My husband and I dine at Nonno's frequently and the food is fantastic…read more The service is top notch and very friendly. Enjoy Franco stopping by our table to check on everything.

Ended up stopping in here on a business trip just by chance, given it's a little bit off the beaten…read morepath, but well worth it. The main guy Franco, was an excellent host and you can tell just by sitting there lots of regulars know him by name and he's extremely well-versed in options to suggest. As a result, I ended up getting the zuppa di mare and a Moscow mule, both of which were fantastic and will definitely be back!

Not sure how you mess up pizza but it was aweful!! Save yourself & go across the street.read more

Pine bush has its fair share of pizza restaurants. However, Pudgys also has a menu serving…read moreeveryone's taste buds-a little something for everyone. I do have to say my favorite thing about this place is, Consistency!!! Chicken bacon ranch slices-salads-tostadas-and the wiiiiings(so many flavors) I think I know what I'm ordering tonight.

We had dinner twice at Lombardi's Restaurant during our vacation in the area. First time, my wife…read morehad the chicken parmesan, and I went with the lasagna (w/ a sausage side). The chicken parmesan was excellent, but the lasagna was Out of this World amazing, the best I've ever had. Pasta was so silky tasting, light & airy. Perfect. The portion size was also ginormous, but I managed to finish it all ! Loved it. Marinara sauce was also spot on. The bread that came to the table before our meals was superb, and my wife had a sangria with her meal which she enjoyed very much. Came back a few nights later, but this time we had to do a takeout order (our dog had been injured at the farm the day before and we did not want to leave her at the airbnb by herself). So I picked up two entrees -- a shrimp fettuccine alfredo and a salmon dinner. The salmon was first-rate, but the shrimp fettuccine alfredo was clearly the winner tonight, it was fantastic. We appreciate that they did not go overboard with the alfredo sauce (like so many restaurants do), the chef clearly knows how to prepare Italian dishes. We also had a slice of cheesecake and a tiramisu for dessert -- both were stellar, we loved them ! Lombardi's Restaurant in Gardiner, NY is Top Notch in my book. The staff are very friendly & attentive, especially David, he was extremely personable and funny. We live over two hours away in Connecticut, but we plan to come back to Lombardi's in the near future, that's how much we enjoyed our dining experiences there.

Nice place small dinning room, took long time for food to come 2 baskets of bread long lol with…read moreonly 1 other table when we got there, Salad ok, food wasn't that great just ok. The bartender was very nice but walking by thru restaurant quite loudly sorry but too distracting! Need some background Italian music in restaurant there is none. Olive Garden has better choices & fresh grated parm cheese !!

Update: Feb2025- liquor license and food update. Had the vodka sauce special with prosciutto...any…read morepasta type works and have had them all: ravioli, stuffed shells, manicotti! The wine selection is great and prices are great. They are still getting draft beer settled but they have a few options plus bottled beer. Adding pics of wine menu and the manicotti (I've already eaten some, sorry). But so delish. The bread is to die for and we can't stop raving about it! Our favorite pizza is to get 1/2 Crazy Chicken, 1/2 penne vodka...love that the pizza is so crispy. Last week we had 1/2 cheese and 1/2 meatball and it was amazing also. Can't go wrong here. Different from other pizzerias in the area.

Hidden gem alert, Amalfi Trattoria has not only got the basics down it has the nuances, in customer…read moreservice, hospitality and quality Italian American food down to a tee!! Their pizza is one of the very best pies we have had anywhere; excellent crust, tomato sauce and oh my that cheese! Seldom do you get a pie where the tomato sauce has not been masked or at the very least, minimized by the cheese. Amalfi manages to give you a pizza that is a well balanced symphony of ingredients. My meatball sausage, fresh mushroom, green pepper with onion Cacciatore Parmagian was other worldly. Even the Field Greens Salad with Raspberry Walnut Vinegarette was a stand out, stand up take notice beginning to our meal. Phil, our server, could not have done better and his recommendation for wine was picture perfect. This little Italian Resto is a gem and worth a drive from almost anywhere especially if you wish to rekindled those very special memories you had when having Sunday dinners at your Nonna's.

Good food, great staff, nice atmosphere and reasonable prices! For a small "hick" town, it is a…read moregreat place!!

What a pleasant surprise to find a fine dining restaurant in the middle of downtown Wurtsboro…read more Service was quick and attentive and food and drinks were tasty. Prices are higher end but the ambiance is very nice and cozy and romantic. Limited parking in their lot but there's plenty of free street parking. I'd probably come back for another special event.

Food/Drink: Pizza by the slice! Pretty good New York style pizza. Large amount of options and…read morecombos. Full Italian style menu, appetizers, entrees, pizza, soups, salads, and desserts! Pizza: Nice brick oven style and Sicilian. Dinning Area: Pretty large, open, area. Benches, large counter. Plenty of seating! Prices: Relatively cheap. 2 slice and fountain special for $12! Parking: Plenty of space, side lot. Bathrooms: Bathrooms were small and clean. Atmosphere: During the weekday lunch rush, It was crazy. Staff/Attendants: Staff overall was decent, and unsociable. Been a few times and will return.

I called Tosco's before my 7:00 dance class in Pine Bush and ordered a pizza to be picked up at…read more8:15 this evening. I got there at 8:15. I was CHARGED for the pizza. I assumed it was ready. THEN, AFTER I WAS CHARGED, they admitted they did not turn in my order at 7:00 when I first called them. I have evidence on my phone that I called. This is crazy. Then I was told to SIT IN MY VEHICLE while they cooked my pizza. I live in a nearby town. I was tired from a long day and hungry, so I waited. The pizza is half cooked and tastes terrible. No, I can't drive back to Pine Bush tonight. This is not good service at best, and dishonest at worst. I was told I could get $15. off on my next order. No coupon, nothing to prove that I can do that. They have my first name only, and my phone number. So no, this is clearly NOT a real offer. I will never, ever go back there again. And the pizza? I don't think it would be good even if they did cook it, and they did not do that. Horrible place.

Apparently I've been in the dark about this. The bar was moved with the locals, whixh is nice to…read moresee, and the dining area was filled with the same. The food here is authentic & top notch, its not often that I want Chinese food because its always so basic. This is the real deal. The rice alone, its dark, not greasy, loaded with pork, so good. I got the sesame shrimp&my husband the general tso, and we enjoyed it all. Large portions too, we needed a to go container. The gentleman taking care of us very nice, I would recommend this place for sure

Great service. A little loud near the bar, so if you like quiet, sit in the back room…read more The food is great, and the portions are big