Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Services - Pima Mayfair

    Property management

    Pima Mayfair Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Pima Mayfair

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    4 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Property Management 664 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Rentals America

    Rentals America

    (25 reviews)

    Richland Heights West

    We searched the Tucson area for property managers ... and found many…read more Many we wouldn't consider! Then we checked Rentals America reviews and were very favorably impressed by the positive reviews by both owners and renters. We're delighted that Charity King represent us. To paraphrase the advice for having a happy life ... Happy renter, Happy owner Ira

    I was re/searching property management companies for my first-ever rental property. I wanted…read moresomething local but also an agency that had longevity and, of course, good reputation/reviews. I recognized early that given the sheer impossibility of satisfying all tenants, or owners, no property mgmt company is going to have higher than a 4-star average. And then I came across R.A. with a solid 4+ star average. As I read through dozens and dozens of reviews (here and other platforms), there were a couple of managers themselves who stood out. One was Laina (who turns out to be a supervisor) and the other was Irene. My first inquiries (whether to retain them, what I need to know to be a good LL, and what to watch out for) were directed to Laina as I was preliminarily curious about their management style, prerequisites, and costs. I was especially concerned about the tenant vetting and application process. Laina was extraordinary - always easy to reach and never rushed me in my relentlessly probing questions. I was impressed by the guarantees and the no-commitment promise that RA stands by as well (that's confidence!). Once I had finally settled on RA to manage the house I had purchased I was fortunate to be assigned to Irene. She is meticulous, punctual, responsive, demanding, patient, persistent, and somehow still manages to accomplish all that with good nature. I wouldn't want anyone possessing less than every one of those standards to be responsible for supervising my home. She is also accessible by direct texting and email and has always responded within hours if not minutes. When I thought my house was ready to be listed Irene stopped by to lend her critical eye. I kid you not, she found 15-18 things that needed fixing, cleaning, removing, painting, or installing. And fair warning, many of those issues are deal-breakers for RA (refusing to publish my rental until they were fixed). However, their high operational standards translate into presentability. It took me, plus a hired handyman, almost 2 weeks working every evening and wknd to get the entire list finished... and it made a world of difference. It's remarkable what "you can live with" vs what is appropriately marketable. R.A. was running a summer retainer special of $599 that included all of the above and also professional photos for the listing - on par with the industry. The $99 flat fee/month for management was another selling point. There are a couple of companies that will manage for slightly less (e.g., $75/mo) and a couple that charge a flat 10% per month no matter how high the rental price is (which is ab$urd). RA's costs include two random inspections/year, the dreaded eviction scenario, and it places them between you and the tenant as the primary contact for all things - from complaints, to rent, to repairs. Once you've hired RA, you'll get a monthly newsletter and occasional articles about being a "landlord" and about market conditions in your metro area. They are loaded with helpful tidbits and illuminating graphics. Note: rent is typically due from the tenants on the first of the month but the transfer to your bank account will occur on the 10th or 11th of the month so digure how to float your mrtg payments accordingly. There is a bricks/mortar location just north of Campbell/Ft. Lowell and that was also important to me - to lend legitimacy to the company. It is modest, with basically a front desk and small office but it's staffed by a receptionist M-F from whom you can get sample documents and preliminary questions answered too. At the end of the day, property management is 30% fees/costs and 70% skilled diplomacy -- between owner/Mgmt and between tenant/Mgmt. You need to have those relationships working smoothly, precisely because of the inherent friction points that they so easily generate. In Laina and Irene RA's mgmt team does a tremendous job navigating each.

    AZ 1st Realty Management - AZ 1st Realty Management company logo.

    AZ 1st Realty Management

    (13 reviews)

    If I could leave negative stars I'd give them negative 10!…read more My swamp cooler still not working after line was flushed and they don't want to fix it. They say it's running at the specs of the manufacturer. This thing is rusted and when they switch from heating in the winter to Summer they don't take a shop vacuum and remove water deposits or the rust so they clog the tubing and they are using hoses that are too small. This has been a nightmare!! Neighbors punching my husband in the face, threatening to burn my building down having guns shot by the same woman. They don't enforce the rules they have in the lease. It says you can only have one car per residents but some of them have cars that haven't moved in years as you can see no tags since 2022 and the spider webs are growing under that car. Had gun pointed at me! I just don't want you to rent here because they never stand behind their work and we pay for upkeep on the grounds and landscaping has only been here a handful of times my husband rakes our side of the driveway and waters the plants. I had to call code enforcement right after we moved in and the cabinets in the kitchen were just rotten. Thankfully code enforcement told them they had to fix this stuff but still can't get the swamp cooler running!!! It's a simple machine that takes very little effort to fix and again still 100° in my house! They want me to move and pack in this heat and then leave it rent ready???!! I don't think so!!!!! DO NOT RENT FROM THIS COMPANY!!!

    The best property management I personally have experience! I have been with them for over 5 years…read moreand have nothing bad to say! Office personnel is so sweet and professional

    Pima Valley Realty

    Pima Valley Realty

    (12 reviews)

    Midtown

    Bridget Barry is both a bad and an absentee realtor. She sends her assistants (who seem to be…read morethrown under the bus and have no idea about the properties) to viewproperties and then doesn't answer questions over email, too busy with "clients". She fails to communicate and takes offense at renters trying to know more about the property they want to inhabit. I didn't get very far in the process because she never alerted me to the fact that they had moved on from our application. I wouldn't put it above this place to be planting fake 5 star reviews among the real 1 star ones. A shady company all around. Do not trust Bridget Barry.

    Terrible, no good and sorry excuse for a professional property management company. The female who…read moreruns things is obnoxious, lacks humility and is downright cruel. This woman has the audacity to claim that 2 residents who passed away within 24 hours of each other have "broken" their lease. How? By passing away? As far as the property goes, many issues were never addressed including leaky windows, water damage and so much more. Pima Valley is in direct violation of Arizona Renters Rights and has been reported to numerous agencies. There is a reason Pima Valley is rated so low. They are awful human beings. Stay far away from this business. Slumlords. Update 2/12/2026: The real issue with this business is Deb. Deb was caught red handed by children of the deceased residents in question discussing privileged and private financial information with an outside party who has no authority to receive this information. I have also spoken to this businesses attorney and made him aware that private financial information has been shared by Deb and that both parties cease and desist immediately. The attorney was perfectly reasonable and understood. Deb was and has always been completely unreasonable and completely ignorant to basic facts. For us this is not about the money, it is about the principle. Deb, look at your reviews. They all say the same thing. You are unable or unwilling to do your job properly. You are unable or unwilling to maintain an acceptable level/standard when it comes to business. Time to hang it up and do something else. You are destroying this companies reputation.

    Fort Lowell Realty and Property Management - After thousands in deposits and advising things need painting and cleaned, this is what I was forced to move into and what I pay $1400 for..

    Fort Lowell Realty and Property Management

    (100 reviews)

    Richland Heights East

    This review is specific to Juan Miller and Cari Rascon. Juan…read moreMiller is personable and exceptional in his work, often going above and beyond to ensure that all issues are addressed. Cari Rascon is by far the best property manager I've had the pleasure of dealing with so far. She handles all issues promptly and professionally while still maintaining a level of personability, which is refreshing. Both Juan Miller and Cari Rascon are valuable assets to the Fort Lowell Realty company. Thank you Juan and Cari for all that you do.

    I have been here at Craycroft Commons for going on 10 years now, when the property was 55 and over,…read moreno smoking, no pets. This year the property has turned itself upside down with the property manager, Ana Consuelo, the "Onsite" and tenants who have decided to mount surveillance cameras on the property. I fully understand Ring cameras and camera bulbs, but personal surveillance cameras covering the property as seen by my photos. What happened to personal privacy? All this starts with Property Manager, Ana Consuelo who does not care about the property nor the tenants living here. She has never visited the property to see how the tenants are doing. One meeting a month would be nice to see how the tenants are doing and listen to any grievances. The "Onsite", who Ana Consuelo hired, is not doing her job. The plants in the courtyard are slowly dying as she waters when she wants, as seen by my photos. I will be posting once a month on how this property is going, as I yearn for the old days. In closing, I would appreciate if management would replace Ana Consuelo and the "Onsite". Thank you... NEW ITEM WITH PICS... One of the tenants moved a pot directly in front of another tenants door. From pot to door is 15 feet. Would this classify as a fire hazard? Should tenant who moved pot be charged for endangerment? So much drama at this apartment complex now.

    New Concept Property Management - Mold in walls

    New Concept Property Management

    (27 reviews)

    We worked with this company for around 5 years, signing and most of questions about issues were…read moreover the phone with them, and it was ok, not great, then communication was thru text or emails, always unavailable to answer the phone or return calls, until recently, that a problem in our rental occurred, what they did it was very unprofessional, not answering concerns, not being truthful, telling prospect tenants in a disrespectful manner that the house was not going to be available for rent for several months, the property manager was more professional than the owners. House inspections didn't happen as expected, they only returned a third or the deposit even we knew that the expenses for damage was more. We decided to end our contract with this company. Ali A.

    RUN! Don't walk away from ANY property managed by these people. They are SLUM LORDS. They are all…read morerelated to each other and all their "contractors" (Johnny and Sons, particularly) are just handymen that work for them. I rented a higher end townhome from them in La Paloma. The house was INFESTED WITH RATS, had MOLD GROWING IN THE WALLS, and an old, decrepit AC that routinely broke down and created extremely high electric bills for me. I notified them of the sound of rats in the walls (see video) in early November, and they dragged their feet getting a guy in the attic space until January. The pest control guy said the attic was "full of rat shit". BTW, inhaling rat feces can lead to death (Hanta virus). Mold was discovered in master closet from a leak inside the wall. I had to pay for a mold inspector to come out. During remediation, rat feces and mold can be seen in the videos/pictures I'm attaching. Both my four year old son and I developed coughs and insomnia living here.. not sure if it was from the mold, rat feces, or both. To top it all off, they are now nitpicking over ridiculous things at move out, blaming me for weak water pressure in the kitchen. There is a hose spigot on the other side of the kitchen faucet wall that corroded due to 40 years of neglect and it just busted off. Johnny and sons then "jimmy rigged" the spigot, and the water pressure then nose dived in the kitchen (see corroded spigot). After all this headache (literal), they are now only giving me back half my rental deposit.. even though I left the house in immaculate condition (even paid to have carpets and floors professionally cleaned). Needless to say, I'm now taking them to court.

    Pima Mayfair - propertymgmt - Updated September 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...