that they don't serve ranch, as if customers wanting a dipping sauce is some kind of character flaw. Not everyone enjoys pizza exactly the way you think it should be eaten. Making a point of mocking customer preferences isn't quirky or charming--it's obnoxious. Serve ranch if people ask for it and focus on making great pizza instead of lecturing your customers. read more

The pizza here is delicious! I really enjoyed the service and even the ambiance. I was introduced to Cider boys and now I'm a fan. Cider boys strawberry magic is highly recommended. read more

See all

We went there for a quick bite after golfing nearby. Had a draft beer and a big slice of pizza for only 10 bucks. It hit the spot and the server was busy, but took good care of us. read more

PIES and PINTS - the name says it all - what's not to like about a restaurant specializing in PIES and PINTS. We've been fans of this place for years and have never had a bad meal or bad service. They have a wide variety of options for your pizza, allowing you to order some "standards" or to customize your own pizza. We usually opt for a half-and-half pizza, with my wife picking her favorite for one side while I do the other side. Then we usually end up eating from both sides. They also have some great salads to complement your pizza. Our favorite is their anti-pasta salad. A regular is big enough for us to split and share. A real highlight is their selection of beers. They have an extensive beer menu - sorted by type (ales, porters, etc.) the choose from. They have a beer for every taste. They also have a great patio. read more

Loved our chill server, who enjoyed bringing hubby IPA samples and sharing behind the scenes on Black Friday (pumpkin pie for staff). We were there end of night and thrilled the kitchen was still open and our server wasn't rushing us away. Also enjoyed our tucked away booth. Really just the meal we needed. It's six weeks later that I'm getting around to writing this and still remembering the great experience. Oh! And totally appreciate the ability to order half and half pie. His & hers. Brilliant! read more

See all

Cannot say enough nice things about this place. Owner is incredibly kind and the food is great! Highly recommend!!!

Great pizza and salad. Good service. Prices are in line with today. Tipped 20%. Watch the extra 3% charge for nothing.

The pizza was great but they got our order wrong so when we arrived we had to wait an additional 15 minutes for them to prepare our pizza. We didn't dine in but I'm glad because they were in need of some additional staff to bus the tables and clean the bathrooms because they were both filthy. I'd get pizza to go again but wouldn't dine in read more

Pies & Pints - GF Sriracha Shrimp Pie - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Pizza was bomb.. "Gorgonzola" sauce... SHOE sauce. Don't ask for ranch bro ambiance was okay, I got pepperoni pizza but seriously DONT get that sauce. read more

Pies & Pints - Lg. Margherita Pie - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

The pizzas are very good! They have quick the array of beers and ciders you could try something new everytime you went and it would take weeks to get through it all. The show stopper though is the potato pizza appetizer. It's like potato skins but better. Mashed potatoes right on pizza crust topped with cheese and bacon and chives with a big side of sour cream!! read more

We visited on Wednesday 10/8/25 around 5:30/6PM. This was my 2nd time here. First off, the guy (I wish I knew his name!) who seated us is cute as a button and had the best personality- super upbeat and sweet! Second, Rachel provided excellent service! She is wonderful. Third, Eddie, the GM (I'm assuming), is a GEM! He spent time at our table chatting about their gf options w/my kiddo and I. My son, Griffin, is gf due to his autism diagnosis resulting from a medical injury. Eddie was so kind to us and I am grateful for the conversation and his goodness. We live 2 hrs away, but frequent the area for shopping and will certainly be visiting P&P time and time again! Love this place!!! read more

Pies + Pints gets it right- each and every time! We got the white pie, add mushrooms and sausage. It has a symphony of flavors and textures. The whipped ricotta adds a creamy richness, complemented by the earthy freshness of mushrooms and the perfect spice level from the sausage. Roasted garlic cloves provide a delightful burst of flavor without overpowering. Even with carry-out, it retains its hot and delicious allure. A truly satisfying pie that hits all the boxes! read more

Pies & Pints - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

My friend and I visited Columbus for the first time. We wanted to know what Columbus is known for food wise. Pizza came up and we decided that's the perfect meal fresh off of the plane. I did some research and was led to Pies & Pints. I ordered the margherita pizza as well as the wings. We enjoyed our meal. Our waitress was nice. The only takeaway is that the wings were listed as "hot wings." I didn't taste the hear. Sriracha is the sauce used in the marinade but it's missing the kick. Overall, it was a great time. read more

Pies & Pints - Char Grilled Hot Wings - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

Street corn pizza, add pepperoni or chicken. If you're a corn/elote fan this is a must order.

This place is so great. I love the friendly staff and the food is awesome. I love the wings with Sriracha. The ambiance is very cool and laid back. read more

Pies & Pints - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

We had lunch at pies and pints. I learned to not get jalapeños on anything. They were very hot. But the heirloom and street corn pizza as well as the nachos were very tasty. We do prefer our nachos with loose toppings. The baked on toppings ok. Just our preference. The service was prompt and friendly and all of our questions were answered. The music was really good and very suited to the restaurant. read more

Pies & Pints - Nachos - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

Myself and a friend, wanted to try a place we had never been before. And surprisingly I haven't been to this restaurant before. But the pizza was very good, very flavorful and our waitress was very nice. The restaurant can get very loud at time, hard to hear yourself think! But overall it was a good time, I would say the overall experience and food 7/10. I would definitely go back to try more pizza options. read more

See all

Fun environment and the food is just ok. The crust is good but the mozzarella pizza lacked on flavor. Mushroom pizza was too greasy and rich for me. We also had Greek Salad and it was very big for a small size and very tasty. For two hungry people with salad, beer, and large pizza it was around $47 so reasonably priced. read more

Pies & Pints - GF Mozzarella Caprese - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

Delicious pizza when you're looking for something more elevated than the basic chains. They have really unique speciality pies, such as the Grape and Gorgonzola one I had. I have never seen anything like that before and it was amazing. They have great vegetarian and pescaterian options which I love to see. read more

Pies & Pints - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Pizza was delicious and the service was amazing. I will definitely be back when I'm back in town.

Great pizza... We love Pies and pints. This anapasta salad is awesome. The pizza is quality and delicious. Plenty of beers to choose from and the waitstaff is always great. This is a great choice for pizza. read more

See all

Searching for the best pizza in Columbus and I discovered this isn't it! I ordered a Margherita pizza and a pepperoni and mushroom pizza via DoorDash. This order took over 45 minutes to get to me. Way too long! Neither of these pizzas were worth the expensive price tag. They are super skimpy on the toppings. In other words, they were almost not even there. I am tired of these places that feel they can just smooth some sauce on some crust and throw a handful of ingredients on it and call it pizza. The sauce honestly tasted like some Ragu out of a jar. This pizza is not worth the price tag! read more

Pies & Pints - Margarita Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

I've been coming here for years. Let me start with they have what I consider to be a unique flavored wing and dipping sauce. They are legit amazing. I'd come here if only for the wings. I love the Hot mamma pie. It's got the right amount of heat and it never gets old. They have such a dynamic menu but I don't typically stray far from the Hot Mamma. The beer selection is seasonal and extensive. They have great local rotating taps. If your style of beer is out of season they'll have what you like in a bottle or can. Any beer lover will find a great beer here. I started coming here the second week they opened and I'll never stop coming back!! read more

See all

service was slow, pizza was good, average price. the large is LARGE so if you are splitting for 2 get the small read more

Pies & Pints - Lg. Chicken Gouda Pie - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

I called Pies and Pints earlier in the week to see if they accepted reservations and they advised that they do not accept reservations - they are a first come, first serve establishment. We arrived on a Friday around 5:30 PM. We were advised that there was a 30 minute wait. No biggie. They take down my number so that they could send me a text once our table was ready. Once they took my number, we headed over to the bar to grab a drink. This is a no no. Due to COVID, you are not allowed to grab any drinks unless you are already seated at a table. Boo. Once we were seated (30 minutes later), we ordered a couple of drinks and the pork and pepper nachos. The pork and pepper nachos were the reason why I picked Pies and Pints for date night. I saw a pic that someone had posted on IG and they looked delicious. Well...the nachos were pretty disappointing. While the pulled pork tasted great, half of the tortilla chips were naked and bare. The top half of the nachos were covered in melted shredded cheese which left the bottom half covered in nothing. I think that if they used melted gooey cheese, the nachos would have been much better as we would have been able to spread the toppings around. They could also add a bit more of the pulled pork to the nachos. The pulled pork was smokey and had great flavor, but there was very little pork added to the nachos. I left the description of the pork and pepper nachos below. Pork + Pepper Nachos PORK & PEPPER NACHOS Seasoned black beans, jalapeños, cheddar cheese, salsa, scallions & chipotle crema Now, for my drink. I ordered a glass of Prosecco. The pour was weak! The bartender filled up only a quarter of my wine glass! For our main course, we ordered the special which was the Baja bean pie. We also ordered a Caesar salad. The Caesar salad was so good! It was super seasoned and tasted great to me. It was a little too seasoned for my husband. We ended up having to take 75% of our pie home. Let me tell you - this pie is not great for leftovers! We ended up having to pitch it after reheating one slice. Another BIG boo.I left the description of the Baja bean pie below. SPECIAL - Baja bean pie - REFRIED BEANS, CHEDDAR CHEESE, CHORIZO, RED ONIONS, JALAPENOS, AND BLACK OLIVES. FINISHED WITH SOUR CREAM, SCALLIONS, AND TAJIN. While the pie was not good reheated, it was freshly made and had many great flavors. I should also note that we had two pies. The first pie fell off of our table as we were just sitting there eating our first slice. The staff said that this apparently happens all the time! It was pretty comical, but scared the crap out of me at the same time! I am not sure if we will return, but I will say that they do have a great beer selection (according to my husband) and a super friendly staff)! read more

See all

Extremely oily pizza, the entire crust is soaked in oil. I tried to absorb some oil with napkins and barely finish half and I had an upset stomach the whole day. read more

Mushroom Garlic, Grape & Gorgonzola, Siracha Shrimp, Italian, Sweet Corn are all phenomenal. Love the fact that on large pies you can split 50/50 even between specialty pies. read more

Gf pies with a twist! We were determined to try all new flavors and branch out. This didn't disappoint! Elote-esque pizza?!? Sounds weird, but oh so good! Corny, creamy with a bite of spice. Yes. Papadew pizza with bacon and honey and crumbled salty? Droooolworthy. Chicken Gouda was yummy too- but the bacon seemed to burn in the cook. Compared to the other two outta the box flavors it was hard for it to compete. Thumbs up from all. read more

Great pizza and beer selection.Service very good.Huge bar.Prices in line with other pizza establishments

Pizza was amazing as always, but the service was beyond outstanding! After picking up pizzas for dinner, my car wouldn't start. Three employees came out to try and help me jump my car. While my kids and I waited a few hours for AAA to arrive, they constantly checked on me. Shout out to Miranda, Tonya, and Brendan for being amazing humans! Pies and Pints is lucky to have you as employees! Thank you again from the bottom of my heart! read more

First time this location and we sat at the bar. It was late afternoon on Saturday and there were a lot of staff on for few customers. I figured they would be busy soon, and they were. I got a bottle of Rose for $21 (by the glass is $7). The bottle was given to me in a chiller, which was perfect. They do have a large selection of drafts and give samples upon request. My boyf chose Rogue Honey Kosch. I ordered the House Salad with added marinated shrimp, and house vinaigrette. They seem to be gorgonzola crazy on their menu (not for me). The salad was good, especially with the shrimp, but there were too many pieces of iceberg core and I hate that. I set them aside and wished for more greens. I got a White Pie with added roma tomatoes and pesto. The pesto is a premium topping. In reality, it is only drizzled atop the pizza. The pizza was fantastic, and the leftovers over the next few days were still flavorful. This will probably be in our rotation in the future, but I will stick with the pizza. read more

*This was a pre-COVID visit. The smell is the first thing that greets you when you walk into this hipster style pizza place. It's quite delightful. The decor has a sort of industrial feel with all the metal. The draft list is exemplary and they have some sort of program that allows you to see how much is in each keg. It's not really sure what the benefit is to that. Maybe beer tastes different depending on the part of the keg it comes from? Decent bottle selection too! The nachos and salad that we ordered were on point and very tasty. The presentation wasn't bad either. It was quiet on a Sunday afternoon in late October. We were the only ones seated at the bar for our entire visit. Next time I'll try out the pizza! read more

See all

We went there for the specific reason that they now carry a great Portuguese beer called Super Bock; they are the only place in about 400 miles that does! It was amazing! The pizza was great and the staff was super friendly! We will go back! Cheers! read more

So glad I found this place on Yelp! My family and I were in the area and figured this place got really busy on a Friday night for dinner, so we made sure to come early (around 5) and got a table right away. The only problem was that our waitress wasn't in yet, so we did have to wait a little while to place our drink and appetizer order. We did get the wings, which totally have a different flavor, but my dad and my husband loved them. We also ordered the cheese bread, which the kids loved, a regular pizza, and then 2 GF pizzas. The GF pizza is really good, not the best I have ever had, but good! We also got the draft root beer - great! Seventh Sons Seltzer - tangerine is ok, but the raspberry is great! read more

Worse place ever, horrible service, horrible food. Kids plate was all cold Service took over an hour. Never coming again read more

This was our first time at Pies and Pints and we loved it! We had a big group and we ordered lots of food to share. For appetizer we had char-grilled wings and garlic cheese bread. We also had the Sriracha Shrimp, Mozzarella Caprese, Steak and Mushroom, and Chicken Gouda pizza pies. Everything that we ordered was really good. However, my favorite for the appetizer was the char-grilled wings and for pizza it was the steak and mushroom and sriracha shrimp. They were also very generous when it came to the all the toppings, including the meat. We went for dinner on a Friday night and the place was packed. Even though it was really busy, we had great service from our server. She was very friendly and accommodating. The place was nice and clean and great for group of people to hang out and eat good food. Highly recommend this place and will definitely be back! read more

See all

Great pizza and yummy wings! The team was very friendly and tried really hard to accommodate tv requests read more