This is not good pizza. The bread tastes like cardboard from how hard it was, the cheese was very…read morerubbery, and the sauce tasted like watered down canned tomato sauce. At this point I'd rather eat the Chuck E. Cheese pizza than this again. Crazy when the kids agree with me as well. First and last time I'll order from here.

The pizza is delicious, the staff was friendly, its carry out so no place to sit and eat, but the…read moreinside is about what you'd expect, a cute little pizza spot. The price isn't too bad considering the product they put out.

Stopped in on a Sunday evening to try a few different pies. As I'm getting older, perhaps my tastes…read moreand preferences are changing, so I'll share my experience and anyone reading this can take it for what it is. I did not order ahead, I placed my order in store to get the hottest possible pizza, and I ended up ordering 3 small pies to try some different slices. I ordered two small cheese pizzas, one with mozzarella cheese and the other with Romano cheese, and the third pizza was a deluxe. To begin, I really enjoyed the Romano cheese pizza. The Romano cheese has a sharp flavor, but it doesn't over power the sauce in anyway. The sauce was sweet, tangy, and really shined with the Romano. Most important, it wasn't greasy. The mozzarella cheese pizza was good, but the thicker cheese reduced the sauce flavor a bit, still good, and with all of the pies, the crust is a very light and airy crust which is pleasant to eat. Lastly, for the deluxe, I could have done without that. It was greasy, heavy, but my biggest issue, you can tell some of the toppings came right from a can. Overall, 3.5/5 for me at this pizzeria. I'd come back again, however, I'd stick with the cheese Romano pizza.

Been loving the pizza for years a must have if you ever in the area please try them .read more

Came up from Dayton for work and decided to try Red Plum... and wow…read more Tried the sausage & meatball NY-style and the four cheese Detroit-style -- both were unreal. The sauce is seriously next level, some of the best I've had. The Detroit had that perfect crispy edge while still soft inside, and the NY slice was just straight up classic and done right.

Love red plum pizza. Detroit style is my favorite. The crust is so crispy and flavorful.read more

I have been in the Cortland Ohio area since 2020. I have not found a good pizza place until…read moretonight! This was delicious! The crust was not so thin to be cardboard or thick to be cake. The sauce was so old world flavorful. I'm hooked!!!!!

Salad was skimpy on fries and pizza wasn't hot no taste. Used to buy from them not no more and…read morewings were dry tasted like they just heated up in microwave

Don't get into the weeds about a 4 versus 5 star review, and please read the entire review. First,…read morethis is my go to place after trying it for the first time 8.16.26. This is for certain, New York (Eastern Pa. Northern N.J.) style pizza, which is refreshing after enduring the Pizza in my part of Ohio. I grew up in NE Pa. and when it comes to Pizza, Cheese Steaks, and overall Italian cuisine, I'm very critical and have transported hundreds of doughballs back to Ohio, so I could enjoy real pizza. I was thoroughly pleased to take the first bite, and subsequently, the next 3 slices, of a pizza that had a good hydration, great undercarriage, and a solid ratio of cheese to sauce. I drove 35 minutes to try it, and I was not disappointed at all. If you're like me, and didn't grow up in Ohio eating what they refer to as pizza, you should absolutely give it a try. Service was fantastic, and the woman that took my order, and checked me out, was very personable, and obviously part of the family that runs the business. Getting in the weeds a bit, understanding that I'm a snob, LOL, The dough had the correct structure, but IMHO, could be cold fermented for a longer period of time to develop much more flavor. Other than that, sauce and cheese is completely subjective, depending on what you like. I can't wait to try the rest of the menu, and appreciate the effort and the food. You now have a customer for life.

Bella Napoli in Youngstown is a cozy spot for classic Italian comfort food. The menu offers…read moreflavorful pizzas, hearty pasta dishes, and generous portions that feel homemade. The service is friendly, and the relaxed atmosphere makes it a good choice for a casual dinner, family meal, or takeout. The food is satisfying, well-seasoned, and reasonably priced. If you're craving traditional Italian flavors in the Youngstown area, Bella Napoli is worth checking out.

This place is a staple in their community. Was waiting to visit the Packard Museum and we stopped…read morehere. I had their all meat pizza oh man yum also had 10 bone in wing with hot their hot sauce. Excellent. The young lady waiting on our group of 7 was totally awesome. Loved the decor and it made you feel like you stepped back in time which was awesome I forgot to take pics because we were all talking about how great it was and how awesome the staff was for us out of towners

The small deep dish pizza served us was mostly very thick, dry bread. There was only a small amount…read moreof filling. We threw most is the pizza away.

On Tuesday, I ordered a pizza for pickup on Wednesday. Arrived at the specified time. Door was…read morelocked. Called 20 minutes later, no answer, left a message. They called back and said they had my pizza. I called back a little later to verify that they had my pizza ready. They said they did. I went and pizza wasn't ready, It was still in the oven & I had to wait for it. No discount offered, no apology, nothing. Last pizza from Boardman Cornersburg. From now on, I will go to Cornersburg location only.

this place is constantly locked-up, even when there is a guy working inside…read more I talked to someone that knows the situation. She said they have trouble finding counter help and they have trouble buying food stock items!!!??? They close and turn out the lights on their whim. WEIRDO-RAMA situation. This place used to be the best.

This has been our favorite pizza for decades. And that's saying something in a town filled with…read moredelicious pizza. But.... as delicious as it's been, the green peppers are no longer fully cooked. It makes a Huge difference in the pizza. Some may prefer it, that's fine. But it just isn't the same.

Craig Hockenberry I…read morecan walk to Cornersburg Pizza in Poland. Great people every time I go in there. I have had it several times in the past two years and it ranks right up there with the better pizzas in The Youngstown area. Craig Hockenberry