My girlfriend's 11 year old nice gave this place 4 out of 5 stars, and I'd have to agree with her…read more But there seems to be a lot of hate on here for some reason. The pizza is certainly not burned, and it is incredibly cheap for what you get. $25 for a HUGE pizza AND garlic knots? They're going to go out of business at this rate. How do they keep the lights on? That would be $60 at least in Seattle, or even 20 miles closer to the city. The pizza smells incredibly fragrant while it rides shotgun on the way to your destination, it has a strong garlic scent. It's was really tempting not to sneak a piece on the way home. But it was worth the wait. With nice thin crusts and great ratios, this pizza is a hit if you're in the area. There's not a ton of other options in liberty either, so you might as well check this out

Great pizza place!! Slices are fresh and very tasty too. Better than the pizza places in Monticello…read morethat I usually patronize. I was out in liberty at my chiropractor's office and decided to give them a try. Great choice!! The selection was vast for custom slices, but I got a plane slice to try it out and I'm glad I did. I will review it again next time I try something new. The owner was very nice and working side by side with the employees, I like that!! Give them a try!

Tough review. Food was good my family liked it better than me however. You need to know they are…read moreoutrageously slow. 40 minutes for cheesesteaks. Eventually the wings came out afterwards. I had time to kill so it wasn't a big deal. Had it not been for the delays they may have done better. BUT they pull the same old trick everyone seems to be up to lately and up charge you for using a credit card which infuriates me so they lose a star for that. Your price is your price. Don't screw me over after I've had my meal. My cheesesteak was too salty and I didn't care for the mushrooms on it. Seemed like canned or something. Just not great. Bun was perfectly toasted. Others who got cheesesteaks liked them but banana peppers on one were really tart. Wings though are what helped. My family thought they were fantastic. They were too hot for me as a medium but I'm a light weight there and know it. Either way you can't stop and be in a hurry but there was a steady stream of people in and out. Just stop with the dang up charges everyone please!!

Much respect to Bianca who is gradually taking over the day to day operations from her mother. This…read moreplace is legit, many specialty slices and rolls. Garlic knots are some of the best I've had anywhere. The custom made "Pancho chairs" are unique and colorful and add character to a large space.

Every time I would pass by Liberty I would see the spot and yesterday finally tried their pizza. It…read morewas a giant slice and delicious! The prices are great and the owners are very friendly. I went back in to try their fries and will definitely be going back to try the other flavors. The place inside is small but cozy and there is a spot in the corner fit for two to eat. If you're looking for delicious Queens worthy pizza, this is it! Update:They expanded their seating area! Now you can go in and eat a giant pie inside instead of trying to devour the pizza in the car.

First time customers. While at the restaurant there were a few customers for takeout orders. Young…read morefemale at the counter was polite, when she came to our table to take our order. We ordered a thin pepperoni pizza and two bottled sodas. Pizza was really thick,s/p, napkins were on the table. We were not offered any hot peppers, cheese, garlic etc. Pizza tasted like it was made from frozen dough. We were not impressed with the food. We did eat the pizza minus the crust and took the leftovers with us to be polite. We paid the bill, tipped, went on our way and disposed of the rest of the pizza in the garbage when we got home. We will not be back.

As far as diners go, this one's in the middle of the road. Food is OK, and Service is terrific. My…read morefavorite thing about the Liberty diner Is that their menu has such a variety, not just of food but of portion sizes .You can order a half a sandwich and a cup of soup, or a small version of salads and sandwiches. I ordered a half a pastrami sandwich and a cup of soup. The rye bread was stale. I thought it was toasted, but the bottom portion was wet so it wasn't toasted, It was stale.

As our family was leaving the Catskills we wanted to stop for breakfast…read more Liberty diner was the perfect stop that was enroute to NYC. The diner is very festive, upbeat, and lively. Loved that they are one of the very few places in the Catskills opened late hours. Large variety of choices on the menu, the food is very good, coffee was great. Service was excellent. Loved that they serve cocktails if your in the mood for a glass of wine after a long road trip, or other spirits. When visiting the area this will definitely be a place I visit for a sit down, bite to eat.

Try and try again this place is nothing like it's original owners, Frankie and Johnny. The service…read moreis not great. The food taste is subpar quality is not good. Prices are high portions are small...service is sadly not good at all...When you carefully explain exactly what you want to your waiter and they still bring you something that is not right and then say nothing about it when you tell them it is not right. You gotta give up on a place. It's just not worth spending the time or money.‍ That is why this restaurant is pretty much empty every time I've been in there and at 7 o'clock at night they're ready to close. It's a disappointing restaurant with disappointing food.

Excellent food and service. The atmosphere in the resultant I like being in your home dining room…read more The food is excellent.

I love this spot already! My first visit was for ice cream and the staff was so sweet. I received a…read morelot of ice cream with the brownie sundae and you can add any topping that you like. There is a large selection of toppings. I returned and tried there pepperoni personal pizza and fries which were delicious as well. They have a selection of sandwiches, pizza, etc. The staff is friendly and there is plenty of parking. I definitely recommend this spot to anyone!

Staff had bright green outfits that stood out to me for it being an ice cream shop. It was very…read moreneat and clean. They also serve fast food such as burgers, and the girl behind the counter said that was a popular menu item when I asked. I'm impressed with their dip flavors that included coconut, which pleased me. This seems to be a bright little gem in this otherwise simple town. I was just passing through when I saw the bright sign and the fun logo, so I pulled around. Glad I did.

Great spot. Tasty pizza. Was passing by and decided to stop. Will definitely visit them on my way…read moreback.

We stepped in here while on a road trip and was charmed. This is a small but fantastic old-school…read morediner, run by hardworking owners who welcomed us warmly and led us to an open booth. The space inside feels about as wide as a railroad car but as homey as a local gem can get. The menu reads like a classic diner's, with everything from breakfast to dessert. I ordered the Hungry Man Special, which comes with a stack of pancakes, two eggs, bacon AND sausage, and home fries. For $16, this was an enormous value and practically a wealth of food. My husband ordered the chicken salad, and they were more than amenable to his ask for grilled chicken instead of the menu-standard crispy. The chicken was tender and cut into easy-to-eat strips. Everything was well cooked and got to our table within minutes of ordering. Service remained fantastic throughout, and judging from the friendly conversations around me, it's clear that there were lots of regulars and return visitors. Definitely step in if you're in the area and in search of dependably good food.

Stepping into New Munson Diner on Lake Street in Liberty feels like stepping into a local gem that…read moreperfectly blends old-school diner charm with a menu that's surprisingly versatile. My visit on August 30, 2025, left me with the kind of satisfaction that only a solid diner experience can deliver--one that makes you want to return just to try more of the menu. To start, the garlic bread with marinara was exactly what you'd hope for in diner comfort food: warm, golden-brown edges with just the right crunch on the outside and a soft, buttery center. The garlic wasn't overwhelming, and dipping it into the tangy marinara added that classic, crave-worthy touch. It was the kind of simple appetizer that sets the right tone for what's to come. The Santa Fe Wrap was a highlight--grilled chicken cooked to a juicy tenderness, paired with creamy avocado that balanced beautifully against the smoky bacon. The cheddar added sharpness, while the lettuce and tomato kept it fresh and crisp. It's a hearty, flavor-packed wrap that manages to feel indulgent without being heavy, something you could happily order for either lunch or dinner. On the spicier side, the Buffalo Chicken Wrap brought a zesty kick. The buffalo sauce was bold and tangy, just spicy enough to wake up the taste buds without overwhelming them. The blue cheese inside mellowed the heat, adding a cool creaminess that tied the whole wrap together. Each bite felt satisfying, with the wrap itself holding everything neatly--a small detail, but an important one when you're eating something saucy and bold. Service throughout the meal was friendly and efficient, with staff that seemed genuinely attentive without being overbearing. The diner itself has that cozy, casual atmosphere you want in a local spot--welcoming and lively without being too noisy. Value-wise, the generous portions and solid flavors made the price point feel more than fair. Overall, I'd give New Munson Diner a strong 4 stars--a reliable, tasty stop with plenty of menu options to keep you coming back. The wraps in particular stand out as fresh, flavorful choices, and paired with a shareable appetizer like the garlic bread, you've got yourself a diner meal that's both comforting and satisfying.