Yes yes YES! This is quite literally the best pizza I have had in my entire life. Who knew it would take this long to finally find that. So cool that they are opening up TWO new locations in Boardman & Kinsman to spread the pizza goodness!! The Detroit Hot Honey Roni is my favorite. This was my first time having Detroit style pizza and it makes me feel like I don't have to travel to truly experience it. The baked cheesy goodness of a crust is phenomenal. Flavors? Out of this world. Cupping pepperoni is simply the best, their sauce doesn't give me heartburn and considering I try to stay away from red sauce that says a lot! OHHHH but their basil is always so fresh and flavorful. I think I could eat a bowl of it! The Detroit Chicken Bacon Ranch is also delicious. Best CBR pizza and I've had a lot of em. No words! The Detroit 8 Mile, same thing. Raving about it! I was thoroughly pleased that you literally get slices of garlic clove on top. The hot peppers ain't too hot & it's just GOOD! Period. Penna Alla Vodka with a fresh baked roll... my Lord! This was on a separate visit, but figured I would include it in this review. (I have been there 3 times within a month, oops) Pasta came out piping hot, flavors were immaculate; sausage, sauce, cheese, basil, OH MY! Just try it. I cannot wait to continually support this business and try new things with each visit! read more

See all

I saw we are getting a Red Plum in Boardman , curiosity got the better of Me. I decided to go to the Warren location rather then wait til our location opens Nov 1st. Restaurant is Beautiful, staff very friendly and tons of parking. One of my dearest friends went with me. They have a great stocked bar and nice outdoor seating for those that prefer that. We started with the Oven Baked Meatballs, plentiful with a nice amount of fresh ricotta, it also came with a huge roll with fresh garlic and spices on it. The Meatballs were delicious. We tried the Plum Salad...the flavors were amazing the Feta was soft and creamy and the dressing was unlike any I have ever had. Best Salad. Small size enough to share. We tried a few Pizzas...took 90% home. First up New York White ...I added Ricotta to it. It was cooked to perfection and full of flavor. Second up was Detroit style The Butcher...My friend said it was really yummy, with a great amount of Sausage Meatballs and Bacon. This is the Ultimate choice when those ingredients are your Joy. We got smaller size with 4 huge square pieces. The under carriage of this pizza was pure perfection. Third up was New York Style Pesto, Vodka Sauce and Red Sauce with the perfect blend of Mozzarella, We chose to have them not add the pepperoni. This pizza delivers every flavor imaginable. I'm going to ask them if they can recreate on Detroit crust which is my new favorite. This pizza was tied for my favorite.... Fourth and final the tie for first place pizza.. Detroit Style Greektown ... Between the fresh spinach and the creamy Feta add olives hot peppers and light Mozzarella this pizza was Epic. The under carriage was perfect. The pizza delivered crunch after crunch bite after bite. It doesn't really get better than this. Our waitress was wonderful. We had her bring each pizza out in its box as we really only shared one square of each pizza. I am New York Born and live in Ohio. Truly here There are very few pizza establishments that truly bring it. Red Plum 100% delivers. Quality, Taste and price. Excited they will be in My neighborhood when the new location opens. This is a truly hidden gem. I plan on going back very soon. Hands Down Best of the Best!!!!! read more

See all

if ya look at my reviews, I gave Red Plum a solid 5 stars few years back. Basic thing is this - the pizza is solid WHEN it's done right...last few times its been over cooked more and more, and tonight? Almost charbroiled and inedible. See the pics.....SMH (2nd pic is a chicken sandwich, also burnt). Shame of it is its bout the best pizza around IF ya catch em on a good night, but less likely as again this has been my experience last two visits. Unfortunate. read more

Came up from Dayton for work and decided to try Red Plum... and wow Tried the sausage & meatball NY-style and the four cheese Detroit-style -- both were unreal. The sauce is seriously next level, some of the best I've had. The Detroit had that perfect crispy edge while still soft inside, and the NY slice was just straight up classic and done right. read more

Good thin pizzas, outstanding price for what I paid for. Wait was a little long, but they're new and trying to pump out 1000 doordash orders. read more

Well this one hurts! Be coming to Red Plum for a few months now and my wife and I thought this was the best pizza in the area... Well that changed today, we've been noticing that the quality and consistency have taken a dive for the worst. We always ask for well done and they haven't been able to provide us with our request. Today we ordered our usual and a side salad the pizza was so under cooked it had to be eaten with a knife and fork and the salad never showed up. We are wondering if this place changed hands in the past few months? Needless to say we will never be going back, time to find a new favorite... read more

I do not understand why this place is the pride and joy of the entire community. Honestly, it's just not that good. Their thin crust is not thin. I don't get it read more

Red Plum Pizza And Pasta - Brooklyn pizza large - Italian Near Me - Warren, Ohio

Another successful dinner! Again the food was better than could've been imagined, the service was friendlier than "Cheer's" (tv show)!!! I absolutely LOVE this place!!! If you're visiting or taking out friends/family this place is a MUST!!! read more

Red Plum Pizza And Pasta - Chicken wing so good my kids finally finished their dinner almost! - Italian Near Me - Warren, Ohio

See all

Pizza absolutely bangs!! I can't wait for this place to open in Canfield as the Howland one is great. Nice vibes. Good service. That's all we need. read more

Their Detroit Pizza is awesome. The sauce on it is the best homemade I've had. We actually ask for extra sauce on top of the pizza. There pastas are well worth it also. Probably one of top go to pizza places. read more

I have only tried the Detroit-style pizza here, but I would come back and have come back for it any time. It's always so full of flavor, served hot, and also reheats well. I've only done takeout, but every time I pick up, the dine in experience looks great. Will be back to try it sometime! read more

Sandwiches are 2 1/2 inches by 10 long (more than one of us got sandwiches, and they are very small, hardly filled) . Fries come pre made frozen from somewhere else with salt and PEPPER on them. Yuck! Nothing special tasting about any of their overpriced food that was served cold. read more

Disclaimer this was a door dash review. Honestly, this restaurant should be ashamed of the product they put out at the price they do. I've never had anything as disgusting as their motor city deep dish or flavorless as their New York white. The best part of this meal was the boy salads, which were nearly 11 dollars for two. The pizza sauce on the red (motorcity) tasted spoiled, and all the toppings were burnt to a disgusting taste or a crisp. A 4-piece pie which was less than 6 in x 6 in, cost me nearly 16.00. It didn't have the ricotta scoop advertised on th website on any of the four pieces of pizza. I ended up feeding this to my dogs The white New York was 18.94 for the medium (which at arrival was more of a personal pan size) with five extra charged dipping sauces on the side. It was covered in cheese with no sauce or even olive oil. The bottom was burnt, and the crust that met the cheese was nearly raw and doughy. The peppers had no kick or flavor and were a mushy consistency. They had no crispiness to the bite like a pickle would, which is what I am used to with hot pepper pizza. I rarely say this about restaurants as I think everyone has good and bad days, but this is an establishment I will not return to, as 80.00 for a meal I couldn't eat isn't worth a second chance. They got an extra star from 1 to 2 because they remembered to include all my extra sauces, which generally the restaurant always forgets when using door dash. read more

Red Plum Pizza And Pasta - Receipt copy from door dash - Italian Near Me - Warren, Ohio

Ate here in large group and service was excellent plus very friendly. Had wings which where really good and pepperoni Sicilian which was on point. Would come here again for sure read more

Red Plum Pizza And Pasta - Pizza and drinks - Italian Near Me - Warren, Ohio

Red Plum is the best, 8 mile pizza is the go to for me on football Sundays. Wish they had more desserts Thou.

I was in the area on a work trip and was recommended to go here and try a plum salad. Omg... I am SO glad I took the recommendation because that salad was truly incredible. I sat at the bar and had a fabulous conversation with the bartender who was very friendly. I told him I was torn between getting a pizza and the salad and he let me know I could do a side portion of the salad! I also got a pizza (you can split them in half to try two different thing), and it was also great. This place is tiny but so cute with great service. Definitely go, and try the plum salad!!! read more

Red Plum Pizza And Pasta - Pizza - Italian Near Me - Warren, Ohio

For weeks I've been seeing mentions of this restaurant all over social media and swore to myself that I need to get there ASAP and I finally did yesterday! I viewed the menu beforehand so I knew what I wanted when I called to place my togo order. The young gentleman that answered the phone was very well-spoken, knowledgeable and friendly. He quoted me my wait time and I headed to the location to wait and pick it up. I arrived a little earlier than my quoted wait time, so I sat in the car for a little before heading in. Once inside, I checked in at the front counter and paid for my purchase. My order still wasn't ready for another 15 minutes or so, which was past the quoted wait time, but this was no issue for me as they were obviously actively working to fill numerous orders for guests dining in, carrying out and via DoorDash. A young lady brought my order out and thanked me for stopping in. Once back to my car, I couldn't wait to open the pizza box and give my first slice from RP a taste. Before I could, I noticed that half of my pizza was missing a swirl of ricotta, and it wasn't as hot as I felt it should have been, so I headed back inside. I didn't mention the temperature to the staff but I did the missing ricotta that I had paid for and was listed on the kitchen ticket I was given. The same female employee that handed me my order originally said she'd fix it herself right away, and she did. Despite the temperature of the pizza, it still looked amazing and I finally tasted it and was not disappointed at all with the flavor! The Detroit crust was absolutely amazing. There is nothing better than caramelized cheese and boy was I in heaven! I live in Boardman and definitely have my favorites there but I would drive here to order this type of pizza again for sure. I also took advantage of the $9.99 pasta special and ordered the Sicilian Alla Vodka and was pleased with the generous portion size, temperature taste and appearance of it. My added side salad was missing the dressing, but I didn't notice this until I got back home. Even with the minor issues with my order, I would not hesitate to come back here. I have several friends and coworkers that were awaiting my review who say they will definitely give it a go now. I will see you guys again soon for sure! read more

See all

What a great place. My nephew suggested going there. We ordered the Detroit style supreme and some garlic wings. They both where great. Definitely a place we plan on going back to. read more

Red Plum Pizza And Pasta - Detroit Supreme - Italian Near Me - Warren, Ohio

really decent detroit style pizza - quite happy was in the area and wanted some pizza for an event and stumbled on this place - they do a very good job read more

Nice small place with good dishes and friendly service. They have a small selection of quality beer and wine. read more

Red Plum Pizza And Pasta - Medium Chicken Bacon Ranch Detroit Pizza - Italian Near Me - Warren, Ohio

See all

We stopped on our way to Youngstown. The reviews were good and the pizza did not disappoint. The staff was also wonderful. Thank you

Hidden Gem. The name says it all. Pizza and pasta is all they do, but they do it well ! We had the pasta tonight. Their attention to detail shown brightly. Each ingredient was cook perfectly. And when combined to the dish it was enjoyable to all our senses. Service was beyond acceptable. Staff was attentive, cheerful and knew when they were needed. I must say, I am pleasantly surprised. I did not expect this quality out of a "plaza pizza shop". It is soooo much more than that. I would have given another half star if possible. True rating from me would be 4.5. The only downer was they did not serve standard Iced Tea, just some flavored version. Definitely a grate place to dine. read more

Red Plum Pizza And Pasta - Fettuccine Bolognese - Italian Near Me - Warren, Ohio

See all

After trying most pizza places in the area this place is the best. From the Detroit style to the thin crust, we were very happy with this place. read more

Amazing pizza and wings !! Fast and friendly service never disappointed!! Dine in or carry out the quality is always there !! The food is constantly delicious read more

This pizza place has an amazing atmosphere and the decor was very nicely done. They offer several types of pizza, but we only tried the NY style. We found it similar to NYC pizza but the crust is a thicker on the outer edge. The selections of flavors were perfect. We really liked the Margherita and Brooklyn styles. The guys loved the pepperoni. I just wish there was more seating. read more

Food and service was great! Pizza was one of the best ever. Wings were crispy and moist! read more

Red Plum Pizza And Pasta - Supreme pizza - Italian Near Me - Warren, Ohio

See all

One of the best gluten free crusts pizzas I've had in the Howland/Warren area. Nice and saucy, and the pepperoni has just enough spice to set it apart from others around town. read more

Stopped at the RP for a drink and something light to eat. We were totally disappointed that they don't really have a full bar. My hubs ordered vodka & tonic...no tonic. Almost everything we tried to order they didn't have. We did get a Greektown pizza on a NY crust (thin) which was good. The poor server was the only one working. Probably won't be back which is sad. The owner's original restaurant is excellent! read more

Food and service were great! We ordered Detroit and New York style. I personally liked the New York better and that usually doesn't happen! Salads and penne were delicious too. read more

Great service! With great food to go along with it! The food is super affordable and definitely worth it.

Have eaten here twice now and once just take out. All three times I was very satisfied! First time we got a Detroit Pizza with peppers and pepperoni it was so good. So much flavor! The next time I ate inside with friends. We ordered the bread and peppers OMG SO GOOD! Then we ordered a white New York pizza and that was delicious. We all had beer it was a great evening with great service. The third time was just as good we ordered the bread and peppers again and this time white Detroit pizza. I like the white pizza better in the New York stuff style. But I liked the Detroit better with the pepperoni. We had S'mores Martinis after ver happy with drinks food and service! read more

Red Plum Pizza And Pasta - Cheers to the Red Plum! S'mores Martinis - Italian Near Me - Warren, Ohio

First off, I love this place. My complaint is with ordering online and trying to call in an order. 1. When you order online to pickup they force you to a delivery menu. Why , I want to pick it up. Plus the prices vary depending on who you pick. I wanted to use my gift card but that payment is not offered. So, I decided to call. They answer promptly then put you on hold. FOR EVER. I've actually been put on hold and drove over to their location before they answered. read more

I ordered a gluten free Margherita pizza last week and it was so bad I couldn't eat it. The little sauce that was on the pizza was actually SOUR. I thought it was just me, but someone else tasted it and said the same thing! Our order also included a large regular crust pizza with pepperoni and was told it was good so I don't understand what happened with mine. I was told how tasty Red Plum was but my experience was less than positive. Someone else ordered wings and they said they were delicious. read more

This restaurant has a great feel. The pizza is well priced and has a stellar flavor and texture. I came in during peak hours by myself and was able to get a seat at the bar while waiting for the food. (I got it to go) The wait staff was very friendly. I'll be back. read more

I highly recommend them. They have quality food and excellent...excellent customer service. Go with the Greek pizza, you can't go wrong read more

Red Plum Pizza And Pasta - Greek pizza. - Italian Near Me - Warren, Ohio

Always enjoy a delicious meal here. The pizzas are great! Although it's one room, we didn't feel awkward about that.

In the Warren-Youngstown area this is undoubtedly the best place to get pizza. The Detroit style pizza is so far the best Detroit style I have gotten in Northeast Ohio, bar none. The quality here is impeccable and every time I review another place I use Red Plum as the gold standard. I made a yelp account to write this review that's how amazing their food is. Highly recommend to anyone in Northeast Ohio. read more

Mahoning Valley Italian family owned restaurants you have a problem. I'm not talking to any of the Five Families. Wedgewood, Inner Circle, Belleria, Sunrise, Cocca's.. you, you, you, you, and you good. Everyone has their favorite YO pizza pizza and any discussion of Valley pizza has the potential to end like Pavlik - Taylor. Your 5 are made men. Cafe Capri, Vernon's, 422, Leo's you're good too. Who doesn't love a night out at a classic sit down? That's a whole nother thing. Pass the peppers and oil, please, Nana. Everyone else? Problem. Red Plum is a gem. I live in 224 Land so it seems the acme of foolishness to drive up to Howland for pizza. But I saw the unique menu and we headed northward. Red Plum is another of the ubiquitous hole in the wall shopping center Italian eateries. It has a few tables and a bar as well as a carry out counter. Humble but tastefully decked out like a Robert Irvine remodel not done by Lynn. Lynn can turn a bowling ally diner counter into Spago in 2 days. But I digress. Red Plum in nice but plain. It's not stuck in the 20th Century. Started with salads. They were of the quality of one of the sit downs listed above. Gourmet house made dressing. Mixed greens. Bougie tomatoes. Not iceberg, tomato wedge, packet. $25 dinner quality for $6. While the entrees look good, the pizza is the specialty. Instead of another family recipe from the boot, they offer US regional specialty pizzas in the style of Detroit, NY, and New Haven. We had the Detroit and they will make half & half for less carnivorous spouses. It was nothing short of spectacular. If you're never had DDD it's like eating a cheesy Sicilian style pillow. It just hits different. Cannot wait to go back & try the New Haven. Their "thing" is their ovens. They have a dedicated oven for each style perfectly calibrated. Not a conveyor belt in sight. Fresh ingredients as well. Not greasy. Quality ingredients, a vision for the fare paired with skillful preparation, and great service. Simple but not easy. The wait staff is refreshing. So excited to be part of something and so proud. They are anticipatory, help each other, and authentically friendly without being annoying. If you've grown apart from your favorite neighborhood Boomer Italian casual sit down and you're looking for something better and fresh, make the trip. Gas is cheap now. If you're a Boomer family casual Italian restaurant and you want to see 2022, you should probably secret shopper Red Plum yourselves and step your game up, capisce? In closing two thoughts.... why not add Ohio Valley style (Steubenville DiCarlo's) to the menu? And how about a second Red Plum on 224 to go compete in the epicenter? The old TGIFriday on 224 & 680 or the old Outback would be great locations in the heart of the business district. I'm just sayin. Great job Red Plum team. I could walk to a family Italian place where I live in 224 Land. But I'll be making the 30 minute drive instead. You should, too. We'll definitely be back! read more

One of my favorite pizza places around here. I used to love the Detroit style pizza but I've had it a few times where it came soggy...I do still chance it once in a while. Overall, great pizza and wings. read more

Can I just tell you how much we love Red Plum? It has become our families go to during this crazy COViD mess. Cause let's face it when your stressed - you want great food and for us that's pizza. - and OMG does this place have THE best pizza in the area!! We have had the NYC, The New Haven and the Detroit and each and everyone of them are excellent! My sister loves the NYC best. It's just like being in NYC and having a slice... but in the comfort of our home. We just do a simple extra cheese pizza and it's easily enough for she and I to make two meals on. My favorite is the Detroit. The fresh Ricotta on top just makes it so rich that I can only eat about two slices! Ohhh speaking of cheeses love their cheese calzone too! Not a fan of the red sauce but that's ok I can do without the dipping! As a cheese lover this little envelope of melted cheeses is pure Heaven! My daughter and husband love their pasta so that gives them a break from my pizza binge! And save room For dessert! You want the cake. Always get the cake! read more