This is the second occasion in a year that I had to go to Pinkey's for car repair/service. They do a great job and even move things forward more quickly than they originally estimate. My almost 9 year old looks shiny and new . Even cleaned the interior! Absolutely recommend them! read more

Here is a little extra note added to my recent review of Pinkey's: I came back about a week later to collect an item that had fallen out of my car but they didn't know who it belonged to. I think they had inadvertently forgotten to uniformly adjust the air pressure in all 4 tires. When I asked if they normally do that when they do work on 1 or more tires, they offered to even out the air pressure right while I was waiting. This was exceptional service! read more

I was very impressed with the service at Pinkey's! I had to get my car fixed after somebody backed into my door and they had it done for me very quickly. The process was smooth. They also cleaned my car before returning it back to me. Their communication was also very nice, I receive text message updates on my vehicle status. 10 out of 10 recommend! read more

I got bumped into in a parking lot and decided to use Pinkeys for the repair. The process was easy. I scheduled a time to drop it off, and the hand off was smooth. They resolved the issues I had had, and the repairs were very well done. Even better they cleaned my car, inside and out. It was like new. Definitely will go here again if needed. read more

I'd give 10 stars if I could. They keep you informed every step of the way. My car looks good as new and they even cleaned it.

Someone backed into the side of my car, so I went to Pinkey's because it's one of State Farm's vetted auto shops. The estimate process was a breeze, and I didn't have to deal with any of the payment/admin stuff myself because of their relationship with State Farm. I was blown away by their service and the results--every single person I spoke with was so kind and efficient. I guarantee I will be back for all of my car maintenance in the future. I feel like the incident that brought me in was worth the hassle because I found this place and got my car immaculately cleaned! Highly recommend. read more

Incredibly friendly and down to earth service. As a woman, it's not common to find mechanics that won't assume I'm clueless. While it did help that I somewhat know my way around a car and an engine, every employee I spoke with greeted me with eagerness and respect. They stuck to their word, they did what they said they would, and they did it quickly! I used their service through life360's app and while the tow there was abysmal (tow truck driver locked my keys in my car and Pinkey's got the car unlocked, free of charge) my experience here was stress-free. You have a lifelong customer! read more

My car was parked and involved in a hit and run. The team at Pinkey's helped me take care of the mechanical damage fast so I could drive the car and then took it back for the cosmetic stuff a bit later. They were lovely throughout the process and the work was completed as expected and as schedule, both times. I hope I don't have to go back for that kind of work again, but if I did I'd go here, every time! read more

My 2022 Kia Soul was broken into and the side window was smashed, along with the ignition being completely busted open. Always have insurance! I called around, but ultimately Pinkey's got me in the next day. After insurance covered a bit, I only had to pay $100 out of pocket. It's convenient that you can pay over the phone, in person or online. All I had to do was show up with the car and let the technicians do their magic. My window looked brand new! Shout out to Frankie!! Thank you read more

Friendly people but wasted my time writing up an estimate for me knowing they were unable to get parts for my car. Went to make an appointment with them and they then disclosed they can't service my car. Why entertain the idea/waste everyone's time if you don't even have the capability to fix my kind of car?? read more

I don't normally Yelp auto body shops but the service my mother and I had today was exceptional. Ricky was very kind and went above and beyond for us. My mothers truck was broken into last night. We contacted Pinkey's this morning and they came and towed the truck and repaired everything in a matter of hours. They even got it all done in less time they quoted! read more

I have driven by Pinkey's and know many like the shop - I called a friend today because I have a 2008 volvo XC wagon and it got messed up when my mechanic in Bayside, WI (OM) changed the serpentine belt - because the car had 155,000 miles (my friend agreed good call). We drive and recently drove from Bayside, WI to LDI, Maine - 1400 miles. My friend Marcus and his son Reid said USE PCAB - Rick "Pinkey" Feest and his crew are honest, and do good work - always. Rick - I look forward to meeting you soon - we have more work to be done and my husband met with a mechanic here in Maine today - who explained fully - we need the lower section of an air box for the car - also need a new battery box - previous mechanic in Bayside broke the box - on purpose. Upsetting - I do know he was under a time frame that he had underestimated. Keep doing what you are doing at Pinkey's in Milwaukee/53212. P.S. I understand you do have loaners for the day to drive so one can get to work! Mary W. read more

They were so helpful and easy to work with. We took my son's beater car in after an accident assuming it was totaled given its age and condition, but Pinkey's got the car back on the road in good condition for a really reasonable price and saved us a ton of legwork and money. I hope to I never have to go back, but if I do need bodywork done in the future, I will definitely choose Pinkey's. read more

We have had multiple cars fixed by this company. In the past we dealt with Rick, who was great. most recently we dealt with Steven who is just as good. If you're looking for an honest company to do great work on your car and keep you advised along the way, try these guys. read more

I loved my experience visiting Pinkey's to repair my broken side mirror. From the moment I first called asking about an appointment I was met with consistently kind and helpful staff. As a woman with her first car I was concerned about being ripped off or told inaccurate info but Pinkey's is a no nonsense kind of business that clearly wants to help their customers. Very clean, covid safe and efficient. They even washed my car after fixing my mirror! I have nothing but positive things to say about this business. read more

My wife hit a truck tire on the freeway and took out the plastic piece of her bumper- it needed to be reattached. Pinkey's got her in immediately, had a very reasonable quote and had it fixed and her car washed very well the next morning! Excellent service and work. Highly recommend ! read more

My wife took our vehicle in for a second opinion/quote on a subframe issue, and Pinky's stated that it wasn't even worth looking at because a repair would cost more than the car was worth. Fair enough. The real problem was that the mechanic followed that up with, "just bat your eyelashes at daddy and have him buy you a new car." My wife's father had passed away just about a year prior, of which she took the opportunity to inform this "gentleman." He replied, "well, then bat them at mom instead." Real class act. Couldn't tell you anything about their prices or work, and it doesn't matter for me at this point. Would never go back. read more

My car was recently wrecked and it's the first accident I've ever been involved in--needless to say, I was scared and clueless. Pinkey's has made this ordeal painless (after the fact) and easy. I haven't had to lift a finger, except to drop off my car and sign my name. I've heard legends of repair and auto body shops ripping people off, but they've treated me like a princess with a broken car. I highly recommend them. read more

This place does a professional job every time. Drive up, they inspect the damages, they assess in five minutes, give you an estimate that DOES NOT CHANGE once the work is completed, and you get your car back like nothing ever happened. I got in three fender benders over the past year and took my car to Pinkey's all three times. One star deduction because the inside of my car wreaked of paint fumes when I got my car back and still does to a certain extent. I hope it goes away completely. Otherwise, good show Pinkey's. read more

Pinkey's is the place to go for kindness, fairness and expert mechanical skill! It's a family-owned business with three generations of experience and know-how and an old-world integrity and personalized care established by founder Grandfather Ricky and continues on in his son Ricky Jr, his grandson Ricky the 3rd, and with all the other wonderful folks over there. Last week on Friday while pulling out of my driveway I crunched my left back fender. Right away I drove over to Pinkey's because I trust them having had two positive prior experiences there since moving to the Milwaukee area 16 years ago. I got a quote within 10-15 minutes, they ordered the part needed, and Tuesday morning did the repair. The work was done beautifully with my car back to me later the same day. I highly recommend Pinkey's, they're consistently a great shop! read more

They get dome in the amount they say they will at the price they quote you. Plus, they seem to be a bunch of really friendly and kniwledgeable guys.Great customer service!! read more

I took my car into Pinkey's for rear bumper repair. The car looked great when they were done. The estimate was the most competitive one out of all of the repair shops that we checked with on the north shore. Very satisfied! read more

Took my car in for a mild repair. Turns out, it was much less expensive than I expected. The place was really convenient, the guys were all really nice. If needed, I would definitely return. read more

Took my car for minor body work. Scratches and yellow paint from post I rubbed against were still visible when I picked up the car. One of the owners told me to take it back to fix next Monday. I did, but we couldn't really agree on the quality of the work they performed. It seems that to take all scratches out it needs to be painted, not just buffed. But at time of quote this distinction wasn't made clear, and obviously, I didn't knowingly agree to pay for a job that would leave some scratches. Not worth my time pursuing this matter, but I wouldn't take my car there again or recommend to anybody. Also, there was a sense of annoyance by the person I talked to, when really, the only one that has a right to be annoyed is me! read more

This place is terrible! State Farm lists this place as one to do repair work covered by their insurance. I brought my 15 year old car there to get an estimate for repair work needed because of an accident. The estimate was more than the car was worth so I decided to try to get it done for less on my own. The car was there for 3 days while we waited for the estimate from Pinkeys (we got their estimate the next day) and for State Farm to let us know the amount that would be covered. Since they weren't going to do the repairs, Pinkeys wanted to charge us $45 for storage. That's $135 for parking the car in their parking lot! Luckily State Farm stepped in. BTW, they close at 5:00 every day and are not open on the weekends. That should give you a clue about how concerned they are about their customers with jobs. The guy I talked to on the phone about the storage fees was a jerk, too. He compared leaving the car with them for the estimate to parking a car at the Bradley Center. Yeah, that's realistic! read more